If you are looking for great pizza, don't let the "limited" atmosphere of this restaurant make you…read morego elsewhere. The pizza is absolutely fantastic, the service is friendly, and the prices are reasonable. Having grown up in the NYC metro area, I am pretty demanding when it comes to pizza. This place serves some of the best anywhere, better than a lot of the places I've tried in the city and in NJ. If it was in the city instead of a small town in NC, it would absolutely contend for the best of NY award!

This is okay-good pizza. Not authentic at all…read more The crust and sauce are the highlight, but only when it's fresh. Ground beef as a topping? No Pizza Regina? And I'm not sure what's going on with the toppings on that Supreme. All that said... it's probably the better pizza place in Newton. But you don't have to go far to find better.

Wow. Super fantastic pizza!! First time trying Geppeto's…read moreand I wasn't at all disappointed. I opted for delivery and placed my order online (mobile phone). Delivery time was less than expected and less than promised (which is always a good thing). I got the "original" crust which I thought was a little thin for original but it was great. Very good flavor crust. Toppings were very fresh and tasty. I wish there were more of these in the Charlotte,NC area!

First time for pizza crust not good very thin and soggy , cheese and bad , sauce bitter . Store…read morebought better

Great Italian food best around love the Alfredo and pizzas and baked spaghetti and cheese calzones…read moreEverything here is delicious

Food is amazing extremely affordable! I had Mild wings delicious crispy with their house made…read moreranch. The chicken Alfredo I got for lunch the next day pictured below after reheating in the oven 10/10. Service was amazing very friendly helpful & caring staff. Go see them!

Place is a small and nothing fancy with just a small counter at the window for seating, so you…read moreshould order to go or have it delivered. Order pizza and wings, the pizza is a bit on the oily side but still good and the wings were good, cooked nice and crisp. Their online ordering requires a cell number, which is unnecessary, just their way of getting more customer information, I would like to order pizza not sign up for a barrage a text messages.

The pizza here is delicious. They also pack it with toppings so you definitely get your moneys…read moreworth. It is a NY style and the flavors on the pizza balance pretty well. The meat came through a bit more on this pizza, but that was to be expected. They are always friendly and quick inside making pizzas and taking orders! I would recommend this place to anyone wanting some good NY style pizza in NW Hickory.

In Conover visiting our daughter and husband. For dinner they took my wife, two grandkids, and…read morehere. I was cautious about a pizza place next to a gas station. Wow, was I surprised. There are movie themed decorations all around. Robocop, Gremlins, Back to the Future and others. Pinball machines in one area, and a Glaw machine with space creatures in another. Very colorful and fun ambiance. Our daughter suggested the Salad / Pizza / Pasta / Soup buffet. We agreed and started with salads from a great variety of choices, even Green Peas, my favorite. Grandkids went straight for pizza slices - several times. Excellent salad fixings. The adults started on pizza, and a great variety of pizzas available, not just a couple. My son-in-law mentioned they always had three different soups at same end of pasta choices. He came back with a bowl of Italian Wedding soup, his favorite. When I finished my salad ( I try to eat slowly with good food) and got a bowl of that soup. Hot and delicious! I ate every bite of it. Then I tried a bowl of a creamy soup that looked like Potato soup but with Broccoli and Carrots. It was also very good but Italian Wedding soup was the best. My grandson, a HS Senior football player, about 280, came back with a small bowl of spaghetti, and about a dozen meatballs balanced carefully on top! He mentioned they also had Lasagna. Wow. I passed the pasta and grabbed a piece of Mexican pizza - hello delicious Taco! And also took a piece of Apple Pie pizza, my daughter's suggestion. It was wonderful! Best ever. Our server, Ash, was unbelievable! It was a busy time with most tables taken, but she managed to keep our drinks filled, our plates cleared, and asking if we needed anything. Wonderful food, great fun ambiance, and top notch service. This a pizza place on Steroids! If you're in the area, you must try it!

I love there food everything is always delicious delivery always on time and very nice. Food is…read morealways hot.

I placed a pick up order for the Slice/Side & Drink combo. For $11.31, taxes included, I was able…read moreto get a huge Slice of Pepperoni Pizza, a Side Garden Salad & a Sweet Tea. It was easy to place my order online & it was ready when I went in for pick up. Staff greeted me as I entered & I was quickly helped & on my way. The restaurant appeared clean & there was plenty of seating. Overall, I think it's a good place to grab a quick, affordable bite.

Food was good. Kids meal one of the few still at that price (drink included). In and out both needs…read morecleaning, but most esp outdoor seating! Line could be long during meal times since they also have a lot of phone/online orders. Service was so-so.

Beautiful restaurant. The most amazing food. Our service was a little off however I enjoyed the…read moreexperience. I am assuming with the crowd, might have been a little to navigate with the wine tasting. Etc. When I say the best goat dip cheese ever!!!!

My friends & I met here on Friday afternoon for a drink & some bites. First, I want to say that I…read moreloved the vibe & decor. They offer a variety of seating options from the bar to tables to couches, as well as a patio out back. We started off at the bar for a drink. I tried to order a couple of beers they happened to be out of so I settled on the Mango Wine slushie, which was huge & had such a good flavor. We then ordered a couple of Flatbreads & Goat Cheese Dip that everyone loved. The rest of their menu looked amazing as well so I want to go back & try a variety. It was very laid back environment. We were there early so it was not too busy. We noticed a lot more people trickling in as a musician was setting up for live music. Do not be fooled by all of the work downtown - the roads are navigable & there is plenty of parking nearby!

Just stopped in to grab a pizza for lunch at Papa John's. Great service! I asked for a couple of…read moreextra peppers. He totally hooked me up. And then my girlfriend asked if I could get some plates after I had walked out. I went back in, and the guy was very glad to accommodate my needs. Great spot make sure to let them have plenty of your business.

They do not like to honor their closing times. We went to go order a pizza for carry out, but they…read morewere closed 30 minutes earlier than what is on their door. The store is way so bright on the inside that one needs sunglasses at night just to see. They do have a good flavor, but their portion sizes are too small for their prices.

Ordered a Deluxe Salad and picked it up. Back at the office I discovered it had no meat. I called…read moreand asked if it should, the lady said yes, took my name and number and said they would make it right. The next day I called to get a correct one. The lady that answered said I could get the meat free, but would have to pay for the vegetables. Wow. A wasted trip and not the food I ordered. Now I need to drive back and pay for their mistake? Passing on chubbys mediocre customer service going forward.

Extremely costly and our food (subs) were only mediocre at best. We did not eat inside so not sure…read moreof service. Not my favorite.