When you come here, expect to wait about 45 minutes to an hour for your pizza. This is part of the cooking process that is very unique to making a crisp, flavorful, lack-of-grease pie. Read the bottom as to WHY. We arrived about 5pm on a Saturday. Not real busy. 1 minute to someone taking our drinks order, 2m30 to having drinks on the table and placing our app and food order. Apps were on the table in 15 minutes. Had an order of the Tracy bread with garlic sauce. Get the garlic sauce and just dunk your sticks like they're Oreos in milk. Delicious. Another 42 minutes and our pies were brought out one by one. Cooked to perfection, the bacon wasn't floppy, outer crust held its shape, and the base crust wasn't thin like a proofed crust. And also... no grease! It was moist, but it was the tomato sauce that was giving it the moisture. Would I order again? Heck yes. Would I have 3 beers before the food arrives? Heck no, lol. LITTLE SECRET ON WHY IT TAKES SO LONG: aluminum pans are used instead of dark pans which would otherwise cook faster. If they used dark pans, the outside and the crust would cook too fast, and the middle would be floppy and undercooked. This and the oven was the key to a stiff, flavorful pie. Would return again. 10/10. read more

Fantastic pizza with incredible service and a really positive vibe. One of those places that just gets it right.

One word for Jake's: WOW! Consistently one of the best pizzas in Green Bay and the Fox River Valley, Jake's today continues the years and years of excellence established by the original Jake's The sisters Cara and Brooke did not skip a beat when they bought the original "Superior "pizza and continued the tradition. Just the mention of their name brings back many incredible pizzas over the many years. Whenever we get to Green Bay a #1 stop is Jake's. If you haven't dined there be sure to change that. I wish we lived closer so we could be frequent customers! The incredible crust, the house-made sauce and other ingredients are the best! Add the great service and wonderful ambiance of this gem all makes for a fabulous pizza experience. You'll not regret stopping in! And no, I am not a relative or connected to the place. read more

The atmosphere is great, the staff is friendly, and the pizza was delicious at a good price!

Carry out was available when promised. Pizza was delicious! I ordered here because news article said they would be closed to protect their employees during heat spell. Their values are in the right place. Thank you!​ read more

Got a dinner here off the vegetarian pizza and tried the sausage and pepperoni pizza. The pizza was cooked very well but still had a soft center crust. The crust isn't what I remember from the original Jakes. Service was good. Nothing special, nothing bad. I was disappointed with the lack of menu and the fact that there is no salad option at all. It has been 7 years since I have been here, it may be another 7 before heading back. read more

While they disclose its 45 minutes for a pizza, one couldn't help but wonder if the employees would slow down taking shots with customers, they could cut down on that order time?? Aside from the awful service, when asking for plates we were told no (thought restaurants usually have these). Bartender said "we don't have enough for the restaurant, fold open a napkin" Was seriously waiting for Ashton Kutcher to come out the back door any minute. Don't recommend. read more

Burnt food overcooked unseasoned pizza horrible service long wait Beer specials on wall they didn't have read more

Wow!!, my wife and I just enjoyed one of the best pizzas we've ever enjoyed. Cara was the greatest, helping us understand why their pizza is so darn good. The real reason, is they love what they do. I have found my pizza place whenever I visit the Green Bay area. Oh, by the way the prices are very reasonable and the the whole place just make you feel like your at the bar next door to your home. Very, Very pleasant place. One more thing, sitting in my hotel room enjoying my cold pizza from last night and yes!! it's one of the best i've ever had, don't worry if your over priced hotel room doesn't have a microwave, you won't need it. read more

Cubano pizza is super dank buffalo chicken pizza is amaze balls do you want great food and service? Come to Jake's! great ambiance read more

Everything. Great food and service. The atmosphere was casual but nice. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

Had not been to Jake's in a while. Did not like the classic pizza. Very little meat and cheese and taste. Nice place and people.

The absolute best pizza in Green Bay! We take all our friends and family there when they visit. Highly recommend the Shrimp Scampi Pizza!

One of a kind pizza!!! The people that run the place very personable. Great every time!!!

Cara & Pinkie made my visit memorable. Shrimp Scampi gourmet pizza was scrumptious. I ordered small and only consumed half. I anticipate the leftovers. Hinterland Brewery Cherry Wheat beer was tasty Love the hometown vibe. Always have... Shine On read more

Jakes Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

I was looking for a place for a couple of quick drinks and some takeout food when I got into town. Stopped in to order a pizza to go and had a absolutely delicious Bloody Mary with homemade mix that was garnished with a pickled mushroom, pickled onion, olive, and a pickle - highly recommend if you like bloodies. Ordered my pizza to go - got a 9" Personal Special - Sausage, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, onion, black olive and with recommendation if the bartender garlic(which is fresh slices of garlic). Pizza had a great crust and was cooked perfectly. There were a lot of toppings and the sliced garlic adds a lot of flavor if you're a garlic fan. Atmosphere was neat filled with what was clearly regulars later on a Sunday night. Service was quick and friendly. Pizza took about a half hour from when I ordered - enough time for 2 drinks! read more

Jakes Pizza - 9" Personal Special - Sausage, pepperoni, ham, mushroom, onion, garlic and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

See all

This pizza recipe is made from the great Jake! So delicious and worth the 45 minute wait. The location is cozy and the staff is friendly. Heather Peterman has her work and face all over this place which brings me joy always. I will forever love the large garlic and jalapeño combo pizza! read more

Jakes Pizza - Fresh garlic and Jalapeño pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

I have been a Jake's fan for a lot of years. Last night 12/7/23 after spending $70 for three to go pizzas I'll never go back. They were burnt, so dried out the cheese didn't even move. The person who cooked and let them out the door did not represent your business in any positive way. read more

Great food, excellent service. My fiancé brought me there last night. I absolutely LOVE their pizza. Our server was a sweetheart. My friend Kat recommended Jake's months ago, now I know why. Full bar, great food, excellent service. I would definitely recommend Jake's Pizza. read more

This pizza is underrated for the area. It's easily the best I've encountered and the atmosphere and vibe of being a hole in the wall pizza joint makes it even better. The sauce, crust , cheese and toppings are all high quality. If you have a hankering for a great pie and don't mind a 45 minute wait, this place should be top of your list! read more

We ordered take out. It was absolutely delicious! Tavern cut with nice crispy crust. The herb bread was good, but not the highlight. Would absolutely recommend for easy pizza. read more

This place is busy quite often, especially the small bar area. They have great service and excellent food! The place is small, with a small bar area and some booths, along with some high tops in the bar area. The pizza takes about 40 minutes to make, but so worth the wait!! I always get a custom pizza, and their breadsticks are pretty good too. They have a full bar, which is nice! read more

Nice spot for local home made pizza. Pizza took a little longer to come out but portions were great and it was tasty. We ordered the tracy garlic bread (which was yummy), small bbq chicken pizza and small classic special. Over all experience I'd give it a 7/10 (my taste buds). Nothing bad to say. Great customer service and great location. read more

Service was great and pizza was good. Concerned with how loud it was in the place. Need something to help absorb the reflective conversations and kitchen noise so it is easier to enjoy company conversation and place menu order. I prefer pizza with more of a hand tossed crust and more cheese but that's a personal preference not the pizza places concern. read more

Classic, and a good classic at that. Pizza always, always (!) starts with the dough - good dough, good pizza, and Jake's has a solid dough. The crust is nicely chewy and crunchy, with a nice flavor. The pizza sauce is a touch to sweet for my taste, but still works nicely with with the pie. I love the sausage! I will always order double sausage. The pie is nicely portioned, without to many toppings, or too few. There are very few places that serve a good pizza in Green Bay, and Jake's is one of those. If you are stopping in or ordering to go on the weekend make sure to give yourself 30-45 minutes, but the wait is worth it. And you can just order some of their wonderful bread sticks or meatballs to tide you over while waiting for the main event. read more

This place confuses me a bit. My husband went to order a pizza and they told him they only do deep dish. They may want to take a trip to Chicago because when he arrived home with it I was surprised. This is a pan pizza not deep dish and it was okay. The crust was tasty for a pan pizza and the toppings were fresh. It was nothing special though and waiting that long for it was a bummer. Not sure I will be back anytime soon there are better places in Green Bay. read more

Jakes Pizza - Pizza with thick crust. - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Okay I rarely give out 5 stars since I always believe there is room for improvement. But come on this is Jake's! Best pizza in GB! The only thing I could see as an improvement could be an expanded seating area but they get it done with what the building provides. Always friendly, always delicious and you never have to twist an arm to get someone to go with you! read more

Incredible! If your in Green Bay do not miss Jake's. Incredible pizza, incredible atmosphere in a very cool building, awesome owners and staff. This is a special piece of America and of Green Bay's history. An incredible family with a deep love for Green Bay. Did I say don't miss it? read more

See all

Really cool building. Good service and decent pizza. We got a classic pepperoni and a classic everything pizza. The crust was a little thicker than I prefer it, and the everything had a ton of mushrooms...which I wasn't expecting. Still good stuff though! Will be back again to try out other toppings and/or their deli sandwiches. They also have a full bar. read more

No food yet. Been waiting for 45 min for 1 pizza. Thinking about walking out! update: took an hour for 1 pizza - it was good but we were starving! never going back. read more

Jakes has a really good vibe. Great service. Pizza is good. The pizza is better than franchise pizza but I do miss Billoti's. My only comment is the Crust. could've been a little crispier. It was a little too moist. read more

Visiting our kids who live in the area. Wanted to buy pizzas for dinner on Saturday night, using yelp reviews to ask if they wanted or had pizza from various places, prefer to support smaller places when we travel. . . Daughter said everyone raves about this place, it was just a couple miles from her house so we ordered carryout. Ordered a small vegetarian, large classic and a small scampi pizza. Dont agree with all these reviews-- maybe they had new staff in the kitchen or something? -- but seriously these were overbaked pies with no real taste other than salt on these pies. Fifty bucks for cardboard yuck. Dominoes, Pizza Hut and Glass Nickel would have been so much better for a third of the price for what we got. Not recommended. read more

Hands down best pizza in Green Bay, maybe even the best pizza I've ever tasted?? Loaded with mushrooms and peppers on a unique tasting thin crust. I've never dined in but I look forward to picking up a Jakes deluxe when I come back to Green Bay! read more

"I don't eat thick crust pizza often, but when I do, I eat at Jake's" I think that's my new motto now. I've never really been a thin crust guy, but I'm going to have make an exception from now on. Most thick crust pizza is either too poofy (Pizza Hut), too chewy (Sicilian Style), or drenched in oil/butter, and it detracts from what you are actually going after: the cheese and toppings. Jake's manages to balance everything in good proportions. The crust is firm with a nice bite without being either dry or oily. The sauce is well seasoned, not too much, or too little; and the cheese and toppings are plenty and fresh. For $10 I got a personal pizza with quality toppings that more than filled me up. Well done, Jake's. read more

Crust was thin & crispy. Fresh mushrooms were good. Got a salty taste from the fresh Parmesan. Our server was very attentive & friendly. Pale ale tap beer complemented the pizza. Also tried the big meatball appetizer-spicy & cheesy! read more

Jakes Pizza - Classic with onions green peppers, sausage, pepperoni & ham and of course mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

New location same great taste! I live in Appleton and have not been at Jakes since they loved and once again was happy. Great service, great pizza! read more

Jakes Pizza - Killing time waiting for the awesome pizza - Pizza Near Me - Green Bay, Wisconsin

We absolutely love Jake's Pizza, especially the Timmeh sticks! We usually get pick up about once a month and the food is always hot and ready when they say it will be and always delicious. read more

Best pizza north of Chicago. Period! Definitely recommend. Good selection of craft beers. Although the pizza takes time, its worth the wait. read more

Went their for the first time. The staff is very nice and friendly.The pizza is good but not great. Order a large pepperoni pizza and the price is affordable. Not to be rude prolly won't go back. read more

I celebrated my birthday with friends and family at Jake's. We felt at home and everyone enjoyed themselves. The staff was very attentive and the food was fabulous! I love the thin, crispy crust and tasty toppings. I would definitely go back again. read more