Star ratings are difficult sometimes! I'd give this place a 4/5 for Idaho BBQ. However, we just…read morefinished up a Texas BBQ trip and this is would rate a little lower if it were located out that way. Here's the breakdown of what we ordered... Fantastic: Cucumber salad, broccoli salad (probably the best I've had) Very good: Mac and cheese (so cheesy!), beans, pulled pork, buns, sauce Average: Chopped brisket Below average: Coleslaw (big pieces of cabbage, a little bland) We are so happy to have found this on our drive to Boise. So much better than a fast food joint! We slammed every bit of our food and feel more than satisfied. Also, the prices were very reasonable. Thanks for a great experience, Burley Bros! Keep up the good work.

Outstanding BBQ! Pulled pork had great flavor as did the Memphis-style sauce. Very nice that they…read moremake their own sauces (and a nice variety) in-house. They were out of the brisket so I will be back soon to try that.

Brisket sandwich was great, lots of meat! Split the sandwich and was full (not sure why people are…read morecomplaining about not enough meat!). Get it with spicy bbq sauce, which is not really spicy, but has a nice kick.

I was excited to try this place as it was highly rated. I ordered my sandwich that had pulled pork…read moreand brisket on it. The portions were very generous and the brisket was dripping with juices when it was being carved. I ordered a side of Mac and cheese. It looked so good on my tray. Unfortunately my Mac and cheese was overcooked and had gummy noodles and a soupy texture despite being made with real cheese and being seasoned well. The brisket was as good as it looked but the dry and woody pulled pork ruined an otherwise perfect sandwich. The service was lackluster. I felt like I was bothering the staff. Make smaller batches of food so they don't overcook and train your staff to engage people. You are in a food hall, your competitors share a dining room with you.

we had this BBQ for a dinner party with my kids from Ammon, Pocatello, and our daughters' that were…read morevisiting from Philadelphia oh yeah, my sister who is here from Virginia also. His food was amazing. My husband and I have been everywhere, just about all 50 states, Canada, Porto Rico, and Europe and hands down the best BBQ in the world as we know it. We just order it to take to Idaho Falls for a guy's shower (diaper party). His ribs are amazing, his brisket I don't even cook it that well. His pulled pork and ChubbyZ' pulled pork are the best ever!!!!! If you are having a party like us he is so great to work with and is bringing it to my husband so he can take it to the party. How convient is that. So if you want lunch, dinner, party or just snackin' fun out where he is and get there early cause he runs out. Bryan and Carol Kelsey

The food was delicious. We had the double burger and biscuits and gravy. The biscuits were ample…read more The burger was juicy. The service was great. The waitress was kind.

This is a very nice place to eat every thing is fresh and very nice people work here.hamburger and…read morefresh French fries

We were jazzed to try Smokey Bone as an extension of this food hall…read more The menu was pleasantly overwhelming. Thought the three-meat sampler was good bang for our buck: brisket, pulled pork and smoked pork ribs. $18 for generous portions. We were gonna try the wings but after the server heaped the mounds of brisket and ribs on our tray - we scratched them. We also got corn bread and slaw for our a la carte sides. The meats were good, and good without the BBQ sauces (Carolina Vinegar, Spicy BBQ, Alabama Horseradish). Though we were basically drinking the vinegar by the end of the meal. The ribs were our favorite - lovely, crispy exterior with charred ends and tender once we dug in. The pulled pork was alright. Tasted more like it would work better as a topping on some mac or fries than as a main protein on your plate. I loved the corn bread. Dense and appropriately brittle. It was a fitting companion for the meats. Don't know when we'd be in town again to give other menu items some attention, but Smokey Bone has left a lot of good eats to the imagination - enough to know we could recommend this place to other out-of-towners without getting our foodie cards revoked.

Not impressed with this bbq! Got the brisket and corn bread…read more Flavor on brisket is just ok but without sauce it's dry! The corn bread is just ok more sweet cakey flavor than a good bbq corn bread. The young man cutting the meat was fine but the girl at the register wasn't. I asked for butter for the cb and she forgot it. When I looked in the box I asked her for the butter and she tells me there is none. I ask if there's any in the back and she says no without going to even check and they were not busy. Then she gives me the same meh face she gave the guy in front of me when she told him they were out of the beans. Made no effort whatsoever to go out of her way to do much of anything. And this was at 6 pm on a Thursday night. Not a good experience.

This food amazing pork being tender and ribs pull right off the bone. Out doors and amazing people…read morethe best bbq

mediocre on the best day ... no brisket, no hot links sides…read moreare just OK ... I'm sorry I KNOW BBQ all over the south This is great BBQ IF you've never had great BBQ

Upon walking in we were greeted and then allowed to select from the posted menu…read more It was a hard choice because everything sounded great. But I finally choose the Outlaw with a side of coleslaw. The bun was very tasty and fresh. The brisket was tender and flavorful. There were two strips of bacon on top of the brisket and three onion rings on top of that. I took off the top bun, added some BBQ sauce and then proceeded to enjoy each thing piecemeal. Until I came to just the brisket and the bottom slice of bread which was small enough to fit into my mouth. It was all yummy. This was our lunch after a visit to Butterfly Haven which was wonderful and I would highly recommend both businesses.

Great BBQ restaurant. Busy people carefully crafting to perfection, fantastic homemade BBQ in an…read moreiconic Blackfoot landmark building. Tucked away down an offstreet, past anything else a person would go to sits a plain, dusty parking lot full of cars and trucks--That's how you know it's lunchtime at Smokin Gun BBQ. As soon as you open the door you are surrounded in old west theme, with old Coca Cola ads, Western movie posters on the walls, and old style wooden bench seats. You order at the counter, giving an insiders view to the sweet, busy, long time resident couple, Clint and Jeanne pouring love into the food. Immediately, Jeanne rushed over to us, not in the strong raspy southern drawl you'd expect, but sweet and softspoken as a dandelion. "I'm so so sorry, we got a really big order this morning, so we are out of brisket, and nearly out of ribs." She hurried back to work on the other side of the counter. One would think, "What? A BBQ place w/o brisket and ribs," but looking around at the full dining room of people grubbin down, they knew "everything here is good." So, without fuss, I ordered a Smoked Turkey Sandwich & Mac n Cheese. The turkey sandwich comes on jalapeno sourdough, with bacon ranch, swiss cheese and lettuce. She got some Pulled Pork and Coleslaw. Omgosh!, that turkey sandwich is magnificent! Crunchy, chewy, & grainy sourdough, with supreme house made dressing!! They make all their unique dressings in house. I will go back to Blackfoot just for that. The Mac& Cheese, lol, more like mini tubas bubbling with warm cheese. We didn't talk much to eachother during this trip cuz, 1. She was busy with verbalzing sounds to her juicey, smokey pork & slaw. Also, Clint entertained us at table side. Glib old guy with plenty of stories about his younger days, and his love of old western movies. He also proudly brought samples of their sauces and feature meats--It was a blast!, and I'm better for having met them! Please come show them some love, but show up prompt cuz first come first serve. Check the Pics.

Was a little worried about the price until I got three days worth of food! Love the root beer…read moreselection. The yellow sauce is so great.

It was okay. The local community raves about J Brian's but we found it overhyped and underwhelming…read more The Mac bowl was the most disappointing as the Mac & Cheese was something akin to Kraft Deluxe, but the photos make it look much better. The meat itself was good, but in the words of Abby Lee Miller, we were waiting for it to be great.

I normally don't eat barbecue north of the Mason-Dixon Line, but this place was in an old Texaco…read morestation and is veteran owned so I gave it a shot. I got ribs on their recommendation and brisket and both were tender and tasty. The spicy sauce was the way to go. The service was above and beyond though - the nicest people I've encountered in a restaurant in a long time! I wish them the best and I will be back.

Fantastic Food Great People…read moreAwesome Deal Recommend the Nachos and the Sampler Plates We had the nachos at lunch and took the 3 meat sample plate to go home for dinner. I am eating that now and couldn't be happier Great Cornbread and Mac Cheese too!