1. O'Reilly Auto Parts

    1. O'Reilly Auto Parts

    0

    Menasha, WI

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    O'Reilly Auto Parts

    5.0 (1 review)
    Closed 7:00 am - 9:00 pm
    Updated a few days ago

    Services - O'Reilly Auto Parts

    Auto battery and fluid recycling

    Vehicle battery testing

    O'Reilly Auto Parts Photos

    From this Business

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - O'Reilly Auto Parts

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Valerie W.
    95
    302
    60

    8 months ago

    Sam was very kind and helpful. Checked out my car out in the cold with me after masking my purchase to be sure it was right

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - O'Reilly Auto Parts

    You might also consider

    Custom Offsets - The wheel smh looks nothing like the one on the box or that I ordered

    Custom Offsets

    (119 reviews)

    (Original Review) The wheels would have been great, if…read morethere hadn't been a manufacturers defect. Unfortunately, we bought the wheels a couple of months before installing them, assuming they would be great. When it came time to install them 2.5 months later, we found out there was a bad manufacturer's defect in one of the wheels that could be seen with the naked eye. Also, it was severely out of balance and the wheel cap didn't fit. Customer Service was super lacking. Phone number just leads to voicemail or referral to email them. Emailed them, and they basically said "not our problem, it's been over 30 days, you have to contact the manufacturer." So, we did, and the manufacturer's representative said "it's no big deal, we will replace it, but you do have to go through Custom Offsets." Ultimately, the ONLY option they gave us was: We had to pay for another new wheel, wait for it to arrive, make an appt and pay to have the tire swapped, and pay for shipping to send it back so they could "inspect it and refund us." Long story short, they sent updated every 2-4 days for nearly a month saying "the inspection hasn't happened yet" (keep in mind, the defect was VERY apparent). Finally, we called VISA and submitted a dispute (after 6 weeks of back and forth with this terrible company). They looked over our documentation and agreed that Custom Offsets was wrong, approving the dispute amount for the one extra wheel we were forced to purchase) Ironically, the SAME DAY VISA opened the dispute, we received an email from Custom Offsets saying the inspection was "complete" and the refund was being issued. I have to believe this was NOT a coincidence. I guess you just have to get the big dogs at VISA involved before they quit playing games with you. Save yourself the time and effort and buy from someone else. (UPDATED REVIEW) After posting reviews online, a representative from Custom Offsets reached out with a sincere apology for our troubles.  He was very nice, and even offered to send out an extra wheel for future use in case it is needed.  This gesture was appreciated, but I do wish they had put more of that effort in the first stages, before having all of the troubles along the way... It would have been the difference between a 5 star review and a 2 or 3 star... We understand that things happen, but the response from the company makes all the difference.

    Payed hundreds of dollars for a rim that turned out to be the wrong size, tried to return it and…read morethey claimed a tire was mounted when our shop said they didn't mount one, then I get told we can pay additional money to get the rim we can't even use back or just be out the hundreds of dollars with no rim... meanwhile throughout the process I asked multiple times for help figuring out the correct rim size and not once did they help with that. So still driving on a cracked rim out of necessity with no clue how to figure out what size I actually need.

    O'Reilly Auto Parts - autopartssupplies - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...