Sister2Sister Cookies are the very best! Since moving to Shelley Drive it makes it easier for me to avoid the busy traffic of the old location on Broadway. My favorite is the pecan chocolate chip, my wife's favorite is the chocolate chip and my 92 year old mother in law's favorite is the monthly special! I don't think they make a bad cookie! From the front door to the drive thru they are always so helpful and friendly. If you go in and see all the different cookies in the case, I promise you will buy more than you came in for! Neat ,clean, friendly and the smell of fresh baked cookies, what's not to like? Don't forget to get a bag or two of the frozen cookie dough for home. So convenient when you need to have a simple dessert! If you haven't visited Sister2Sister then make today that day! Go get Full read more

See all

They moved to a new location. These cookies are fabulous when hot. 6 cookies for 16.02 read more

Everything here is always so delicious I wish they wouldn't have moved from Broadway read more

My wife was in hospital following surgery and wanted something sweet. Bought a dozen mixed cookies, AMAZING! Pricey, yes but they were amazingly delicious. read more

The service is great. But the owners treat their employees so rude. I was in the store and they were berating these high school girls. For cookies. Give me a break. read more

Great customer service and tasty treats! I love to buy these cookies for my clients as thank you gifts! They are always a hit!

My first time ever here and it was a recommendation from my uncle who is a local around Tyler, Texas. He explained it to me as these big and chewy, soft cookies. And in that moment, I was excited, and ready to go on a mission to try these cookies. We get there with maybe 15 minutes to spare before they had to close and there was a line of cars in the drive thru in this tiny place, on such a busy street. We waited in line for a good 5 minutes or so and I was getting more excited by the minute to bite into these delicious cookies that I have been hearing so much about. Finally, we get to the window, and we ordered a box of 12 cookies. They unfortunately were out of the snicker doodles and sugarcookies. But that was fine with me, as I was more interested in trying the traditional chocolate chip cookie. Ended up getting about 4 of chocolate chip, 5 macadamia, 2 oatmeal, and 1 double chocolate. After getting our delightfully aesthetic box of cookies (for the gram and this review of course), I took my first bite into a chocolate chip cookie. Now, ladies and gents, I love me a good, soft and chewy cookie with some sort of texture - and this cookie had it all. I enjoyed every bite. My taste buds were in pure bliss. And I was just absolutely in love. Had to show my friends back in Houston and I am definitely going back! read more

Sister2sister Cookies - Chocolate chip, double chocolate chip, white chocolate macadamia, and oatmeal chocolate - Bakeries Near Me - Tyler, Texas

I know first hand why this place is so busy! They have this cookie making DOWN! Purchase frozen or done. Just order some and enjoy. read more

Amazing cookies! My personal fave is the double chocolate but everything we've tried so far has been great!! We make sure to make a stop here whenever we're in Tyler. read more

Sister2sister Cookies - Menu - Bakeries Near Me - Tyler, Texas

These are the cookies you wish you could make at home, with the added convenience of a drive thru. They are the perfect cookie combination of lightly crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Definitely the best cookies in Tyler - if not the best cookies ever read more

The best bought cookies I've ever had. The chocolate chip with pecans is the absolute best!

These folks make amazingly great cookies! Never thought I'd like a strawberry cookie but it was delicious! They have a rewards program which is great also! Yes you may pay a little more for their cookies but I'm telling you honestly it's worth it hands down! Highly recommend you try it! read more

I love this place and I love the people! It's a local cookie shop with a drive thru! Melt in your mouth delicious cookies. Many flavors to choose from. Totally recommend!!! read more

We love their cookies! This is our go-to gift for friends, family, teachers, etc. I am so thankful for their drive- thru, and that they serve coffee. :) I also appreciate that they serve smaller cookies-- "Little Sis," and not just the big ones. read more

Sister2sister Cookies - Thank you gift for our veterinarian at South Tyler Animal Clinic. - Bakeries Near Me - Tyler, Texas

See all

They have the best & softest snickerdoodle cookies in the whole wide world. And the ladies there are so helpful & nice.

Everybody knows sister to sister is heavenly!! The chocolate chip pecan is my FAVORITE. Warm for 15 seconds and then enjoy!!

The best cookies I have ever had! Yummmm! Nice treat for a co-worker's bday or to bring to group meetings. You can't go wrong with ANY of the flavors! read more

Om Nom Nom Nom!! These cookies are addictive and delicious. A dozen chocolate chip will run you $17. They make a perfect last minute gift. Support a local business and give the Sisters a try. read more

Sister2sister Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Tyler, Texas

We love these cookies. These are our go to cheat day treats! The Lil sissy's are a great size. The people are always nice. The new location in Tyler can be a bit annoying, once you take a bite of your cookie you'll forgive the uturn! read more

Tasty cookies! Kind staff. Small shop and hard to get to. Defn East the cookies the day you purchase them as some don't survive well. That said I have traveled 2000 miles to share these with friends back in my hometown. Soooooo, just try a ziplock. ;) read more

When in Tyler go get these cookies! Wonderful flavors and beautiful packaging so also works great for easy, thoughtful gift!

Delightful cookies! I've never been disappointed with any flavor and chocolate chip pecan are my favorite! I love the two sizes! Little sissy's are the cutest and just the right amount for ladies and the large are "man-sized"! Try them all! Use the adorable gift box for gifting someone! read more

If you haven't had one of these ridiculously good cookies, what the heck are you waiting for? Don't leave this earth without eating one, or a dozen, of these amazing cookies. Seriously, your life won't be complete. read more

Sister2sister Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Tyler, Texas

Best cookies in Tyler! When I first heard about their cookies I would ask everyone what their top flavor was and the only response I would get is "all of them!" I ended up buying a variety of flavors and sure enough could not pick one single cookie out. The cookies are thick, soft, and packed with goodness! Every time I drive to Tyler I always bring Sister2sister cookies back with me to share in Houston! read more

Loved these cookies! Uber thick and soft. A lot of cookie if you are not into cookies.

Hooked me up in a pinch with some of the tastiest cookies ever! It was too hard to choose just one, just buy the mixed box!

soo good ...went again today...so fresh 2..love theyre varieties...i only wish they had the lil sis in all the flavors..its about 23-25 dollars for a bakers dozen..so b prepared...go ..today!! read more

I've eaten fresh cookies from here that were awesome . The drive thru is convenient too. You can even have cookies delivered . I received a tin of cookies today from a local business to thank me for being a customer. I was disappointed to find the cookies were dry and crumbled as if they were not fresh. So, I don't think I'll be buying any to ship to friends or family . read more

YUM. HUGE cookies. Worth paying almost $8 for 4 cookies. Didn't have any of the smaller sizes available but will have to try next time. Cute shop, sweet employees, cute packaging. Love that they have a drive thru since parking is weird with the sign in the middle of the lot. To be fair, I was driving my husbands huge truck so maybe it's not that hard, hah. FINALLY somewhere that makes an oatmeal chocolate chip!!! Love love love read more

Delicious and huge cookies (like getting three regular sized cookies from GAC, stacked together!). Not overly sweet, with a great texture and fresh taste. It was my first time there, and I was pleasantly surprised by the size of the cookie for the price. Will be back! read more

Wow!!! Just wow!!!! These cookies are like nothing I've ever tasted before. They're really worth it. I recommend the chocolate chocolate chip. No such thing as too much chocolate. I also think pokeos and this place should do a colab. read more

Best cookie place in Tyler, BY FAR! I know it's location is a little bit south for some people but it's well worth the drive. Best cookies have got to be the lemon and Italian cream. I swear my family gets cookies here at least 3-4 times a month. Sometimes they have day old cookies for a dollar or something like that and they are still so delicious. A Tyler must-try if you are visiting or new to the town. read more

My hubby bought these for me for Valentine's Day and holy smokes they were the best cookies I have ever eaten!!! Addicting. I'm so excited about the new broadway location!!! read more

The BEST cookies I have had in a long time.I got the 1/2 dozen the chocolate chip w/pecan and the double chocolate chip!!!!!!!!! I will be back im sure by way its drive-thru so you don't have to leave your car to pick-up this wonderful piece of HEAVEN!!!!!!!! read more

I've been here way more times than I should admit. These cookies are addictive, I can't get enough. My only complaint is the lackluster customer service I've received a few times. (few, again, I go way too often) They aren't technically rude, just terse and lacking smiles. I still gave 5 stars because the cookies are so delicious. read more

These cookies are so freakin good. They are enormous and oh so delicious. The only reason this place is getting 3 stars from me as opposed to 5 is because of the rude older lady that works there. She gave me attitude and was so mean. I'm a customer ordering 20+ cookies, be nice to me. I wanted my boxes to be marked differently since I was taking some back to Houston for friends and family. She said I can't change the box, just wanted her to add a letter on the box so I could tell them apart. She was so rude makes me not wanna go back. Beware of the bitchy older lady working the window. read more

If I had to make a list of the best 10 things in Tyler, Sister2Sister would be in there somewhere near the top. Ok, probably *at* the top. Their cookies blow away the garbage you get from the chain cookie stores at the mall. Also, if you have that feeling of emptiness in your life, these cookies do a great job of filling the void. read more

These are the best cookies I've ever had! I take them as gifts to people and everyone LOVES them! Plus, the owners are such wonderful, caring people. These just make my day! read more

These are the best chocolate chip cookies I have ever eaten. When warm, holy moley. Love that they have a drive thru.

Sister2Sister makes the BEST chocolate chip cookies I've ever had. They're big and rich and chocolatey. The ladies that work there are nice as well. read more