Came here on a thursday at 6:30 PM with a reservation, but it wasn't super busy, so you could probably get by without one. There's an area in the front that was more of a typical restaurant atmosphere, but we sat in the covered garden room in the back, which was a really nice ambiance. We ordered one of their specials, a toast with arugula and beef carpaccio, as well as the squid ink pasta, which came out to be $60 total. The beef carpaccio on the toast was my favorite bite of the meal. The bread was also a good level of crisp, and I liked the flavor of the spread on top. The squid ink pasta had a good tomato and white wine flavor in the sauce, and I enjoyed the al denteness of the noodles. However, I did find the pasta to be a bit sandy, so I don't think the clams were fully cleaned. read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Squid ink pasta - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

This is a really cute date spot! The garden seating is beautiful with a glass ceiling even in the winter. It wasn't too cold either. The flatbread pizza was really good. The bread was soft and chewy! I would pass on the NY strip steak though, nothing special. I might try the ribeye next time. I did LOVE the bone marrow toast. That was probably my favorite bite of the night. I would also like to try the octopus next time. For dessert, I had the affogato with vanilla hazelnut ice cream and the panna cotta. The panna cotta was the star of the two dishes. I'm curious about the tiramisu too. Another reason to go back!! Overall, would recommend. read more

See all

We visited on a Wednesday night, and agreed it was a charming spot. The space is surprisingly roomy for Brooklyn, and the garden area was especially lovely. The rain lightly hitting the clear roof added the perfect cozy ambiance. Food-wise, I really enjoyed the salad. The freshly cracked pepper on top was noticeably flavorful, though I'm personally not a huge fan of having to cut the lettuce myself. The true standout, though, was the Cacio e Pepe. Buttery, rich, perfectly peppery, genuinely a showstopper. I'd go back for that dish alone. The only downside was the service and organization. A few minutes after being sat down, we were asked if we needed more than an hour because a birthday party would be taking the table later. This felt strange and unnecessary, especially given how much open seating the rest of the restaurant had, I don't know why we were sat in the section to begin with. Throughout the meal, the service wasn't very attentive, and the subtle rushing took away from what could've been a really relaxed dinner. The menu is a little overwhelming, but delicious food and a lovely space. I wish the service matched the rest of the experience, but it seems to be a great place to throw a birthday party. read more

See all

We were in the mood for Italian and decided to stop by Montesacro to check it out. From the outside, it appears to be a small, cozy spot but once you step inside, there's a garden area off to the left with additional seating in the back. The ambiance is dimly lit, warm and inviting, it's perfect for a date night or a relaxed dinner with family. We started with the focaccia and burrata. The focaccia was crispy, light, and flavorful. For our mains, we ordered the cacio e pepe, the margherita pizza, and the bistecca (NY strip). Each dish was executed well and full of flavor. The cacio e pepe was perfectly balanced, the margherita was fresh and classic, and the bistecca was cooked just right. All three are definite must haves. Good service, price point is $25 to $35 on average. read more

See all

Really cute vibes and staff! I picked this one off of Yelp and reading reviews and my craving for pasta. I was not disappoint! Pictures always help me out and I really appreciate seeing what the menu had to offer and I asked the staff member what was good. I was craving a good protein and got the grilled octopus to start and then the cacio e pepe. The octopus was grilled and came over top this chickpea and celery (thinly sliced) olive (thinly sliced) salad. I thought I hated chickpeas but love love love them now. It was a simple and and mild in flavor but the octopus cut like butter. It was larger than I thought but for the price its a good portion. The cacio e pepe was creamy salty and everything I was craving that I had to eat it all (NO LEFTOVERS THIS TIME). Its a cute spot to go for a date and I wish I had seen the garden area but so glad I stopped in! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Menu and drink - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

We walked into this restaurant and there was a small receiving area but the area in the back is beautiful. There was no line but we waited for a few minutes for the host to come out. read more

See all

I didn't dine in, I went to pick up a takeaway order and the place is beautiful! The staff was very attentive and friendly and ready to help. The food was incredible INCREDIBLY GOOD. I had the little gem salad and a side of broccoli. The only thing i will say was that it was pricy, but it's deserved when it's THAT good. read more

This is a really cute date spot. There's a charming bar up front and a beautiful garden area in the back that's surprisingly spacious. The food is amazing--everything about this restaurant feels perfect. I'll definitely be going back! read more

My wife and I had a 6 pm reservation on a Saturday and were seated right away. The garden dining area is gorgeous and has a retractable roof which was open. All of the staff were friendly and attentive. We selected porchetta, coppa de testa, and carciofi for appetizers. The porchetta and coppa de testa were the personification of porky goodness! That said, the carciofi stole the show! Perfectly tender and served with mint pesto and paper thin lemon slices, absolutely divine! My wife had the New York strip steak, served with an amazing layered potato side, and delicious greens. I had the pinsa from the specials menu. It featured ramps, fava beans, Calabrian chili, and lemon zest. Texture was awesome and the flavors were the essence of spring. Have to admit, the Calabrian chilis are hot enough to be addictive. My wife enjoyed the barolo wine by the glass. Truly a fantastic dinner! read more

See all

Ambiance is lovely; the garden seating in the back is covered and had a great vibe. Our wine was chosen for us and both options were perfect for each of us. We had the squash to start; I loved the honey but my friend found it too sweet. We had the beef tartare as well which was absolutely delicious. For mains we shared the recommended pizza (also had honey) and the carbonara. The pizza crust is light, sweet and delicious. Definitely memorable. Service was very attentive at the beginning of the meal and less so towards the end. We barely touched the carbonara and it still ended up on the bill. read more

See all

solid 3.5/5 but rounding up! i can't believe i never noticed this spot before! they have a small bar upfront and large covered garden area in the back. super cute vibes and service is nice however we felt extremely rushed. granted it was a friday evening but they didn't let us know about a 90 minute limit on each table when we sat down, they just came around asking to clear the table, pushing us to order dessert and bringing the check over. perhaps it was on the resy screen when we made the rez but a reminder when they seated us would've been nice. we ordered the - gem salad: came w cacio e pepe vinaigrette which was delish!! 10/10! super flavorful and seasoned to perfection - cod: came on a bed of lentils and tasted fine but forgettable 7/10 - carbonara: i was most excited about this dish since seeing photos of it on yelp but it was really disappointing! the sauce was bland, lacking flavor, and the pasta was a lil tooo al dente for my liking 6/10 will i be back for dinner? probs not but for some reason i feel like they'd do a good brunch! maybe id come try for that. read more

The ambiance, service, food basically everything was GREAT! I really like the lightning in the space. It felt so elegant and cozy at the same time! It was a nice dinner spot for a girl's night! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

We came for a double date on a blustery evening in early March. We had a reservation that our party was late for and they still seated us, which was greatly appreciated. We ordered the ponte milvion pinsera to share -- it came with a decent amount of potatoes and the mozzarella was delicious and creamy. It was difficult to cut, maybe it would be better to cut it before served? It's not like an enclosed hot pocket but more of an open face pizza. I ordered the Pappardelle after discussing with the waiter and my husband the a red sauce special pasta. His was definitely better, despite mine coming highly recommended by the waiter. I found my dish to be incredibly salty, to the point where I could not finish it and ended up drinking water to satisfy my hunger. We opted to skip dessert and left. Overall, the ambiance is lively and could be nice, it was dimly lit and great for date night or dinner with parents. The food left a lot to be desired so hopefully they can work out the kinks! read more

What a beautiful and stunning spot! The seating area in the garden is breathtaking and super cozy and romantic and all of the exposed brick is simply perfect. The food is incredible - I am still thinking about the burrata and cacio de pepe a week after being there. Ample drink choices to choose from and the staff were so friendly! I am already thinking about my next trip back to the area just so I can come back again :) read more

See all

Seated for 4 at 7pm tonight reservation at the Garden. I nominate this establishment as one of the best Italian spots in Williamsburg. The garden is a perfect place for intimate dinner or if you plan for an anniversary with your special someone, this could be it. Food wise, everything is marvelous, not a single margin error. We ordered the Arthicoke app which we think taste wise, it's just okay, portion is tiny. We also ordered Fritto Miso which we found it quite delightful [fried wild shrimp, squid, broccoli rabe] comes with their homemade tartar condiment. Then we proceed to order their pinsa with honey [this is a must order, very tasty!!] perfect crust, texture, the thinly sliced meat paired well with the honey and cheese. We also ordered the Bistecca - quite chewy, the meat quality could be better, nonetheless... cooked to perfection temp wise [we ask for medium rare], and Spaghetti Nero [squid ink pasta with seafood], this is really good for what it is. I would love to try their wine but since Im driving, I skip it, maybe next time... definitely a return customer for sure!! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza with broccoli rabe, spicy pork sausage, and burrata. Pannacotta with anise drizzle... The chicken!!!! Fabulous service! A great dining experience!!! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The large room in the back is GORGEOUS! I ordered the carbonara and it was delicious. My party really appreciated that the handheld payment system was able to be programmed to split the bill evenly amongst everyone then we could pass it to each person individually to pay. This is SUCH a great piece of tech and I hope more restaurants implentent this technology. read more

Great atmosphere. Montesacro is really conveniently located by the subway station. Walking in, there's plenty of seating inside but also a beautiful outside area that feels like you're dining and drinking in a garden. The menu is a good size , so there's plenty to order from without feeling too overwhelmed. What I love about Montesacro is the quality of the ingredients - the pasta is house made drawn durum-wheat and the pizza is proofed for 72 hours. We ordered a variety of dishes from the menu from steak to octopus to salad to pasta and pizza. The food came pretty quickly and everything was well seasoned. Some dishes are bigger than others but in general the portions are a good size. The atmosphere is great for any setting so I'll definitely be back to check it out again. read more

See all

This is a great restaurant! If you get the avocado toast definitely add on the smoked salmon. It was delicious! I also had a margarita pizza that was well made and delicious. Ambience in the back or what they call the "garden" was really nice. Service was great. read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Made reservation on OpenTable for a special occasion and even stopped by two nights beforehand to see if there was any way to reserve a specific table for our group. Unfortunately, the server working at the time wasn't welcoming, wouldn't take my name, and just told me it wasn't possible - it would be first come, first served even with a reservation. On the actual night, I arrived 45 minutes early, and the host who greeted me at the door was also not warm or friendly. I felt like I was being a bother just by asking 2 questions. For such a special occasion, it was disappointing that the table offered to us was right by the entrance. When I politely asked to move more toward the back, the host seemed annoyed. Thankfully, once we were seated, everything turned around. Our server was absolutely fantastic - warm, attentive, and made us feel truly cared for. The food was also incredible! We had drinks at bar after and the bartender was not welcoming either. This restaurant has so much going for it, but a little more warmth and hospitality at the front would go a long way in making the full experience match the quality of the kitchen and restaurant service team. read more

unbelievable experience. the overall experience from the guest service to the quality of the food was outstanding. We each got a pasta and split the pizza (pinsa) - for the pizza we got the Casal Bertone. It was phenomenal and we will be returning just for that! Perfect balance of salty with the kick of sweetness of honey. Pasta was flavorful, and ending the night with the affogato dessert. will be coming back! read more

See all

have been here many times and food is always delicious no matter what we order. had them host an engagement party dinner as well. read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Cacio e Pepe, pizza - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Cozy and full of charm, Montesacro is the perfect spot to gather with friends or a date. Don't be fooled by the small space when you first walk in, the garden space in the back is just as charming and beautiful as the front. The staff was attentive, friendly and helpful. We got the lattuga romana, carbonara, branzino, tiramisu, and hazelnut gelato. For drinks, we got the portia, farmacista, and a cappuccino. Everything was delicious. Some favorite bites/moments: - The depth of flavors and textures from the crunchy khorabi, the nicely charred artichoke and the lentils paired beautifully with the grilled branzino. 10/10! Highly recommend! - Shoutout to our server for asking if we wanted bread to soak up the leftover sauce from our carbonara. My love language! - The bits of hazelnut in hazelnut gelato. Next time I definitely want to try the salted caramel gelato. - The tiramisu - because coffee! It was light, not too sweet and had great coffee flavor. If montesacro isn't already on your list it needs to be. It's a whole mood. And if nothing else, get the branzino and the tiramisu, you wont regret it! read more

See all

Beautiful spot love the cozy romantic date night vibes!! Parking is a blessing if you get it but great on Sundays. Food is delicious, portions are not so great and pricing is fair. The pizza was the best tasted so good it's been so long since I had a good slice of pizza. The pasta was good but the portion was a bit small given the price you pay. Service was not so great, they were busy but sheesh me and my friend had to ask for complimentary bread 5 times (I low key counted it) and had to ask for refills for water few times as well without them doing it themselves but funny I had to raise my hand to get their attention because nobody cared to come attend my table beside just bringing the food we ordered!! I been lately so disappointed with a lot of places in regards to their service and this place was horrible for service as well. read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Front of the restaurant - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Montesacro serves up some really good pizza in a cozy, vibey spot. It's perfect for date nights or an intimate dinner. Just know that the space is pretty tight, so expect to be close to your neighbors. The ambiance is super dark and moody, which adds to the charm, but it's definitely not the place for a big, loud group. Overall, great vibes and great pizza--would definitely recommend! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Brooklyn has become our new favorite food spot! This place is simply delicious. We started off with two pinsas; infernetto and casal Bertone. The ingredients were fresh and a good size to share with 4 people. For a drink, I got the paloma and we shared two pasta dishes and a steak one. We had the carbonara, rigatoni and the bistecca. The only thing that bothered me is that they wanted to charge us $5 a person to clean up after our "cupcake cheers" (each cupcake is $4) from magnolias so we finished my best friend's birthday dinner with a cappuccino. We might be back for more pinsa ... read more

See all

Decided to try this place with friends the other night for dinner. Wow is all I can say. Beautiful restaurant great service very nice menu and amazing food.! Everything from the appetizer to the pastas to the Pinza style Roman pizza was incredible. Our waiter was friendly and knew his stuff. Cannot wait to go back to try more things. read more

See all

The ambiance of Montesacro is great! I have walked past this restaurant so many times and I was surprised to find out how big the garden area is. We walked in on a Sunday late afternoon and the service was great. We got the mushroom ravioli and the panino. The pasta was well balanced and the mushrooms on the pasta went so well with the ravioli. The panino was lemony and had a good crunch to it. I would definitely come back to try their pinsa! read more

Montesacro Pinseria Brooklyn - PANINO MILANESE - Italian Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Great spot with quality ingredients and authentic Italian meals. We were all satisfied with our choices. We Had: Apps Suppli Artichokes Ottaviano pizza My meal: Pacherri Desert: Coconut gelato read more

See all

The pizza here is phenomenal. I had the infernetto. The crust is light with a delicate crunch and delightfully fluffy towards the outside; it holds its shape, and isn't greasy. The meats are tender, complex, and well- seasoned with a bold pork flavor. The tomato sauce is tangy and bright, cutting through the other intense flavors without overpowering them or drowning the other ingredients. The cheese tastes pure, natural, and fresh. Service was quick and the waiters are friendly. They'll happily tell you about how their food is made with more love and authenticity than many places in Rome, which I can attest to. The decor is warm, clean, and cute. It feels like being in the sophisticated home of your favorite Italian aunt, in the best way. The covered patio is spacious, comfortable, and warm. If you're thinking about eating here, just do it. You'll struggle to find a better dining experience in all of New York. read more

Montesacro is THE ULTIMATE date night spot. While the interior is small, the outdoor space is charming and romantic--a true hidden gem. The octopus is always a great choice, perfectly charred. The prosciutto and burrata is a must-try! My personal favorites are the carbonara, simple yet delicious and the squid ink pasta, which has just the right amount of spice . I always order the bistecca to share--it's delicious and juicy, especially when cooked medium rare. You can't go wrong with any of the pinsas; they're all fantastic. I absolutely love this spot--the food is outstanding. read more

Montesacro is a really unique spot in Brooklyn it feels like you've stepped into a cozy Roman hideaway. The atmosphere is warm and rustic with just the right mix of modern touches. The staff was attentive and the food was the star of the show. Outstanding all around!!! read more

Food - Delectable! Service - Exceptional! Decor - 100% my vibe! Beautifully dimmed lights with modern light fixtures and plants throughout the space give it a romantic feel. Ambiance - Quiet and intimate. Perfect for date night or catching up with a close friend. It wasn't loud, so you could actually have a proper conversation without having to raise your voice. From the moment I entered and warmly welcomed by the host, I was all smiles. Much love and gratitude to my friend who understood the assignment. Well done! Yes, I'd absolutely recommend it! read more

See all

I had no idea that this place had a chain, but apparently, there are two locations in San Francisco. I'm surprised that there's only one in NYC. It's best if reservations are made as it can get filled up, especially during brunch times on the weekend. From the outside, it doesn't seem like it would be large. But there's a nice garden area in the back. It's really nice in that space and it's fully covered with glass walls and very airy. Came with 3 other people, so we decided to get an array of dishes such as the suppli, which has tomato and basil croquettes. It usually comes with three, but they gave us four. It was delicious. I totally recommend that one. We also decided on the Brioche French Toast, which was sweet and tasty, too. It has seasonal fruit compote, vanilla whipped ricotta, abs NY maple syrup. Another plate for the table was the Carciofi, which had baby artichokes and mint. That one was just alright. Nothing compared to the other two dishes. I shared a pasta and pizza dish. We ordered the Mezzaniche Alla Carbonara and the Infernetto. I enjoyed eating the pizza or, rather, pinsa as it is labeled on the menu. I ordered this light pink drink and tbh I forgot the name of it. The entire table sampled it, and all thought it tasted great. It is on the brunch menu just as a FYI. read more

See all

A pinseria! I have never had a pinsa, and after trying this place, I still haven't. When we entered during lunch time, it was like a small cafe with a bar to the right. A guy came out and led us to the garden dining area past a walkway (where the bathrooms are). It was really cute, and I can imagine it being a romantic spot at night. I ordered from the lunch menu. My eating partner and I both got pastas because that's what we were craving. The waiter offered to us the lunch special by adding on an argula salad. It was maybe a + $3 difference in price. I said sure! The salad came out looking like it was a a parm dish on a bed of arugula. Simple and tasty. The carbonara was not the same as what we had in Roma, Italia, but it tasted good. They were able to give us tonnarelli instead of the medium cut pasta. The guanciale was so crispy. The paccheri was the better pasta of the two. The ratio of pasta to sauce was just right. The flavor was great. I might have preferred having a different type of noodle, but this was an interesting take on ragu. (We could see this restaurant from our room view over at Hotel Indigo across the street.) read more

See all

Stumbled upon this spot while in Brooklyn, really enjoyed it! Excellent atmosphere, attentive service and fantastic food. The menu is varied and we enjoyed that the vegan and vegetarian options are clearly shown. Would absolutely come back! read more

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn, where romance meets gastronomy, Montesacro Pinseria beckons with its tantalizing blend of roman culinary tradition with a modern flair. From the moment you step into its enchanting outdoor oasis, cocooned to embrace a greenhouse vibe. You're transported to a world where every bite is a symphony of flavors with incredible service. As the first dish to grace our table was this delightful grilled asparagus side dish with a light dressing. We loved the freshness of it and the lightness of the dish itself. For our main dishes we had the Tonnarelli Cacio E Pepe, a masterful creation of simplicity and sophistication. The al dente strands of tonnarelli went perfectly with the velvety embrace of the Pecorino while the symphony of cracked black pepper adds a crescendo of flavor that leaves you yearning for more. Next dish was the Pollo Al Mattone, a culinary titan in its own right. The Amish half chicken , tender and succulent , bears the marks of a grill. Imparting a smoky allure that you'll just love. Paired with verdant embrace of broccoli rabe and zesty charm of a charred lemon. Each bite is a celebration of harmony and balance for a foodie! At the end of this amazing meal our palates are satiated and our hearts are full from a great experience. read more

See all

Another neighborhood go to. The front is cozy bar vibe and the back is an open garden vibe. The move here is the roman style pizza. Pastas are good too. The staff here is always so helpful and attentive as well. read more

The cutest Italian restaurant! came here for brunch with my mom and little sister on a Sunday and made reservations, which highly recommend doing so for either brunch or dinner. We booked for the dining room area which is in the indoor garden and it was so nice! The staff are very friendly and took care of us immediately. All of the cocktails and list of wines sounded amazing, but I decided to just stick with a mimosa. They don't have bottomless--but they still have a really great brunch selection. My mom ordered the avocado toast with smoked salmon, my sister ordered the montesacro burger and I had the pietralata pinsa (basically carbonara as a pizza). Everything tasted so delicious and fresh. My mom's avocado toast was honestly to die for and I'm not one to order avocado toast at places since it's an easy at-home recipe, but this one was so good that I would genuinely order it next time. The pietralata was good but if you're looking for a saucy pizza, I would recommend getting a different one, like the infernetto. Highly recommend coming here if you're spending the day in Williamsburg! read more

See all

From start to finish, one of the best Italian spots in Brooklyn perhaps even in NY. I'm sure every menu item is fantastic and there really are no wrong choices. From the apps to the pizzas to the desserts, all were amazing. Caracalla pizza and pistachio pinsa/tiramisu. The back space is perfect for a large family event and it was very baby friendly so definitely a plus. Quick attentive service. Nothing more you can ask for. read more