I stopped by with CM to check out the fish fry last night. When we got together for an impromptu…read moredate, a friend's check in at another fish fry reminded me that (1) it was Fri.-- fish fry day! and (2) I seemed to recall this was the day of St. Regis's fish fry, which, unlike other fish fries, is not offered every Fri. in Lent. Upon confirming this with the handy-dandy PGH fish fry map, we headed over to check it out.
Neither of us had been to a fish fry before, but I'd been to other Catholic church fundraisers (carnivals, bazaars, etc.), and it worked similarly. The event is held in the church social hall, which is around back on Childs St., and was well-signed. You go in, give them your order, pay, and then pick it up, with the whole process taking maybe 10 min. max. The volunteers were very friendly and pretty efficient, despite some of them being older. The prices have gone up a bit since 2013 (presumably due to the cost of fish), but are still quite reasonable, esp. for the amount of food.
CM and I both ordered the fried fish dinner for take out, which consisted of a fried fish sandwich, coleslaw, fries, and chocolate cake. Most everything was excellent--the fish was nice and crispy, the roll was high quality and didn't fall apart (my pet peeve with fish sandwiches), the coleslaw was crisp and not soggy, and the cake was moist. The only item that I was less than impressed with was the fries, which were of the frozen crinkle cut variety, and were soft, lacking a crisp exterior. Had it been available, I would have ordered mac and cheese instead of fries, but they were out at the time that we visited (5pm). For our take out orders, they wrapped the fish in foil separately from the roll so that it didn't become soggy in transport. Our bag also contained ketchup packets, but no mayo or tartar sauce, and no napkins or utensils, which would have been nice to have.
Overall, we were very pleased with the quality of the food, esp. for the price (total check: $20). While I'm tempted to award a 5 star rating, the non-crispy fries and lack of mac and cheese and utensils and condiments prevent me from doing so. Nevertheless, this is a great fish fry to check out during Lent if you're able to catch it (no pun intended)!