We have been going to this thrift store for almost six years, and during our visits we usually find something we often didn't know we needed (or wanted). They sell donated furniture and home goods, as well as jewelry, books, and games. Profits benefit a local Christian school. Because their inventory turns over so quickly and they get new items constantly, they can't hold items longer than COB that day. Each week they have sales on different items so it's helpful to check their Facebook page. The staff are friendly and helpful. Prices are very good. Parking is free Ave right out front. read more

New2You Thrift Store - Thrift Stores Near Me - Williamsburg, Virginia

This store used to feel more like a traditional thrift store with affordable pricing and fun "treasure hunt" finds. Over time, it seems to have shifted more toward a resale/antique boutique model, with many items priced closer to online resale values. I completely understand that costs have gone up, and I do appreciate the store's mission, the friendly staff, and the quality of many of the items they carry. Their furniture selection in particular still seems fairly priced. That said, shoppers looking for lower-cost thrift store bargains may want to adjust expectations a bit compared to years past. read more

This place really is a hidden gem. It's hard to believe that it is a thrift store, because it has a very upscale and classy feel to it. Everything is very well organized and presented. A varied selection of items, prices were great, and the people working there were very friendly. I will absolutely be going back again next time that I'm in Williamsburg. read more

Great selection of nice items. Upscale thrift store with very friendly staff that provides excellent customer service!

Very pleasant and welcoming staff especially compared to the other places we had visited in the area ("consignment shops" ) where Williamsburg snobbery seems to be a thing around here. We had a really good experience with very fair prices. Cute shop that benefits a school! Will definitely come again when in Williamsburg! read more

From looking at comments I see this store has come a long way. It is a delightful gift shop with helpful staff. A hidden gem in the Wmsbg. area! It is immaculate with quality items presented in a gift shop setting. read more

We were there yesterday and we purchased 2 ladder back chairs. Your store is amazing and such good prices. The staff was really helpful and friendly. We will definitely be back again when we come that way. read more

For eons, I didn't know this store was here - so I missed all of the negative experiences some folks seem to have had. When I finally found this spot, it was clean, brightly lit, well-stocked with only quality items - which is rare in a thrift shop! - and the ladies working there were very friendly. Expect to see furniture, antiques, and a small but all name-brand array of clothing. I learned that this is to raise funds for a local private school's scholarship program, so when you shop here you are supporting a great cause! read more

I've been in this store several times and it keeps getting better! Not only was I greeted by the lady in the front, she was very helpful asking if I found everything I was looking for when I checked out. I found a newer, high quality 12 quart enamel pot with a lid for $10, great for making soups and I am tickled. Before new management came in, the store was not a very well kept place and seemed kind of grungy to me. Well, times have changed and I am impressed! I think their prices are fair and store well put together. They have a holiday section that is helpful when looking to decorate and clothing and accessories are fashionable and worth a look. If there is any criticism for the store it's that there may be too much to look at on the shelves but if you are a treasure hunter it is a fun store to be in. read more

New management is horrible. It didn't seem like they knew what they were doing. Prices have sky rocketed and the stuff isn't that great. I wouldn't mind paying a little more if they had good items but the items new2you put out is broken and very used. I would not recommend this store and I certainly will not be back. Costumer service was horrible I was not greeted when I entered the store and when I asked for help the older lady didn't know where anything was. read more

This is a wonderful little boutique-like thrift store. It's a great place to stop in on a regular basis to Look at all of their new items. Very seldom will you see anything that is junk. This is a great store with large variety of items. Typically you will see antique-type Furniture and collectibles. They carry a nice selection of brand-name clothes. Add this to your list of stops if you live in Williamsburg or visiting. Good luck bargain hunters! read more

This place is a little diamond in the rough. While it is small, it is well presented and organized. The prices are great and we will definitely be back! read more

This store is filthy and unorganized! If I could rate this store less than a 1 I would! The employees are rude, when I asked for help they act like they don't want to be there. I will never come here again and I am going to tell everyone I know never to shop here. read more

Really smelt bad, like it was never new to begin with, plus is always close. no bueno.

When building a business it's always best to remember people who have put in hard work to ensure YOUR success. I will never shop at your store and nobody else should spend their hard earned dollars there either. read more

This is an okay thrift store but I would not contribute to it's recipient, Williamsburg Christian Academy. There are a lot better area thrift stores that don't sponsor schools like this. No great finds when I was there but the staff was polite. read more

The reviews that say this store is filthy, has broken items, has bad employees, that "they don't want your business if your not a bible thumper" could not be further from the truth. I've been visiting this store once every couple of weeks for quite some time. The quality of the items in this store is awesome. As with all thrift stores, might have to clean something up a bit when you get it home but it's a thrift store not a department store. I've bought dishes and silverware there is pristine condition as if it was never used. The employees are just as friendly and helpful as they can be. They are always putting out new items from the back and moving things around to make room for new items. As for the "bible thumper" comment, not one time in the entire time I've been going to this store has anything even remotely of this nature happened. This is a wonderful thrift store staffed by wonderful employees! read more