Incredible selection, great place to buy silver eagles from Buddy is easy to work with, he works on thin margins This is the best place to get value They are always ready to serve you read more

Offered me $135 for three silver 90% dollars one is very rare 1886 O . offered 300$ on eBay for it

Very considerate and friendly. It's my go to for selling of coins, silver and gold. I think I get fair pricing

very pleasant ppl and wait on you right away. They give good prices . I will go there with anything .

I took some v nickels in to sell and Buddy gave me a great price. I will definitely go back. Terry read more

Didn't get the price I supposed to get. Never gotten a itemized receipt. Best to know the value of your merchandises. Do not bring too many items at one time because you will be confused. I feel cheated. Not happy with the result. read more

Worst service ever seen at a shop. Owner and staff had no interest in showing any coins to me. Seemed "too busy" to deal with anyone other than their local customers when I travel the country to buy coins at shops. read more

the outside of the store is not welcoming. the inside of the store has no display cases. the store has hundreds of boxes. the store makes you feel claustrophobic. Every item has dust. The staff is unhelpful boarding on rude. All items bought can only paid for in cash. The store hours are a suggestion. They close when the want. Call ahead to make sure they are open. read more

The best coin exchange in the valley for expertise and service. We have sold jewelry here and have always been treated fairly. Today we went looking for "sixpence" to top off our Irish wedding. Guess what??? We were given the coins for free. What a great place! read more

Keystone Rare Coins - Something old , something new, something borrowed something blue. And a sixpence on her shoe!!! - Antiques Near Me - Allentown, Pennsylvania

Had some scrap gold, silver coins, and paper currency that I wanted to sell. Buddy the owner, was the one who let me in on a Saturday. Didnt realize it was by appointment only on Saturdays, but he still welcomed me. You walk in and your surrounded by coins on all sides. So automatically you know your dealing with someone whos been doing it for a long time. So he went through what I had brought with me, and actually offered me more than i expected. One of the Morgans I had brought turned out to be a fake, and he picked it right out. I was extremely satisfied with this visit and will definately go back. read more

I needed some quick cash so I decided to sell some foreign gold coins I had. I went into the store knowing the current melt value of an ounce of gold and the actual gold weight of each coin. I met with Buddy and we did some back and forth. Buddy was polite and reasonable. Ended up getting 93% of melt on some English gold sovereigns and 97% of melt on a Taiwanese gold piece. Buddy's initial offers were fair-no lowballing and we closed quickly and easily. For ANY sale to ANY vendor, do your homework first and protect your own interests. I would confidently deal with Buddy again in the future. read more

I Went To Keystone Coins Today Everyone Of The Staff Was Very Nice I Had Some Coins To Sell And I Knew What They Were Worth I Spoke To The Owner Buddy He Gave Me Much More Than I Expected I Recommend Any One That Has Coins And Jewelry Should Go There To See Buddy You Will Not Be Sorry Matt Berry read more

My wife talked to the owner recently and had an agreed upon price prior to going to the shop for the trade. When she arrived the owner back-pedaled and tried to low ball her for their own personal gain and tried to get her entire collection which is worth more than what they tried to low ball her for. I'd avoid this shop completely and save yourself some time #ripoff read more

The owner was very easy to work with and gave fair price for items put to sell very happy with deals struck and would recommend if you need to sell i'm sure you will be more then satisfied with what this broker has to offer. . ask for Buddy read more

Went to keystone. To start off , raggedy looking establishment. Nothing looks organized everything is old and dirty looking and the staff there match. The customer service is terrible. Some of the women there always have an attitude, and have spoken to me rudely. The owner is unorganized, tends to be unresponsive when called, and shady with business dealings to say the least. He tried to swindle me out of my money and got defensive because I knew better. I'd go to a trap house before going to them. If I can offer them a suggestion get a new owner, preferably one who doesn't try to scam you out of your hard earned cash,clean up and practice being nice to people and maybe you'll be able to elevate that sorry excuse for a business into something respectable. :) read more

Stopped by this place, bought a little 90%, liked the price. Went back home to get a grand to stock up a little more and they closed 50 minutes early. I had a 32-mile drive. Guys if you could, give me a slight break on price next time i come in and all good. I'll retract and upgrade review. What a bummer! read more

Man these guys are kind of mean. I came in looking to buy either some silver dollars or half dollars, basically for one purpose. I'm thinking of taking a magic course this year, and wanted four decent sized coins to play about with, to learn some slight of hand moves with something more substantial than a quarter. I wanted not great coins, just something I wouldn't care if I wore down, scratched up, etc.. I explained this pretty clearly, and was looking for some scrap silver, basically. I didn't tell them that my wife and I actually do have a small but decent collection of good Sliver coins, and I've bought coins before. Maybe I should have. Well let me tell you, they treated me like I was a bumpkin. First they tried to up sell me silver proof dollars, which was not really my goal at all, totally not my needs. When I said no to that, they offered me Kennedy half dollars, at about 25% over spot price, by total weight, when I know darn well they are only 40% silver. So they wanted $7.00 per coin on a coin whose melt value is about $2.10. I could take a markup, but that was ridiculous. Their attitude was also awful, they basically made it clear I was wasting their time just even being there. I mentioned the percentage of silver, and that I both looked up the spot value before coming out, and expected a a mark up, but the attitude was 'the price is the price', and they also made it very clear that they sold 'LOTS of bags of these' and that my trying to buy just four coins was a real pain in the arse, and why was I wasting their time? With the implied, if you are buying only a couple coins how dare you negotiate or criticize our prices? Almost I even agreed to buy the coins, It isn't a lot of money, and traffic has sucked recently. It would have been worth spending the extra ten bucks for my purpose just because I had already driven out. But they don't even take credit cards? I didn't take any cash, and I wasn't about to write them a check, with their attitude. I'm kind of glad I they don't take credit cards, after thinking about it, very glad I didn't spend any money there. Let me be clear, for the first time I ever walked in, and a small transaction? I am not obsessed over the price. The entire attitude was sour. Well, poor customer service, sketchy vibe too. Too bad for them, we have considered looking for a place to sell our nice small set of Morgan and Liberty dollars all in good condition. Or also, alternatively to add to it, and fill some holes (which I'd prefer) depending on how the finances go this year. I think it is going to be the later. So I was kind of auditioning them with a small transaction. I hoped to find a nice reputable dealer. Let's say they did not meet my expectation of someone I'd do future business with. I'd stay away. They made it clear they don't want my business, so they aren't going to get it. read more

It is hit or miss here. If you want to buy/sell silver, ensure you call ahead to get a quote or you may be in for a surprise . One day I called when the spot price was hovering around $32. They told me their price their current sell price was $33 ($1 over spot). Not bad! Pretty close to spot. I came down and bought a few coins. A week later, the spot price had dropped down to $31 or so so I figured I could buy for even less than the previous week. I called them up to get a quote and they told me their price was $34! ($3 over spot)... So lets summarize this: The spot price DROPPED and their prices went UP. Didn't make much sense to me. They lost out on a sale because their prices are all over the map and seem totally random and non competitive. I ended up making a large purchase online instead. read more

Dont trust these people they give you one quote by phone then when you get there they drop price even know the silver price goes up.. I'll never go to sell there again..bad bad place read more

I went in to sell a piece of jewelry. Very fair. They have great ratings on Google so I don't get why the reviews here aren't good.

Wanted to sell my coin collection. I had done extensive research on the value of each piece of the collection. Called Keystone Rare Coins and set up an appointment to have the collection evaluated. Went in the next day. The transaction went very smoothly. Knowledgeable, polite, and professional! No pressure. No hassle. I received a very fair payment for the collection. Tips for selling coin collections: Be organized! Have the coins and currency separated, organized, and labeled. Be realistic about the value of your coins. Research the value of your "rare" coins before you sell. You may be surprised to learn that not every old coin is worth more than it's face value. read more

You can rely on receiving fair prices here whether buying or selling. Anybody who may think otherwise is not savvy as to the frequent and illogical changes in the bullion markets. Keystone works on as small a markup as anybody, and they have been around for many many years, unlike many of these others who pop up and buy what they can and often end up reselling to Keystone. read more

I have dealt with Buddy Kellar at Keystone Rare Coins for a number of years. Awhile back, i sold a number of coins to finance my son's college education. Recently I sold a gold watch belonging to my mother, and received a higher offer than a dealer in my local area. I have always felt I received a good and fair price for my items based on research that I had done, and would not hesitate to recommend them to anyone buying or selling. I am perplexed at the two unfavorable reviews on this site. Their ratings on Google are very good, which I would expect. I have always had a great experience dealing with them over a number of years. Unfortunately, I have no more items to sell, but I would contact them first if the need arose. Thank you so much! read more

The most ethical,honest coin store in the valley for 35 years ! I know, I've been their customer that long ! Don't get ripped off ! Go to Keystone ! read more