My wife and I came to McCarty Place in the summer of 2011, after moving from our previous location…read moreat Riverwalk Apartments. We were initially struck by the updated feel of the living space - contrary to some of the other units we had viewed in the Greater Lafayette/West Lafayette area, McCarty Place offered newer appliances and a more modern feel than most of the other complexes we had viewed in our apartment search.
The size of the units was another determining factor in our move. For just under $800/month, we ended up renting a 3-bedroom unit with over 1000 SF of living space. Our unit is on the top floor, meaning we also benefit from vaulted ceilings, making the apartment feel even bigger than it actually is. For those who are in need of less living space, McCarty Place also offers 2-bedroom and 1-bedroom units, each with the same aforementioned modern feel.
Despite the ample square footage offered, the kitchen in our unit is rather small, and does not offer much counter space or storage. While a pantry is available, if you own plenty of cookware, you may find difficulty fitting all of your items (neatly) into the provided space. Nevertheless, the cabinets seem to be of good quality, and the drawers offer a feature which prevents them from being damaged due to being closed (slammed) too quickly.
One of the best features of McCarty Place units are the bathrooms, which contain ceramic tile flooring and sinks with granite countertops. The bathroom also includes ample shelving, which functions well in lieu of a linen closet. While this may be a problem specific to our unit, it is important to note that the water heater does not provide hot water for an extended period of time, which could prove to be problematic should residents - say, you and your wife - want to take showers one right after another.
Each bedroom in our unit is large, with the master bedroom (obviously) providing the most space. Carpeting in the rooms is reminiscent of a shag style, and appears to be of a decent quality (perhaps most importantly, it feels good on your feet). Ample closet space is also provided, with each of our bedrooms providing plenty of room for all of our clothes, decorations, and other items we need to store.
As stated previously, the entire apartment has a very modern, updated feel to it, something which you will be hard-pressed to find elsewhere in Lafayette. Additionally, the residents making up the community are generally respectful of others, meaning that - for the most part - you won't have to deal with incredibly loud neighbors, parties, or random interruptions of your sleep in the middle of the night.
Outside of your unit, there are some factors to consider which detract from McCarty Place earning a 5-star rating. Most individuals who rent here - as of the writing of this review - are smokers. This isn't necessarily a big deal; however, many of the smokers do not properly dispose of their cigarettes, meaning that you will be seeing them everywhere, from the stairwells, to the walkways, and into the parking lot. Other issues of cleanliness have also been problematic during our stay here. Though the issue fluctuates in seriousness, there have been several problems with residents not cleaning up after their dogs in the grassy areas surrounding the complex. This means that - if you own a dog - you are very likely to step in another animal's waste, something which is not exactly appealing. Thankfully, management has attempted to rectify the issue, which has resulted in a lessening of the problem through time.
In a nutshell, McCarty Place offers a modern, updated living space at a great price, if you are able to look past issues with tidiness and a relatively small kitchen. Whether you are new to Lafayette or in need of a new place to call home, McCarty Place delivers in many key areas, making this a great place to live for anyone in search of a quality living space in greater Lafayette/West Lafayette.