Great little place for ice cream and nightly entertainment, we were there for name the song competition, fun to watch. The ice cream is good too. Lots of flavors, including alcohol infused flavors read more

Cute place with great vibes. Lots of tasty options with more adult-style flavors. The service was super friendly and made for a really nice way to end the evening after dinner with friends and family. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

See all

Nice fresh ice cream on a stop in Leesburg. Easy to park and hang out outside. Only ten minutes from the house

First time at the Leesburg location. This is the best ice cream in the area hands down and I love the VIBE at all their locations. The staff is awesome too. My favorite flavor is the boozy Blackberry and Chocolate Chip. I haven't branched out to other flavors because they usually have that one on the days I go. They also offer a few non-dairy options and regular ice cream. They also have a truck that does events (that's how we first discovered them). They have the schedule on their website. Finally, they offer a range of fun late day/early evening activities at their locations such as Karaoke, Trivia, etc. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

Amazing service. I NEEDED a hot fudge sundae. The folks hooked it up! Will definitely go back!

If I could give Mystic Ice Cream 10 stars I would, mostly because of their perfectly handmade ice-creams, their boozy and non-boozy flavors, and their outstanding service, notably Scott. He's got a big smile and is happy to see you. On top of it he takes the time to explain their flavors, talks a bit about the fresh ingredients - fresh cream, no preservatives! I was sold even before I sampled the ice cream and I was sure no matter what flavor I chose it would all be good. Sure enough my Mocha Crunch flavor was MAGIC - creamy texture but still light and airy, just the right amount of sweetness, and the mocha crunch flavoring itself. Wow to all of it including Scott, a very nice person to know. TIP- Great to know they're open until 9pm, for those of us with evening cravings :-) read more

See all

The Ice cream was great we really enjoyed the adult flavors we tried. The service was really great even with them training they were very nice. We really loved the ambiance would definitely have to come back. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Cherry Amaretto - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

With lots of unique flavors (13 of which were adult flavors) and as many of non alcoholic everyone can find some that tantalizes their taste buds! Highly love how the owner tonight made sure everyone ordering loved what they were ordering! Refreshing that he truly was all about customer enjoyment! Individual size is $8 but invludes 2 large scoops! Shareable are $11 with 4 scoops! Next time you want a treat stop by this cure welcoming place and definitely try the chair in the corner which is super comfy read more

Seriously the best ice cream I have ever tasted, with the nicest people serving it. Very cool vintage decor, lots to look at, great vibe. The boozy ice cream was delicious, but the standard ones even better. read more

Verrrryyyyy yummie ice cream. Every flavor was incredible. Too hard to decide. Ended up just doing two flavors in a small - which is more than enough. Four locations. 600 gallons a week. All home made. Very good. read more

See all

Came down for ice cream with my mother-in-law and wife for the first time and man was this place awesome! The inside is very retro with iconic vinyl covers around the wall, old movie posters, and awesome seating options. The strong window is lined with lava lamps (love them) and gives a great view to people watch. The ice cream I got was also amazing! I managed to take a picture of my half-eaten ice cream before I devoured it. They have some alcoholic ice creams and normal flavors. The person who served us was also great! Good conversation and helped us figure out what we wanted. Super friendly and seems like a great person. 10/10 would recommend, especially if you've never been here before. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Half-eaten strawberry & banana foster ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

I'm 62 years old and this place is hands-down the best ice cream I have ever enjoyed it. It's a very unique late 60s and 70s kind of vibe. I can't say anything bad about this place. The service is absolutely wonderful. Very friendly. read more

Great customer service and a great atmosphere. We stopped by and were able to try out several tasters to decide on what we wanted to get. Ended up going with the coffee ice cream. It was extremely potent in a good way and you could tell it was made with real coffee. The small was massive by itself and ended up being eaten over several days while snacking on it. We will defiantly be coming back to try on the rotating flavors when in the area. read more

See all

A wide variety of homemade icrle cream flavors. There are boozy options for adults and dairy-free options, too. The ambiance is what you would expect from the name. There's lots of tie-dye and 70s albums all over and it smells of patchouli. The lone employee who was here was very polite and friendly. read more

I have been to the store in downtown Leesburg also there truck that they come to the community I live in. Their ice cream is very rich and dairy products and quite full of flavor. I have only eaten the regular ice cream not the ones that have alcohol flavored. That's my choice however, I know quite a few people that have tried the alcohol flavors and really like it. Whenever I am craving some ice cream this is the place I will hit. It's nice that they have the mobile ice cream truck that comes to my community. Always a good treat. read more

Great service and excellent ice cream! The flavor choices are so much fun! It's great to have an ice cream shoppe for adults and kids nearby! read more

Super friendly. Super tasty. What's not like about Mystic Ice Cream? Answer: The price. 2 small cups of ice cream cost me $17. That's with a dollar tip. I think that is over the top for ice cream cups. Granted: this is home-made goodness. But the high prices will keep me from regular visits. read more

The ice cream was good, but it wasn't worth eight dollars. The karaoke was music to slit your wrist by. I won't be back sorry

Absolutely adored this place, the amazing people and the ice cream is homemade and delicious. We were greeted by a female and male behind the counter who were an absolute pleasure. Such kind people with remarkable stories, and it was even greater to hear how this owner has paired up to help the community. They have various flavors of ice cream and ADULT ice cream. I had a mix of the Baileys and White Russian ice cream. I've been back 3 times since. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - White Russian and Bailey's ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

An asset to downtown Leesburg Main St. Generous scoops. Conventional ice cream, and alcohol infused. Yay I am a fan. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Outside seating and people wstching. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

Their ice cream is cheap quality $10 minimum. You're gonna spend if you don't leave a tip for one scoop of ice cream the ambience is really nice. The service is just basically tip you they give you a nasty look if you don't tip actually not really so much luck as they make you feel like you're less than human read more

Outstanding home made fresh ice cream! I'm not a big ice cream fan but this place nails it, every choice actually tastes like the flavor it is. Fun decor, clean surroundings. Worth a trip !! read more

What a fun and wonderfully flavorful place to visit if you are in town. All of the ice cream is hand made in small vats ... which means the very best of care has been taken in producing a quality product! Our party enjoyed rum raisin, the ever so boozy Kalhua and coffee. As well as strawberry while the hubby went for a very large chocolately shake made with the Frankenstein flavor. Nothing was left over... so A+ on the choices! In fact, it was gone before I could get a photo! The gentleman who assisted was also a joy... and the store, decorated in a funky 70's motif kept everything groovy. read more

We had a fabulous time at this delicious ice cream shop! Thanks to Paula for helping us to find the right flavor of ice cream to enjoy. I especially appreciated the fact that they had a non-dairy selection of ice cream -which by the way was super yummy. The rest of our group truly enjoyed their liquor-enhanced ice creams. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Paula our amazing server! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

I was not expecting the store to be what it was, but it was pretty cool. The employee (who seemed like the owner) working the night I came in was insanely friendly. We ended up getting 3 different orders of ice cream. Portion sizes are nice, and the ice cream is good. If and when i'm back in the area, I will absolutely stop back in for more. read more

I have had this multiple times it is very good my favorite flavor is Rollo or anything with caramel I love caramel a lot I don't know what you guys do but I love it. The guys their are really nice I don't know their names but their really cool. I don't have any pictures but I wish I took some the inside looks like the 1980s or whenever peace was suppose to be celebrated I forgot what it's called. read more

Such a great ice cream shop with delicious homemade flavors. Scott served us and is extremely friendly and helpful. Love the decor and atmosphere. We had the "adult" Kahlua Fudge Brownie and Classic Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl for the DD Both were great! read more

See all

Great ice cream shop in Leesburg! I love how they make their own ice cream. This is their 2nd location. The atmosphere is fun and nicely decorated. The staff is super friendly and helpful. Most importantly the ice cream is delicous with unique flavors! A bonus is a salted pretzel stick in your ice cream for that added salty to your sweet! read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Peanut Butter Crunch.....so good!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

We love the Baileys flavor ice cream It has a great flavor and true to taste. Great consistency. The service is great and looks like the people always having a fun time. We usually take it to go read more

I have gone to mystic Ice Cream for 3 years to get ice cream and the ice cream is incredible. The atmosphere inside is very relaxed with movie posters and artists and very colorful. If you go frequently you can get a stamp card and if you get 10 punches, you can spin a wheel and get a free gift! The people who work there are very nice down to earth and make me want to come back read more

An absolute wonderful experience. The ice cream is homemade, and they come virgin or loaded. The ambiance was a throwback with album covers, 45's, and other vintage decor. A definitely must visit. read more

See all

Infused ice cream available for Adult beverage lovers. You can even try samples prior to purchase. Service was great too.

Tasty tasty ice cream. Lots of cool flavors. The staff were all very nice. My daughter and I really enjoyed it. I wish it was closer so I could go back more often. read more

Great homemade ice cream and excellent staff and great place to hang out. This is the Leesburg, FL location which is in downtown Leesburg and tend to head to this location to support downtown Main Street businesses. No outside seating but the inside seating makes up for it with all the memorabilia on the walls, etc. There are two other locations (Eustic and Fruitland Park (which has many activities on different nights (karaoke, trivia, game show, etc.)). There is also a ice cream truck that they have that goes to events, etc. read more

We came by to start our road-trip shenanigans early with some ice cream. We had Peanut butter whiskey and jam, coffee, cherry, Kahlua fudge. The were all delicious. We grabbed two shirts to be our road-trip shirts! Fun place and great ice cream! read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

See all

The ice cream is made in small batches so you know it's fresh. We sampled pretty much the adult ice creams and ended up getting Banana's Foster (absolutely amazing) my husband got the White Russian and then a blueberry one. Both of those were good as well. The man works was super nice and helpful since we'd never been there before. read more

They're ice cream is that good.And the workers are kind people.I can't think of a single reason for anyone to dislike it.And I don't think there is any better ice cream place. read more

Mystic Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Leesburg, Florida

See all

Great homemade ice cream. The staff were nice. The ice cream as tasty. I would definitely go back. I wish it wasn't so far away.

Great little ice cream shop! Friendly efficient service and wonderful ice cream! The shop is decorated with lots of cool memorabilia. We sat and visited and consumed our ice cream and never felt rushed. Will definitely go back! read more

Really good ice cream! Unfortunately, nearly as expensive as filet mignon! Weird hours, always check before making the drive.