Knowing the ice cream is made with local dairy and in small batches makes indulging so much easier. It's almost always busy and service has always been great. If there's a wait it's worth it. It's places like this that's actually made me never wanting bigger named ice cream brands again. Quality is great, tastes amazing and for what you're getting it's super affordable. read more

Love this place. This time we got a peanut butter cup milkshake and one Java jolt milkshake with a banana. read more

See all

Had to stop by our favorite Island Ice Cream store the Island Creamery as we were going through Salisbury. Same great flavors and friendly service as Chincoteague. read more

Island Creamery - Stopping by the Salisbury Island Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

See all

Ok, so I didn't contact the owner but a friend talked me into trying island creamery again (twice actually) and I definitely caught them on a bad night. This time I ordered the chocolate peanut butter milkshake and it was DIVINE! The ice cream was creamy and delicious and the milkshake was just thick enough. This is going to be my new "treat" when I do well or I need a pick up. Apologies to the owner. Definitely give this local ice cream shop a try! read more

Delicious! We are gluten free and the website clearly is marked for products that contain gluten. So yummy! Highly recommend the Bourbon Caramel Crunch!!! (Yes there is a small amount of alcohol used to flavor it) hubby had the cherry vanilla shake and he loved it. Place was clean, fast, and friendly, and they have a drive through if you don't want to park and walk in. read more

Delicious! Tried the vegan coconut and Key Line pie. Both were outstanding. Try the waffle cones too.

This is one of the very best homemade ice cream spots I've been to and is definitely my fave in Virginia! Lots of flavors and they get you through the long line very efficiently!! I've never had a flavor I didn't like, but Pony Tracks is my fave. read more

Peanut butter cup was ah-mazing!!! Mmmm mmmm. The drive thru was easy to use and the staff super friendly.

My wife was craving ice cream and we came across the reviews for Island Creamery and needed to check it out! We were happy to see that in addition to walking in there was a drive-thru option. The employee was helpful in explaining a couple of the flavors to us and she decided on a scoop of pineapple upside-down cake on a waffle cone. We pulled forward and were greeted by a friendly, smiling face. The ice cream cone looked very good and my wife really enjoyed it!!! read more

Island Creamery - Pineapple upside-down cake on a waffle cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

The staff here is so gracious. There's an array of flavors and the root beer floats are phenomenal.

One cannot find a better ice cream but,.... for $7.00 plus for double dip in a cup, you should get two good dips. Many times the ice cream doesn't make it over the rim of the cup. Give your customers two true good dips. read more

I don't really like ice cream that much, but I am a sucker for Island Creamery. The employees are soo friendly! When I asked for details on a sundae, they actually knew what it was and explained it to me happily! Haha. Sizes are massive-so, when you're paying for a small, you're paying for a pretty big portion of ice cream, just something to keep in mind. I wish their drive through line was a bit longer, though, as I frequently notice it stops in the middle of the road next to the building. Well, it just goes to show how much people love Island Creamery! Give it a try if you're in the area. read more

super delicious ice cream and all the workers were so kind and attentive! got a kids cup which was the perfect amount for me :) read more

Island Creamery - Blueberry - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Melts In Your MouthNot In Your Hands! Awesome Ice Cream, Variety Of Flavors, Good Prices, Great Customer Service

Favorite ice cream spot in town! Good selection of flavors. Employees are always pleasant.

Ice cream is good. Very creamy. So many flavors to choose from! Workers are pleasant and quick.

Great service, patient with explanations and good portions. I will return but with two people. This small cone is enormous. read more

Island Creamery - Peanut Butter SMALL scoop on homemade cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Best ice-cream in the area! The staff are very nice. It's a nice small ice cream place with a drive through. The drive through line is usually long, especially in the summer time, but it's worth the wait read more

great tasting and generous portions!! so many flavors - just ask for a sample to narrow down your choice!! read more

Island Creamery - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Definitely some of the best ice cream I've ever eaten. Sometimes I take out ice cream and store it in my freezer at home. I will, on occasion, eat the ice cream for a delicious,nutritious breakfast meal. Breakfast, supposedly the most important meal of the day. I removed one star because they are really expensive. read more

Best scoop I've ever had. Not exaggerating. The Butter Pecan specifically. Love going here!

I live a few hours away but was going to be 30 mins away at an event. I knew they were recently named best ice cream in America, and I wanted to see if this was true. So I made the trip (ended up being 90 mins round trip) and it was TOTALLY worth it! The servers were very friendly and gave me some suggestions and encouraged me to taste a couple flavors. I ended up doing half cake batter and half marsh mud (double dark chocolate). They were rich and creamy and delicious. Almost custard-like but truly just fantastic ice cream. read more

Island Creamery - Cake Batter and Marsh Mud - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

The strawberry sorbet was amazing!!! Kids got cones and they were huge and very tasty. Highly recommended. read more

Island Creamery - Strawberry Sorbet - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Some of the best ice cream on the peninsula and definitely in Salisbury. Their flavor combinations are awesome but know that you can't sit down to eat inside anymore. read more

Sooo good! Huge scoops! Best waffle cone I've tasted. Lots of space for social distancing. I'm a coffee lover. Two coffee flavors. The best one was Java Jolt because of the chocolate covered beans . read more

Island Creamery - Waffle cones and cups single scoops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

See all

Came here on a whim tonight looking to try something new. We were blown away!! We have a creamery close to our home but this one far surpasses almost any ice creams. We'll definitely be back!! read more

Staff was great and nice availability of flavors. The black-raspberry ice cream with rainbow sprinkles was delicious.

Expensive but yummy good. Great choices very adequate Clean and good service. Recommend if you want the real thing

Best ice cream ever! Had the Almond joy and chocolate peanut butter in a cup. Creamy and delicious. Line moves fast and there's a drive-thru. So yummy! read more

Best place for local ice cream. So many flavors to choose from and the staff is always friendly. Definitely recommend.

I don't eat dairy so it is very difficult to find an ice cream place that offers non-dairy or vegan options other than sorbet. I was in town for a conference and saw a line out the door at Island Creamery as I was on my way back to my room. I whipped in and figured I had nothing better to do than to wait to see what everyone was so excited about. The ice cream flavors looked absolutely spectacular; I lusted after them waiting in line, knowing that I would be stuck with a non-creamy icy sorbet. I practically did backflips when the server informed me they had three creamy ice cream options using coconut milk as a base. I enjoyed this dish of coconut and mocha with chocolate chips on top. It was fabulous and overly bountiful. Believe it or not, this dish was advertised as two scoops! The third flavor was chocolate mint Oreo, which I could not try since I don't eat gluten. However, the coconut and mocha flavors were absolutely spectacular and I highly recommend this location. My friend got pineapple upside down cake ice cream and she said that it was equally fabulous. read more

Island Creamery - Seriously This is TWO Scoops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

When I found out that the Island Creamery set up a location in Salisbury, it was like Jesus came down from the Heavens and made a miracle happen just for me. I work down at Wallops Island near the original location, and to hear that another place opened near where I live was like music to my ears. Some of the best ice cream I've ever had in my life. Go here. Now! Why are you still reading this review!? read more

Ice cream is so fresh and delicious! Convenient location and drive thru made it even better. Friendly staff and generous portions! Love this place. read more

Island Creamery - Almond Joy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Love their ice cream! It is a little expensive but you do get a lot of ice cream and it supports a local business! so do not shy away from it because of the price! Definitely worth it! read more

Same as on Chincoteague with out the island.....this ice cream is probably the best stuff ever! I have had amazing ice cream but this transcends the boundaries of a religious experience! DO NOT COME HERE! More for me..... read more

Hands down, the absolute best ice cream around. The waffle cones are good enough to eat as a dessert all by themselves. If you're a chocoholic, the Marsh Mud is an definite must. read more

THE BEST ICE CREAM!!!! The homemade waffle cones will change your life and you will find yourself craving this all the time. Cake batter is my favorite flavor but they have so many creative choices! They have so much more than just ice cream. It's slightly more pricey than some ice cream places but it's definitely worth it for the homemade quality. The staff is always pleasant and very helpful. read more

Excellent ice cream. We had a apple cobbler (seasonal offering) and cherry vanilla double scoop, one double scoop of the vegan chocolate mint, and a small banana split. Fantastic taste, healthy portions, friendly service. But don't let the 'small' name on the banana split fool you. It was large - only had two scoops - but those two scoops were as large as other places' triple scoops. Highly recommended! Note: there aren't many seats so you might need to get it to go on busy nights... read more

THIS IS THE BEST PLACE EVER TO PURCHASE ICE CREAM AND CAKES FROM. For my birthday, my parents bought an ice cream cake from here for the first time. It was delicious! It was half black berry and I think half cotton candy and it was blue and beautiful. It tasted so goood! It was basically just like ice cream but with frosting and stuff not too sweet. Ever since that, we always buy our birthday cakes from here. One time we always got ice cream from here and I ordered a sherbet, I don't remember what flavor, on a cone and they gave a very good big amount of it and it tasted very good and creamy. I definitely recommend for everyone to buy ice cream here and buy your birthday cakes here. Their cakes are like nothing else! read more

The ice cream here is superb! Came in on the first week it opened and saw a massive line forming out of the door and into the parking lot. I was amazed because I have never seen an ice cream place so popular. I was surprised how well the ice cream tasted considering I normally don't consider ice cream for dessert often. If I lived in the area I would consider coming here very often for the cookie dough ice cream because that is the flavor I first got and will never deviate from when going here. Wished I had one of these shops in New Jersey and sad knowing I will most likely not have ice cream from this place ever again. read more