Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Melody Key Private Island

    5.0 (1 review)

    Melody Key Private Island Photos

    You might also consider

    More like Melody Key Private Island

    Recommended Reviews - Melody Key Private Island

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 2
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Square Grouper Bar & Grill - Egg rolls

    Square Grouper Bar & Grill

    4.5(737 reviews)
    2.2 km
    $$

    We stopped by the original location and were thrilled. My husband had the yahoo and I had the…read moresquare grouper. No complaints that is for sure. The fish was fresh and delicious, served with fries and cole slaw. The waitress Jenny was incredible very attentive. Everything was so good that we went again although we were staying in Florida City the ride was worth it. Second time I had the square grouper again and my husband had the shrimp platter. Yummy!!! The shortbread cookies for dessert hit the spot It is great to see a restaurant that has it all -- great food, great service and great ambiance YUMMY!!!!!!!!

    We were really looking forward to trying this restaurant, but unfortunately our experience was…read moredisappointing from start to finish. The online waitlist initially estimated a 60-75 minute wait, not an issue, had a cocktail upstairs and really wnjoyed ourselves. When we checked in, we were told we were next eventhough thebonline portal told us to come. After waiting another 15 minutes, we were told our table was just being cleaned and to wait where we were. A few minutes later, another employee told us we had to move because a different party was holding the door open, so we ended up standing behind the bar with our backs against the wall. It just felt awkward and disorganized. When we were finally seated in the back room, we thought it would be nice since it was quieter, but it was extremely hot. I'm usually the person who is always cold, yet I was sweating through dinner. Service also left a lot to be desired. The food runner handed our hot dinner plates directly to us instead of placing them on the table. I was sitting at the opposite end of the table from him, so I had to reach out and take a hot plate. I even asked if it was hot, and he still practically dropped it into my hands. I had burned my fingers earlier that day, so it hurt!!.. but it was that or drop my pasta!? Our server also repeatedly reached across guests' faces to clear plates instead of walking around the table. At one point my sister didn't even realize she was there until an arm reached in front of her, which was awkward. To make matters worse, two of our dinners arrived about seven minutes before the remaining meals, so part of our table was left waiting while the others' food got cold. We asked for grated Parmesan for our two PASTA dishes. No one mentioned there would be a charge. It took another six minutes to arrive, and when the bill came we discovered we had been charged $2 per serving. We asked for two servings, but three were brought to the table--and we were charged for all three. Six minutes may not sound like much, but after already waiting for the rest of the meals, another delay while watching our server take new tables' orders instead of bringing the cheese felt frustrating. To end on a positive note, three of the meals were good. My mother-in-law really enjoyed the grilled wahoo, my husband liked the BBQ mac and cheese, and my sister liked the fried artichoke. Overall, it wasn't one major issue--it was a series of small service problems that added up and made for a disappointing experience. We hope this feedback helps improve the experience for future guests.

    Photos
    Square Grouper Bar & Grill - Jelly fish lamp

    Jelly fish lamp

    Square Grouper Bar & Grill - Almond encrusted grouper

    Almond encrusted grouper

    Square Grouper Bar & Grill - Let eat and drink!

    See all

    Let eat and drink!

    The Dining Room

    The Dining Room

    3.6(48 reviews)
    8.4 km
    $$$$

    Came back here to celebrate Valentine's Day and the experience was just as special however the food…read morewas a bit disappointing. The bread to start was delicious. The little ball ones tasted like onion and chives, yum! The crispy sticks were okay. We ordered the arugula salad and that was my favorite dish of the evening. Refreshing and light I enjoyed it. We got another pallet cleanser (we knew this time around what to do)! I ordered the chicken and my bf ordered the steak. His came with sides but mine didn't since it came with two little florets of broccoli and a sort of mashed potato underneath. I found my chicken to be very bland, thankfully we had some sauces on the side I could use with it. I will say the chicken was cooked perfectly, great texture, just the flavor was lacking. My bf's sides were good but the steak itself was very underwhelming. Just not what you would expect for the price or like the one we had our first time we dined here. Once again, the vibes here cannot be beat! But the food... certainly can be.

    What a beautiful and romantic little getaway hidden off of the Keys. Only accessible by boat, this…read morehidden gem is a short 15 minute cruise away. Our captain was friendly and the waters were calm. You arrive to the dock and greeted by another friendly employee who will help you with your luggage, answer any questions and show you to your table if you're ready to eat. This is an adult only hotel / restaurant and it makes for a really quiet and enjoyable time. There is a pianist playing which was lovely as the sun was setting. Tim and Jose were extremely lovely to talk with and are definitely an asset to the team. Our meals here were delicious, fresh, and we could not have imagined anything more perfect for dinner. We ordered the tuna tartare, and octopus appetizers along the lobster and fish dinner. The key lime pie and a bottle of wine were added touches to our fantastic dinner. The reason for the 4 stars is the variety on the menu as it is set. A few more options would have been nice, but we don't regret our visit here. Make your reservation, bring bug spray just in case and prepare for a great time away from the busy city. Cheers!

    Photos
    The Dining Room
    The Dining Room - Tuna tartare and octopus appetizers.

    Tuna tartare and octopus appetizers.

    The Dining Room

    See all

    Melody Key Private Island - vacation_rentals - Updated August 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...