Our class routinely eats at Matteo's, lucky enough to have Jamie as our waitress. Much to our dismay, we found her gone on our last trip, and it was glaringly obvious. Jamie is, obviously, excellent with people and provides a wonderful dining experience while at Matteo's. Whatever forced her to leave, it is our hope that someone ,who wishes the place to succeed, would do their best to return the best employee they had to one of our favorite restaurants. Otherwise, we will do our best to fine her. Bernie Dettorre. read more

Picked up take out here, first time trying Matteos. Ordered calamari, meatballs, and Pig and FIg flatbread - all were very good, portion size very good, meatballs had a great texture and taste profile. The calamari is hand breaded, and while I didn't care for the side sauce that accompanies the squid, that was due to my personal preference...the actual calamari was well seasoned and more than acceptable on its own. The Pig and Fig flatbread was unique and well appointed with ingredients, edge to edge, with a nice crust and cooked well. Parking was a breeze, the owner Jessica was out front and gave me a quick tour of the bar and dining rooms, and the order was on time and presented well. As noted in several other reviews, service appears to be friendly and warm. We will be back, and are planning a night out with local friends in the area to visit soon. In today's restaurant environment where so many things are hit and miss, Matteo's definitely hit the mark for a take home dinner for us. read more

This place is consistently amazing! We came as a large group a year ago and really enjoyed it! So when we found ourselves all gathered back in Middleburg Heights again this year we made reservations and they graciously accommodated our group of 20. Our server, Gina was very helpful, friendly, outgoing, and did an amazing job taking care of our large group! The food was excellent too! Their stuffed peppers weren't spicy, like I like, but the filling and sauce was so darn tasty! Their papperdelle was incredible! The brisket in the Pappardelle Al Cinghaile was tender and the entire sauce was flavored nicely! Overall, another excellent meal! If you're ever in the area, stop in and give them a try! read more

See all

So, if you are looking for a tasty snack, go to Matteo's and grab one of their appetizers. You can have a meatball or mozzarella or, either of my favorites: stuffed peppers or calamari with artichokes and olives, which is what I had today and because the portion is so large, is what I will be having for lunch tomorrow! Jamie is a great waitress. Friendly and easy to work with. The restaurant is quaint, as is the area. Enjoy and shop around. read more

Matteo's Casual Italian - Sicilian Calamari - Pizza Near Me - Olmsted Falls, Ohio

They were very good at paying attention to my food allergies and making me a plate of food custom for me. My husband liked his food very much. The area around the restaurant is also very cool. The service was quick, the inner dining area was clean and very open. read more

See all

Food and service was excellent, went during the busy dinner hour but service was timely. We are frequent visitors to this restaurant.

Everything we ate at Matteo's an Italian restaurant located in the heart of Historic Olmsted Falls was delicious! Make sure to try the famous homemade cannolis! I do wish some of the cocktails were prettier since they tasted so good! Excellent service and recommendations! Plenty of Parking available in the lot! Cocktails Limoncello Mojito Elderflower Basil Smash Espresso Martini Chocolate Martini White Russian Dinner Chicken Parmigiana Italian Sausage Wedding Soup Chicken Dumpling Soup Fresh Baked Bread read more

See all

Absolutely wonderful experience. From the food to the servers everything was perfect and I can't wait to go back again!!

Ordered the Lasagna, great presentation but it didn't taste good at all. They use frozen sausage balls. If you're making Italian food, just use fresh items. read more

Made a reservation for 6, but ended up having 7 and they were very accommodating even on a busy Friday night. I shared a bottle of wine and for $34 (that price is unheard of it), it was amazing. The bread for the table was warm and soft. I got one of the specials and it was so delicious. The servings are all really big, which leftovers Italian is always yummy. All the entrees come with salad or soup too! Everyone enjoyed their meals. read more

I have a few friends who own this place and they really run a great restaurant. We always have an easy time getting a table even with a family of seven. Highly recommend. read more

The food here was absolutely amazing. My wife had the pappardelle and brisket ragu, I had a pork chop special. For dessert a pistachio cake. Everything here was so good. We will be back!! read more

Matteo's Casual Italian - The outside of the restaurant. - Pizza Near Me - Olmsted Falls, Ohio

Great food, great service. Lovely atmosphere. Went for lunch. Twice! Fig and pig flatbread - amazing. To be fair, not exactly the flatbread type I'm used to but wonderful crust!!!!!! read more

Oh my gosh.... This place is a dream! Tucked away in a charming old building in the heart of Historic Olmsted Falls! Love this area, it's so adorable. The food is absolutely legendary! I've been here twice in one week! Once for dinner, then today for Sunday brunch. Their crab cakes, are the stuff of legends, seriously! Out of this world. The Caesar salad had excellent flavor. My entree at dinner was beef medallions with truffle oil, risotto and broccolini. It was outstanding! My martinis were perfection. Brunch was a whole 'nother experience. I had chicken and waffles... I cannot express how phenomenal the flavor profile as well as the texture was with this dish. Chicken AND THE WAFFLE, were flawlessly crunchy/crisp then the waffle was perfectly soft inside. The flavor on the breading and syrup was deliciously salty/sweet with a tiny bit of heat! Perfect!! Apologies for the poor quality on the photos... I forgot to take pictures until we had already begun eating. My friend had the crabcake Benedict and it was amazing. PLEASE NOTE~ They only do brunch one day per month! Call ahead to find out when it's being offered. read more

Matteo's Casual Italian - Crab cake Benedict - Pizza Near Me - Olmsted Falls, Ohio

See all

Went here with my daughter and grandson for the Tuesday family deal. We got spaghetti and meatballs, salad, and sundaes. We really enjoyed it. Would like to go back and get the Alfredo. The Tuesday family deal kids eat free is totally worth it. read more

I had purchased a $100 gift card for my daughter only to find out that it was not accepted because the restaurant changed owners again and they wouldn't honor the gift card. Quality of food was not the same. Very disappointing. read more

Website says open Sundays until 8 pm and walk ins welcome anytime without mention that the kitchen closes at a different time We showed up at 7:33 and were told their kitchen closed at 7:30. read more

Drinks strong! Large portions! Service excellent! Wonderful place cute design! Delicious food! read more

See all

Food and drinks were amazing! Excellent service by Jamey! Would recommend going here can't wait to come back! read more

See all

What a very good restaurant. Food was great and service was friendly and professional Would definitely recommend eating here! read more

Matteo's Casual Italian - Grilled Chicken Puttanesca is awesome what a great sauce and flavor - Pizza Near Me - Olmsted Falls, Ohio

4th time here, 1st To-Go order & we were fairly disappointed. The 8 cheese raviolis were dry inside and the sauce was not great & metallic tasting (from a can?). That came w/ a soup. We chose potato leek and it had good flavor but mega salty, like they accidentally doubled the portion. It came in a tiny container and the meal was $20. Yikes. The sauce on the appetizer meatballs was tasty though - more thick & chunky. The meatballs were not mushy at least, like we just had at a place in little Italy. Unfortunately there were only 3 included in the appetizer! That was hard to believe at $14.00! The cheese pizza was French bread style & sorta small at $14 but it was tasty & cheesy. So for $48 it was just enough to feed 3. Not a great value so we would likely not get a to go order again. The order came out 10 mins before quote so luckily we were early. read more

See all

Popped in for an early Saturday dinner at the bar. Their sauce is amazing. Great wine and cocktails. Staff was friendly and helpful. Will definitely go back. Can't wait to have our leftovers! read more

My fiancé and I stopped by here with her son to try out some of the dishes from their menu as we plan to use this location for our reception. This restaurant is a beautiful place, roomy, and quite comfortable. We tried out the shrimp Matteo on the idea that we will be using the chicken Matteo the lemon chicken and the chicken marsala. The hostess allowed us to try some of the sauces, the regular red, there marinara, a vinaigrette type of sauce, as well as the lemon sauce that is the base for the lemon chicken and the Matteo sauces. We met the head Chef and there was a small miscommunication between the hostess and the head chef. This will probably be my only Downside is that neither seemed to agree on what would be in one dish or another. The chef informed us that the sauce for the chicken Matteo would be the same as the sauce for the shrimp Matteo except the chicken is breaded. But it would have the capers and the lemony Zest taste. Hostess did not think there was capers in the sauce. I felt the sangria was a little Too red, tart, so we asked for it to be sweetened a little at which point it was yum, and strong. Everything was very very salty though we were informed that the chef adds no salt so it must be some of the additional bits going into the sauce. Capers, of course, are very salty. The chicken marsala seemed to be a bit rubbery than mine, which was the lemon chicken. My chicken was very soft, very tender and very juicy. We did have an issue with two of the desserts. Well, one of the desserts. We ordered two desserts to take home to try and one of them was good and the other had spoiled. We've already been in touch regarding this. All in all I look forward to returning and testing more dishes. read more

We didn't have a good experience with the food months ago but now that it's under new management, we thought we would give it another go. This place did not disappoint. The bread, the pasta and the brussels sprout were very good! We couldn't forget about the tiramisu which was perfect. This place did a big step up. read more

Finally got in for dinner since the new owners took over..felt super festive! Food was fantastic, had the grouper and risotto. Perfectly done.. Loved the appetizer beforehand as well, bruschetta was so good, could have made EE it mmy meal! Love the vibe! read more

Nice little spot in Olmsted Falls. The food was really good, especially the gnocchi and the pappardelle. The server was super nice and friendly, and we didn't wait long despite being very busy. I would definitely come back to try other dishes! read more

Everything about this place was amazing. We went here to celebrate our father's retirement dinner (as a family of 7). Our server, Myra, was amazing and very attentive and knew the menu very well. She also made sure to give us extra attention as we had children and our elderly parents who had special needs. Food was incredible. We had calamari, mussels, arancini and meatballs to start, followed by soup and salad, and we all had entrees. The bread was amazing too. Portions were good, price was what you would expect for an upscale place in a gorgeous setting and everything was cooked perfectly. We finished off with cannoli and gelato. read more

See all

Several years ago, we were there for a golf banquet and assigned to their party room upstairs. Needless to say, I wasn't impressed by the location, menu, or food. read more

We have always enjoyed Matteo's. The new ownership team continues to provide great food and an enjoyable dining experience. We recently held a private event for my wife's retirement at Matteo's. Every aspect of the event from planning to the event itself went well beyond our expectations. Food, service and accommodations were excellent. Jessica made the planning very easy explaining the different food/drink options available. She was very responsive in getting back to me on any questions I had. The Matteo's team was very flexible with the menu allowing us to accommodate various dietary considerations. The food and service during the event were outstanding. Jessica and Deserai attended to all our needs, while the staff working behind the scenes kept the great food coming out. Food was kept replenished and the drinks were served without delay. Kudos to all working the party that day. I highly recommend Matteo's for private parties. We sure will keep them in mind for future events. Many Thanks to the Matteo's team for making our event a very memorable experience. read more

The food and the service did not disappoint. One of the owners was helping run all the food out and always checking on everyone. Which you don't see all the time anymore. It was a nice girls night out. read more

Fabulous food! One of the best meals we've had in a long time. Large portions, innovative specials. and pleasant service. We knew the restaurant was changing hands a while back; it seems the new owners have improved on what was already a great place. We'd absolutely recommend a visit. read more

Probably some of the best meatballs I've had locally. So flavorful and moist. Great friendly service as well. I'm loving the new ownership. Keep up the great work! read more

Great food, vast menu, specials are on point and who doesn't love Olmsted Falls! This was our second visit and the food didn't disappoint, the initial service wasn't so good, but did I mention the food...it's really good. I opted for the scallops this time around, perfectly seasoned and cooked, not overdone. The beet salad was amazing, so good I almost ordered a second one. I tried my husbands pasta and the sauce was authentic. We have had the opportunity to sit in the main dining room and the bar, admittedly the service is spotty, my opinion but I feel like unless you are regular the wait staff seems to overlook you. But...the food makes up for it. I like to think everyone has an off night or two. read more

See all

Excellent lunch with many choices. We had three different entrees and all were delicious. Tremendous service by Jaimey.

We enjoyed every minute of our dinner, from the food, (the butternut squash ravioli was to die for), to the generous pours of wine. Matteo's was very clean with a friendly atmosphere. The added touch was meeting the new owners, Jessica & Daniel who were a delight to hear their story. I would highly recommend this restaurant. read more

Had lunch today at Matteo's with old friends! The kitchen with Tony Rocco did not disappoint. The food was absolutely delicious. And our server, Jamey, did an outstanding job. She is so pleasant and the pace was perfect. This is a great place to gather with friends! read more

The food is always great, the waitstaff is attentive, but the kitchen is SLOW. Really slow, every time we've been here.

Great place, I called about a week ahead for reservations, asked about their scotch selection because my friend from out of town was going with us and he preferred a certain brand that they normally didn't have, she said she would look into it and when our group arrived she had the scotch waiting for us!! I haven't been surprised in a good way by a restaurant for years. Anyway the food was outstanding with good portions and the staff was excellent. Other restaurants need to study Matteo's to learn about customer service. Thank you! read more

Food was outstanding and service was excellent. Casual dining but still upscale. Highly recommend.

This usted to be one of our favorite restaurants. But since they got new owners menu has changed staff is a little rude . And they have so many flys in the restaurant. My husband and I decided not to return any more it doesn't feel like a family restaurant anymore they just get you in and out like a factory and if there's something wrong with ur food they don't try to fix it. Sad was a good place read more