We have eaten here numerous times over the year when visiting relatives and had good food and service. This past visit was so very disappointing. Philly "cheese"steak was missing a key ingredient, cheese. The "crispy" fries were most definitely NOT CRISPY and not hot. My wife's ham & "cheese" was VERY cheese spare. The server had to look through the sandwich to locate cheese. The McDonald's next door would have been a far better choice. With the cost of dining rising, folks should be aware of poor quality. How sad read more

Scary when we try new places but this was some really good pizza and the service was very good!! Definitely will be returning every time I'm in town!! read more

We order delivery from here all the time! Great pizza, lasagna, and sandwiches. Highly recommend!

Antipasto salad was nothing special and the pizza quality was just par. Nothing to really get excited about after reading several more favorable reviews here on the site. Courteous service was received and we received our food order promptly as well. Dining room cleanliness could have been much cleaner. read more

Of course I had to stop by Mama Cillies to try out their pizza!!! I was not impressed.. Watery sauce. Very sweet ladies that work here, but sheesh, the pizza is watery. (Ordered 5 times before)... I will be sticking with little ceasars down the road! read more

Hands down some of the best customer service I've experienced in a while. We were traveling through from Indiana and they went out of their way to take care of us. We really enjoyed their pizza, the crust was on point and was piping hot. They had both thinner crust as well as deep dish. I wish I lived nearby as this would be my Friday night pizza stop. We didn't try anything other than the pizza so I can't say how the rest of their food is. If you are thinking about stopping in, go for it and support this locally owned business! read more

Momma Cillie's Pizzeria - a sign for the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Harrison, Michigan

I'm a city boy from Chicago and have eaten loads of pizza so I know what I like. Out here in and around Harrison, MI there are a whole lot of chain eatery pizza joints. A lot of folks like Lil' Caesar's, Domino's and the like. When searching reviews, I couldn't find much in the detail of what sorts of pizza were available here. IE Thick, thin, deep, square, etc. So, I referred to word-of-mouth. Two names came up Momma Cillie's and Mr Vetoes Pizza. Both different in their own regard and should be tried. Inside the atmosphere is cozy. Made up like a warmly lit cottage. Dark woods and ample space for many to dine. Tasty smells emanating from the kitchen were a good sign. I called in an order, the order-taker gave me general information. I couldn't find a menu online or via any Facebook accounts, so I ordered something general and easy. A large pizza with sausage, green peppers and onions. Forgot to request extra sauce like I usually do. I had asked if they offered their own specialty creations, which they did but it didn't seem the phone person wanted to run through all the different varieties with me. They had thrown out something with 3 meats and a few too less veggies. But when trying a pizza for the first time, I always find it important to try it with as few ingredients as possible. 20 minutes later and we were on scene to pick-up. Pizza was hot and ready and looked inviting. The sauce amount was nil so I requested a side of "pizza sauce" or their house marinara. I was given a melting to-go portion of their sauce. It looked as though it had been previously frozen. A detail they mentioned about their pizza, is that the dough is brushed with a mixture of butter and garlic. The pizza was like a thick pan pizza. Like Pilsbury dough. The dough was cooked evenly and soft when bit into. (For a different taste, ask if they could do it "well done". I would imagine the crust being crisper in that case) Although sauce was very low in quantity, it was a tasty pie. Thank goodness for scoring the pizza sauce. Many of us chose to dip portions of our slices in that goodness. Would have been nice if it were warm and we had an additional serving. The size of a large pie was alike a Medium anywhere I frequent back home. Pricing was affordable and quality far above any chain pizza businesses. (A little less than $20 dollars for that pie) Kids and adults dug the flavors. The pizza was gone pretty quickly. If feeding a group of 5+, definitely inquire about larger sizes or ordering an additional. (Again, this is where it is important for a business to have marketing on the web. A facebook account with recent menu or a link to a menu through a third party restaurant site. ) Something to note: I give it 5 stars based on my visit, the quality and tastes. Again, compared against chain pizza offerings, it's quite stellar. The nearest city is hours away and in a jiffy, this is some great stuff. read more

Momma Cillie's Pizzeria - Pan with sausage, green peppers and onions. - Pizza Near Me - Harrison, Michigan

See all

Great pizza at a very good price. Cute local spot. The service (on a busy Saturday night in June) was excellent. Will definitely stop here again when we're in the area. read more

They have the best food that people are really nice to on it has the absolutely best atmosphere

The pizza and service was very good! The restaurant is nice and comfortable. 1st time customer, thank you

Took 45 minutes to get served, the food was barely warm. They charged us a delivery fee. For what? Bringing my food to the table? We watch 4 tables that arrived well after we did get served with large orders well before we did. read more

My fiancé and I ordered the chicken bacon ranch pizza and we both enjoyed it. Fast and safe carry out service.

The pizza crust was so amazing! The lasagna was also very good. Highly enjoyed, and recommend. Will be a repeat customer in the future.

Ordered pizza from there was not impressed went in dirty tables place smelled horrible and a pizza was bad

Pizza was fair. Service great. Price fair. Honestly Little Caesars is better and cheaper.

Mediocre pizza, poor service. I ordered a pizza by phone and when I drove there to pick it up I waited at the counter for 10 minutes. I did get to watch a delivery driver flirt with the cashier all of that time. read more

I was willing to give this place a second chance, however, I was disappointed once again for the delayed service. Also, when our food did arrive after waiting for nearly an hour, the waitress realized we were missing items that came with our order- she promptly went to retrieve them, and then never returned. Not even to give us the bill. We explained our dilemma to the nice young lady at the front counter and she was able to charge us for our food. The food was decent, but over priced and not worth waiting for. read more

I've been here twice now. The first time my meat and bean burrito was great - although I think it's strange to have to pay extra to get salsa and sour cream. The second time I had a meatball sub. The meatballs tasted great - and so did the cheese and sauce - but the bun was a fail. Although it was fresh, it wasn't toasted nearly enough (if at all?). It was very doughy and chewy. The service was great both times. I'll stop in again. Maybe I'll ask for toasted bun next time.... The fountain pop was great - they have a good mix. My partner had the salad bar and liked it. It looked fresh and clean. read more

Stopped in on our way home from an up north vacation and so glad we did! Delicious pizza ready to eat from the buffet plus salad bar and only $6.95 for lunch! The waitress was very friendly and had pizza made for the buffet based on our request. As a family of four, finding a non-fast food lunch for under $40 is a find. Would definitely eat here again as we pass through! read more

Excellent little place, great food, reasonable prices, friendly service. Definitely our go - to place when in Harrison.

The food is usually really good. The only complaint I have is that they need to drain the water off their salads. I always have to take the antipasto salad apart and spin it in my salad spinner. I wish they would use one. read more

Great pizza, salad and soup bar. On the pizza bar they usually have cinnamon sugared bread sticks that are Great. Servers always pleasant and on task. Also had Lasagna, plan to take some home unless you are hungry!! read more

Have had lunch here a few times. Food is affordable and pretty good. Portions are good sized, if not large at times. Well worth the stop if you are in the area. read more

Good salad bar, good pizza & server was friendly & efficient! They also have burgers, nachos, subs & Italian entrees.

Surprised this place is still in business. I ordered a meal last weekend was told 15-20 minutes, I ended up waiting 40 minutes. Over all food was decent. This weekend I tried ordering a similar meal I asked for multiple pasta dishes was told they didn't have any items like that. Basically a bunch of children working there who care more about them selves and their friends and not the customers trying to purchase a simple meal from them. read more

We stopped in for a fish and chip plate and left sick. Fish was so greasy. When we got home, my husband and I was so sick. Think we got food poisoning. Here it is 2 days later and husband is still sick. Will never go back. read more

Had the Double D burger. Was just a ton of meat. Not flavored. Bun fell apart while eating it. Service was just so-so. Not that busy for a Saturday night, now we know why. read more

We ordered the all u can eat fish. But was never offered seconds. Hmm truly not all u can eat. But overall good food. Service was good. If you want something more than pizza this restaurant offers alternatives. read more

Like another reviewer we were also from Chicago and visiting the area this week. Craving pizza & not sure where to go, we were vacillating between the known, Little Caesar's (not a fan & we are from Chicago after all; home of thin crust & great deep dish pizza) & the unknown Momma Cillie's. We definitely made the right choice. Momma Cillie's pizza was excellent with the perfect amount of sauce, cheese & toppings along with a crust brushed with garlic butter at a very affordable cost. The garlic cheese bread "pizza" (no pizza sauce) was superb & if they'd been open when we left Harrison we would have taken two to go. Our family is going to be craving that for a long time. The pizza is more along the lines crust-wise of Little Caesar's/Dominos only much better. The woman taking our order was also super nice, helpful & knowledgeable about the area & made us feel very welcome. No online menu but if you're in the area stop in & try it. Excellent! read more