Such a hidden gem! For the last two years, we have picked up a key lime pie for dinner and WOW.. just WOW. Best key lime pie! It does come at a high price, I believe it's $28 and the pie is relatively small. It is so good though, really worth the drive. The bakery opens at 11AM, I arrived at noon and they had one key lime pie left! I highly recommend getting there early if you're going specifically for this pie! read more

Y'all, this bakery is the best, a must do in Avon. Multiple gluten free items, which is always a nice surprise. The blonde was absolutely delicious, and made with almond flour. We got chocolate cupcakes, which were also GF. My husband was skeptical because he doesn't care for most GF items. These cupcakes were amazing and both kids were surprised they were GF. The icing was perfect, not too sweet, and really creamy. read more

See all

This place is awesome! They do some excellent work. The peanut butter pie is not to be missed! Went in there today looking for some fresh bread...was hoping to make a Muffuletta. They had this beautiful European style sourdough. It's denser than focaccia, but it was perfect! Had to grab a chocolate and peanut butter cream filled cookie sandwich...had to...never heard of such a thing! I want another one right now Muffuletta turned out perfectly! Love this bakery, solid joint! read more

Island Bakery - Muffuletta stuffing. - Desserts Near Me - Avon, North Carolina

See all

Wonderful! We were created with a smile and eagerness to help. We arrived towards the end of the day so there wasn't a huge selection but what we did get was AWESOME! We purchased bloodies (which my husband gobbled up) and a flourless chocolate torte (yaaaaaas). We also got a key lime pie for Mother's Day. Haven't dug into it yet but it looks promising. Can't wait to come back later in the week. read more

Island Bakery - a box of baked goods - Desserts Near Me - Avon, North Carolina

See all

Absolutely amazing desserts and treats - it's a must try. We came by with a craving of key lime pie and wouldn't have guessed they had some that were JUST baked and still setting. Tried it that night and it was probably the best key lime pie I've ever had. The consistency and sweet and sour balance was perfection. And the whip cream on top was homemade. We also got two cookie cup treats and a red velvet cupcake - all delicious! Worth a trip back to Avon, NC. read more

What a fabulous bakery! The inside of the store is exceptionally clean, a bit spartan in appearance. Don't let let that distract you from the main attraction - many delicious treats! We sampled five different cookies and an apple pecan scone. All were fresh and wonderful. The staff were very friendly. I highly recommend this bakery! read more

Stopped in right before closing and so glad we did! I had an almond blondie that was melt in your mouth. My husband had chocolate everything cookies that he said were rich and buttery. Prices were very reasonable and I recommend anyone coming through the area to stop in. read more

Island Bakery - Front of Bakery - Desserts Near Me - Avon, North Carolina

An island bakery that I am constantly amazed by. Incredible breads, vegan friendly options, perfect brioche, cinnamon rolls & incredible sourdough. European quality breads & stellar service right here in the outer banks read more

See all

The PB cookie sandwich w PB cream and chocolate ganache was soft without falling apart. Best I've ever had, delicious. The blondie bar, the cannoli bar all were amazing. It was so good! My wife got the brownie, she was very impressed. Highly recommend, 10 out of 10. read more

Omg this place is delicious. And the women running the place are incredibly sweet! They had a great selection of cheesecakes, cupcakes, brownies, etc. Prices are SO reasonable as well. A cute little gem; can't wait to visit each year for vacation!! read more

Absolutely the greatest bakery ! Awesome gluten free cookies and cupcakes! I wish we had one in VA !!

So glad to have stumbled across this bakery. I purchased 6 cupcakes, an Oreo cheesecake and a peanut butter pie. ALL were absolutely delicious!! I don't think you can go wrong with anything they offer. So so good!!! read more

The peanut butter cookie cup is AMAZING!!! We called to order more before making the trip home and they were completely accommodating. Don't miss out when you make your trip to OBX!!! read more

Delicious gluten free blondies! Cupcakes and pecan bar were also delicious! You won't be disappointed!

We ordered Pumpkin and Apple pies for Thanksgiving. They were AMAZING!!! I am so happy to see this wonderful Bakery in Avon and can't wait to try all their delicious looking desserts. The service was great and everyone was super friendly. read more

We have been vacationing in Rodanthe for 20+years and have been waiting for a place like this to open up! We loved the gluten free cupcakes, peanut butter sandwich cookies (gluten free) and the coconut key lime cookies.All amazing! And very reasonably priced too! We will be back! read more