Old Chicago Pizza is great! Their pizza is delicious, but I typically go there for their salads... especially their apple, walnut, and Gorgonzola salad... it's yummy! read more

The pizza crust was terrible! We ordered hand tossed, which we've had before, and this crust was even thinner than actual thin crust pizza! UPDATE: www brought it to the waitresses attention and she said it was hand tossed crust. Later i stopped a male employee that had come out from the kitchen. When I started to point out the crust he seemed to already know what I was talking about and said he would bring another pizza. Obviously, the waitress had reported it to the kitchen, but no one came out to correct the problem until I flagged a person down to complain a second time. While I'm pleased to get the pizza replaced, it wasn't until we had already eaten half of the first pizza and only then because I complained a second time. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - No, this is NOT the thin crust pizza. This is what they claimed is their hand tossed pizza crust. - Pizza Near Me - Salina, Kansas

Place could be a little bit cleaner foods great staff suck they got roaches managers don't communicate with the workers

Ate here last night. Somewhat mediocre food. Table service was their shining star this time. Bar service was mid. This place forgot they are a bar. Closes at 10 atmosphere used to be fun not anymore. read more

spaghetti was bland and watery. food/chicken had no seasoning. service was good, just took a while to be sat in an empty restaurant. read more

Went out for my dad birthday, we were seated with a big group so we understood the little wait. Had a good menu and lots of choices. If you do get the Chicken & Mac, ask for extra sauce, if not it will come out dry. Had to wait to eat, silverware came out after food. Overall good, but probably not going to get the same thing. read more

After the Boz Skaggs show on Nov 2, we stopped by for a drink. Server/Bartender had a very bad attitude. Passed on taking our order and went to customers who arrived a few minutes after us. No way she would have missed us. Another employee took our order and gave it to her. My husband got his drink and I never got mine. lt felt deliberate. She wasn't busy at all. We watched her on the other end of the bar as we waited for her to mix my drink. Never happened. But she was DIGGING BOTH FINGERS INTO HER TEAR DUCTS. That's when I decided I didn't want her mixing anything for me. As we got up to leave I calmly let her know my husband didn't touch his drink and that we were leaving. As we turned to walk away we heard a loud slam. Another pair of customers came in a few minutes before we left, they saw her antics. There was an hour to 45 minutes before OC closing time when we got there. I've read the reviews and there are some bad ones for this establishment. My last few visits have been good but this particular visit was a very bad experience for this paying customer. read more

Pizza came to us at room temperature Tasted good just not hot pizza. Manager didn't have the guts to apologize to us or even talk to us read more

I'm from Kansas City, MO. World smallest pizza and not thin. Too expensive for the size. Do they not know how to make a thin crust? Not happy. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - That's the thin crust! lol. Look at how small the box is and then the pizza. It's like a mini pizza for kids. - Pizza Near Me - Salina, Kansas

Stopped in after driving all day from Tennessee before we head to our hotel for the night. We had the chi trio. All very good. I'm very happy the red sauce came on the side as I'm not a fan. I had the chicken apple walnut salad and it was very good. Hubby had the wings. Asked for them to be naked and they were served sauces. He did admit they were still very good. All in all good good and decent service. With the exception of the coffee I was served. I think the creamer curdled. Kinda gross. read more

Had lunch there today and it was so good! Our salads had lemon vinaigrette dressing that I wish I could buy in a bottle. We also had a farmers daughter pizza with a hand-tossed crust and it was really tasty too! Amanda was a terrific server!!! read more

Where do I even start ; this place is great. Great food , amazing ambiance ! And the service we received from our server Amanda was immaculate. If you haven't stopped by yet let this be your calling :) 10/10 and the Tuscan pizza is a top tier option in case you're looking for a flavorful pizza. read more

We use to love Old Chicago. Then management change a year or so ago. Since then it's been getting worse and worse. Service is slow. Our appetizers were short on count and I was the last to get my meal after they forgot to put in with the rest of the order. Waitress to the manager took zero ownership. It's sad because this could be an incredible place for Salina. read more

We were in Salina for a day and, when we visit new places, we check out their pizza scene (as well as coffee and bookstores). Old Chicago did not disappoint! We went early-ish on a Tuesday, so no crowed and the staff was just begging for people to sit and eat! We were promptly seated and served. Riley was our server and see was on top of it: getting our drinks, recommending items, and all with the friendliest of demeanors. We ordered a large hand-tossed crust pizza with mushrooms, onion, and half sausage and a short order of buffalo wings (5 wings). The food came out in a timely manner and was delicious. A large pizza there is not a huge NYC-sized pie. 8 moderate pieces, but the hand tossed crust was amazing, in you like a slightly thicker crust with and nice handle of dough to hold on to on the outside ring. The toppings were plentiful and no need for extra cheese. The sauce has a touch of a kick to it on its own, but mixes really will with the toppings. The wings were meaty enough and the buffalo sauce was superb. And if you go, try to sit in Riley's section. She checked on us often (but not too often) and would sing here questions, "How's it all TASTing?" etc. So pleasant and who knew we'd get a show with dinner? All in all, a great experience in Salina (along with so many other places we visited that day). read more

My wife and I had been on the road all day and by the time we found a place to stay, we were starving. Took a chance on Old Chicago and couldn't have been happier! Pizza was amazing. Best food we've had on the road so far. If we lived in Salina, this would be our go-to for pizza, hands down. read more

I ordered pepperoni and black olive pizza. only 2 pieces had black olives on it and there was no cheese on half of several pieces. The service was very slow and the waitress never came back for drink refills. This place has really gone downhill. It wasn't even busy so that isn't an excuse. read more

First timer! The wait wasn't too bad. We got to our booth but the chair was dirty. We went ahead and ordered. I got the Farmers Daughter and was actually very good! I got it hand-tossed in individual. The server was nice but did forget a couple things like my co-workers sauce and napkins. We had to remind them a few times till we got it. I understand it's busy but we shouldn't be reminding them so many times for small request. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Farmers Daughter Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Salina, Kansas

That was so swag. 100% recommend the pizza, also had the cheesy garlic bread & Sicilian pepperoni rolls. All amazing, including the bar. Interior was pretty neat, very clean. read more

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Large hand tossed pizza with green peppers, roasted garlic, & pepper jack cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Salina, Kansas

great beers, great service Enjoy the bar and all the selections. The beer tours and mini tours are fun. read more

Easily the nicest Old Chicago I've been too. Visited the franchise in OKC, Wichita, KC, Joplin, Omaha etc and this location in Downtown Salina is the nicest I've been too. Food was great, service was great, beer was cold. They also have an amazing private event room. You'd be hard pressed to find a better place to catch a game and get cold beer in Salina ‍ read more

I find myself coming to town and enjoying a nice meal. Very casual but good food. TVs to watch the game. I love the Italian nachos or a great burger. The menu has a great selection and lots of cold beer on tap. read more

My girlfriend and I patronized this restaurant about three days ago. The pizza and the service were great! The margarita was pitiful little or no alcohol in it whatsoever for $10. Not sure if we will ever go back, plenty of other places to eat. The reply from old Chicago about my review is unacceptable, you blew it, read more

The wait staff was really nice but the quality of the food was not great I got a pizza and within a few hours I began to feel sick and ultimately had food poisoning symptoms three hours after eating the food. read more

Some reoccurring issues with the kitchen. Draft beer selection needs reevaluation and tap lines need cleaned out. All of that to say, Salina does not have many legit options, so this place is still in my Salina top 5 spots. read more

Good food, but they do NOT have Chicago-style deep dish pizza. And for the record, Detroit (from Detroit-style) is in a completely different state from Chicago. read more

Bar service is fantastic, however, there's some kind of sewer smell coming from behind the bar that's revolting. Shortened my stay, couldn't stand the smell. read more

We've had the opportunity to visit Old Chicago twice. The first time was at a location in Wichita. That was some time ago, and I did not write a review, and honestly, I can't recall the experience. So, that being said, I decided to try the local one here in Salina. Let me preface my review, by letting you all know, that I've been to Chicago, IL a few times, and have had the pizza at Lou Malnati's. Because of that, I had a few expectations about what I would experience during our visit to Old Chicago. And I can tell you, my experience was exactly as I had expected. We stopped into Old Chicago, and was given a limited menu. Ok, This is understandable given the current situation. We decided on the "Chicago Thick" pizza, which I naturally assumed was a deep dish pie, similar to that which you would actually find in Chicago. Turns out I was wrong. When I asked if they could make my pie the actual way they do in Chicago, you know, with the sauce on top. They said that that was not possible with the pizza I ordered, and they did have one that was a "Deep Dish" that was made that way, however, they could not make that one. Turns out, the "Deep Dish" was removed from the menu and is not planning a return of any kind. So, we ordered the "Chicago Thick" which came out in record time. And let me tell you it was very thick. The crust was well over 1 1/2" thick. It lacked a decent layer of sauce. In fact, at some point, we were dipping our "pizza" into the sauce that came with the garlic bread and cheese sticks we ordered. The cheese layer was acceptable, and the toppings were a bit over cooked. Now, a little background... Old Chicago pizza was founded in Boulder, CO. Old Chicago does NOT have ANY locations in the Chicago area, and to be honest, I doubt they could survive in Chicago. There are MANY misconceptions about Chicago Pizza. The biggest one is that because it's a deep dish pie, that the crust is thick. It's really not. It may be thicker than a NY Style crust, but what we got at Old Chicago had mostly bread with a scant amount of sauce, and an adequate amount of toppings. I can say that I won't be eating there again. I will, however, plan another trip to Chicago, and stopping off at Lou Malnati's. In the mean time, I will be making my own pizza's at home. read more

Went in today about 3:30. Ordered drinks and an appetizer and asked our waiter if we would have drinks and appetizer first then order a pizza. No bartender at the bar and we waited 10 minutes then I saw someone come from the kitchen to the bar, chewing and wiping her mouth with her hand. Our waiter came by and we asked for our drinks. He said he told her and she was going to start them. Waiter said our spinach dip appetizer was almost done and asked for our meal order. So we ordered our pizza even though we wanted to have our drinks a appetizer first. The drinks came. My Margarita was terrible! The mix tasted old and no salted rim. Dip was ok and the pizza nothing special. Second time we have tried and disappointed both times. Maybe bartender needs to review health codes and making a good margarita. Server need to not rush people. Besides us there were 3 tables of 2 and 1 person at the bar. Will not be back to this OC in Salina. read more

This was our second time eating here. Food was terrible the first time we came, we decided to give it another try by ordering something different. Flies everywhere you literally need to keep swapping around cuz there's so many flies coming for your food. It KILLED my appetite. We barley touched our food, it was disgusting. Waste of money honestly, food is not great. read more

I order ticket to see Kansas, I looked to see where to eat at, I seen my favorite place was in Salina, next block over from my concert so I was happy, was I disappointed! No, Friday was cold but Saturday afternoon was nice, took lady there to eat,the patio was Saturday afternoon because of sun but not all the time,pub Irish crawl was that day,the staff was super nice and when you meet lady, you would luv her too just like the staff,I forgot I'm not Olathe, where happy hour is seven days and here it's just Monday to Friday,the building is nice and two ways to get in,nice parking lot in the back, easy to get in and out,just finished a mini tour and had to explain to server what to do, I don't mind helping out, as a mug member wanting other guests to have the same experience I had, looking forward to go back read more

See all

Food wasn't bad...service wasn't great....half way through my meal I reminded my server about my beer that I had ordered....paying attention to detail is rather important to me.... read more

Food was good but took 30 minutes to get it. At 230 in the afternoon. I also knew 2 of the managers there that wouldn't even look me in the eye. Or bother to fake it and say hi to a paying customer. This is a small town where everyone knows everyone and if you want to survive, you better at the very least, AS A MANAGER, say hello. Extremely disappointed in the disrespect. Kristin was great, per usual. read more

Best beer location in Salina, hands down. At 40 taps, they have about double what nearest competitors have, with very strong selection of central Kansas beer including Defiance (my favorite), Three Rings, and Blue Skye down the block. The "Chicago deep" pizza is in the style of Uno Pizzeria franchises, which is not actually Chicago style, but it's satisfying. They also have other crust styles. Good lunch value with personal pizza bottomless salad. Wings also solid. Antacids helpful with their whole menu though... But mainly I'm here for the beer, good happy hour deals, and great weeknight late night deals (half off!). Very busy, long waits during peak times, so happy hour and late night is way to go. read more

The Philly cheesesteak was amazing with the jerk seasoned fries. I forgot about this place until we stopped on a road trip. It will for sure be a new go-to. Awesome service and great food! read more

Went in for lunch with the office staff and two of us ordered the lunch special pizza and salad. When we got our pizzas, neither one of us had noticed that our crusts had been mixed up. However, without missing a beat, one of the managers, Andrew, had already come out with 2 fresh pizzas and said there was a mix up in the kitchen. So, we ended up with 2 pizzas to go on the house ! Kudos to Andrew and the kitchen staff. read more

The service was fantastic. The salads fresh. The wings succulent. Good beers. And the walk along Main Street was interesting and is going to be wonderful when finished. What a wonderful surprise this restaurant was. Everything was good but a special thanks to the staff. read more

Ate there tonight with my husband and our food was delicious and our service was excellent! I highly recommend the Italian nachos

the service was good but the pizza was mostly sauce and almost no cheese and the toppings didn't even go 2/3 of the way up the slice.

I decided to give it a try. Big mistake! The food was horrible. I ordered a pizza, spaghetti, and cheesy garlic bread. The pizza was actually one of the worst I have ever had. It tasted old. The sauce wasn't good, and the thick crust was terrible. Save your money! I have felt nauseous since I ate half a slice of pizza. I definitely think the ingredients were outdated. I definitely won't go there again. read more

Service is pretty slow, the food was as expected like any Old Chicago. You're better off just going here for the happy hour specials.