Good food. Fun vibe. Great music. We got drinks - house shots were fun. Loaded fries were awesome.read more

Great food and great atmosphere. Love the open building in the summer. The staff was very friendly…read moreand our friends even had their dog with them table side.

The food is a bit expensive. I understand it is a "bar", but would like to see a kids menu. Would…read moreprobably frequent the place more if it was more family inclusive with the menu during the day.

The dress code is "come as you are". I've eaten at this bar several times over the years and never…read morehad a bad meal. The clientele tends to be the biker fans and I mean this as in what to expect, more than forewarning. Walking in the front door you will need to go around a pool table and perhaps pause to allow the player take their shot. You'll need to pick your own seats, inside or outside. The bar is largely open to the outside and has a leisurely atmosphere. I chose a seat near the front of the bar looking out toward Lake Erie. Our server (Boots) doubled as the bar tender. Boots was polite and efficient. She was very familiar with the menu and was able to answer any questions. For an appetizer we settled on the Cheese Curds. We had two craft beers from a modest list. The beers were cold and hit the spot. The curds arrived shortly thereafter. They were hot and tasty, accompanied by a side of ranch. I had the Cajun Shrimp Burger (medium) and a side of Tater Tots. My wife ordered the Grilled Chicken Wrap with the Fair French Fries on the side. Our entrees arrive in a timely manner. She was satisfied with her wrap, saying it was "good". If you aren't familiar with what a "fair french fry" is and I would be in that group, they are thinly sliced potatoes. Thicker than a shoestring and thinner than a standard fry. They are deep fried until brown. My burger was overcooked to well done. I didn't get much Cajun flavor but it was a good looking sandwich. The shrimp were large. Even with the negatives, it was good! The tots were perfectly cooked. As stated earlier I've eaten here several times and never been disappointed and the prices are reasonable. Give it a try!

Smash burger oh yum Great staff, great food, Halloween and…read moreXmas crawl stop here fun stuff... also pool league night on Thursday

I have been going to GOTL since I was little. Had the absolute worst service on the strip here…read moretoday. And the owner was present and was more concerned about playing guitar than the lack of customer service we got here this afternoon.

Wife and I came here years ago and had a really super meal...this time, not so much. Kinda like a…read moredivey style seafood restaurant, but the real "star of the show" is the shooting gallery behind the bar. It is an original piece of equipment from the famed Coney Island amusement park in New York City from the early 1900's. It was brought to Geneva-On-The-Lake in the late 1930's and installed in its current location as part of a small amusement gallery where it was eventually covered over and forgotten. Some time in the early 2000's (during a renovation of the space) it was uncovered and brought back to life. It still works to this day, and the owners were delighted to crank it up for us to see. As for the food, sadly the meal left a lot to be desired. The house salad to start was just fine topped with a balsamic dressing, but the smoked lobster dip and the lobster lasagna were just not good. You could hardly taste any lobster in the dip, and the lasagna was too oily, did not have enough cream sauce and did not taste super fresh. The other couple dining with us that evening was also less than impressed with their meal selections...so although the nostalgia factor was high, our dining expectations were not met.

We had dinner here our first night in town, and I think we have mixed feelings as a group. It's…read morekind of a divey seafood place right on the strip. When we walked in, it was pretty empty, but did end up filling up. They have some local wines, which was nice, and an interesting menu. The decor is a mish mash, with a creepy lobster tank that may be inhabited by the Babadook, and a still functioning shooting gallery wall behind the bar. No shooting, but they turn it on about every 20 minutes and all the pieces move while creaking and squeaking. I ordered the Apple Salad and the walleye special, and was pleasantly surprised with both. The salad had a house honey lavender dressing that went well with the apples and carrots, seemed fresh, and was a nice portion size. The walleye was a generous portion, well cooked, cajun style, and served with garlic and oil spaghetti. I enjoyed my entree quite a bit. My friends were less enthused with their entrees, both prepared well, but smaller portion sizes. It's an interesting place, and maybe worth a visit for a drink or appetizer. Again, I did enjoy my food, but the overall experience was interesting.

We had such a great time here! The next time you visit Geneva-on-the-Lake be sure to stop in here…read morefor food or drinks. The menu is full of Irish traditional specialties (shepherd's pie, Irish stew, Guiness, Harp) as well as typical bar food. Some of the items might not be available, but that is clearly stated on the menu. When we asked for Irish stew, they were out of it. To be fair, this is kind of common these days. Murphy's Pub is up there with other Cleveland area Irish restaurants like the Harp or PJ McIntyre's and is worth the drive out to GotL! Our server was excellent, our food was also excellent. The music and ambiance definitely have an Irish vibe. It has outdoor seating as well as indoor. Family friendly. Easy walk for anyone on the main strip in GotL. I have to give a special recommendation for the pork wings, which are a unique appetizer. The "Murphy Sauce" is a unique secret which you have to taste to believe.

Very good food with very very nice employees, nice Irish atmosphere, we ate there 2 nights and ate…read moreRueben fries appetizer, and pork wings yes pork , very interesting very good but a bit pricey, and also a Rueben sandwich was good

I gotta say this was a nice find. We were out and about. Wanted some dinner. Started looking around…read morefor a close place. And found this place. We got there around 5:00p on a Saturday. People already eating and drinking. Deceivingly large. Walk in and bar is to your right. To the left are tables and such. We went to the bar. The bar had a good amount of people. We ended up close to the windows on the other side. It was fine. Bartender came right over. They have a good selection of alcohol. Flavored vodka's. I got salted Carmel with coke. Delish! Kathy got cucumber vodka and sprite. Very refreshing. We got menus and asked bartender to recommend some items. He said wings good, burgers good, chicken and waffles and Mac and cheese. Funny we didn't get any of those. Kathy got the brisket dinner. I got the rueben with a salad. Both good. And prices were good too. They came out in about 10 mins. Salad was good. The Rueben was hot . I ate half. Good amount of corned beef not too skimpy. Kathy's. Brisket looked amazing. And it was good. Brisket tender with side of baked potato and broccoli. BBQ sauce on the side. And a loaf of bread. All for $12.99. She ate half and took home too. It was good and filling. Bartender was nice and informative. Place had a good mix of people. Looks like a nice hang out. Prices were good. Drinks good. Can't complain. I'd definitely go back and try something else.

Excellent service!! The food was amazing!! We enjoyed the fresh hand breaded fish fry and pulled…read morepork sandwiches. Major props to Mac for greeting us immediately and helping us find a table. Food came out fast and hot! Great food, great drinks, great prices, great atmosphere! So glad we stopped at The Boot!

The service was excellent. We had the salmon and the walleye and both were good portions and were…read moredelicious!

Four of us stopped in for a drink. We enjoyed our drinks and conversation with the bartender. We…read morehad ordered a pour of Buffalo Trace, Widow Jane, a beer and a Manhattan. She wasn't sure how to make the manhattan but eventually poured a nice drink. We got our bill and the two special pours of bourbon and the beer were 28 dollars. For the simple Manhattan we were charged 30 dollars. We told her this was crazy but she refused to listen. We paid the bill but I will never set foot in this place again. What could have been a good memory of Geneva on the Lake and GOTL brewery was completely ruined. If you do go to this place, and I recommend you don't, make sure you ask the price of anything you order.

Had a quiet dinner at Horizons after a rainy day, but the view and sunset made it so much more…read moreworth it! It was one of the restaurants open during the off season. The bourbon cocktail was flavorful, but the espresso martini lacked real espresso with no foam. The entrees and bread were amazing, though, and we had plenty to take home!

This was a great experience as most of the restaurants at GOTL are primarily bar food restaurants…read more If you want an upgraded experience id recommend Horizons at the Lodge.