DO NOT HIRE. We hired Gulf Coast Property Management,…read morespecifically speaking to AnnMarie, to lease and manage our rental property in Fort Myers beginning in January 2026. The property remained vacant for over four months while under their management. During that time, the property was reportedly shown only twice. Despite the extended vacancy, we received very little communication beyond automated weekly emails stating there were "no updates" and "no recommendations at this time." I had to repeatedly request information regarding marketing efforts, showing activity, tenant feedback, and ANY recommendations to improve leasing performance. We were willing to adjust pricing and make changes if necessary, but we were provided with absolutely no proactive guidance - guidance you would expect from a professional property management company. On top of that, our new property manager went out today and discovered that the utilities had never been turned on, and there were mouse/lizard droppings throughout the home. We trusted Gulf Coast to help us rent and take care of this home as we are located out of state. They wasted 4 months of our time and thousands of dollars. This company is a scam and will not take care of your property.

We had a frustrating experience renting a vacation home from this property management company. The…read moreproperty was not properly prepared for our stay, and communication from the management company was unreliable throughout. The pool and outdoor areas had not been cleaned prior to arrival, making a key amenity unusable for the first portion of our trip. There were also issues with bedding that required multiple visits to resolve. Communication was inconsistent--we were told we would receive a call back regarding these issues on the first night, but that never happened and we had to follow up ourselves to get a response. Additionally, important details about the property setup (including a tenant on the property with visibility into the pool area) were not clearly disclosed during booking. While a partial refund was eventually issued, it did not feel proportionate to the disruption. Overall, this experience reflected inconsistent management and a lack of attention to detail.

Robert and Janet R Bradenton, FL…read moreTwo years ago, my wife and I decided that it was time to move to Florida. We wanted to rent in the Sarasota area but found places were going very fast! Then we came upon a rental from Florida West Coast Property Management and got in contact with Aimee Bahk. We knew we had to move quickly and Aimee helped get us through the process with ease! Aimee was friendly and professional. She knew the steps we were required to take for us to be approved as renters. Aimee quickly responded to any questions we had during the process. Once our move was successful, Aimee continued to keep in touch. We only had a couple of maintenance issues, which we considered normal, so we notified Aimee. Her response was fantastic! Aimee quickly got the help we needed for the repairs. On more than one occasion, Aimee would say "I appreciate you" as tenants. Well, we appreciate Aimee and want to thank her for all she has done to make our dream a reality!

We have been renting-out our Bradenton condo since 2008 and up until switching to Florida West…read moreCoast Property Managers about a year and a half ago, had a dreadful experience. You might say we were in an unhealthy, co-dependent relationship with our former management company. As in most relationships, it took a crisis for us to realize how badly our former manager was; our former tenant basically sold the property furniture out from under us and the manager claimed ignorance. Anyway, I digress. We were fortunate to have been referred to Florida West Coast Property Managers ("FWCPM") by a realtor when we were considering selling our property. The difference between our former management company and FWCPM could not be greater. Our manager Aimee Bahk is professional, courteous, and a delight to work with. She has helped us through many difficult situations such as finding new tenants and managing repair and installation work orders. If you are in need of excellent management for your rental property on the Florida west coast, look no further than the staff at Florida West Coast Property Management.

Nancy Werner was recommended to me by a friend who praised her highly for her expertise in the…read moreSarasota real estate market and I'm so happy to work with her. She helped me with purchasing my second home and made the process so easy and stress-free. Her demeanor is professional, calm and laid back - no high-pressure sales schtick, Nancy was on point with everything we were looking for. I was on vacation in Sarasota and had a limited amount of time to look for houses (I take my beach-time seriously). Nancy took my 'wants, must haves, and would be nice to have' into consideration, she patiently drove me all over hill and yonder to visit several houses. On my last day of vacation, we finally found the house I was looking for in the perfect neighborhood and in our price range. We did a mail away closing she handled all phases of the process, it was so straight forward, she explained all the documents and it was as relatively stress-free as one can expect. I can get geared up (I'm from NY) and I really appreciated her calm and practical demeanor. Nancy and John are also managing the property and tenants until we retire in a few years - she's doing a fanastic job! I'm so happy with Nancy and John, if you're looking to purchase a property or someone to manage your rentals, I highly recommend Nancy and John!

John is a wonderful realtor. He demonstrates a high degree of prfessionalism and patience. My…read morehusband and I were 1st time home-buyers and he was very helpful, listening to our concerns and helping to show us around the area we were interested in. Within a week of searching, he successfully showed us all of the homes on our wish list and had an offer accepted and ready to close in 30 days. If you are looking for a no-frills, honest and experienced realtor, John is definitely your guy!

Nancy Werner was recommended to me by a friend who praised her highly for her expertise in the…read moreSarasota real estate market and I'm so happy to work with her. She helped me with purchasing my second home and made the process so easy and stress-free. Her demeanor is professional, calm and laid back - no high-pressure sales schtick, Nancy was on point with everything we were looking for. I was on vacation in Sarasota and had a limited amount of time to look for houses (I take my beach-time seriously). Nancy took my 'wants, must haves, and would be nice to have' into consideration, she patiently drove me all over hill and yonder to visit several houses. On my last day of vacation, we finally found the house I was looking for in the perfect neighborhood and in our price range. We did a mail away closing she handled all phases of the process, it was so straight forward, she explained all the documents and it was as relatively stress-free as one can expect. I can get geared up (I'm from NY) and I really appreciated her calm and practical demeanor. Nancy and John are also managing the property and tenants until we retire in a few years - she's doing a fantastic job! I'm so happy with Nancy and John, if you're looking to purchase a property or someone to manage your rentals, I highly recommend Nancy and John!

We have been working with Sarasota Property Manager, Nancy Werner, at sarasotapropertymanager.com…read morefor years. She helped us buy our house and she takes care of it when we leave town. She goes above & beyond with anything we need for property management from plumbing fixes, cleaning, car services, yard work, the county office, etc.. She is on top of everything asap. We feel so lucky to have found her, as we have worked with other agents and no one compares to her. We would give her 100 stars if we could. Nancy is really the best Realtor and Property Manager!

We live in Sabal Bay. I have been trying to get a front gate sticker for my wife's car for months…read more No response, runaround, that person isn't available, etc.

Updated this review. They've done better in the last year. I hope they continue to improve.read more

If everyone knew about the dynamics and the family behind Richard Jennette they would seriously…read moreconsider not dealing with them. Ask about Richard Smotriski his nephew and Kayla. I am surprised Jennette is still in business. They actually did a good job of being ahead of the curve. My experience with them was from 2010 to 2014. I worked for Quality Counts. Sad part of this is. Those individuals did not care about the clients. It was well played and they made millions. cheers on that note. as an insider perspective, they are very evil and I participated in taking advantage of clients through Jennette Properties along with them. I needed to get this off of my chest. We took advantage of every opportunity to do just enough. I give it to them. I learned how to hustle as a worker for them.

Had an excellent experience with Jennette Properties when we recently signed a lease for an annual…read morerental. The agent assigned was Ronda and she was very professional, friendly and knowledgeable. She was very responsive to any questions and was very good in communicating with us. The time, care and guidance she provided very much helped the leasing process go easy and smoothly.

DO NOT HIRE. We hired Gulf Coast Property Management,…read morespecifically speaking to AnnMarie, to lease and manage our rental property in Fort Myers beginning in January 2026. The property remained vacant for over four months while under their management. During that time, the property was reportedly shown only twice. Despite the extended vacancy, we received very little communication beyond automated weekly emails stating there were "no updates" and "no recommendations at this time." I had to repeatedly request information regarding marketing efforts, showing activity, tenant feedback, and ANY recommendations to improve leasing performance. We were willing to adjust pricing and make changes if necessary, but we provided with absolutely no proactive guidance - guidance you would expect from a professional property management company. On top of that, our new property manager went out today and discovered that the utilities had never been turned on and there was mouse/lizard droppings throughout the home. We trusted Guld Coast to help us rent and take care of this home as we are located out of state. They wasted 4 months of our time and thousands of dollars. This company is a scam and will not take care of your property.

If you are an owner considering working with Gulf Coast Property Management find someone else. This…read morecompany is absolutely awful. I am a neighbor of an airbnb they manage. They are completely non responsive to problems with their renters, they don't care who they put in the house so there have been several parties, large numbers of vehicles, loud music, people roaming in our yard and police coming to shut it down, most recently Memorial Day Weekend. This is a residential neighborhood but Gulf Coast really doesn't care. They don't qualify the tenants so there are often many more people than the house is supposed to hold. After the last hurricane the home was in terrible shape and it was more than two weeks before we ever saw anyone from the property management company to clean up all the debris. At that point I actually texted the owner of the home. This company is a disgrace, not someone you would want to be handling your income property or second home.

River club is lucky to have Erika. Dote as one of the managers of the Castle group. She always…read moreanswers our phone calls and does a great job trying to solve all our problems. Sometimes I think she has a magic wand. We are lucky to live in River club and have her watching over us.

Castle Group / HOA Management Review - Concern Regarding Enforcement Procedures…read more My experience with Castle Group while they were managing Providence Lakes Master Association has been extremely frustrating due to the way an HOA violation matter was handled. I understand that HOAs have rules and that violations need to be addressed. My concern is not that I received a violation notice -- my concern is the process that followed. I received a First Notice of Deficiency regarding an alleged property issue and was provided time to correct it. I later received another First Notice of Deficiency regarding a separate matter. However, before receiving a Notice of Intent to Impose Fine, notice of a Fining Committee hearing, or an opportunity to appear before the committee, the matter was escalated to an attorney and I was charged $200 in attorney fees. Under Florida Statute Chapter 720.305 and the Association's own recorded Fining Committee Resolution, fines require specific procedures, including proper notice, at least 14 days' notice of a hearing, an opportunity for the homeowner to be heard, and approval by a properly appointed Fining Committee before a fine can be imposed. I repeatedly attempted to resolve this issue directly with management. After finally reaching Shannon, I was told that because the matter had been sent to an attorney, I needed to contact the attorney. When I contacted the attorney's office, I was informed they could only communicate with the management company. This left me without a clear path to resolve the issue. My concern is the lack of communication, the escalation to legal fees before the required process appeared to be completed, and the difficulty getting a straightforward response from management. I have requested documentation showing that all required steps under the Association's governing documents and Florida law were followed, including notices, Board actions, and Fining Committee records. Homeowners should expect fair enforcement, clear communication, and proper procedures before being charged additional fees.