Every time we go, we try something new and it is always good! My husband likes their donuts, I go…read morefor a pastry mostly, and my mom likes their cakes. We have ordered cupcakes here for birthdays and it is a hit. Pro tip is to sign up for texts so you know when special flavors or deals are happening. Wide selection in store to grab and go and parking is super easy!

My neighbors are getting married this weekend, and I got it into my head that I needed to gift them…read morepetits fours with hearts on them. I don't know where I got this idea, but it seemed like the perfect casual wedding gift to receive from a neighbor. And once I got it into my head, I was determined to make it happen! My search for these mini cakes led me to Taylor's Bakery. They have a selection of petits fours available in their bakery case (Easter themed right now). I ordered my desserts online to be picked up the next day, because I wanted hearts. The petits fours are 2 inches by 2 inches, which is much larger than I thought they would be. I was thinking they'd be bite-sized, but they're more like three or four bites. When I showed up to pick up my order, they didn't have them ready, and I think they had lost my order, but they quickly added hearts to some blank petits fours. All of their petits fours are the same almond-scented white cake with a thin coconut icing. I was hoping they'd have a filling or something in them (a layer of jam would have been nice!), but no, they're just cake and icing. I got a flower-decorated petits four for myself to eat in my car as I drove home (aka the best way to eat anything), and it was so soft and melted in my mouth. It was the kind of cake that didn't even require chewing. Yum! They are known for their cakes here, and I can see why. They also have a big selection of other baked goods, like bars (raspberry and lemon), brownies, donuts, Danishes, cupcakes, cinnamon rolls and lots more. I picked up two cute Easter cookies for my kids, which were decorated with blue icing and jelly bean eggs. Taylor's Bakery has been an Indianapolis institution for 112 years! Which means you need to visit this bakery at least once. While I was there, I saw several people come in and order all kinds of goodies. They had a steady stream of customers. I love that Taylor's was hoppin' on a weekday afternoon.

The COOLEST cakes in Indy! Classic cakes does a fantastic job…read more They aren't cheap but for the attention to detail needed to create something like this - it's art. I don't even want to cut it. When you do though, the cake is delicious! Lots of flavor combos to choose from. They're also super nice - when I picked it up, the guy that brought it out helped me carry it to my car and was super pleasant. Highly recommend if you want a unique and gorgeous cake. They're the best in town.

I ordered a birthday cake with a horse head design on it for my wife's 70th birthday. They did a…read morephenomenal job. Everybody at the party was talking about it and asked me where I got it. I told them that I got it from Classic Cakes in Carmel. They said that they thought it was a beautiful cake. Jerry M Sheridan IN

Very happy with my experience at Simply Perfection Cakes. Rose was very easy and nice to work with…read more My cake was delivered and flowers assembled before I got there and I was completely blown away. It was beautiful! Thanks again!

15 Cakes!! I had…read morethis bright idea to have 15 cakes made for my wedding and use them as centerpieces. I'm so grateful that Rose didn't laugh at me and think I was crazy. This worked out perfectly! All of our guest loved how rich and moist the cakes were and I loved the value of cakes v. flower centerpieces. Our guest loved them so much that they ate them all! We had 1.5 slices allotted per guest and we still never had a taste. I can only believe that means they were delicious. I would most definitely recommend this vendor to a friend.

I'd had the privilege of enjoying Cretia Cakes at Zoobilation and Museum by Moonlight and fell in…read morelove! Both times--if I remember correctly--I fell in love with the caramel cake. While I was initially bummed to find out they didn't have an always-open storefront (or perhaps not yet ), I knew that when the chance arose for a cake or cupcake order, I'd want to order directly from Cretia Cakes. In hosting family and friends recently, this was the perfect opportunity. I ordered three dozen cupcakes: caramel cupcakes with caramel flavored buttercream (some they also added caramel drizzle on) and coconut with coconut buttercream. Incredibly moist and delicious! Some cupcakes it feels the icing is the star while the cake is just average, but I truly enjoy the balance of both and I believe Cretia's offers this. The team was careful to verify my order to ensure it was right and even followed up further to ensure they followed all of my details correctly. Pro tip -- 1) Cretia has cake and much more! I also ordered three pans of yeast rolls which were so scrumptious and perfect with the rest of our dinner. 2) Be sure to check their website and social media for specials and deals. I missed the deadline for mine so don't miss out like me! Highly recommend Cretia Cakes for your next gathering -- big or small. Thanks Cretia & Team!

Everything was delicious! I really like the dew drops and the mexican wedding cookies. Her…read morecaramel cake is divine and the homemade rolls were so buttery and soft. everything was 10/10

I stopped in for some pan dulce, and yes, Kelly's has some pan dulce. You will find your conchas…read moreand your puerquitos. You'll also find galletas, orejas and much more. I decided on a sugary cuernito, except mine was shaped more like a circle than a horn. It was still delicious. When you walk into Kelly's Cakes, you will see a bakery case to your left with all of the pan dulce and bolillos. Then there's a smaller refrigerated case at the front by the register with cake slices, jelly / pudding cups, and some whole cakes. From reading the other reviews, it sounds like Kelly's makes cakes and desserts to order, but I don't know about that! I was just stopping in to get a sweet bread. If you're looking for some pan dulce on the east side, this is a great place to find it.

Amazing selection of all sorts of sweets at affordable prices! My husband and I enjoyed picking out…read morea few different options and will definitely be back!

For those who are unaware, Scoop Shack has grown…read more Formerly located in a small strip center at 71st and Binford, Scoop Shack has expanded into the former Regions Bank located in the very same parking lot. The new location affords Scoop Shack a more appropriate space for their growing event/birthday business. It also offers them the chance to explore some additional opportunities with the space. Scoop Shack now also has a more "proper" outdoor area comprised of the space that used to be the drive-thru for the bank. Oh, and yes. The bank's safe area is still here. It's kind of a cool feature. There's also a play area for the kids. So, I knew I needed to revisit and update my review. There are two van-accessible parking spots out front. There's also one along the back for the outdoor section (there's a window where you can order without going inside). There's still a two-sided, double-door entry. It's about the only part of the whole experience that isn't super wheelchair friendly, though it's not bad. Both owners have a background in healthcare - so, the awareness of disability is pretty obvious - there's even a ramp to the back patio area. As this is a fairly recent move, the interior is still growing. There's a nice, comfy design to it. Prices are still reasonable. They still offer four and six flavor flights. Their ice cream comes from local fave Sundae's. There's a combination of half-booths and tables for seating. They've also added a handful of light food items (like hot dogs), though they're still keeping it simple. Scoop Shack does catering, parties, events, and more. They offer sundaes, shakes, ice cream nachos, walkabouts, chocogattos, a variety of hot/cold drinks, and some bottled/canned drinks. There are two unisex bathrooms - both are accessible. I've grown very fond of Scoop Shack. I think they started right around my first review in 2021 (not exactly an easy year to open up a new shop). The neighborhood has really embraced them. I definitely recommend a visit. While I loved the old space, this old space is definitely a great move for Scoop Shack.

I love this place and their new location is so nice! They're right by the old one but they have a…read morepatio and more space inside. The staff is always so nice and quick. Hand down some of the best cream in town.

Eats by Chef Mel specializes in specialty cakes and cupcakes. What makes Mel's work stand out is…read more... EVERYTHING! First, you are dealing directly with a real, compassionate & knowledgeable chef. She has tons of experience and is always experimenting in the kitchen. She's never satisfied with "good enough" and continually strives to create new flavor combinations & design new artwork. Second, she uses QUALITY ingredients. You truly get what you pay for. Her flavors are always rich, fresh & authentic -- things you won't find at your local grocery store. Third, her products are GORGEOUS! She truly prides herself in her work, which you can see in her beautiful pieces. Each one is unique and she is willing to work with you to create what you're envisioning. I highly recommend using Chef Mel for corporate events, family gatherings, as a way to say thank you to employees, birthdays ... the list goes on :)

Mel is amazing and her creativity is unparalleled!!! Unbelievable customer service and will work…read morewith you to make your dream come true

The Dubai bundt cake has been calling my name, so I decided to stop in on a whim. To my surprise,…read morethe Dubai cake was still available. When I got to my destination, I allowed the cake to come to room temperature because I don't care for cold cake. First bite...yum. There was good chocolate flavor. The cake was moist and the buttercream was not overly sweet. As I dug towards the middle, I got to the most important part- the pistachio cream. It was the perfect texture, which I attribute to letting the cake come to room temperature. I would definitely get this again. As far as the store, it was clean, and the service was quick and staff were super friendly and helpful.

A delicious guilty pleasure. I like the size of the bundt cakes. The service is always good.read more

The staff were super friendly and helpful. The store is well lit and has lots of options. The…read moreprice is worth it. One of the most amazing donuts I've ever had.

Always exceptionally flavorful cakes and pastries. Dense and delicious cakes! Definitely my go to!read more