Thought was an Italian restaurant get some good eats nice Italian name . But stay away from pizza it's a dominoes in disguise . An the Italian hoagie yuck . read more

Best. Pizza. Ever. My family and I moved to Lebanon from New York when I was 7. My mom and dad both worked full-time. Needless to say, we lived off this pizza. Even today when I visit my mom I still frequent this place. The only difference - my husband comes along. He's in agreement that this is some of the best pizza he's ever had. Not to mention the cannolis that are made-to-order. Love the pizza. Love the place. Love that it's a family-run business. If you're passing through (God, I hope you're passing through - because Lebanon sucks) you should definitely make every effort to stop here. read more

Called in an order for a small sub. Menu says it comes with Italian dressing. They said I could only get mayo or oil & vinegar. I chose the latter, but got neither on the sub. Very slow service even though they were NOT that busy. Guy walking around doing very little, and when my sub came out from the back, it took about 5 minutes before this guy realized it was mine. To top it off, he overcharged me!!!! Pretty sure I won't be returning. read more

This is my all time favorite place for pizza - and trust me when I say I've had a lot of pizza! The only reason I give it four stars instead of five is because they often don't answer their phone and it's almost always a 45 minute wait for pick up. It's so so good though! read more

I recommend it it was very good food and also great service. Also a nice atmospheric just to relax with family friends and you can't go wrong. read more

Very disappointed in the large grilled chicken salad I purchased. When I took the brown bag containing my salad from the cashier, I could not believe the bag was so light. Got out to my car and opened it and was quite perturbed how little it was. Not much chicken as well. Never again, I'm done!! read more

This is our favorite pizza in Lebanon! We've ordered other things which have been average, not bad but not overly fantastic. But the pizza is always fantastic over everything else! read more

Been here many times before in the past and have always enjoyed they're food; subs, pizza, and desserts super yummy.

We visit her quite frequently the food is always great we always have great service . Very worth your time and money to visit here . Prices are very reasonable . read more

Great pizza and they deliver! We've ordered for delivery and picked up from here a few times already and their pizza is consistently good. read more

Pucillo's Pizza & Restaurant - Good pizza. They deliver. - Pizza Near Me - Lebanon, Pennsylvania

Loved this pizza so much! I can't believe I've lived in this area so long and only just tried it today. I can't wait to try some other things on the menu, their homemade bread looks amazing. The staff was super friendly and even gave me free garlic dipping sauce. I will be a frequent flier here I can promise that :) read more

Pucillo's Pizza & Restaurant - Large pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Lebanon, Pennsylvania

Well let me say that one of the biggest qualifiers is they deliver , we live out in the boonies of South Lebanon with nothing but cows and corn and they will deliver to us . The second thing is the food is pretty good . We haven't ordered pizza yet but we have had sandwiches, wings and fries . The sandwiches are above average thee wings are good but the fries left a little to be desired but like I said every time we have called it has been kind of late almost closing time and they pleasantly take our order and get the food right out to us read more

Ordered a turkey melt & French fries. This is what I got. That's not turkey, it's chicken. Also note the brown chunks in the lettuce. It was completely soggy & forgot the fries. read more

Pucillo's Pizza & Restaurant - a plate of lettuce in a styrofoam container - Pizza Near Me - Lebanon, Pennsylvania

See all

I ordered a large pepperoni pizza with extra cheese. I also ordered mozzarella sticks. All for delivery. It took one hour and fifteen minutes to deliver to my house less than a mile and a half way, and the pizza was that cold that the cheese would fall off the pizza. I had to re-heat it myself. The mozzarella sticks were cold too. read more

I had a cheesesteak it was well below average I would not go back. You may want to stop if it's the only place open or you ran out of gas. This place was better in the past read more

Pucillo's Pizza & Restaurant - the dining area - Pizza Near Me - Lebanon, Pennsylvania

Tried their newest addition to the everyday menu, Shrimp Scampi pizza! Let me tell you, it was phenomenal! I love that during these hard times this business has been continually supporting our community. Can't wait to try more dishes! read more

Delivery service is way to slow. It takes an hour to get to my house that's 9 minutes down the road for a sub and pizza. They do not follow instructions by customers as well. read more

Excellent pizza. As close to NY pizza as you'll come in this town. And I've tried them all. The first thing we did when we moved here was go on a pizza and Chinese food hunt. Still haven't found Chinese that measures up to NY, but this pizza does. The crust is thin and crispy not soggy and disgusting. There is the correct ratio of cheese to sauce and its frankly, delicious. Have eaten it since moving here from NY in '92 and plan on continuing to do so. And they have fresh filled cannolis, which is the correct way to eat them. You do not fill and cannoli and let it sit till it's soft and disgusting. You fresh fill them so they are hard and crispy. Very good filling. Certainly beats the disgusting things I've tried here before passing themselves off as cannolis. Cream cheese? Really you guy?!!! Well we are in Lebanon. Guess I should just be happy they didn't put gravy on it. read more

Fabulous pizza! Great sauce, crust and lots of cheese. Friendly staff. Very busy- great sign. Located a few miles off of Rt 501. So hard to find great pizza nowadays- until now. read more

Do not order from here. -okay pizza -Everything else is sub-par -mess up orders frequently (thanks for the onions I specifically asked not for) read more

Love their food, and the fact they deliver to Myerstown!!! Prices are very good, pizza is great, subs are excellent. Can get a kids Mac n cheese meal for only $2. Would recommend to anyone read more

Great food! Particularly enjoy the slice pizza, salad & drink lunch special. Take co-workers and their subs and fries are good, too. Good prices and service. Happy. read more

We've been a customer on and off for the past 15 years and liked some selections. Over the past 2+ years though the menu and the food have greatly improved! The pizza is great - the sauce, the crust, the toppings and the price! I've liked every sandwich so far, but don't care for some of the veggies included in the salads. We're only 3 miles away so we always pick-up, and never have to wait. And the staff there is very friendly. read more

The owner delivered my pizza today in a snowstorm. Unfortunately I did not have a tip for him (he doesn't take card tips over the phone). After apologizing, he gave me look and explained that he was only happy to have my business. What a great guy. Wonderful pizza too! Highly recommend this place. read more

Truly feel this place is hit or miss. Food is usually decent but service level is all over the place. We keep coming back but delivery service lacks so badly we just pick up ourselves. Definitely can be "off" on the phone and at the counter... but again, hit or miss. read more

Hands down some of the best Sicilian pizza you'll have ever tried east of NYC, to me at least. Dough is always nice and fluffy and the sauce is amazing. We drive over 45 minutes one way to get this pizza when we can, as we are not local to them! read more

Solid pizza place. It's always crazy though so call early or you may end up waiting for an hour.

A month ago I would have given Pucillo's 5 stars!! I would have said their sicilian was the best in town, even the best I ever had. Unfortunately it's been hit or miss and mostly miss lately. The pizza comes with too little sauce so we order extra sauce. Then the pizza comes very soggy and saturated with sauce. So the next time we say slight extra sauce, with no success. The last time we will ever order sicilian pizza from Pucillo's was yesterday when it came to us very thin in the center, soggy on the top with very sparse cheese and actually burnt to a crisp on the bottom. What the heck happened to this place? I previously recommended to many. I MUST go back and retract my recommendation. My guess is they lost a very good pizza chef and now don't have the ability to train their employees to be consistent. Work on it. We might try again in a few months as we did plan to make it our regular Friday night family treat. read more

Should have read online reviews and heeded warnings. Food arrive more than 2 hours after ordering and almost an hour and a half after their stated arrival time. Don't order from here if you want your food timely. read more

The quality of the food has to me gone way down, and after a visit there with some other people a few of us became sick. I had the chills and stomach cramps and felt really tired, and one more person had stomach issues all day as well. I will not be going back there even though I live in Lebanon county, and I really hope "new" owners can maybe buy the place and just make it a diner instead of another pizza place! And I know that its a family run business which makes it that much harder for me to write this review, I think this is my first negative review that I have written on the internet! And one last thing, the help seems more interested in talking with each other in the kitchen than attending to its customers. So while I really love the location of the restaurant with its farm views, every time I pass by I think of the huge potential this location would be for a really good place to eat in Lebanon county with its scenic views and its somewhat quiet location off of RT 897. read more