Small neighborhood bar. The pizza was great. Mostly locals and very friendly. Dine in and carry out pizza. Detroit style is not always easy to find but they have it here along with thin and Chicago style. read more

Yummy foods, great customer service, and friendly staff, clean. Never been here but I will come back for sure read more

Magoo's Pub and Pizza - 4 topping pizza - Pubs Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

The food was really good and it was really great service. I recommend this place for everybody.

Pizza was really awesome. Thin and Detroit crust. Service was great and attentive. Fun and loud enough, but could still hear my lovely wife. read more

Magoo's Pub and Pizza - Pubs Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

Limited menu of sandwiches but they focus mainly on pizzas and calzones. Everything I've eaten there so far has been very good.

I am from Chicago and moved down here 30 years ago and have yet to find a pizza close to what I would get in Chicago until Friday night!! Ordered a large deluxe original crust. Was the best pizza hands down here in Lafayette. We will be ordering our pizza from here only. Next we will try it with the thin crust!! Thanks magoo's!!! read more

Very meh. I got wings and bosco sticks carry out. Maybe the food tastes better drunk. The bosco sticks seemed a touch overcooked. The cheese inside was not stretchy or melty. The nacho cheese tasted cheap. The wings were ok. Nothing special. They were tiny. I just didn't want to finish anything because it wasn't as good as I expected. My husband and kids had the pizza, but I did not. They said it was ok, but they'd rather have pizza elsewhere read more

Magoo's Pub and Pizza - Bosco sticks - Pubs Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

The pizzas were great! We loved all the styles. You can't go wrong and the prices are amazing. Service was spectacular. Great sports bar with a bunch of TVs. Highly recommend coming here! read more

If you want a great pizza this is the place. Along with ice cold beer and great service.

A local bar with great food. Love their Chicago style deep dish pizza. Probably best pizza in town in my opinion.

Great thin crust pizza, not fan of the crumble sausage!, besides that, some great wings too!. Love their friendly service and it reminds of a great neighborhood bar. read more

The food was great, ambience super fine! Christmas party going on and we had a really bad service from our waitress (Tami). Apparently she was making judgements about us to excuse her to serve us, like you guys are ready for checks when we're not, rudely, after that she brought us the check, cause she judged us drunk! And believe it, she said that in our faces!!!!!!!! Thankfully we were not drunk at all to remember all this. Super inconsistent with what we're expecting from her, since we said that we're not ready for checks. Anyways, hopefully this feedback will help with quality of service! Others waitress around were super friendly. read more

I've lived in Lafayette Indiana my whole life, and I've grown up with Tom Riehle in his establishments around town, and have been...will always be...a big fan of his. Magoos is a small place with big attitude filled with local Northsiders. The wait staff is well trained and very nice! hubs and I were there last Friday because we'd heard rumors of this phenomenon deep dish pizza now being served. We got the Detroit style pepperoni. Holy S%!T was is delicious! Perfectly crusty burnt cheese around the edge just like it's supposed to have. Loads of toppings! The chew to the crust was perfection! You know how sometimes you can catch a glimpse in the kitchen at a place and wonder if you should actually eat the food after seeing what you've seen? Well, not here. There's a large opening for you to look right in, and the chef is amazing! The live music is always great! The patrons are incredible. We were bellied up to the bar and in no time everyone was laughing to talking with everyone. I think they have cash drawings here as well. I didn't get a pic but the outdoor seating is quite nice too, with speakers so it has ambiance too!! One last thing; even though Tom DOESN'T have Sauvignon Blanc they DO have wine. The Pinot Grigio was surprisingly good for this little hometown bar. They even have challises for you to drink your wine from like every princess should have!!! read more

See all

Stopped in on a Wednesday evening for pizza and beer. We were the first customers in at 4pm. As soon as you open the door, you can smell the pizza. It is slightly overpowering at times but not bad. Magoo's is non-smoking and has a renovated patio for smokers. We ordered the Chicago-style pizza and it took maybe 15 minutes to arrive. It was hot and very filling. I consider this a 'destination pizza'. It is the type of pizza you drive to get because you like it that much. They have everyday tall boys for $3 and other specials. It is a local, after work crowd with a mix of young and old. We always enjoy coming here and look forward to coming back soon. read more

See all

First timer at Magoo's. Great pizza options! 2 members of our party got a rum and coke and I ordered a margarita. Drinks were mixed well. We ordered a 16" Detroit-style pep and sausage and a 16" hand tossed deluxe. Wonderful! The Detroit-style had a nice caramelization of the cheese. Sauce was not too sweet, not too spicy or salty. Definitely looking forward to the next time I go back! read more

See all

Their pizza is the best in town. Hands down. That rhymes and you know it rhymes. Admit it. Also, their beer cheese is exceptional. On top of all that, they are always so friendly when you walk in. You want the best pizza and a smile? Go to Magoo's. read more

I'm a bit of a pizza connoisseur, but I had never heard of Magoo's a week ago. Now, we've had carry out pizza twice in a week. This review is only limited to their Detroit Style deep dish pizza. Both times we had the pepperoni and sausage large. Hands down, this is the best pizza in Tippecanoe County, and probably the surrounding counties. I'll have to try their other pizza styles soon. read more

Stopped here to grab a quick bite. Very quick service, affordable and DELICIOUS! We loved the laid back vibe and friendly feel. Would highly recommend! read more

Magoo's Pub and Pizza - 7 inch pizza - Pubs Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Great takeout pizza. On time and efficient on a busy Friday evening. We ordered cheese bread, thin, original, and deep dish pizzas. Zero complaints from our college kids that are self proclaimed pizza experts! read more

The staff very friendly ,food was AMAZING! DEFINITELY a return customer, Very clean, down to earth atmosphere.Cant wait to try the deep dish!!!Nicely done .You all Rock! read more

Pizza and house salad are the best. Brothers say their Stromboli is better than Arni's. A bit noisy. Tables are a bit too cozy with each other. I'd recommend. read more

We stopped in for dinner last night and WOW! We thought the pizza was fantastic. Great flavor in the sauce and the crust was perfection. Bravo..can't wait to stop in again. read more

Pizza is top notch in town. Easily top 5 in Lafayette! Non-smoking, a Plus for dining in.

One week ago, July 13, 2024, my 55th class reunion was at this establishment. Arrangements were made beforehand, and the owner and staff were extremely accommodating and professional! We had our reunion in the outside dining area. Food was excellent, service was wonderful and the atmosphere was great! They even made arrangements to accommodate special requests I had. My thanks to the owner and his wonderful staff! read more

Magoo's Pub and Pizza - Decided to dress up for the occasion, being as I wasn't able to make the formal event the next evening. - Pubs Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

Small college town feel with fantastic pizza. It's a must try and the prices are great.

If you haven't tried Magoo's Pizza, you are missing out. Their pizza and breadsticks are the best in town!

I have been to Magoos three times now and haven't had the best experiences, the first time I ordered a regular hand tossed pepperoni and sausage and got a sausage and onion barbecue pizza, very surprised to take a bite and find out it was a BBQ pizza so obviously they gave me the wrong order, I tried again and ordered a regular hand tossed with pepperoni and sausage and it was done correctly but didn't wow me what so ever, I do like Detroit style pizza occasionally so I read on the menu that a small two topping 8 pc was $14.00 and was made in sqares with crust then toppings the cheese and sauce on the top which is a traditional way of making Detroit style pizzas, I didn't look at the pizza when I picked it up which was a mistake and the $14.00 two topping 8 pc pizza turned into a $17.80 6 pc pizza with little to no sauce and the sauce was not on the top it was under the cheese and topping which is not how it says they make it on their own menu, so even with tax it shouldn't have been more the $15.00 and it looks like they charged $14.00 for the pizza plus added a charge for the two toppings that the menu said it came with, bottom line either they have no clue how to make a Detroit style pizza and have no clue what the menu says on there website or they word the menu sketchy so you don't understand the preparation and actual cost, my experiences have led me to the point that I probably won't go back anytime soon and if I do ot will be to try the Chicago deep dish which is one of my favorite if not my favorite style of pizza anywhere, but due to the high cost of their Chicago deep dish it scares me to order something I won't like or enjoy, my advice to the owner or management would be to look at the website and and make sure your menu items are correctly priced and make the pizzas the way your menu says or write how you prepare your Detroit style pizzas because you do not prepare them the way it says on the menu read more

Great pizza, great service. Very cool local vibe. Dropping our kid off at Purdue and stopped in on a Sat night. Very friendly patrons as well. A+. Will be back. read more

Best in Lafayette. Pizza best. Service a+. Pricing low. Only place that bill shows two prices. With credit card or cash payment. We return for sure!!! read more

Found this gem of a place while we were searching for food during Purdue parents weekend. Close to campus and the pizza is outstanding. Great neighborhood pub atmosphere and our server was lovely. read more