I don't know where to start, went to the place, and offered to buy ammo at the same price they were selling it online. Basically told me, I'd have to buy it online and pay for the shipping. I also asked if they had any AK ammo in stock, and they told me they had zero rounds, when I walked around I saw they have a least five cases on the floor, when I asked about that, they told me they weren't for sale. Asked to look at one pistol and it was like I asked to pull their damn teeth one at a time. Finally let me examine one, I asked if I could make an offer, the guy said no, took the pistol back and made a show of wiping it down with a greasy cloth, like I had damaged it. I was specifically looking for 300 BLK, which was selling for about a buck a round at the time, which, was the going price on online auctions as well, they wanted 30 bucks for the same ammo they were selling online for 20. FURTHER, the reason for "New" ownership, is because the previous owner LOST or MISPLACED the records for over 2600 firearms, that were never logged in, or listed as sold. ATF allowed transfer to a new owner, which, I can't for the life of me understand, these people are terrible. read more

i bought an "ak" there and the "staff" treated me sh*t!! i stood for 10 min. waiting for one of the 3 people working there talking to notice me!! i had to raise my hand like a child in 2nd. grade!! after the transaction that seemed to last forever i asked the aassociate if they had any ak mags. for my rifle,,he looked at me and waved his hand toward an area of the store!! i walked out of the store with no mags. before my temper would have taken over!! i wouldnt accept a free rifle there!!i hate,,hate that place!! i will never go there again!! read more

*Buyer Beware** *Do Not Buy Here** Complete scam artists! I've bought a few guns in my time and I've never had to ask, Does it come with sights on it?' Their listing didn't say it was optic ready, which it's not, or no sights included. Their response, 'Well we didn't say it came with sights. I would not recommend this company to anyone!! Also I would look to avoid www.Gunbroker.com as well as they support this company and think they're reputable. read more

I took them two weapons to reblue. They lost action screws for one and failed to properly reassemble the shotgun. They left out the magazine follower, spring, plug, and retention ring. This group of yahoos is totally incompetent. I wouldn't let them work on my cap gun. If I could rate negative stars, I would for sure. read more

Not sure what happened to this place but service and attention to details they have lost. I purchase mass amounts of amok and guns from this business but in recent months find myself hesitant as they show signs of going out of business. Careful with your purchase they are not guaranteed like they use to be. read more

Absolutely enraged. I recently purchased a revolver on gun broker from this seller. I've now been informed they are closed until Tuesday due to "inventory" So I said to them so your selling guns you don't have in stock! No answer from them. Sad! read more

I'm done! Called and went in 3 times to inquire about selling a couple of long guns. Was told to call when Tyler was in because he had to take care of that. Called when I was told and he wasn't there. Apparently they don't know what customer service is and didn't even ask for my number for Tyler to call me. There's other gun stores to choose from, so I suggest Tyler gets his business together. read more

These people are a fraud. They make multiple listings on the Gunbroker website and if they don't like the results of the auction then they say the item is out of stock. They use another profile "A***5" to bid up prices. They bid us up to $4500 on a rifle that retails for $749 They then claimed the items are on backorder but didn't offer to put us on the list?? Instead they simply refunded our payment a week later hoping we would go away ***Come to find out they don't even have a backorder with the manufacturer!?!*** read more

BUYER BEWARE. Purchased a "Factory New" firearm from this business. Upon receiving, it showed clear signs of damage/use. Contacted business and was given run around "This is a manufacturer's warranty issue" and told to send to S&W for eval, but promised a refund if necessary. Sent to S&W who generously repaired several damaged parts/areas and received the firearm back. It still showed signs of damage though so I contacted seller for a refund. They walked back their promise to refund my money and told me that this was a warranty issue. The firearm clearly did not leave S&W factory in that condition. Extremely dishonest business. They must purchase their positive reviews read more

Sportsman's Supply - Damage to "Factory New" firearm that seller refused to refund money for - Guns & Ammo Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

See all

Sorry, but I don't get the ratings on this page. The shop has phenomenal reviews on GunBroker, and after winning an auction for a NIB 1911, I then found this page and thought maybe I'd made a mistake. I was sweating waiting for the gun to arrive, as a few on Yelp had said they ordered NIB guns that in fact weren't. All I can say is, the transaction went through in seconds, the auction price was fantastic... at least $200-$300 below current "Buy Now" market prices everywhere else... there were no "bots driving up the price of the gun"... the transaction processed in seconds, the gun shipped first thing the following morning, as the auction ended after business hours the night before... It arrived in 2 business days... and it was perfect... as advertised... still covered in original gun oil from the manufacturer and flawless. I was so concerned after reading this site that I'd reached out to my FFL to make sure he inspected it and took pics before I arrived in case I had to dispute the transaction. He told me he's taken deliveries from them before and had never had a problem, and said the comments calling out GB for having fake reviews are BS. So they've got amazing reviews on GB... amazing reviews on Google and everywhere else I've looked, but a whopping 1.5 stars on Yelp. Tells me more about Yelp than it does Sportsman's Supply. I'll buy from them again in a heartbeat and have already send links to my son as well. read more

I purchased ammo off these clowns on gun broker. The ad said $20 shipping and free in store pickup. I called them up on my way to pick the ammo up. The ignorant guy that answered said they no longer offer in store pickup and I had to pay $20 for shipping. I said I don't want it then as it was no longer a deal. He said I'll have to pay some sort of fine then. I said why does it say free in store pickup on the site. He said f$&k you and hung up. read more

Sportsman's Supply - Proof - Guns & Ammo Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

An absolute $850 nightmare! Purchased an AR 2 months ago from them on Gunbroker. It didn't arrive, I contacted Sportsman's, they said it was shipped to the wrong location by mistake and they would correct the matter. Lip service and nothing else. I had to contact UPS - UPS told me it was the seller's responsibility to do so. I told Spotsman's. More lip service. Now they don't even respond to EMAILS. The good part is I'm an attorney and will be making their lives miserable in the next 24 hours if they do not immediately rectify this situation. read more

I bought 200 federal fusion .338 200 grain bullets on Gunbroker for at least $20.00 less than anywhere else that i could find. They arrived quickly in perfect condition. A successful interaction. read more

Buyer beware. I won an ammo auction after outbidding their bot. I spent a ridiculous amount of money only to be told there was a shipping delay due to being short staffed. A few days later I received an email they would ship the item out that day. We are now into the following week and the ammo was never shipped. Sportsman's supply lies, up charges hundreds of percent,uses bots to raise auction prices and never ships what they sell. Do not buy from sportsman's Supply!!! read more

I won an auction on gunbroker.com. Saved at least $200 bucks. When I called about shipping, the lady who answered the phone was polite and courteous. 8 days after the auction I was getting my finger caught in the action of my first ever semi auto shotgun lol. Oh well, live and learn. You guys rock!!! read more

Avoid this operation. They are a big seller over gunbroker.com. I won an item which was a gun part; to wit a barrel. A barrel does not need to go to an FFL. It is a part. Sportsman's Supply never shipped the item because they insisted that they needed to send it to an FFL. They do not know the basic gun laws -nor did they collect tax (and maybe the FTB should know about that). I was charged a "restocking" fee for an item that never left the premises; where a portion of the restocking fee was for shipping charges that were never incurred. There is an employee there by the name of "Taylor" who would be well advised to check her poor attitude and obnoxious indifference. Further, because gunbroker.com listed Sportsman's Supply as an A+ seller, obviously gunbroker.com cannot be trusted with their seller reviews. Accordingly, due to the experience with Sportsman's Supply, this will be the first and last transaction over gunbroker.com. I spend a lot of money on firearms, gunsmithing and handloading. The swagger and indifference of Sportsman's Supply is seriously going to come back to bite them when the gun buying frenzy slows down. read more

Ive dealt with this place since the original owner opened it. He was an awesome guy. The son took over some years later and was a nice guy but eventually got too greedy. Moved him to even say hi to me even after 35+ years as a customer and hundreds of transactions. Then he sold it and the place really went to hell. The new owner is a smug prik that cant be bothered with walk in customers. Wont be back. read more

Rating this place is difficult. While the older gentleman tried to help me and gave decent service when he could, the younger woman who handled most of the transaction was quite disappointing. I explained that I was new to weapons. She sighed many times like this was a big bother to help me. When I asked about maintenance for this one thousand dollar device, she suggested I look it up online. When I pressed to see if they sold products for cleaning and lubrication, she reluctantly took me to that section and handed me a box. I noticed this expensive kit was not thr right size for my weapon...she said they were out of stock. I gave her a puzzled look, and guess what, she thrn acknowledged that product was in their storage bin outside, at which point... voila! She gave me the right kit. How hard should I have to work to spend money? Her impatience with helping a non-expert was palpable. Ultimately, I did not feel valued and would not return to this store. When I returned to pick up the weapon, another hour wait, though they promised I could call in and bypass the line at time of sale. Maybe if I were male or more advanced in knowledge, they would have been more helpful? Maybe they don't care? The line wraps round the store, so I have to guess they treat some customers better than others. read more

I found an item on Gunbroker and Sportsman's Supply had quite a few of them listed. I had a maximum price in mind and I bid on and lost four auctions as they were selling for $40-50 over my price. The fifth auction I was surprised to find out I won as there were 28 bids. Real bids, no bots like others here surmise. I know there was no bot bidding as I won the item well under my maximum bid and 12% under MSRP. Sportsman's Supply did NOT bid up the auction and then sell to me at a price under what others were paying. I paid immediately and within an hour I received my tracking number. The tracking number became active that evening and the item arrived two days later. Completely new, unused, and in prefect condition with everything in the box. The service I received from Sportsman's Supply was absolutely flawless. They earned my trust and respect. read more

They use bot accounts to hike up the prices on gun broker. Don't get baited into spending more money because they will just repost it when one of their bot accounts outbids you. They win big if your foolish enough to keep throwing money down to win. read more

Stay away from this store the new ownership is a complete joke over priced on everything. Primers used to be 80.00 a brick now two weeks later they are 140 dollars and 14 a sleeve for a 100 YOU GOT TO BE KIDDING ME. I was told that that's the price everyone else is selling it at so that's what I'm charging. Powder is all 44 dollars when the same stuff at other stores is 28 to 30 dollars. Ammo way overpriced!!!! Again stay away you've turned a business into a complete joke!!!! Also gun broker scam artists buyer beware you've been warned!! read more

I bought a new in box mossberg 500 off of their gun broker account shipping was fast I payed on a Thursday and it was at my gun store on Monday. Only problem was the top of the receiver was scratched and the fore grip had something silver paint or something on it. read more

Sportsman's Supply - Guns & Ammo Near Me - Butler, Pennsylvania

See all

I've read several negative reviews about Sportsman's Supply after I had placed my order with them. The reviews made me extremely concerned. Would they send the correct product? Would they send all the parts related to the product? Well, my experienced was one of the smoothest purchases, payment, shipping, and finally receiving the correct product with all the parts. I don't usually file a review. But now I know Sportsman's Supply will now have at least one 5 star review. read more

I bid for gun on gun broker which was offered by sportsman supply. It was for a derrenger NIB. When it arrived it was not NIB. Gun wasn't bagged, no manual or warrantee card. Ok, the outer appearance looked good. When I went to field clean it to go shoot, one of the firing springs was missing. The cam was cracked, & the extractor didn't work properly. No way a new gun. Left e-mail about it, no reply as of yet. Am in contact with Cobra to get the parts to fix it so I have a gun & not a paper weight. Won't be dealing with them with this example from them. Probably will be contacting ATF on this kind of practice. read more

Drove up to pick up a gun broker purchase of ammo as I usually do, I was informed that they no longer allow ammo pickups in store they have to be shipped, nowhere on my auction page did it say that they were no longer allowing pickups for ammo. Their customer service was terrible they told me they don't have to post that they can just do what they want I said for them to show me in the auction where it was listed that they changed their policy. She found a new listing for something else that had it in it but not in my particular auction. I said I wasn't paying the extra money for shipping that they could cancel my order and I better not get a negative feedback on my GunBroker and they told me that it wasn't up to them it was up to GunBroker. They continue to inflate the situation and got me even more upset and mad they don't have any customer skills in dealing with customers in that store. The lady in there had her boyfriend in there which started threatening me with violence at the same time. I was upset and my voice was very loud so one of the employees stepped outside with me. I told him they either sell it to me or I was leaving not a problem. She came outside and started on me again and then her boyfriend came out and threatened me again. Just be careful when you go to sportsman supply they have terrible customer service I used to deal with them for years I spend thousands and thousands of dollars there they just lost a very good customer. read more

See all

These guys are great! Very polite and accommodating! Store was well stocked. Completed my firearms purchase quickly and efficiently. Will actively seek to do business with them again in the future! read more

Bought a NIB S&W 629-6 off Gunbroker. It has scratches and the famous S&W ring on the cylinder from use. And it has a canted barrel. This is used not new. When I contacted Sportsman's Supply, the reply I got was send it S&W for warranty work. I will never do business with them or gunbroker again! read more

I was high bidder on 14 items on GunBroker. Went to their store to pick them up and they tell me they no longer allow store pickup. They always used to allow store pickup and we're very friendly. This time they were very rude and said the only thing I can do is have the items shipped at $15 each or pay the relist fee. With what I bid, paying shipping would be more than the items were valued at. I had no choice other than to pay their relist fees, and I got nothing in return. If they don't allow store pickup, then their posting should state that. Over the past I had purchased over $20,000.00 of items from them. No more, I will never purchase another thing from Sportsman's Supply in Butler. read more

I found an O/U shotgun on Gunbroker which exactly suits my needs, and after placing a bid wondered if it might be a good idea to check this store out before considering going any higher. I have never seen so many consistently negative comments made about a retailer anywhere, so decided to do some extra checking. From their online profile details, it appears to me as though they may be having bots do their customer ratings as well as driving bid prices higher. They have over the past 12 months 41297 positive comments with what looks like a high percentage coming from repeat commenters, 108 neutral, and 279 negative comments. In a perfect world it's possible that they could have roughly 14000 transactions commented on in a month.....so I called the store directly with a question, which the CSR answered but then said that he wanted to go take a look at the shotgun to see if there actually is such an item. I said "why?" and he responded "are you there?" several times before hanging up on me. My takeaway is that they have a very, very young staff with no knowledge of their product, no manners, no accountability, and I'm letting their bot outbid me. read more

Beware, bought a brand new gun online at gunbroker.com, got a good price but the gun came with a messed up foldable stock and 2 stripped screws right out of the box. They ignore my emails. Not happy with my services. If they want to fix the issues then I might be happy. Just so frustrating. read more

I have never been to their shop, and I never will.! On organized and unprofessional. How do you miss place a $1700 cashiers check?? And then have the audacity to tell me I have not sent payment.?!?! And then the merchandise that I purchased wasn't EXACTLY what I received. And apparently according to Facebook and others you can sell the hell out of ammunition, good for you.... Anybody and everybody do yourself a favor and find some other place to do business with. read more

Adding to the list of one star reviews. First time new customer and will definitely not be back. The ownership needs to learn that this is something that many of us do for enjoyment and can simply choose to do business elsewhere. I hope others read the review and support other businesses that appreciate their customers. read more

I've purchased many items from Sportsman. They've always been timely whether I pay by card or check. I see a lot of people complaining about bots and such. If you don't know what you're bidding on and how much it's worth, don't do auctions! I win less than 1% of the items that I bid on. Nothing personal, it's just business. I will continue to do business with them. read more

I won an auction for 500 22 caliber bullets through Gunbroker.com and was very pleased with the transaction. I emailed them a couple questions and they replied quickly. They even called me before the shipped the bullets because they had a question instead of just assuming, that's going above and beyond in customer service. I would definitely use them again. read more

Rude, annoying employees. Apparently uninterested in face to face transactions anymore. Way high prices.

Got in a gun that I have wanted for a long time. Scalped it on Gunbroker instead of selling it to me.

Had a very lengthy mishap with Sportsman Supply over charging me 41$ For a scope I won and didn't know about. I bid on 2 more and won those but still had to pay the 41$ for the phantom scope. Ended up it was Gunbrokers fault for not notifying me. Evidently,according to Sportsman Supply it had happened to other people also. Still not right to charge me for Gunbrokers screwup. Evidently their motto is if youre screwed you lose. So.... take it from me... Deal with them at your own risk! BTW, one of my scopes went to frickin Alaska. But they did find the mistake after several Emails. And priority mail is around 7.00$. They charge 15$. read more

Read the other reviews about these yahoos. Someone needs to explain that the customer pays their salary. Their prices are inflated almost as much as their condescending attitudes. Avoid these people and spend you hard earned money at another gun store that cares about customers read more

I had been bidding on stuff from them on gun broker and getting out bid. I thought nothing of it but then I noticed the next day would be selling another one. Same pictures and when I read they are just stock pictures and not the one of the actual one I started thinking that was not right. The firearm I am looking for I am not willing to pay a certain price for. It is fair market price more than I would pay for it from Big Daddy. I was getting frustrated because after 4 times coming close to winnowing the bid and loosing 2 times to the same account then taking a screen shot of it. I realized they were using bots! I come to this yelp page and find out that others have said the same. The will not hurt for business right now. They have over 300k sales on gun broker so they might never go out of business, but if your thinking about buying from them don't. I think most gun stores are good to their customers and fair to the people. They are not and when I called about this issue they were very rude. I do not know why they would act so rude to someone asking a question, but I feel it was because I was asking about the issue of loosing a bid and the fire arm coming back up when they said they only had one in the past few months. If your still reading this my recommendation is the market will right it self once this Covid 19 is over they will lower their prices and when they do I recommend you take your business somewhere els. Good luck out there. read more

i tried to purchase a revolver from sportsman supply through Gun Broker.com. As the auction was ending I noticed the same bidder was out bidding me. When the auction ended the other bidder had won, fair enough but then I noticed the same revolver was immediately relisted. It was so obvious and blatant, Sportsman's Supply are scammers. I will never try to purchase anything from them again, pathetic. read more