When "okay" is decent…read more Crosby's took over Arrow Mart awhile ago and made some changes. They installed new pumps and rearranged the store a bit. Okay is when a business might not be the most comprehensive nor best managerially but still worth patronizing. This fueling/convenience store happens to be situated on the favorable corner of a major intersection. Their building, and pumps are situated such that you can fuel out of the major prevailing winds during the winter. And the pumps are under a canopy. Fairly easy in&out. Easier than 7-11 on opposite corner. McDonald's next door. CVS across the road on other corner. Strip mall on the 4th other corner with Fingerlakes Coffee Roasters, AutoZone, pizza shop, Chinese take out, liquor store. Aldi is close by. Gas prices are competitive for the location. Food & beverage prices are what you expect. Crosby's also operates the adjoining Subway store so, at times, the clerk will be assisting them or stocking. It's a lean operation. Crosby's also did away with selling coffee but there's an excellent coffee house across the road. They're stringent with "ID'ing" including lottery tickets so be prepared to offer your ID. Also they sometimes tend to only accept NY State ID's which can be a nusiance for tourists or out-of-state visitors. The employees have always been pleasant and helpful which is a plus. [ I rarely give out 5-stars because, well, that takes incredible achievement.] This Crosby's gets 3.5 stars.

ARROW MART Convenience Store. Your average convenience store, 8 pumps, beer/cigs,…read morelottery,milk,coffee, etc. NOTE: they only accept NY State issued IDs. Connected directly to a Subway Shop. Open 24/7/365. McDonald's next-door. Fairly easy-in/easy-out.

Can't believe I haven't reviewed this place yet, considering I'm in here all the time. Overall I'd…read morehave to say it's one of the cleanest places I've ever been to, restrooms are usually very nice looking, the staff seems to keep up on making sure the store itself is presentable. Everyone is friendly and more than happy to help with random questions. I did however only give it three stars which I'm thinking maybe four stars, only ding them one star for what I'm about to say but it's one of my pet peeves, one of the things that really bugs the crap out of me, so I took away two stars.. I drive a lot as most people do that come to a truck stop and when fueling up I like to wash the window. This place has really good window washer fluid by the gas pumps it actually suds up a little bit when washing your window. The squeegees are always brand new looking and have really long handles, and the washer fluid itself is in a big 5 gallon bucket so they typically are never empty. (Unlike Speedway gas stations where they are always empty).. But anyway for the past 2 or 3 weeks, I've noticed that the washer fluid out by the pumps is getting a little slushy. It really shouldn't do this if it's mixed properly and with the amount of grime on the window even being slushy it still worked but I could see the problem developing. Sure enough I go in there this morning and all of them are frozen solid. I did ask a couple times over the past couple weeks to random employees about it and I got a shoulder shrug from one and another one a few days later said that it's awfully cold out. This of course was my point but my interpretation was they didn't feel like going outside to do anything about it because it's awfully cold out. I know a lot of you are probably thinking I'm making a big deal out of this but it's my personal preference. I'll pay an extra $0.20 a gallon for the gas if I can wash my windows.

This place is always so clean... gas pumps, restrooms & store area…read more Hungry? They have a great selection of snacks, sandwiches and drinks. Small gift items, too. Friendly staff. Would definitely recommend.

Amazing owners are continually improving. The same employees day in day out which tells you its a…read morepositive workplace! amazing fish fry / shrimp... on that special weekend every month. Been shopping and stopping at this store for 45+ years. Best owners since Harold Langdon 35 years ago. Stop in say hello to Patty, Steve & The gang... Don't forget your sarcasm card. just watch out pulling in and out. It's a rural highway 55mph, two intersections, and big trucks frequent this rural country store, making some big blindspots at times.

Their pizza is awesome! Loaded with cheese and not expensive at all. I highly recommend them!read more

The Dandy is a godsend for this area. They are convenient store XL. Their location is perfect!…read more Their parking lot is huge, and they even have a place for RV's and Trucks to pump gas. It can be busy, but never waiting for a pump. They also have an easy order fast food, for this area that's a big deal. Run in for milk, beer, snacks, whatever. They will have it. Employees always nice and work hard. The place is clean, bathrooms always clean.

So happy to see this gas station. This area used to be a "gas desert"! Rt 414 is now easier to…read morenavigate without having to hit a side village first to fill up!

Friendly staff. Great spot to pick up a pizza, burger or sub. Prices are fair it's a good local…read morestop for lunch and clean. I'll be back. My roast beef sub was YUMM!

Awesome Friday fish fry. Hubby says the breakfast sandwiches are to die for! Great for breakfast…read moreand lunch.

Not realizing my mom picked up a drink and after drinking the whole thing realized that it expired…read morein October of 2025... For reference it's March of 2026.

Very convenient location and the staff is very friendly. Great variety of goods for such a small…read morestore.

Not very often can you get a receipt from the pump . You can't move your car from the pump before…read moreyou walk in to get a receipt from the cashier or someone else pulls up to the pump and clears your amount off before you get to the cashier. This store has the laziest employees!

management needs to pay attention to the pumps and make sure they are in working order and…read moredistribute paper receipts. its a very busy station and locals and tourists depend on it. it reflects poorly on the village of Dundee to have a business that is not well run. Are all Dandy Marts like this or is the one in Dundee the ugly stepchild?? It's a shame!