Went to The Brick Oven tonight with my cousins for dinner, and I can't believe it took me over 20 years of living in the area and driving past it countless times to finally try it! I ordered the prosciutto chicken with a glass of Moscato, and it was absolutely excellent. The chicken was perfectly cooked, and the sauce was rich and full of flavor. We were also served fresh-baked bread with whipped garlic butter to start, which was the perfect touch and a great way to kick off the meal. Everyone at the table thoroughly enjoyed their dishes, and the overall experience was warm and inviting. Definitely looking forward to coming back again! read more

The Brick Oven - Prosciutto Chicken - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

My first time here I like to start out positive the staff was really nice. I ordered pizza margarita the dough was really good and cooked amazing the only issue was it had zero taste the sauce was bland nothing had taste to it. They use big diced tomatoes on it they should be sliced in my opinion but either way they had no taste. Also got chicken parm the chicken was good but the side of pasta was low quality mushy watery pasta. Maybe attention to detail this place could be good. I usually like to try places twice maybe it was just an off day. read more

Ordered take out pizza Sunday 7/19/26. The pizza was very good. Crust was excellent and I was glad they put very little sauce on it. I will definitely order pizza from here in the future. Price was very reasonable as well read more

Waitress was super nice. The wedding soup was so salty neither of us could eat it. The broccolini was good. My mom wasn't thrilled with the pizza. The best part was the Waitress. I doubt we will go back. It wasn't the easiest to get in. I had to move their statue and open the gate to get my mom in. read more

See all

Our first visit to this place. Best part of meal was the fresh, warm, chewy Italian bread. I ordered cavatelli. Husband ordered chicken brocolini. Both ordered Italian wedding soup. Soup was just AWFUL! It actually tasted burnt. I requested that someone in the kitchen taste the soup because there was something wrong with it. We both sent the full cups of soup back and were never offered the salad instead. Nothing was taken off the check and when I asked at the end of the meal what happened about the soup...the waitress said that they said it was fine. Cavatelli was just ok. $23 for meat sauce and 1 meatball. Nothing special. Husband's dish had undercooked broccoli and a bland white sauce. When we were offered parmesean cheese and pepperflakes I said yes to the Parma cheese and was delivered a little plastic cup with a lid that had about a teaspoon of cheese in it. For the price I would expect to get fresh grated parm. If they are serving powdered parm, couldn't they just put a shaker on the table? We were disappointed and will not return. read more

Being seniors in our 70's the choice of smaller portions which were just the right size. The food and service was excellent, we will probably go a couple times a week. read more

Came in on a Friday during lent for the fish fry and veggie lasagna. Took forever to get waited on, but service improved after that. The chowder had big chunks of veggies in it, but was very light on the clams and flavor. The walleye looked beautiful, but had a very strong fishy taste to it---not good. Also got a side of pirogies which were excellent. The cabbage and noodles was the best item on the table. The lasagna was okay, but also lacked a lot of flavor. The men's room stunk like sewer gas. read more

The Brick Oven - Vegetable lasagna - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

See all

Amazing food. This is my new go to Italian place. Homemade. Fresh. The bread the pasta the sauce excellent. Will try pizza next. Nice staff. read more

The Brick Oven - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

The anchovies and onion pizza was a disaster. Out of the whole pizza tasted anchovies three times. After first piece I told waitress they forgot anchovies. She went back to kitchen and told me they are blended into the pizza. After paying for Anchovies I expect to taste anchovies! Not my kind of place. read more

This restaurant sponsors a Classic Car Show on Wednesday's 5 pm on. During that time the restaurant offers a reasonably priced buffet outside. If I'm not mistaken it's $10 for one trip and $24 if you want to go up for three trips. They have a DJ playing car show music. Local classic car enthusiast are there with there beautiful cars. This show will go until the end of September. My husband and I like eating from the menu inside. He really likes there spaghetti and meatballs, I've tried their pizza and chicken club sandwich. The waiter is such a nice guy. He always makes sure that he makes our food just right. The restaurant is very clean and spacious. read more

The Brick Oven - Dining room - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

excellent service and great dinner....haven't gone there in a long time...we were pleasantly surprised.

Just walked in and so far so good. Got seated right away. Ordered Caesar salad. Wings as an app. And the Rosso pizza to see if I can finally find good pizza near Cleveland. Caesar came out and was great. Lite hand made dressing. The wings were also crispy and good. Large order of wings. Really good. Flavor was good could have used a flavored flour to give it a little more flavor but all in all good and cooked perfectly. So far so good. Well the pizza came out and wow was I disappointed. I still haven't found any place that understands pizza in Cleveland. Too much flop, too much cheap tough too eat cheese. Dough was great and it was cooked perfectly but way too my much cheese. Service was great. read more

Stopped in to this little Italian restaurant after some shopping and it did not disappoint at all! The food was amazing! The I had the cavatelli and meatball was absolutely perfect made! I can't wait to come back again.. he had the chicken picatta and I don't think he took a breath between bites! We also ordered the stuffed peppers which were fairly spicy (which I was warned about) and he devoured read more

See all

Love love love their food! Cozy atmosphere, Great service! One of my favorite places to get some amazing Italian food!

If you like Italian - go here!! Husband had chicken prosciutto and said it was delicious I had veal parm and loved it!! We will be back read more

The Brick Oven - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

See all

Nice and modern interior decor. Service here is fantastic (ask for Alyssa!). The owner also comes around and greets people. Food is pretty good. I had the basic meat ravioli which was just ok, but the menu is pretty large so, I will visit again and try something else. read more

See all

This is one of my favorite restaurants and my favorite dish! Service is fantastic, it's a little hidden gem in Middleburg Hts. read more

The Brick Oven - Shrimp and Angel hair pasta in a Lobster Romano sauce - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

We came here for Mother's Day, first time here, and it probably won't be a go-to for us. Our waitress was so sweet and attentive. I ordered the pasta special, which said it was cheese ravioli with crab on top in a creamy sauce. The sauce was delicious, as was the ravioli, but there really wasn't crab on top......it was imitation crab, which was really disappointing. Not worth the $25 price tag, that's for sure. I also ordered a side salad to go with it, which was underwhelming.......one small grape tomato, one small cucumber slice, and a few slices of shaved carrot, though the white balsamic dressing was pretty good. My boyfriend ordered the Bianca pizza with sausage added (which they skimped on), and it wasn't bad overall. Anyway, I know they've been around for a while, but I don't see us coming back here anytime soon. read more

Hate leaving a bad review, but I've been coming here for 10 years and not sure what happened. Used to be great-not so much anymore. Service is awful. Heard the crew swearing and having personal conversations from the kitchen and in the dining room. Our waitress never checked in, took plates, or brought bread. Had to chase down the hostess to get service. The manager ended up boxing my food I hardly ate. All in all, I hope they make changes to turn things around. $70 later, I won't be back anytime soon. read more

First time at this site and I am pleased to say they are checking all the boxes . Italian cuisine (or pizza) has to be one of the most popular and available restaurants anywhere you go. Thus, it is a delight to find those places that are doing it well. While there is an incredibly casual vibe here, they do pay attention to the the issues that can best define a well managed eatery. First off, the place is clean -- from the menus to utensils. The floor is not carpeted which, unless cleaned weekly, can become a petri dish of organisms and rotting food -- smart move. The glasses, dinnerware, and even napkins (paper, but high end) are well considered and spotless. The table covering, not linen (smart move again) is a synthetic; easily maintained and cleaned. Now on to the food. Having watched Food TV's "Restaurant Impossible," I have come to suspect restaurants with overextended menu selections. Truth be known, they can't handle it. Brick Oven selections are sensible and fill one page -- a sufficient selection of appetizers, entrees, salads, pastas, and pizza. And a couple of desserts. Same with the wines -- Affordable. We chose the house salad, baked bolognese, Veal parmesan, and the house salads. (Grated cheese is extra; not parmesan but okay.) Salads were sufficient and better than average with mixed greens, cuke, and the obligatory cherry tomato. (Might impress me next time with two tomatoes.) But the main dish is the star. Both pasta dishes were extraordinary and well priced (here's hoping they can control prices in this crazy world.) You can see from the photos that the portions (especially on the veal are generous.) Linguini was perfect (and I didn't even caution that I like it al dente -- they know how to cook pasta.) And before I forget --Everything is reputed to be made on site and I believe it. The bread and butters (whipped, one with garlic and parsley) are better than I have gotten in other high end places. Brick Oven is on target and more satisfying than any other Italina I have had in the Strongsville/Middleburg/Parma area. Thanks to staff John, Brittney, and Heidi for a spectacular experience. See ya soon read more

The Brick Oven - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

What Happened , was always a dependable go-to restaurant, been a customer since the doors opened -50% occupancy - waited unusually long just for drinks- then for Caesar salad - bread ? . Then it started, our 2 orders of chicken tenders , were so burnt -also black - couldn't cut with a knife, forget the fries . The chicken prosciutto was not even PROSCIUTTO chicken - who knows ! Paid for drinks and salad LEFT - Give them a second chance - Don't Know - NEW KITCHEN STAFF ???? read more

The food is awesome!!!!! But hope that you don't get Heidi as a server. She forgot our appetizer, took foreverrrr, and only filled up our waters once. We were waiting for things for so long that other servers noticed and had to help us (twice). She didn't bring us plates! When we got a pizza for the table!! We were lucky that I had a bottle of water in my purse to fill up our glasses. Sorry Heidi - $1 tip. read more

The Brick Oven - P - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

I start every review with "behind the innocent facade of a..." well, this place is no different. We seek these places out, knowing they exist, and just waiting to be found. This place is delightfully decorated, and could be a suit and tie place with little effort. A word of advice, take it easy on the bread and butter...it is homemade and absolutely delicious! I ate too much, and had to split a pizza, which was amazing. The service, food and other staff were amazing. If in the area again, will hit it back up! read more

Had dinner there this evening. A party of 5 one had the cod it was cold Another one had chicken parm it was burnt one had shrimp with angel hair it was pasty when the server brought our checks we asked for coffee & dessert the regular coffee was cold. It was a very disappointing dining experience! Needless to say we will never go back read more

East Coast Pizza Snob here. I'm gonna say this Joint is an Ohio 10! Would stand its ground in Philly or NY too. We or the Rosso with pep and black olives. Good NY style dough and crust - the sauce and cheese is a go! The only thing missing is that classic NY pizza oil that just does nothing seem to be available outside of The East. Really good. Gonna change my four to a five . We had it delivered so I can't speak to anything but product - and what is more important? Not bad!!!! We also had the sausage stuffed peppers and the peppers might be a little hot for a tenderfoot. I admit to scraping out the goods and not eating the pepper on the second one. read more

Unfortunately, our food was very subpar. The chicken piccata had zero lemon flavor and was tasteless. The chicken prosciutto was good. We ordered a meatball appetizer which hadn't been delivered to the table even when we were finished with our meal. Our glasses remained empty as no refills of tea were offered. At the end of the meal we questioned why tax was on our bill as our dine-in was during the Ohio tax free period for restaurants. The manager refused to correct our bill when we pointed out that Ohio law states "Since food is taxable when it is dine-in, any menu item, including soft drinks, that is less than $500 would qualify for the sales tax holiday exemption." Under FAQ on the website, "Can vendors choose not to participate in the sales tax holiday? No. The sales tax holiday is set by law and vendors must comply." We were made to look like idiots when we inquired on this. Management would not correct their error. Sadly, we will never return to Brick Oven. read more

I get that it is Covid all around and service is slower. The service has nothing to do with the review. The food was TERRIBLE at best. The breading is so thick you can barely cut thru it without the meat coming out of the breading. Pork chops....dry! Salad looked like it had sat for a while. The bruchetta chicken sandwich, again, get through all the breading and maybe there you will find the chicken. Just not at all good. The bread was ok though. read more

Always have a good experience here. Family meals are a great deal! Pizza is always good but so are the pasta dishes. Worth your time and money for sure. Very nice staff as well read more

Visited on a Tuesday at 2 with my 15 yr old son. The place is really nice with plenty of tables and fancy linens and a few tables outside. Plenty of parking. The ladies bathroom is nice with marble countertops and 3 stalls...I know what you're thinking, let's get to the food! We ordered a small pepperoni brick oven pizza (6 nice-sized slices), mozzarella fritta (brings 3 large pcs with marinara sauce), grilled chicken sandwich with fries. All delicious! Oh and they also serve beer and wine for my party people. My only complaint is the bathroom was really dirty which surprised me because the place was empty. But who cares about the bathroom the food was great. I will be back with Clorox wipes and disinfect spray lol jk. read more

See all

I ordered a pizza and requested the crust be only lightly toasted. They agreed and offered to put basil on it. When I brought it home I found it was burnt. Thanks for nothing. And thanks for also omitting the basil. I know... a first world problem... not a serious life event. But if you want a good review, you've got to earn it. Thumbs down. read more

Working in the area and decided to order The Brick Oven via door dash. Went with the margherita, and was super surprised with the quality of the pizza. Very flavorful, great choice. Would definitely recommend them and would eat here again. read more

The food is not as good as it was a couple of years ago and the prices went WAY UP! The portions are smaller. We ordered two dinners and two appetizers for three people. Plus three soft drinks. It was $80. My son got mac&cheese and asked for the shrimp option. That was $25. read more

Went to lunch by myself on a whim to this location not knowing it was previously connected to the Bucci family restaurants until the waitress and I started talking. Apparently they remodeled at the end of last year and, in my opinion, it looks great ... nice and fresh and clean! I looked at lunch menu online before arriving and had my mind set on the chicken parm with penne but when I got there the chicken piccata sounded good to me ... they removed scallions and added capers. Salad and bread came out ... both were very good ... chicken piccata was perfect!!! Service was excellent too! To the person who left previous feedback ... give them a second chance because my experience was excellent and I will definitely be going back!!! Sorry forgot to take pics read more

Nice new find for a fresh made Italian meal, would have never expected such a great little restaurant in the quite strip mall. The service was great our waiter did a fantastic job on serving us with out being annoying and we never had to ask for anything. The menu is of a good size with a lot of great choices and will fit any budget, the atmosphere is typical Italian darker for a more of a romantic feel but I did feel underdressed in jeans and nice tee shirt. The food was very good the bread that came out was very hot and fresh with great taste soup was good as well (think homemade but hard to tell) and our entrée was good as well pasta sauce had nice flavor could have been a little thicker and richer but was good and breaded chicken was top notch. Over all great spot for a quick meal or to start a romantic evening, will definitely come back. read more

The Brick Oven - This was the menu as of 12-20-19 - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

See all

I'm leaving this review due to the waitress we unfortunately had for the 5 minutes we were there. ---------- I loved Bucci's Brick Oven in Middleburg Heights. I used to get their angelhair with blush sauce and sausage. They had wedding soup and their bread was so good. It's been about 3-4 years since I've had it. So I drove my mom and I about half hour to this place so I can get what I wanted. I saw that Bucci's is no longer associated with the restaurant which is now known as The Brick Oven. They had a lunch menu and I saw that it said due to the lunch hours, they're only using the limited lunch menu. They had linguine Alfredo and regular macaroni with tomato sauce. I thought making a blush sauce won't be difficult. It wasn't on the Bucci's menu but they always made it. I asked the waitress about it and she was thinking and since I wasn't sure if she knew what blush sauce was, I described it. She replied "I know what it is. I've worked here 24 years". Well excuuuuuuse me. She then said no (without asking a manager) and we can only order what's on the menu. I get limited lunch options and if they couldn't do it, I understand. But did she need to say how long she worked there and do it in a very curt manner? No So we left. I gave it 2 stars because the restaurant looked very nice. Shame we couldn't try any food. She wasn't getting any of our money. read more

Came by for lunch today. Food came out super quick. Flavorful sauce and crust. Reasonably priced as well. Good experience. read more

The Brick Oven - Pepperoni Pizza - Italian Near Me - Middleburg Heights, Ohio

What more can you say aside from YUM!!!!! House made dressing on the freshest greens. Meat balls that are pretty close to mom's. Home made wedding soup and fresh bread - haven't even mention the pasta that you can't stop eating - wait I won't have room because of the Mediterranean salad - everything is really good!!! Worth the price!!! read more

This place doesn't look like much on the outside, but the food is DELICIOUS!!! We ordered the calamari, chicken pomodoro, chicken picatta, and chicken parmigiana and each dish was beyond good. Def come here if you like good Italian without all the bells and whistles. read more

Haven't been to this restaurant since before COVID and liked it well enough back then so I thought I'd make a special trip because they don't open until dinner time now, no more lunches, at least not yet. I was greeted immediately seated immediately and a server was there in seconds. So far I can see service hasn't changed. Was 4:15 so not many diners yet. Ordered my iced tea and decided I would splurge today with an appetizer and an entrée. Little did I know that I was going to have so much food I would need two doggie boxes. The entrée I ordered was the cod filet which came with broccoli, roasted potatoes and the biggest salad you ever want to see with enough cheese to make Wisconsin proud. A side salad this was not!! I also was delighted to receive a basket of their bread with herbed butter scoops which is exact same recipe they used couple years ago when I was last there. The appetizer meatballs on bruschetta was stunning. There was two bruschetta slices on the bottom with a giant 3 inch meatball on each slice with a lot of sauce and plenty of cheese. Delivered piping hot; they warned me about touching inner plate which was just in the oven. I ate about half before my entrée arrived which I couldn't even touch. There was so much food and the service remained stellar as it was before the pandemic. This is a little restaurant which I think used to be a Buccis but I'm not sure if it still is or this is a new restaurant name. It's in a strip mall a little bit south of Southland on Smith Rd before the post office. Italian dining at its finest but does NOT smell like pizza parlor!! High praise to this same group of people who have treated us for at least four years I remember. When leaving noticed MANY more patrons filling the left side of eatery and it was 5:30. My personal 'hats off' goes to Brittany, my server today. Hope she enjoys my triple tip to her--she worth every bit of it!!!! Try it. It's neat tidy clean well swept and more then you could ask for n fine dining read more

Pizza and wings are phenomenal!! Can't wait to go back! Definitely did not disappoint! Pizza was cooked perfectly