Cheese, cheese and more cheese! One side of the place is alllllll the cheese. The other is the…read moregift shop. There are so many varieties of cheese available. Everything like traditional cheddar and swiss to more unique options like veggie, and buffalo wing. Most of the cheese had samples. It was a perfect way to get a sense of the differences between some of the varieties (standard vs smoked vs aged for example). Most cheese could be purchased in blocks, slices and cubes. They also had some beef stick options, dips and cheese fudge. I had never heard of cheese fudge before so was very intrigued. It had a different texture and flavor than traditional fudge but was definitely worth trying. They also have traditional fudge on the other side of the store. There were workers behind the counter actively packing cheese and willing to answer any questions you might have. Much like other tourist attractions, you have to walk through the gift shop to get to the cash registers. The line was kind of long, but it moved fairly quickly. This was a great stop with a lot of tasty products. Definitely recommend a visit!

Stopping at Heini's is an Amish country tradition. What was always great about this place, was…read moretheir samples. You could try all the cheeses and take home your favorites! COVID guidelines took that away, but I'm happy to report the samples have returned Locally made from fresh ingredients, you will find some of the best tasting cheeses here. Plenty of other interesting items as well, like nuts, candies both new and classic and many other things for the eager tourist.

Best place to buy cheese on the planet. Their Colby is as addictive as Crack. Wonderfull people and…read moreservice

I love this place! The extra sharp white cheddar is like nothing else! I have dreams about it. lol…read moreIf you're in the area and you don't visit, you'll never know how good cheese can be. Also they give tours!

What cheese is available is still good, but to be honest it is a shadow of its former self. In the…read more90's that place was amazing! I went back last summer and was very very very disappointed. I assume new ownership and a lack of managerial skills is the reason. The cheese is still decent, but the place is nothing like it once was. But, to be honest, what is. The 90's were the best of times and we are living in the worst of times. That being said, the cheese is still good.

I bought several cheeses, apple butter and pickled eggs! All did not disappoint! they had several…read morejams, canned fruits, relishes and spices all from Amish hands. Delicious!! My sister bought wine!

I visited in July 2025 with some friends. We were visiting Ohio Amish country for the day and…read moredecided to stop by this store. My friends really wanted to visit the Guggisberg cheese factory but they were closed for the day. This store offers not only cheese but other smaller grocery and household items such as butter, apple butter, mugs, t-shirts, etc. I don't like cheese so I didn't buy any cheese. My friends may have bought small cheese blocks but I can't remember. They did sample some cheese which they liked. MY PURCHASES -- I bought an Italian bread dipping mix which is a small tin of herbs. I finally tried the dip in April 2026 by adding olive oil the dipping bread in it. The spice mix is too strong so I don't like it that much and I don't believe it was made locally. I also bought Apple butter which is locally made and tastes good. The Apple butter is too sweet for me though so I've hardly eaten it but it goes well with toast. If you're in the area, stop by this local store. The back of the store is cute because of a little fountain and a well-kept lawn. **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 87/250 total reviews in 2026 - 928 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 19 May 2026

Part deli, part gift shop, part factory. This cheese shop's…read moreclaim to fame is is that they are the creators of baby swiss. They are apparently now one of the largest manufacturers of swiss cheese in the US. When you enter, there is a shop which is a combination of gift shop, cheese accessories and grocery items. There is signage that shows off their awards, talks about some of their history and also takes about the difference between regular and baby swiss. The deli where you can get freshly sliced cheese is in the back. The clerks were extremely friendly answering questions and providing samples of anything you want to try. Much like the outside, the inside continues the swiss theme. The reason I gave it four instead of five stars is the space itself. It was really congested even though it wasn't really all that crowded. I can't imagine what it would be like on a busier day. J don't know what, if anything can be done about this that, but it definitely can be hard yo navigate if you have mobility issues or don't like crowds. Oh and the cheese hats are a fun nice touch.

This place was an absolute mad house on a Saturday afternoon. I don't know if it was the perfect…read moreweather we were having or if that was the norm for a Saturday at Walnut Creek Cheese & Market, but it surely made for a stressful shopping experience. Lines were wrapped throughout the large market and I found myself weaving between carts and lines everywhere. There were several displays that I couldn't reach, but what I did get to was tempting! I browsed the extensive cheese and meat selections, all of the candy, and some of the baked goods in the center. I left with cheese curds, meat sticks, and a plastic clamshell of root beer barrels. I thought the prices were fair for the quality of the products. The store was massive and laid out in an organized way. They even had a seating area upstairs that I would love to come back and check out.

Aisles are tight but so much to explore!…read more There is a full grocery store with bonus things tucked in. Great service at the meat counter. We found a lot of unique items that aren't a carried at normal stores like some bulk items, seasonings and baking supplies. They have a fresh bakery area and a whole sections of jams and jellies. Plus lots of cheese!

They have an amazing selection of meats and cheese! The staff is very knowledgeable and friendly…read more The shop is small and puts me in the mind of a quaint country market. They have a wonderful selection of cheese knives, boards and fondue pots. When I asked them to help me with a meat and cheese board for my Halloween Wedding they went above and beyond!!! I plan to continue to use them for all of my catering!

I love this place. They have quite a few specialty deli items like cheese and meats. If you're…read moremaking a charcuterie board, you need to go here. The owner is super nice and willing to let you sample the product before you buy. Very nice inside. If you're looking for specialty items, this is the place.

The freshness of the cheese and everything else they sell. Wish I lived closer. Never been…read moredisappointed with the quality or the service.

Fabulous Sausage at Yaggi's ~ we get it shipped to our door along with their fabulous Swiss cheese!!read more

Incredible selection of Amish cheeses and bake goods..read more

From the owner: Valley Cheese has been family owned and operated for three generations. We specialize in Amish…read morecheeses, meats, jams, jellies, beef jerky, noodles, chocolates, gift baskets, party trays, and much more. Come try our full line of deli meats and cheeses sliced to perfection for the perfect deli sandwich.

Decent sandwich lots of cool candy's. Place deserves an F for customer service. I observed 2 older…read moregentlemen struggling to place sando/salad orders, while 4 employees twiddled their thumbs. Trying to find their eye glasses, attempting ask question to which the response amounted to yellow form, white form, menu below, you fill it out. One obviously infirmed man, tried failed, sat down to rest, then tried again to fill out order firm. I have run businesses and delis, the forms make sense in a mad lunch rush, sure, but otherwise it's license for young employees to be brusque to rude. Management fail!

We had the pleasure of enjoying a huge lunch, a full sub and large salad, enough we made 2 meals…read moreout of it, and the wide variety of drinks, beers and the Candy selection was incredible. It reminded my husband and I of our childhood and going to 5 and Dime stores. The staff behind the counter were so nice, accommodating to those who did not know how the ordering was done. The tall lady and the one with a full brace on her leg (didn't skip a beat, mind you) and the gentleman making the food were so fast, had smiles on their faces, laughed and sang along to the music. You could see they were happy to be there and were having fun serving you some wonderful food. The young lady working the register was kind and sweet and you could see the young man slicing fresh meats and cheeses so you know for sure just how fresh everything is made. Far better than Subway or other Sub Shop we have ever been to. Will definitely be going back and making it a regular lunch stop when we are down town. Did I mention the prices? You can't beat them!

We drive from western Pataskala to buy bulk orders of meat here. I've been a professional chef for…read more43 years. Ingredients make a big difference in your food. I get the best I can and will drive 60 miles to Collins and back 60 to get home to get the best. The service, kindness and smiles match the quality of the meat. Thanks.