1. Signature Realty & Management

    1. Signature Realty & Management

    0

    Saint Augustine, FL

    Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Signature Realty & Management

    1.0 (1 review)

    Services - Signature Realty & Management

    Property management

    Signature Realty & Management Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Signature Realty & Management

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    May Management Services - Senior Management Team at MAY

    May Management Services

    (6 reviews)

    I understand that property management company's can have a thankless job. And, although I do not…read morelike to express negativity for businesses and their owners, I am going to use this Yelping forum to share my thoughts about May Management and their not so sparkly business dealings so far within our community. I haven't seen any positive influence from May Management. Currently our neighborhood provides this company thousands of dollars to handle what exactly? Association Dues? A local community board member could handle this same kind of administrative rigmarole. Seems like a waste of money to me, but I am not versed in all of the nuances of property legal matters. What has really recently infuriated me was an email sent out regarding a specific neighbor to all 800 or so members of our community. I know the thought process behind the public outreach, but do not understand why other members of our community that have had the same situation did not get the same humiliating scrutiny... Perhaps because that particular community member had challenged some of the traditional thinking regarding the politics within our communitys association and board?...Coincidently fishy as our association board and May Management work so closely together, but I cannot say, but it seems like bad business indeed. Additionally, the one and only time I needed assistance from our May Management property manager, he did not provide any immediate action or insight. Again, why is our community paying for this kind of service???? Not impressed with May Management at all.

    What a great group of people! They really make you feel cared for. I would absolutely recommend…read moregiving MAY a call if you are looking for a professional yet personalized management experience!

    Davidson Realty - 1st Annual Shooting for SAYS Event - We raised $30,000 for St. Augustine Youth Services!

    Davidson Realty

    (21 reviews)

    I worked with Shelley Nemethy at Davidson Realty on the sale of my rental home in Saint Augustine…read more It was an epic battle of a listing that lasted almost a full year. Right off the bat, Shelley distinguished herself as the most responsive Realtor to my listing inquiries. When I tried listing early last year, I seemed to run into an endless series of unfortunate events. First, a small overlooked leak lead to a major repair that required redoing the entire ground floor. That took 5 months of mold tests, repairs, fixes on poor repairs, an accident from the contractor that flooded the home again, more repairs, and more fixes. Then, after all that, my tenant got into a car accident the week before he was scheduled to move out. After a month delay, the tenant moved out and we started listing the home. But after only a couple of weeks with only a low-ball offer, Hurricane Maria struck and I got hit with water intrusion and damage. Then, we had to go off market to wait for the weather to clear so we can repair the damaged stucco and leaks, as well as repairing new water damage to the ground floor, again. Another 4 months of repairs went by and finally, in mid April this year, we hit the market. After a grueling few months, Shelley got an offer at my target price. At that point, I was pleasantly stunned. After 45 days, we closed, finally. Throughout the whole ordeal, Shelley patiently followed through with endless trips to check on the on-going repairs, insurance adjustors, lab technicians, appraiser, and more. Most impressive was her patience in dealing with a very frustrated seller. Being a long-time broker and investor myself, I knew how much effort and time it must have taken on her part. Even when I repeatedly bemoaned how ridiculously cheap the market price was for my rental ($95/sqft) as compared to what I deal with on a daily basis in Silicon Valley ($1000-1500/sqft), she stayed professional. Shelley kept plugging along to get me a favorable result in the end, well deserving of the bonus commission I gave her. If Davidson Realty weren't clear across the country, I'd be fighting to hire her for my brokerage. They've got a good one.

    Our experience with Davidson Property Management was awful…read more We had them rent our house for us after we moved from the area. We replaced all of the carpet prior to our renters moving in, we had the entire house professionally painted and everything was in perfect working order. Our tenants moved out in March 2021 and the move out pictures Laura sent us were horrible, blurry you couldn't tell anything from them. She tells us we need to replace a few light bulbs and one slat of one blind and everything else is great. She does this and refunds the renters their deposit! We put the house on the market to sell, our agent said we may have an issue because the house is not in great shape but it's a sellers market so we will see what happens. We finally get the pictures from the inspection done by the buyers and the house is horrible. The carpet is ruined (after only 3 years), the renters dogs have destroyed the baseboards as well as the back door. The back yard was dug up and destroyed by their dogs. There were so many other things but bottom line is never use them! They will only care about their 10% and not your house.

    Ann & Jeanie - Welcome Home North Florida Real Estate - Serving St. Johns

    Ann & Jeanie - Welcome Home North Florida Real Estate

    (7 reviews)

    These two ladies are the best! Quickly got their arms around our needs and showed us properties…read morethat met what we were looking for. They handled the transaction really well, even through the minor bumps and got us to the finish line quickly and painlessly. Post closing support and help was great and super appreciated. they just did a great job and went above and beyond! Would highly recommend them and will use them again down the road.

    Buying a house with these ladies was a great experience! Jeanie was the calm and patient saint we…read morespoke with and toured with the most, while Ann was the wizard behind the scenes. We truly believe they had our best interests at heart, and they worked really hard (even late at night) to ensure that we literally received everything we wanted. I had a bizarre schedule at the time, and both were extremely accommodating to seeing houses based on my schedule. Plus, I always had TONS of questions--which were never an issue for them! At one point they even found a house that had every single item on my "checklist", BUT, it still didn't feel right to me. When I rejected it they didn't even blink an eye, just hit the trail again! Truly, there's no stress or pressure when they are at the helm, and we never felt like we were on a 'pushy used car lot' when we spoke with them, unlike other realtors we met. Jeanie and Ann are incredibly honest and trustworthy, they moved quickly, were very flexible with our sometimes rigid schedules and preferences, are excellent and fast communicators, and worked tirelessly to successfully find us the right home. We cannot imagine how anyone will regret having them as real estate agents. We are so thankful we found them!!

    Signature Realty & Management - propertymgmt - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...