Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Keith's Custom Taxidermy

    4.5 (6 reviews)

    Services - Keith's Custom Taxidermy

    Taxidermy

    Keith's Custom Taxidermy Photos

    More like Keith's Custom Taxidermy

    Recommended Reviews - Keith's Custom Taxidermy

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    7 months ago

    Quality, time, and cost were superior to other taxidermists I've used. Highly recommend!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Troy M.
    26
    12
    0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 years ago

    Keith's is great. He's an honest guy doing great work. Lots of high level work there, but ultimately it's just a great go to spot

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Keith's Custom Taxidermy

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Arctic Circle Taxidermy

    Arctic Circle Taxidermy

    4.5
    (8 reviews)

    I brought in a musky and northern pike to get restored. Both had been hanging on the wall at my…read moreparents' house for almost 50 years. Arctic Circle Taxidermy did a fantastic job restoring the fish to their original quality. This included the repair, replacement and/or repainting of many of the fins and cleaning the fish, all to "bring their looks back to life." They did a superb job!! I now live in CT. Arctic went to great effort to ensure these fish were carefully packaged for the journey east - building crates to hold and secure each fish, individually wrapping all fins with bubble wrap and tape, and carefully surrounding the fish with various packing materials. The fish arrived in perfect shape and are now displayed proudly at my house, bringing back wonderful childhood memories. I was very pleased with the quality of Arctic's work and attention to detail. I found their pricing very reasonable and staff quite pleasant to work with. I recommend Arctic to anyone having similar needs.

    I am so disappointed with the work done to my pet turtle of 24 years. I dropped my turtle off on…read moreMay 15, 2025 (and sent pictures of how he looked alive). On the contract, Peter said it would take approximately 60 to 90 days. After numerous unanswered calls and texts sent to Peter, he finally answered my call in January 2026 and told me to call back in a month. I called back and was crying on the phone, telling Peter of all the holidays in 2025 that were missed without my turtle; but Peter was really rude to me. I got a call the beginning of May 2026 telling me my turtle was ready for pick-up. I was horrified at what I saw when I went to Peter's shop on May 11, 2026, almost a year after I dropped my turtle off. The texture, color and shape of my turtle's head, neck and legs were just horrific! Only the top of his shell looked like him. Peter offered to do touch-ups and kept my turtle to try and make my turtle look better, but the damage was already done. I finally took my turtle home on May 27, 2026, crying all the way back home. I don't know if this was the first time Peter was trying to do a complete small turtle (the size of a saucer), but he really botched this job. So, beware, customers!

    Old World Taxidermy

    Old World Taxidermy

    1.0
    (1 review)

    Whoa!! Stay far far away from this outfit. If I could I wouldn't give any stars at all. This man…read moretook aprox 8 YEARS to complete my 10 bird mounts. The first mount he finished was decent so I gave him more birds to mount. However, all the rest he mulitated and the mounts don't look anything like the birds are supposed to. The eyes are wrong color and shape, the feathers were awful and he put padding exactly where it should not be. And I told him how it should be done, showed him large accurate photos of the birds, came by to check on them and again mentioned the eyes and other issues and he still ruined them. They don't look anything like they are supposed to. I gave him absolutely perfect specimens and he ruined them all but the first one he completed. All I can do now is throw out the really crappy ones a maybe keep about 3 that are acceptable. I gave him some very beautiful and very rare species and he gave me back trash.....and I PAID HIM TOP DOLLAR to boot. Next time I'll have my 3 year old grand son do the job, surely he can do better AND it won't take 8 years to do the job. I'm so disappointed. Anyone reading this better beware. He tried to make excuses for his crappy work but that doesn't cut it when I see on his workbench that he butchers the critters rather than make them look anything even remotely similar to what they should look like. Don't waste your money with this outfit. If you do you won't be happy with the results. I am so disappointed that I felt the urge to sign up for yelp, so this is my first review and probable my last. Its sad, I had so much faith in this guy and he ruined $1000's of dollars worth of specimens plus I paid him $1000's to do it. STAY FAR FAR AWAY FROM OLD WORLD TAXIDERMY!!! FYI, I don't not exaggerate one bit in this review. Actually, you should hear how I REALLY feel but I'm trying to keep this clean. BEWARE BEWARE BEWARE!!!!!! Come on.....8 years to mount a few birds...and he still &%$#ed them up. I'm not familiar with yelp but if someone needs to contact me [if there is a way to do so] I'll be happy to explain further. This is 100% the truth and I held back my true feeling on his performance. Now I'm out a ton of $ because of his incompetence. Find another taxidermist and good luck. If old world taxidermy can reply to this review don't believe him for one second. His excuses are not valid. OH! I paid him in full last year and when I just went to pick up the last of the mounts he said I still owed him. I have proof that he is paid in full. This guy is too old to do business anymore.

    From the owner: Chicagoland's #1 taxidermist…read more Welcome to Old World Taxidermy, located in Palatine, Illinois!Old World Taxidermy provides over 30 years of experience in full-line taxidermy services. We are a USDA licensed dipping station located just 20 miles from Chicago O'Hare airport (a designated port of entry), which allows you to have your overseas trophies to be shipped directly to us. Our reputation has been built on quality and service. We are deeply committed to giving our clients the best in artistic creativity, craftsmanship and materials. The experience, the pride we take in our creations, superior workmanship, and exceptional attention to every detail reflects in each piece. Let us help to capture and preserve the memories of your hunt and enjoy our one-of-a-kind mounts. We will gladly offer pre-hunt assistance and send you free shipping tags as well. We are deeply committed to giving our clients the best in materials, craftsmanship, and artistic creativity. Our experience with painting, sculpting, photography and hunting enables us to create custom design museum quality mounts. Offering:* Custom - designed museum mounts* Trophy mounts* Trophies from all over the world* Exceptional attention to detail* Artistic creativity and craftsmanship* Custom-designed museum quality mounts & more!Visit our showroom or website today for more information!

    Keith's Custom Taxidermy - taxidermy - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...