Very friendly fish is fresh. It takes me back to kind of what Hatteras Island used to be.read more

Reasonably priced and phenomally fresh. Great service. Locally family owned. Answered newbie…read morequestions with grace.

Amazing selection. Fresh catch selections are restaurant grade, huge beautiful filets and steaks;…read morevery reasonably priced. Made fish tacos with the Mahi. Spicy boiled shrimp is a must buy if nothing else. Raw oysters were incredible quality. Also, they have a vintage '80's GD Fall Tour shirt on display.

Great service, prices were good and Shrimp was incredible! Will definitely be back to pick up more…read morethings to try.

My new go-to spot for seafood on Hatteras! I came across a…read moreFacebook post about Jeffrey's and knew I had to check it out--and I'm so glad I did. From the moment I walked in, I was warmly greeted by two friendly smiles behind the counter. For a fish market, the place was impressively clean--absolutely spotless. Their selection didn't disappoint: beautifully cut filets, whole fish, and everything in between. I picked up some shrimp, a generous cut of tuna, and a container of shrimp salad. Everything was incredibly fresh. The tuna was so good, I seared it as soon as I got back to the house. My son and I devoured a pound and a half like it was nothing. The shrimp were just as delicious, and the shrimp salad was the perfect beachside snack. Can't wait to go back--I may have just found a gem.

This is a hidden gem. They have a outdoor eating area that you can byob. The steamed shrimp and…read moreshrimp salad were great. The customer service was top notch. It was super clean inside with many options. You will be thankful you stopped here

This was recommended to us by a friend and WOW! It did not disappoint! We actually went twice. Trip…read more#1 we did the traditional seafood boil. It was our first time trying something like this and the staff were incredibly helpful with instructions, tools needed, etc. Even threw in butcher paper to cover our table at home which was an awesome touch. Next night we went back and got some fresh fish filets to cook at home which were fresh and delicious. As other reviews have said, there are a lot of places like this in OBX but I would keep going back to this one!

I have lived on the Outer Banks for 30 years and I have been to all of the seafood markets. There…read moreare three reasons why I make the drive to this market in Avon. Number 1, the seafood is the freshest and of the best quality. Number 2, the drive down Hwy 12 is beautifully scenic (especially if you have children). And finally, 3, the owner John is so friendly and knowledgeable, I simply enjoy the conversations with him. I refer to him as Dr. Seafood because he prescribes crustacean perfection. Thanks again Surf's Up Seafood, we can't wait to see you!

On the last day of my stay in Avon, wanted to bring some outer banks home. With 6 hours drive ahead…read moreof me, I wanted something fresh but will withstand the drive during summer time. Sunrise offers perfectly fresh local fish and frozen ones too. I took home a hunk of tuna, sea bass and shrimps. They were still so fresh once thawed, even after sitting in my freezer for another month. The guys at the store were kind and friendly. Happy to explain and offer options. Definitely recommend!

My husband went here to grab us steamed shrimp for dinner! We went close to closing, so they…read morealready turned off the steamer. But we got a lb of shrimp and cooked it easily in the oven. Delicious! My husband said that the place was nice but also very simple. We'd come back!

Alex's Shrimp Shack is a gem! The shrimp are bursting with flavor, the service is friendly and…read morequick, and the cozy ambiance makes every visit a delight. Highly recommend this spot for a delicious dining experience!

We stopped by and got a pound of steamed pealed shrimp for about 17 bucks. We bought some roasted…read morecorn as well and a bowl of banana pudding for dessert. It was all great. We ate it on a picnic table outside of the place. Alex was there roasting corn and was quite friendly and talkative. Nice guy! The next day we came back and loaded up on things like frozen Grouper, frozen Ahi Tuna, etc. Also picked up some crab cakes and banana pudding that we cooked at our RV for dinner. Great place. Try it.

Ordered a half bushel right around 3pm on Father's Day and they were able to fulfill our order…read morewithout issue. Great service and amazing crabs! They were cooked to perfection and loaded with crab meat. The price was super affordable too. Made for a great Father's Day celebration. Thanks!

Great crab legs and even better customer service!! Definite must when in the Outer Banks.read more

Illegal discrimination, bullying and denied access based solely on disability. Laws in photos and…read morecan be found on ADA.gov I'm a disabled veteran and my Service dog is a medical and mobility necessity. We go above and beyond to meet our responsibilities and be courteous to the business and general public, we only ask that our rights respected in return. When education is the issue we carry the laws that explain their rights and responsibilities as well as ours and willing to educate. That was clearly not enough. The moment we entered the door the gentleman behind the counter made it clear he did not care what the laws are or how clean and professional the service K9 was and ordered us out of the store which is a Civil rights violation. Personally this is an insult. I am disabled and entirely dependent on my medical and mobility trained K9 because I serviced this country. I have every legal right to be where everyone else is allowed but illegally denied it. These laws are sadly not enforced but regardless I'll be filing a report with ADA and DOJ. https://www.ada.gov/topics/service-animals/ It's impossible to argue that my dogs are service dogs. You can find us on YouTube at YouTube.com/@biblicaldogs

Stopped at the market late in the afternoon on Sunday. The market was incredibly clean and smelled…read morethat way. Limited fresh selection... but that is our fault, we were late! Thought we wanted grouper but tried Tile fish at the recommendation of the gentleman behind the counter and now can't wait to eat it again. The fish was fresh, shrimp were sweet and briny. Service was friendly and helpful. They have potatoes, veggies and other seafood supplies. Stop in for seafood if you are in the area!

I've been staying in Hatteras for a while this spring. This place has been consistently operated…read moreby friendly and helpful staff members. The store is clean and well-organized, and the parking lot is small but ample. Honestly, it's the staff that gets my five stars, though. Always welcoming, always helpful. Not a huge variety in what they carry, but they have all of the basics and more. Canned goods, produce, health care items, bakery items, stationery and school supplies, dairy, seafood, meats, deli; all there.

Nice little area for any last minute needs. They have beer, snacks, clothes etc. Friendly staff and…read morea good area for browsing as well.