Small thrift boutique with nice finds. Wished they had more large sizes and more shoes. But…read morewhatever they had was good quality & good brands. The prices are insanely reasonable. Other than the higher end brands & jewelery, everything is $5. Except today was Half Off Day so I was ecstatic about that! I got a dress AND sweater for $5. Staff was so helpful and friendly! What i love most about this place is that a portion of sales goes back into the community. Whenever it's the local schools or to senior centers or families in need. So not only are we saving money & saving landfills but we're also helping out.

Amazing little thrift shop. Clean. Great prices. Nice items in good condition. Have been several…read moretimes. Recommend!!

I just discovered this charming new thrift shop in Mendham, 6 Hilltop Road, behind Grand Bazaar on…read moreHilltop Ave. It's well organized with deluxe brands (Brooks Brothers, Pink are some men's shirts). The proprieter, Eric, is very knowledgeable about sizes and brands. I got two beautiful men's shirts, and the women's clothes are also stylish and upscale. Prices are VERY reasonable ($20 for the two shirts). Eric says he gets new stuff all the time and has discerning taste. Recommended! Thursday - Sunday 11:00-4:00.

From the owner: Location is temporarily closed until further notice read more

I'm a big fan of everything Mid-century modern. Finding this little gem by chance, made me feel…read morehappier after I got that horrendous coffee down the street. I'm not from the area at all. I actually couldn't find this nugget on Yelp, so, ta-dah! I added them. I didn't ask the lovely lady at the desk, but I figure they are relatively new (?). Upon entry, you are greeted by a vintage tension pole lamp, followed by glassware, stemware, plates, dishes, serving ware, and the most fun cocktail party pieces, every MCM loving mad man or woman should have in their collection at their Eichler or (a good copy of) van der Rohe home. Perhaps, the owners will add some furniture with time - it would be nice to see an extended website catalog. I look forward to returning to this little boutique, to see the evolving merchandise.

Jo has a lovely shop filled with treasures. I have purchased a few antiques from her for our new…read morehome. She's very willing to locate items if you are in search of a special piece. This is a definite stop while in Chester

Exquisite collection of antiques, beautiful curation. Fine jewelry and Hermes collection of scarves.read more

Recently popped into Reclaimed on a whim & I'm so glad I did. Wendi (the sweet owner) has curated a…read moregorgeous selection of pieces at great prices. Will definitely keep coming back

From the owner: Reclaimed is a consignment boutique in Pottersville, NJ, offering a mix of effortlessly cool…read morefashion, vintage home pieces, handmade goods, and bridal gowns that won’t break the budget. Everything’s handpicked, with an eye for quality, style, and a good story. At Reclaimed, we believe sustainability should be stylish—and fun! Whether you're hunting for a unique fashion find, a one-of-a-kind gift, or a special piece for your home, you’ll discover something that feels good to buy and good for the planet. Come visit us and shop with purpose.

I was just waking around and happened to pop in here! What a cute place. I wish I had some more…read moretime to chat with the two friendly ladies working there. They were definitely not gonna let us walk out of there without buying something or looking at all the options lol! Most of their stuff is hand made from artisans and they had a great selection. Definitely a high end vintage feel. I love this little store!

Great store with wonderful handbags, jewelry and other accessories. Patsy the owner is…read moreknowledgeable and extremely personable. Highly recommended.

quaint store with a large variety. prices are very good for thrifting. will repeat when in the area…read moreagain

Great little shop. conveniently located and good prices. Always enjoy going here. Clean, neat and…read moreorganized

Very nice good stuff good price many varieties parking easy clean i bought many things every time…read moreI went there

Fun store to look through! There are some gems but you have really go through the inventory. There…read moreare cheaper thrift stores but they have a nice assortment of furniture. The clothing choices are in the early 2000s to 2010s. There are some more vintage pieces but not as varied as opposed to a place like savers. I would come back if I'm in the area. It's right across the street from a park too!

This was my first time visiting Cheap Maggie's, and the experience was a mix of curiosity and…read morecaution. When I first walked in, I went to the side of the store that has shoes and miscellaneous items. The floor in that section was noticeably dirty, and there was a damp smell in the air, which made me uncomfortable enough to move on quickly. The other side of the store was much better and had most of the clothing. They have a men's section and a women's section, along with racks labeled for certain brands. Some racks weren't labeled at all, so you really have to take your time and look through everything individually to find pieces that stand out to you. Toward the back of the women's side, there's a shoe area, plus a children's section, lingerie, and hosiery. There's definitely a lot to browse through if you're in the mood to hunt for deals. I ended up finding a T‑shirt, a top, some trouser socks, and a couple of men's ties. I didn't see a large amount that I personally wanted to purchase, but there were a few decent finds. The store attendant -- possibly the manager -- was extremely pleasant and gracious. They offered me 10% off my total since it was my first visit, which I really appreciated. Would I return? Possibly, but more for a few small pieces rather than a full shopping trip. It's the kind of store where you might find a gem if you're willing to sort through a lot of inventory.

I went to the Cheap Maggie's in Gillette, NJ. I will start by saying that do not come to cheap…read moreMaggie's expecting thrift shop prices because you will not get that. I believe cheap Maggie's is a store where they purchase overstock products and sell them in their store for a discounted price. For example they had UGG shoes on sale for $59.99. I purchased a timberland belt for $17.99. My mother brought a three items and she was given a $10 discount on each item and she paid a total of $114.97 for three items. Overall, I'm assuming the prices are fair because they are cheaper than what you would purchase them for at the actual store that they come from. I saw items from stores like Lululemon, American Eagle, UGG, and Bloomingdale's. I feel like you could find some cute items here you just have to take the time to actually look through the racks. As for the sizing I felt like I saw a lot of smaller sizes. I saw some large sizes but not many XL. Also, I don't recall seeing any plus sizes.

The prices are higher than they should be. I was also surprised that they didn't have more items to…read morebuy.

Goodwill is the worst place to donate your stuff. It's run like a for-profit store. They take…read moreyour goods for free and then sell it at a mark-up. They pay the employee peanuts. The millions in profits are given to the executive management. It boggles the mind how this is fair. I think that organization should lose its non-profit status.