This is the absolute best jewelry store in NJ. Everyone who works there is so friendly, knowledgeable, patient, honest, and professional. I've had the pleasure of working with Mike, Faythe, Jim, Irene and Andrea for years and I wouldn't bring my business anywhere else. Mike does fabulous custom work and he's always extremely honest about cost/expectations and the final result is always a WOW! I recently got engaged and Faythe was such a pleasure to work with. We told her our budget and she got to work right away sourcing the perfect diamonds and setting. Did I mention that we were under a two week time crunch? Well, they custom made the ring in under two weeks and it was everything I could ask for and more. Next time you want a sparkly gift or just a watch battery, definitely stop in. You won't regret it :) read more

I received one of my very first pieces of fine jewelry from Michael Anthony at the age of 6 when I was a flower girl in my cousin's wedding and have been coming ever since! The quality you receive both in product and in service are unsurpassed. The majority of the staff has been employed here for a decade or more which I think speaks VERY highly of the business and it's owners! I wouldn't hesitate to send everyone I know here, whether it be for a large important purchase or a small repair. Every client is treated with the same level of respect and given excellent service. read more

I highly recommend Michael Anthony Jewelers. I needed to have a diamond removed from a ring and put into a pendant necklace. Everyone in the store is extremely knowledgeable and helpful. They helped me pick the perfect chain and it came out beautiful! Michael set it himself right in the store while I waited. They are reasonably priced and honest with the estimates and actual cost. When you need a jeweler that takes pride in his work, and runs a family business where they really care about their customers go to Anthony Jewelers. read more

I am so pleased with the service here. I was told for 5 years by every jeweler I went to that I couldn't get my wedding band and engagement ring soldered together because they are two different metals, but they did it for me in no time for a very reasonable price, and the work is concealed. They also cleaned that ring set, and another ring I got sized, as a courtesy, and I don't remember my rings ever looking so nice!!! Customer service was great as well, and I will return to them as my jeweler for all my jewelery needs! read more

Whether you are purchasing, fixing or appraising Michael Anthony Jewelers fulfills all your jewelry needs. From purchasing high end gold and diamonds to replacing a watch battery this is the place. Every piece of jewelry they have is more beautiful than the next!! The staff is warm and inviting as well as incredibly knowledgeable! Overall a beautiful store, with friendly staff and gorgeous jewelry everywhere! I have and will continue to refer my friends and family! read more

Ten years ago, on the day before my wedding, I ran into Michael Anthony's I am sure somewhat in a panic, to get a pair of earrings and have been going there ever since for any of our jewelry needs. From watches to bracelets to custom earrings Michael has provided us with beautiful jewelry as well as amazing service. Not only do we consider Michael as our go to jeweler we consider him a great friend as well. Julie and Eric Friedman, Roseland, NJ read more

Amazing!! The staff is so helpful, kind and truth worthy. The jewelry is nothing shy of perfect! My husband and I have been going here a few years and won't go anywhere else! I recently got my engagement ring reset and the owner took time to help design it with us. Needless to say it's beautiful and far exceeded my expectations!! He even called me during the time he had my ring to give me updates on its progress. I would highly recommend them! read more

I went in to see if they could make a girls dream happen! I ask them to create a dream wedding band that is not your normal band, They took my idea in my head and created the most magical ring of my dreams. I highly recommend them to any one, there customer service is so amazing and wonderful! There workmanship is unbelievably amazing. I am so pleased with them if i could give them 100 stars I would. Thank you again read more

Highly highly recommend Michael Anthony Jewelers. My fiance and I went to the shop with the intention of putting together a custom made engagement ring. Faythe made the process so easy and enjoyable! We were apprehensive going into the process of engagement ring shopping because we knew so little but Faythe was patient, super knowledgeable, and honest and put us so at ease. It was a wonderful experience. read more

Love, love, love this store. I recently lost stone in a family heirloom. Not only did they do an amazing job, when I picked it up, the salesmen expressed their joy comes from satisfied customers. I recommend them to anyone looking to purchase, repair or just browse. Their customer service is genuine and I always enjoy employees conversations when I'm there...It's worth a visit read more

I would highly recommend Michael Anthony Jewelers. The quality of jewelry is the best by far. Whether you need to have a piece of jewelry made or something simple as a new watch battery you will be treated with the same respect and attention. The staff is very caring and a pleasure to do business with. Stop by the next time you need that special gift. read more

Michael Anthony Jewelers is the place to go for Jewelry. They have beautiful and classic pieces. The staff is sweet and knowledgable. Being that they are a family owned business and have been around for quite some time, you can 100% trust that they will stand by their product & never disappoint! I always refer my family and friends. read more

I've been extremely impressed with the quality of the products and the service offered within this business. Time and time again, I am completely satisfied with my purchases. And the owner himself is so gracious and helpful! I HIGHLY recommend making all your personal and giftable jewelry purchases here! read more

A fantastic jeweler! I was truly impressed with their customer service and the quality of their workmanship. True professionals! I had two items repaired at the store and I was very happy with the outcomes. Reasonably priced, friendly staff, and quick service. Thank you!! Highly recommended! read more

A few friends recommended MAJ so I decided to make the 45min trip. Needed my Grandmothers ring appraised as well as a new chain for a pendant she had given me before she passed. The young woman (Faith I believe) was so sweet, knowledgeable and helpful!! Definitely worth the trip for me! read more

The absolute best Jeweler i have been to in my life. Michael takes his time out to make sure you are taken care of and the whole staff is friendly and remembers your face and name. I recommend Michael to all of my friends and will continue to do so. I will not go anywhere else! read more

Amazing customer service! I wouldn't think of anywhere else to go to purchase jewelry! They have 2 locations and are very helpful and give each customer there undivided attention! I send everyone here! They have a great selection of jewelry and the quality is beautiful!! read more

Today was the first time I went to Michael Anthony's jewelers and my experience was beyond exceptional. Michael, the owner was very friendly and took his time fixing a necklace that I didn't even purchase at his store. I would definitely go back! read more

They are great, helpful, and provide excellent service. The custom work done on my jewelry was of excellent quality. I highly recommend them