Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Pizzeria Puerto Madero

    3.6 (13 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza
    Open 11:30 am - 9:00 pm

    Pizzeria Puerto Madero Photos

    PIZZERIA PUERTO MADERO ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Outdoor seating
    Good for groups
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Pizzeria Puerto Madero

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    1 year ago

    Helpful 10
    Thanks 2
    Love this 6
    Oh no 2

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tania V.
    110
    244
    1258

    6 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 6
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    6 years ago

    Great variety pizza, fresh surroundings. Prices are reasonably fair. Currently going again since one time just wasn't enough for me.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Pizzeria Puerto Madero Reviews in Other Languages

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 2,363 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Pirilo - El Pecado

    Pirilo

    4.4(821 reviews)
    10.9 km
    $$

    If you're walking by, this restaurant would be very easy to miss. The entrance looks like a doorway…read moreleading to a stairwell or service entrance, and I honestly didn't even notice a sign. Luckily, there was a gentleman outside directing people in, otherwise we may have walked right past it. Once you climb the two flights of stairs, you're rewarded with a beautiful dining space. The restaurant has a rustic, old-world charm with gorgeous décor and an Italian-inspired atmosphere. It immediately felt warm and inviting. There were four of us dining, and we started with two appetizers: the Setas Rellenas and the Chorizo al Vino. Both were excellent, but the Chorizo al Vino was my absolute favorite--absolutely delicious! For my entrée, I ordered the chicken lasagna. I expected chunks of chicken, but it was made with shredded chicken, and wow--it was incredible. The flavor was outstanding, and it ended up being one of my favorite meals of our trip. My husband ordered the beef lasagna, which was also made with shredded beef rather than traditional ground beef. He absolutely loved it. Our friends ordered the Milanesa de Berenjena and the Milanesa de Pollo with a side of gnocchi, and both raved about their meals as well. Since nearly every table seemed to be ordering pizza, we knew we had to try one. We ordered a small pizza for the table, and each of us had a slice. Now we understand why they're known for their pizza--it was fantastic! A special shoutout to our server, Rouil Rodz, who was attentive, friendly, and provided excellent service throughout the evening. Don't let the unassuming entrance fool you. This restaurant is a hidden gem with a beautiful atmosphere, outstanding food, and excellent service. If you're visiting Old San Juan, I highly recommend adding it to your list.

    Killer pizza in an old school Puerto Rican spot. Kids loved…read morethe pizza. Wife smashed a sangria. I enjoyed a couple local beers.

    Photos
    Pirilo - Beautiful inside

    Beautiful inside

    Pirilo - Caprese salad, was incredible

    Caprese salad, was incredible

    Pirilo - Margarepa

    See all

    Margarepa

    Competidor's Pizza - crispy!

    Competidor's Pizza

    4.1(8 reviews)
    1.3 km
    $

    The pizza is really tasty and crispy, and the variety of pizza combinations is insane. They have 60…read morecombinations in total which is more than most pizzerias.

    Competidor's Pizza is a classic neighborhood pizzeria. My family on my dad's side worships this…read morepizza. Every time we are at my grandmother's house and we decide to get pizza, it is from here. My uncle frequents so much that he knows who to talk to to get it delivered to her house, even though she lives outside of the delivery radius. Even though I've eaten their pizza several times and driven by the restaurant, I had never set foot inside. Yesterday, I was in the area and decided to go for carry out. So, I finally stepped inside. The place is very plain. Nothing on the walls, no decorations anywhere, nothing. There was a TV but it was turned off and there were two arcades in the back but they too were turned off. Most likely neither worked. There wasn't even any background music. I went with the Teenage Mutant Pizza. It caught my eye because I grew up on the Ninja Turtles. The pizza had meatballs, ham, and chorizo toppings. I added mushrooms to it. Although good, I didn't love it. The meatballs didn't taste like meatballs. If I hadn't ordered it, I would have never guessed they were meatballs, maybe ground beef or sausage. I've had their pizza many times so I know what they can bring to the table and this wasn't their best. Still good pizza.

    Photos
    Competidor's Pizza
    Competidor's Pizza - Gender neutral restrooms

    Gender neutral restrooms

    Competidor's Pizza

    See all

    Tavola - Lasagna

    Tavola

    4.4(208 reviews)
    10.5 km
    $$

    Wow! This came as a referral from a friend and it does not disappoint. The apps are so yummy. The…read morearancini are so good I could have eaten a dozen. The garlic bread was fine, not as good as the arancini. If you are hungry, get the chicken parm, my god it is the largest portion I have ever seen! I ate one of the 3 cutlets they served. Most times when a place gives a ton of food it is ok, well this was fabulous. Super thin, light breading that remained crispy and just the right amount of cheese and sauce. The pizza was good as well. For dessert we had a well portioned flowerless chocolate cake which was paired with some vanilla bean ice cream. Divine! We sat in the restaurant portion near the secret door to the speakeasy so take your pick on what vibe you prefer. The wait staff were super helpful and responsive. We bought the kitchen staff a round for fun. Great experience, I recommend swinging by if you are in the neighborhood.

    Super impressed by this spot! We were SO happy that we got to sit in the speakeasy for dinner,…read morebecause it was exactly the kind of vibe we were looking for! The food was all delicious, and reasonably priced at huge portion sizes, particularly the chicken parm! The pasta was homemade and the sauces were so good. The weakest things were the burrata and the meatballs. Everything arrived to the table quickly, especially the drinks! We would totally come back on a future trip and will be recommending to others visiting the island.

    Photos
    Tavola - Speakeasy area

    Speakeasy area

    Tavola - Menu

    Menu

    Tavola - Speak easy

    See all

    Speak easy

    Fiore's Pizzeria and Bar - Meat lovers pizza small size

    Fiore's Pizzeria and Bar

    4.6(8 reviews)
    10.8 km

    Fiore's is such a cool spot to come in and grab a pizza while sightseeing in Viejo San Juan, it has…read morea really great atmosphere and the staff is amazing. We started with the pastelillo appetizer, they were fried to crispy golden perfection and both the beef and chicken ones were delicious. The green sauce that came with them was herbaceous perfection and we even got some more so that we can dip our pizza in. We got the pie with roasted garlic, prosciutto and pepperoni which was absolutely delicious. The pizza came out hot and fresh and all of the ingredients on it worked really well together and everything had great flavor. The little bites of whole roasted garlic cloves gives you that slightly sweet, caramelized garlicky goodness that us garlic lovers adore. The legal drinking age in Puerto Rico is 18 so my 19 year old nephew was over the moon that he was able to order himself a pomegranate margarita so it was fun to see him experience ordering his adult beverage! Overall we had a really great experience and the bartender was super friendly and helpful in all of the food and drink recommendations. Definitely add this to your next stop in Viejo San Juan.

    Okay, this is a super cool pizza joint located in San Juan near the ports. It is a great location,…read morewith a clean and cozy dining area inside and outside. They have big screen TV's and music. The service was great, our waitress/bartender made great drinks and our food came out quickly. The empanadas de pollo were hot, fresh, and really good! I would've ordered more but we didn't want leftovers. We ordered a really delicious pizza that had pepperoni, prosciutto, roasted garlic, and salad. It was perfection! The sauce ratio, the crust, the toppings, a true perfect blend! I know people don't travel to Puerto Rico for pizza but I had my fill of the traditional food and this pizza hit the spot! The margarita is basic, the pina colada was to be as expected, but the pomegranate mojito was extraordinary! (And really expensive! $13) Overall I really enjoyed this meal but $40 of the bill was food, $35 drinks! Next time I'll skip on the drinks or just get a beer.

    Photos
    Fiore's Pizzeria and Bar - Beautifully painted pizza peels

    Beautifully painted pizza peels

    Fiore's Pizzeria and Bar - Sampler Plate

    Sampler Plate

    Fiore's Pizzeria and Bar - Nice crunchy crust, won't disappoint

    See all

    Nice crunchy crust, won't disappoint

    Pizzeria Puerto Madero - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...