Sal's Pizza was just sitting right there in the shopping complex where I was running errands and since it was lunch time you know I had to go give them a try. Walking in it's a pretty unusual entrance bc there's a vestibule and then a long hallway before you get to the counter. The counter had lots of pies on display and being that it was my first visit I had to go with a plain slice to see what they were talking about ... but I also picked up a broccoli, tomato and garlic slice as well. Both slices were DELICIOUS! Perfect cheese to sauce ratio on the plain and lots of broccoli, tomato, garlic and cheese on the other. The gentleman at the counter was also really friendly as well. I'll definitely stop back in next time I'm in the area. read more

See all

I order take out. Not impressed. It was fine. I've walked into Sal's before I really liked the pizza. Take out not so much read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Plain cheese - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

See all

This is my first time in years ordering from Sal's Pizza and it will be my last. The chicken cheesesteak we ordered was horrible and incredibly skimpy with the chicken and cheese. Pizza was ok. I don't know how a cook could even put something so bad out, it's shameful read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

They can't seem to get orders right anymore. When an order of fries with cheese sauce and a side of meatballs with red sauce is ordered, what I get is no fries, cheese sauce, and three meatballs with a red sauce. More than half the meal missing and this has happened twice now. read more

We love Sal's for their pizza. Close, quick, and delicious. There are a lot of really good food places in this area and we have a go-to depending on our order. Sal's has great plain pies, nice thin crispy crust, delicious sauce, and great deal for 2 plain pies. We also frequently order their BBQ and Buffalo chicken pies. The BBQ chicken pie is our favorite in the area. The Buffalo isn't the best in the area but it's REALLY good and mild enough for the wife and kids to eat, so it gets the overall family vote. VEGGIE WHITE PIE. If you like white pizza this is one of the best around. Salads aren't bad, we usually go with the Italian. Sandwiches are okay, we usually go elsewhere if we want those things...BUT the Mt. Holly Fries...mmmm mmmm. Not great for the waist line but delicious! Check them out, great people, been around a long time. read more

This is my first time ordering from Sal's and I live right around the corner told my wife let's try them out and wasn't disappointed. For got delivered fast and was HOT! Had pizza with fries and it didn't disappoint read more

Sal's Pizzeria - fries - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

See all

TO MY BLACK COMMUNITY - DO NOT COME HERE!!!! I order a slice of pizza and for the 15 min I sat there I saw them treat the next 2 black customers like and at the same time treat the whites & Hispanics like Gods. After 15 I ask them for update on the pizza I paid for?.......They never put it in the oven. I ask for a refund and left. read more

Got the job done. Ordered the Vegetable White Pizza (Broccoli, spinach and garlic) and a side of french fries to go back to a hotel with. They were both really good. The menu is super stacked and the prices are pretty good in my opinion. I don't know what else is in the area to compare, but I do like that they have a ton of options. read more

This place has good pizza. I don't mess with the chains and I'm from NYC. So when I want NY style pizza near me, I go to Sal's. You know the pizza is quality when you can flip it and no grease falls read more

Walking into the doorway I seen a threshold and a waiting size between two doors which reminded me of a doctors office. I wasn't sure if I was getting a pizza or a cavity refilled. My girlfriends diet fountain soda was flat and at least the pizza was fair and maybe more improvements can really make this place a better experience read more

Great place to get good pizza at a reasonable price. The staff is also very nice. I recommend Sal's. read more

Underrated!!!! Such a great place to eat never disappointed when I order from here. I will say it is a huge relief with everything going on (Covid) to walk into a place that every employee wore their masks even when no one was there. The peace of mind that they taking all the necessary precautions during these trying times in another reason why Sals is the Spot! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - White pizza - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

See all

To David O. Who just left a 1 star review on this place you forgot the part where you started screaming and calling the Hispanic staff "spics" The kitchen was looking for you to give you your slice and you were no where to be found. according to them you started screaming "where's my slice" 15 mins later. The people at sals work very hard at their jobs and it was a simple miscommunication. It had nothing to do with your skin color. I would appreciate if you could not call my dad a "spic" because you were throwing a fit. read more

Ithink following directions is essential when making someone's food. I was looking for a convenient place to get a good sub and complete chores. I chose Sal's and asked if they take specific orders in making subs. I was told yes. I saw the young lady write down my order but it wasn't followed. It seemed intentional to me because I specifically asked lite mayonnaise with spicy mustard and I received a sandwich full of so much mayonnaise it could be squeezed out of the sandwich. It was a slimy tasteless mess. I threw away $15. Never again. read more

Cold pizza. Almost no meat on the cheesesteak. Wings were HORRIBLE. it's very hard for me to get mad over food but these guys took the cake.

Hate to admit that after many years of attending court in the same complex, that I never noticed Sal's Pizzeria before this week. So, after an afternoon session, and hungry from skipping lunch, I drove around to the front of this oldish commercial strip center and spied this TPie shop. Upon entry, I was struck by the orange and yellow walls in the surprising large restaurant. Although dated, it had a wholesome ambiance conducive to an Italian meal. Given the hour, I went with a single slice of Traditional Pizza with Sweet Sausage, and a drink. Good choice, as the slice was larger than average. I asked for it "well done," and that was what I received. Upon lifting off the large attractively orange plate, I was immediately impressed that despite its size and extra weight from the topside, the point held firm and high with nary a quiver. First bite was a full blown crunch through cheese, sauce and meat; all of which were received warmly with pleasure in my mouth. It was a very good slice of pizza, despite being reheated. With this lunch coming in under $5. I was very satisfied with the experience, and will not be a stranger to Sal's. The rest of the menu listed the usual suspects. If done as well as their pies, I will become a regular customer when in Mt. Holly. read more

See all

Always clean, always great food, and friendly service. I've had the pizza, the salad and the fries. I've heard the cheese steaks and chicken cheese steaks are great too. It's a great place to grab a quick lunch with friends during the lunch hour. read more

Ordered delivery through Yelp app. I ordered the fettuccini alfredo. Something was off about the flavor and consistency of the sauce. Chicken was served in three large chunks that did offered no flavor. Delivery time was estimated at 45-55 minutes but took 90 minutes. No utensils were included with delivery. read more

On behalf of J&S Autohaus across the street, we love these guys; We often order a grilled chicken hoagie with garlic, lettuce tomato onion pickles and provolone cheese. They make some good stuff over there and they are all great guys. -Alex Saliba, J&S Autohaus read more

Ordered from here via Uber Eats. I ordered holly fries and a cheese pizza, in the special restaurant instructions space I wrote "please add a side of ranch, a fork and extra napkins. Thank you!" When my order arrived the fries were a soggy, greasy mess, there was no ranch, no silverware and no napkins. What kind of restaurant doesn't give their customers silverware or napkins? What kind of restaurant doesn't read the customer's notes on to-go orders? Absolutely ridiculous. If I could give zero stars I would, I was beyond pissed. read more

Funny enough one of my favorite pizza places for great NY pizza is in Mamaroneck NY for also named Sals. This one is not as good but pretty good. 2 slices and a small drink $6 special including sicilian but not the specialty sicilian he had. By lunchtime they had a pretty decent selection of pies to choose from which is always a good thing. Taste was good, could have used more sauce for sure but still tasty. Good amount of seating inside and guy at the counter was very friendly. Good customer service counts for a lot. read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Decent selection of pies by lunchtime - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

See all

The Last Supper: I've had nothing but great experiences with Sal's Pizzera, that all changed tonight (12 Sept 19). I ordered a large works pizza, along with fried zucchini. The delivery person (the owner) drops my food on my porch, and then has the nerve to call me and ask how much of a tip can he put on my card. I went through the roof. Mind you, this is not the first time this has occurred. If the owner is setting this as a standard business practice, there are other businesses who I can give my money to. read more

I love sals!!!! They never disapoint the pizza &buffalo chicken wrap are amazing! They have been around for a very long time and are a go to in our home read more

The food here is alright, but the people who work here , let's just say I'd rather have monkeys waiting on me rather than the females who work here read more

Very good pizza, wings and paste. Have ordered here 3 times now and have not been disappointed. Food is great, service is great and always on time or early. read more

Love sal's!!!! Staff is super nice. Pizza is tasty. Cheesesteaks are huge and delish! Love the salads and pasta too! Always a great experience! The only negative is that when you order delivery, the pizza loses its edge a bit. It's best fresh from the oven. read more

I really like this place. The staff is friendly and warm. We usually get 2 things from this place. Our favorite pizza is a white with ricotta. I really like the jumbo fried shrimp platter ! In this town it hard to find any seafood. The shrimp are huge and you get a ton of fries and Cole slaw-- oh and bread and salad for an insane price! We keep coming back! read more

Sal's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Mount Holly, New Jersey

I've had pizza here about 5 times now and think it's really good. The first 4 times I ate in and loved it. The crust was thin and crisp and cooked just right. I like crust done and crispy and that is just what I got. The cheese was good but the sauce differentiates this place. I think it is heavy on garlic which is why I like it. The down side for me is the 5th time I tried delivery. I live in Lumberton and it took about an hour to get here and the order wasn't hot it was barely warm. I ordered a plain cheese and some wings and they wing weren't very saucy. I'd recommend this place to eat in but don't order delivery if you live in Lumberton. Next time I want to stop by and try the wings dining in. read more

I tried this place on a recommendation from a friend and they we right. Sal's has great New York style pizza. I ordered half cheese and half sausage/ onion pie to go. After one bite I could not stop eating it. The sauce to cheese to meat ratio was great. I will definitely frequent this establishment again read more

I walked in and waited literally about 5 minutes for someone to come to the front so I could pick up my to go order. 5 minutes into my wait, a gentleman walked in also waiting for assistance. A couple minutes later a man came out the back, looked at me waiting at the register , then looked at the gentleman behind me seated at a table, and says to him "how can I help you?" The gentleman pointed to me and said "she was 1st", the employee says "okay, but how can I help you" Uhmmm what??!! So the gentleman tells him what he's picking up and the employee says to me, "I'll be with you in a moment." Clearly I was next, but the employee took it upon his self to wait on the gentleman behind me. The food was just okay, but my experience was uncomfortable enough to warrant me not returning. I'm not sure if it was racism, sexism, or agism but either way, although I was next, I was not waited on until after the other customer received and paid for his order. The good was just okay. I'm new to the area but will keep searching for the right pizzeria. read more

Delivery driver is HORRIBLE!!! I placed an order on yelp for delivery for my area. This place shows up that it delivers... so of course I chose this place. Prior to confirming my order, I clearly wrote on the instructions area "door on left NOT right"- as I do every time I place an order anymore Bc I know it gets confusing.... but what does the delivery guy do??? He bangs on the door on the right... bothering my neighbor!! Than has the nerve to give me an attitude?!?! Than tells me to never order from them ever again because they don't like driving to mount laurel as I'm already closing my door!! Rude AND disrespectful!!! And honestly...if you don't like driving to mount laurel, sounds like you need to talk to yelp and adjust your delivery areas! And NOT give your customers attitude when you're at the wrong!! But no worries, won't be ordering from here anymore even if I lived in mount holly!! read more

How many places can you accidentally drop a $5 bill on the counter, pay with credit card, run to the neighboring store and when you return for your hoagie and lament about a misplaced bill, he says Found it and gives it to you? Sal's is 1 such place. read more

I would give this place five stars except I don't really like their wings. Usually look for pizza and wings in a pizza place. However there pizza is delicious and consistent. I love their specialty pizza - we usually get the Hawaiian and the white . Both are awesome. read more

Nice pizza place with great customer service. They have a full menu to choose from burgers to subs and in between. They also deliver. I think they have BYob if you want to drink there. I highly recommend this pizza place. read more

Spent last spring & summer at JB MDL (Fort Dix) -- Sal's was a favorite place to go for big pizza slices; great food & great prices, too. It's a small family owned restaurant that makes you feel welcome. A lot of our local friends suggested them so when we had large meetings, we usually ordered from Sal's. read more

We ordered take out, and our food arrived still piping hot. I had the baked eggplant manicotti and it was delicious. The portions were very generous. My husband had the baked stuffed shells with meatballs. He enjoyed his meal also. The food came in aluminum pans with cardboard covers. This kept the food nice and hot. Delivery was accurate to their promise. We will definitely order from here again. read more

Sals is always consistent with the pizza. I'm a big fan of the crust and sauce. I have never tried any of the meals. I will say they have some of the worst wings ever. I'm not sure if they use old oil or what but they are not good, same goes for the fries. They have deep dish pizza but the crust is not that good. Too airy. It's byob and it's great for a quick slice. Place need a little up keep in the bathroom area. read more

This business is definitely under the assumption that good food justifies terrible customer service and poor business practices. No matter what the dollar amount of your purchase is they charge you a surcharge for using your debit card which is illegal in New Jersey not to mention those surcharges are a tax write off to the business. Simple logic would be to raise the product pricing to an amount that would include a padding for the cost of doing business. Additionally, the employees become quite defensive and argumentative upon questioning of their practices to the extent of blame shifting the issue. This is sad to see good food with poor management and business practices..if you order food and don't arrive within 20 minutes you can expect it to be cold because the "cant warm it" and will tell you it is your fault for being late! Interestingly, most other pizza places will make an effort to keep your food warm. read more

Go to spot for pizza.. Their pie sizes are smaller than most pizza places in my opinion but the quality is good and the staff is friendly and fast great pizza, fast service, friendly staff.. No reason not to order from here read more

I ordered a chicken parm sandwich, I had originally called my regular place but they had told me they just ran out of cutlets and could use chicken fingers but I said no that I would order somewhere else. I ordered from here and I got a "chicken parm sandwich" with a bunch of fat chicken tender pieces on it. I'm sorry, but chicken finger pieces and chicken cutlets has a different flavor and texture so read more