SF Wing Foil Academy is based out of his home in Tiburon, his boat and dinghy are docked in the backyard. When I arrived, I was greeted by a female who let me into the backyard and I carried all my gear back and forth from my car into the backyard. As I was bringing my board and foil to the backyard, he came out to greet me and grabbed my foil, brought it to the backyard, and then set it down in a pile of dog poop on his lawn. Once I pointed this out to him, he removed the dog poop from the lawn but didn't bother wiping off my foil. He has dogs, so be aware.
Once I set up all my gear, he had me inflate my smallest wing and wanted me to show him how I get up on the board and flip my wing. This is where the lesson got a bit frustrating, right from the start, as I already know how to get on my 85L board and how to flip over my wing, but he insisted I learn how to do it his way. That is fine, I will try it his way, and maybe I will learn something useful and new. Nope. He has me turn over my wing once I am on the board. This actually doesn't work for me because I am fun-sized (short), and trying to turn over the wing while on the board is difficult. When I tried it on the water, the wing ended up getting stuck under my board. I wing in chop/swell and it requires more balance to be on the board in those conditions, trying to flip the wing over while on the board adds to the difficulty of turning the wing over. Flipping the wing over in the water, swell or no swell, it's a quick flip, it requires no balance, you won't accidentally fall off trying to flip your wing, and it won't get stuck under your board. I bring the wing to the side of my board before I get on my board, and he told me I don't need to do that. However, when I was learning and struggling to get on my board and stay balanced, a previous instructor suggested this technique to me to add additional stability by using the wing for balance. In really choppy conditions you can place your hand on your wing to steady yourself out. I spent a lot of time when I was learning finding what works for me and I felt like he didn't even listen to the reasons I do it the way that I do, he would simply cut me off and say just try it this way.
One of the reasons I wanted to take a lesson was for boat support, please note he doesn't use the boat pictured on the website, he uses a small inflatable dingy just enough to fit two people and your gear. We went out to a flat-water spot near his house only a few minutes away. I liked the flat-water part, it makes it easier to learn anything, but the problem I found with this spot, in my opinion, is has a very narrow area of wind. Both sides of this area are no wind zones. This is probably fine for beginners because most can't stay on foil for that long, but the wind was very light during our lesson and I ended up slogging most of the time.
**VERY IMPORTANT, NO kiteboarding/wing foiling instructor, can control the wind. The wind conditions have no reflection on my rating of this review.**
Once the wind did come up at almost the end of the lesson, I finally got to work on what I came to learn which was to ride toe-side and jibe. As I was talking it through with Josh, I asked him where I weight the board in order to transition. The reason that I asked this question is that when I was learning to kiteboard I took several lessons to feel comfortable riding on my own through some amazing kiteboarding schools and I also took an intermediate lesson on how to jibe on a direction which I actually learned in 1 lesson from a fabulous kiteboarding school on the delta, those schools provided me with detailed instruction on where to position the kite, where my feet should be positioned, and where to strategically weight the board. These instructions helped me to succeed to reach my goals. However, Josh's response was to shuffle my feet, that's it. The problem with this instruction is in order to move your feet, you need to know where to weight the board to stay foiling, when I would try to move my feet, I would just crash because I obliviously wasn't weighting the board properly to keep it foiling. We also talked about when to change your foot position. He told me that in a "real jibe" you switch your feet first. However, when it comes to jibing, I know people that switch their feet before, during, and after the jibe. I have also noticed that some people switch their feet before in one direction, and after in the other direction. I don't think there is one "right" way of doing it, I think it is a personal preference and what works for one person, might not work for another.
Overall, this instructor wasn't right for me. I needed an instructor that could customize the instruction for me and not just use their methods without considering my individual needs. read more