Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lucy's Cakes and Cafe

    4.2 (5 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 3:00 pm

    Lucy's Cakes and Cafe Photos

    LUCY'S CAKES AND CAFE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Lucy's Cakes and Cafe

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Custom Golf Carrot Cake

    Lucy's Cakes was so wonderful to work with while planning a friend's birthday before going on vacation in St. Thomas. We had a beautiful, golf-themed carrot cake and a delicious raspberry cheesecake. Though there was a hiccup in timing, the staff at Lucy's made sure the Birthday event went off without a hitch by delivering the cake directly to us -- showing their dedication to honoring their customer. The carrot cake was perfectly made with an amazing custom tastiness, and you could tell the cheesecake was made with fresh ingredients! I would certainly consider ordering from Lucy's when visiting the island in the future.

    One-tier rum cake with pineapple and coconut cream filling. Decorated with natural orchids and hand-painted detailing.

    See all

    Photo of Ry M.
    81
    264
    3941

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 208 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery - The line at the counter. Be prepared.

    Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery

    4.6(93 reviews)
    0.7 km
    $$

    Everything here was amazing. I was surprised to see such a variety of drink in the menu. Everything…read morefrom coffee to chai and matcha to a golden milk latte. They are constantly coming out with hot and fresh baked pastries to restock the pastry case with, so whenever you come it you will always get a fresh and warm baked good with top notch flavor. I went with the Chai and it was one of the best I have had! I added lavender syrup to it and the flavor was there in the beginning and was really yummy. As for the spinach and feta croissant, it was amazingly buttery and flaky and overall the perfect pastry! The cashier that helped us was very welcoming and kind. The line moved quick and was filled with locals so you know it's a good place to get your start for the day. There is plenty of seating inside to enjoy your food, but also really easy to take in the go. Love me it here and will 100% be coming back

    We stayed at the Hampton Inn and a nearby AirBnB for a wedding recently and this was our go-to spot…read morefor coffee and pastries in the morning. The coffee (and other beverages) were great, but what really stood out were the pastries. Excellent pain au chocolate, bread pudding, and other assorted savory breakfast pastries. Freshly made with flaky crust, truly delicious. On top of that, the service was efficient, they have a decent amount of seating, and the prices were reasonable. Highly recommend if you are staying in the area or just visiting on a cruise ship and you need a snack or pick-me-up!

    Photos
    Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery - Inside

    Inside

    Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery - Order here!

    Order here!

    Stir It Up Coffee Shop & Bakery

    See all

    Shama's Specialties - Oxtail, mac and cheese, pigeon peas and rice; rasta pasta with shrimp

    Shama's Specialties

    4.7(50 reviews)
    1.8 km
    $$

    Our original choice for lunch didn't work out and as we were wondering around, a kind local led us…read moreto Shama's. It was the BEST accident. We were immediately and graciously greeted by our hostess/server/bartender all-in-one Tiffany. She had the most charismatic personality and smile. I loved her energy! She explained the menu to us first timers and she even brought us complimentary drinks to try! The menu basically featured an array of proteins (chicken, shrimp, wings, salmon, etc) and sauces (jerk, creole, teriyaki, and the special shama sauce) you can pair it with. Sadly they no longer serve curry goat and they were out of oxtail the day we went. Each order also comes with choice of 2 sides. I ordered the jerk salmon with side of rice and peas and plantains. My salmon was perfectly cooked and seasoned. I loved the slightly peppery spice from the jerk seasoning. The plantains were delicious. The rice was a little dry for my taste but went well with my salmon. My fiancé got the wings in shama sauce and this was SO GOOD. Would recommend. He also got a massive portion order of macaroni and cheese. They definitely make sure you don't leave hungry here. My friend got the shrimp and it was nicely seasoned as well. Prices were very reasonable for the portion. Everything was so plentiful! I had enough leftovers for a second meal. The only reason I can't give this 5 stars is the ambiance. The decor is very bare bone and feels like much more of a take out place than somewhere you would go for a nice lunch. There's also two TVs and they blast the sound here which can be very distracting when your group is trying to have a conversation. The bathroom could also use some TLC. Otherwise, the service and food was definitely a 5 stars experience for me. Would gladly return next time I'm in Saint Thomas!

    Our server Tiffany is the absolute BOMB. The kindest most accommodating service we got on the…read moreisland!! The food was pretty bomb too. We had the Rasta pasta, rice with pigeon peas, mixed veg and plantains on our first stop here. Jerk chicken was extremely tender and the sauce was the perfect amount of spice. The food did feel a little oily/fatty but we still mopped up our plates! They were out of baked Mac but certainly hope we can try it on the future, yum. Decent sized portions but everything was delicious and we wanted more! Prices are reasonable and match the portion sizes.

    Photos
    Shama's Specialties - Jerk Chicken, Steamed Veggies, and Seasoned Rice

    Jerk Chicken, Steamed Veggies, and Seasoned Rice

    Shama's Specialties - Jerk Chicken, Potato Salad and Rice and Peas

    Jerk Chicken, Potato Salad and Rice and Peas

    Shama's Specialties - Jerk chicken

    See all

    Jerk chicken

    Calypso Cafe - Black bean burger.

    Calypso Cafe

    4.6(26 reviews)
    1.7 km

    We didn't get the same positive vibes as other fellow Yelpers. Sorry to say…read more To start, it's a confusing layout in a historical building. You walk through a jewelry store to get to a small restaurant that combines Virgin Islands Ice Cream shop with Calypso Cafe. Most of the seats were taken, and all we saw was a line to place your order at the front. My husband waited in line while I found a table that hadn't been cleaned yet. It was very busy there. He ordered us 2 brownies and 2 bottles of water for $16. The lady at the counter gave herself a tip by taking $3 of the change and giving him back $1. He was going to give her all the change ($4) back, but after that incident he was floored. To add insult to injury, she didn't give us what we paid for. She proceeded to help the next person in line for an ice cream shake order. We waited and waited and no one acknowledged us after trying to flag someone down. We finally got the attention of a different lady who was helping people who were seated in the back. I think her name is Cameron. She didn't fully understand our frustration, and we had to explain that we didn't get the items that we had already paid for. She made it all right, and even offered to warm up the brownies. We just didn't feel like waiting longer for it. I'm giving benefit of the doubt here since maybe we just didn't understand the ordering system. Maybe there's a service charge that we didn't know about. How could we? We didn't even get a receipt. Perhaps there's another line for Calypso Cafe? I don't know. Honestly, the lady at the counter should have informed Cameron before proceeding on to the next customer. It only takes 2 seconds. I mean, really! Will we go back? Absolutely not! We'll go somewhere else the next time we're in Charlotte Amalie. It wasn't worth the long wait for 2 bakery items and water.

    Love love love! Have so many positives things to say. Service is amazing - quick and very kind…read more Portions are very generous and worth the price. The crepe was filled to the brim with fruit (banana and strawberries) and Nutella. We did also opt for whipped cream, but you can ask for without. Latte was STRONG. The omelette was also packed full, this time with various veggies and even ginger! The toast that comes with is plain white toast topped with butter. The space itself is cozy and cute, although hidden. You will have to walk through a jewelry store to find it. Front of the shop is dedicated to coffee and sweets while the back is for main breakfast and lunch dishes. Highly recommend!

    Photos
    Calypso Cafe - Coffee and tea bar

    Coffee and tea bar

    Calypso Cafe - Sweet crepe

    Sweet crepe

    Calypso Cafe - Sandwich/ dining area

    See all

    Sandwich/ dining area

    Lucy's Cakes and Cafe - bakeries - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...