Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Keene Cookie Company

    4.0 (2 reviews)

    Keene Cookie Company Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Keene Cookie Company

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Rebecca S.

    Rebecca S.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Keene Cookie Company

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Keene On Cookies

    Keene On Cookies

    4.1
    (22 reviews)
    3.5 km
    $$

    The food I have had at Keene Confections has been amazing! The staff is super friendly too.read more

    This cookie shop in Keene is very cute, with adorable decor & inviting looking cookies in the case…read more We eagerly filled a small box with a selection of beautiful cookies ($20 with added tip) and tried them as soon as we walked out. It was immediately obvious that the chocolate chip & snickerdoodle cookies were not fresh. They tasted & felt at least 2 days old. Perhaps it was our mistake for not asking when these were baked before choosing them. The iced shortbread & linzer cookies were good. The raspberry jam between the linzer's shortbread cookies was generous, making it messy to eat - but yummy. The puffy iced lemon cookie itself had a nice soft texture, but the icing on it was aggressively Sprite tasting, & overpowered the cookie. Still we enjoyed the soft cookie part naked. I love a jammy thumbprint cookie, because the cookie is soft & the jam is baked into the center to reduce it to slightly chewy. The 2 we picked here had blobs of jam placed in the center after baking, & the cookie part was almost crunchy, so every bite left crumb & jam blobs dripping on your hands. We got none of the chewy jammy centers or soft cookie parts that make thumbprints so good. I'm giving 3 stars overall because service was very warm & friendly, and the shop is very inviting. Perhaps the best cookies to get here are the shortbreads as they are very cute & seem to hold up well. Or any of the cookies we tried, that appeal to you in the ways they did not appeal to us.

    Photos
    Keene On Cookies
    Keene On Cookies
    Keene On Cookies

    See all

    Eat More Cake

    Eat More Cake

    3.9
    (23 reviews)
    3.6 km

    We have been here numerous times since they opened but have never given a review. I have to sat…read morethat they make the best cupcakes, by far, than anyone in the area. Great flavor options that are delicious. Staff is always pleasant and courteous. They are very helpful. If you are looking for great cupcakes in the area this is your must stop.

    I rarely leave negative reviews, but I felt it was important to share my experience…read more I ordered a custom SpongeBob-inspired cake and provided a reference photo when placing the order. I specifically requested that the cake say "26 Years Later." The bakery assured me they could complete the cake by the date I needed it. Unfortunately, the cake I received looked significantly different from the inspiration photo I provided. The lettering was not what I requested, the colors were different, and the overall decorating quality did not meet my expectations for a custom cake. The frosting was uneven and had visible marks throughout the cake. To the bakery's credit, they did honor the original $60 price I was quoted after there was some confusion at pickup. However, I was disappointed with the final product and felt it did not reflect the design I ordered. I've included photos of both the inspiration cake and the cake I received so others can make their own comparison. Based on my experience, I would not order a custom decorated cake from this bakery again.

    Photos
    Eat More Cake
    Finished (not well, admittedly!) cookies
    Finished (not well, admittedly!) cookies
    Top of the cake

    See all

    Top of the cake
    Ye Goodie Shoppe

    Ye Goodie Shoppe

    4.3
    (22 reviews)
    3.6 km
    $$

    I used to get candy from them as a kid in the 80s and 90s when they were in the Colony Mill mall…read more Went back Nov 2025 and it was still just as good. Staff was friendly, clean with good lighting, and great selection considering the size of the store. It's hard to go wrong with what you choose to get. I'm normally not a dark chocolate person but actually prefer the dark chocolate here.

    In the days of the ever increasing chain stores, this spot is a Keene, NH institution and a perfect…read moreexample of a small business that you treasure for still being around! My wife has been going here since she was a kid. They have delicious chocolates, fudge, truffles with flavors like marzipan and various cremes. You can make your own assorted box and pick your own from the case or they have prepackaged as well. They have a good selection of old school candies like candy buttons, sour patch kids, rock candy and the like. They get creative with things like "reindeer corn" around the holidays and themed stuff for Valentines, etc. I also like how reasonable their prices are-they are more than fair and affordable. If you need a good treat, stop by. Easily found off beautiful walkable main street in Keene, where many other great businesses are as well.

    Photos
    Ye Goodie Shoppe assorted gift boxes; available in Soft Center or Deluxe Assortments in 1/2, 1, 1 1/2, and 2 lb. options!
    Ye Goodie Shoppe assorted gift boxes; available in Soft Center or Deluxe Assortments in 1/2, 1, 1 1/2, and 2 lb. options!
    Quarter Pound Shelves; gummies, dutch mints, cinnamon imperials, chocolate covered Oreos and twinkles, etc
    Quarter Pound Shelves; gummies, dutch mints, cinnamon imperials, chocolate covered Oreos and twinkles, etc
    Gluten Free Truffles in a wide assortment of flavors and sizes!

    See all

    Gluten Free Truffles in a wide assortment of flavors and sizes!

    Keene Cookie Company - customcakes - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...