On vacation at Sugar Mountain over Memorial Day Weekend and I got a craving for a steak. My wife and I left the kids at the condo and snuck away to have dinner at Stonewalls. Without reservations we were seated outside without a wait, I'd recommend making a reservation though. We split a NY Strip medium, a baked potato with all the fixings, & creamed spinach. I opted to top the steak with blue cheese butter and sauteed mushrooms. It hit the spot.... Perfectly. Looking forward to our next opportunity to sneak away from the kids and have a steak at Stonewalls. read more

Stonewalls Restaurant was one of the more pleasant surprises during my time in Banner Elk. It's a beautiful restaurant, and I had been looking forward to dining there for quite some time. From the moment we arrived, the staff was warm, welcoming, and attentive. The atmosphere, however, felt a little mixed. The restaurant seemed to have two distinct personalities. The newer side, where the bar is located, felt polished and cohesive, while the older dining room--where we were seated because it had more availability--felt like it hadn't quite received the same attention. The lighting on that side of the restaurant was particularly harsh, which made the dining room feel less intimate than it could have been. Since it's also the larger and busier dining space, I think small touches like candles on the tables or softer lighting would go a long way toward creating a warmer, more personal atmosphere. I also noticed an interesting contrast between the beautiful leather-bound menus and some of the furniture and wall décor, which felt more reminiscent of a hotel dining room than the upscale mountain restaurant the food suggested. Thankfully, the meal more than made up for those observations. I ordered the wild mushroom pasta with lobster, and it was the standout dish of the evening. The pasta was rich without feeling heavy, the mushrooms added wonderful depth, and the lobster was cooked beautifully. It's a dish I'd gladly order again. My boyfriend ordered a steak, which he thoroughly enjoyed. We also started with the escargot and the crab cakes. The escargot, while not quite on the level of some traditional French restaurants I've visited, was still very well prepared and enjoyable. The crab cakes were outstanding--full of crab, nicely seasoned, and easily one of the best appetizers of the meal. Our only complaint was that there was only one crab cake on the plate; we both found ourselves wishing there had been another. Overall, Stonewalls Restaurant delivered an excellent meal with genuinely welcoming service. While I'd love to see the older dining room updated to better match the quality of the cuisine, the food alone makes it well worth a visit if you're in Banner Elk. read more

Stonewalls - Steakhouses Near Me - Banner Elk, North Carolina

We got sat immediately despite there being no reservations online left. Our server quickly came over and filled our waters and took our drink order. My son's sprite came out quickly, and the bar drinks followed. I loved my holiday punch drink! The restaurant was still decorated for Christmas, but it made it more charming since we are in town to ski for the weekend. She brought out bread, but it wasn't warm, so that was odd. My son and husband still ate it; I did not. The escargot was ok ; not as good as other places we have had it. The fried deviled eggs were INSANE. We loved them so much. My son got the ribeye and a baked potato. He ordered it medium rare, and it was more on the rare side, but he still enjoyed it. As he kept eating, it cooked up a little bit. He ended the night with a cinnamon roll bread pudding with ice cream and caramel. The server lit a candle in it. Overall, we had a great time! read more

See all

Ribeye was lacking flavor. Service was attentive. Left with headache from loud guitarist. Impossible for one to carry on a conversation with loud music read more

Updating this review. Went back to Stonewall's last week. They had an all new bar staff and they were excellent. I also had one of the most flavorful steaks I have had in a long time! read more

A nice atmosphere but the high points are the service, spot on, the steak and prime rib are excellent and served at the perfect temperature. The appetizers were terrific also. ( Shrimp cocktail and fried devil eggs ) Don't miss this place. read more

This was our first dinner here. We spent a weekend getaway near Banner Elk. We chose Stonewalls for our anniversary dinner. We both love a good steak. My husband would have liked more steak options. It seemed a limited menu. (I booked this place because of the escargot app) We started with garlic escargot! Super great. The little crostini with it is a take it or leave it it makes eating the escargot a little messy. For our mains. My husband got the ribeye. And I got the 10oz prime rib. I would have liked a bigger plate for my prime rib. Flavors were all there. For my side I had the sweet potatoes. And I got the mushrooms as my enhancement. Super nice serving. Service was great. But we just wanted a little more... to our dining experience. I thought it was going to be a more intimate vibe For dessert we indulged! We had the key lime pie and peach cobbler. Super yum! Parking is a little tight. FYI. You can park across the street in a nice paved parking lot. read more

See all

Service was great. Food was very bland and not worth the price. We had steak, chicken, fish and pasta. Nothing was great.

Food good but you have to spend some money to get a good meal. The steaks are decent but order them rare. read more

Great service and you can't beat the prime rib. Always enjoy Stonewall's when I am in the area.

My favorite restaurant in the high country. Visit often cause I have a cabin in Banner Elk, if I didn't it would be my choice place while visiting. read more

We arrived shortly after they opened, had a reservation and had a great table in a smaller section of the restaurant. The ambiance was calming and comfortable with a modern decor. Our server was very personable and fun. She was attentive at the right time, giving us ample time to feel relaxed and able to enjoy our cocktails and appetizer of amazing fried deviled eggs. All of our entrees were delicious except for the lobster bisque. No chunks of lobster, all creamy texture with a beer cheese soup flavor. :( read more

See all

Food was very good. Husband's fish had several bones but it was good. Service was great.

We recently ordered takeout from Stonewalls and it was amazing! After a day of exploring the Banner Elk area we were unsure of where to eat so we checked Yelp for reviews. I also had recommendations from our Airbnb host to eat here but was hesitant because of the live music. Often it's too loud for me but this was not the case here. It looked like a simple one man setup with no super loud equipment. We decided to check out the menu in person and to see if there were any specials not listed online, and I'm so glad we did. We walked in, were given menus and directed to the bar to order. The bartender Colton was extremely attentive and rattled off numerous specials with ease, making a recommendation when I had questions. Once home, the food was amazing and we ate every bit. From bread to dessert (delicious key lime pie and crème brûlée), everything was perfect. We will 1000% eat here when we're back in town! read more

Stonewalls - Halibut special with grilled asparagus, and the mushroom pasta dish with shrimp added. - Steakhouses Near Me - Banner Elk, North Carolina

Let me first say, Joel our server was phenomenal and professional. I was a little disappointed in the food though. Had the $8 salad bar and first glance arriving at the bar was.........where is everything. The majority of items were mostly gone or not well stocked. Lettuce had a different taste and ended up not eating it. The homemade pimento cheese was absolutely awesome, in which Joel said we needed to try. Our table order several things; escargot, trout with apparagus, alfredo with sauce, filet mignon, pan blackened chicken with maple brussel sprouts. We each tasted each others foods and the flavors just weren't there for me or our family. If anything, each dish needed salt or a just something. The one time will not deter me from trying again as the atmosphere and service were top notch. read more

The service was amazing - walked right in and got seated without a reservation. Our server was great and attentive. The food is why 3 stars it was just ehhh. We got the potato skins - just lacking flavor with cold melted cheese. I got the chicken which was chewy but the flavor was fine. Mash potatoes were good. Shrimp skewer was just lacking flavor. Hubby got the ribeye, it was fine- nothing special. Kids got the fish was fine after adding lemon and a burger which he ate about half of. Overall the price wasn't bad and the food wasn't bad just not out of this world. read more

See all

Stonewalls is a charming place. The ambience is warm and welcoming. The food is very good. My steak was done perfectly and had a wonderful, char grilled flavor. Top notch. The maple Brussels sprouts were not my favorite. On their own they would have been very good but I don't think they work alongside the charcoal flavor of the steak. My salad was great, as was the cheesecake dessert. All-in-all, a very good meal. The service was very good, too. But don't ask for anything that's not on the menu--the chef is not adventurous. I asked for a slight modification to my steak and the server automatically said no, he won't do it. She was so sure she wouldn't even ask him. read more

Made a reservation and dropped by on our ski trip. The setting is beautiful and elegant while remaining true to its rustic surroundings. There is a full bar and while we didn't order drinks the wine and beer menu looked robust. The service was outstanding and the food was awesome! We had the pistachio crusted trout and the marbled ribeye. Both were phenomenal, as was the salad bar. Definitely a must stop when in the area! read more

Our dinner reservation with Stone Walls was amazing. A great surprise for my birthday with wonderful food. Service was amazing and food experience will be remembered. We will be recommending this location to all friends and family who plan to visit no doubt. An item that was not pictured is the pistachio crusted trout our friend had and he raved about it! I plan to get that next time! Thank you for an awesome experience, we will be back! read more

See all

The restaurant is nicely decorated and was clean. We ordered the hoisin salmon with brussel sprouts and the rib eye with a baked potato. The salmon was cold and had way too much hoisin sauce which was brushed on right before serving it. The maple brussel sprouts were way too sweet with maple syrup just poured on them and they were not cooked well. The rib eye was over cooked and very fatty. The baked potato was good. The one saving grace for the food was the salad bar. It was stocked with lots of good ingredients for a fabulous salad. The service was OK. read more

Wonderful food, wonderful service, and great atmosphere surrounding us. The teriyaki chicken was to die for!

Amazing service and assistance, grateful for the accommodations given weather issues and their hosts/hostesses were beyond helpful

Not sure how this place rating are so high . Worst service and attitude at a restaurant that has low level food . It looks appealing from the outside but that's where the ambiance stops . Rushed and food was not cooked refused a recook because they needed the table and we wouldn't be done in time for the next customers. Way over priced from mediocre food read more

Avoid unless you want to pay for the worst steak you will ever eat. I guess nobody knows good steak around here because this place is abysmal. They served the nerve end cut and it was like chewing the fattiest ribeye in history. No discount either even though I didn't take more than a couple bites. What kind of steakhouse served the wrong cut - this one! read more

Fantastic! We loved everything! I have food allergies, and not the typical ones, so I called ahead of booking our table. The hostess who answered the phone went above and beyond to check with the chefs in the kitchen for me. There was a very small list of things that I wasnt able to have and she let me know about them BEFORE we even booked our anniversary dinner. When we arrived the same hostess greeted us and immediately told me that she was the one who had spoke with me on the phone a few days ago. She then led us to our table, let us know who our server was and that she was aware, and the kitchen was aware, of my allergies. When our server met us at the table she immediately confirmed my allergies with me and let us know about the specials, to which there was a lengthy list, and made sure to let me know what was safe for me to have. My husband ordered the fried deviled eggs, and they let me know about a cross contamination between my allergens and the frying oil for the eggs. I was able to have a couple bites, enough to know that 1) they were delicious and 2) not to push it for my allergy. I had the lobster bisque, it was very good. My husband had the ribeye with blue cheese butter, sauté onions and mushrooms (all up grades, but so reasonable) and their stuffed baked potato (the best twice baked potato you have ever had, but again a very reasonable upgraded side). I had the chicken oscar. My husband's steak was cooked perfectly medium rare and my chicken was cooked completely through AND still juicy. It goes to show that in a proper chef's hands, a steak can be a perfect temperature and chicken doesn't have to be dry. We each had a creme brule for dessert and it was delicious. We were completely stuffed when we left and it was the best meal we'd had in years. The meal was extremely reasonably priced and the portions were large. We've spent more at a chain restaurant for much lesser quality food. Our meal was $130, before tip. We had 2 appetizers, 2 main course meals and desserts. That is extremely reasonable for all of that. The server was fantastic, the ambiance was very nice, the host was exceptional and the food was out of this world. If you come to the area this is a must eat spot, but make a reservation! We're local-ish, definitely close to come back again, and we will! Stonewalls, thank you for an extraordinary night. You made it a very memorable anniversary for us. read more

See all

Walking in is dream like in a mountain town. Outdoor fireplace lit with lightly dusted snow from the night before. Appears the outside area is dog friendly but no heating lamps (I didn't ask, just saying what it didn't appear to have) and it was 25 degrees outside. Immediately greeted by 3 people at 5:30 on a Wednesday. I asked to be seated at the bar since I was singular but they had that closed for seating for the Annual Chamber dinner. They did inform me it would get a bit loud around 6, which was kind. Sat towards the stairs area, which was quaint and only sat a few tables. Doesn't have a partition for noise but they do have a curtain. With that room full of people next to where I was sitting is noisy if you're wanting a romantic dinner, but solo I love the gossip. Haha. The waitress (Reagan) was so kind. She filled me in on the specials and I chose the halibut. But started with the bread and escargot. Bread and butter, how do you really go wrong, but the escargot with pastry on top tasted like dirt. Now hear me out, I eat a lot of escargot and I realize they live and eat most things like dirt. But out of all the times I've had it, it's never tasted like actual dirt. I pushed it aside and told my waitress to keep it on my bill, but I didn't finish it. She kindly took it off anyhow. For an entree I ordered the special halibut and creamed spinach. Both DELICIOUS. The fish was cooked perfectly and the seasoning was perfectly complimented. The creamed spinach is my type of salt level, but if you're sensitive to salt, it's apparent. Ordered the Mississippi Mud Pie for dessert. I'm not a huge sweet eater but I love a good bite or two. Worth ordering and taking to go if you're nearby. Ice cream in the middle. read more

See all

Really confused why this has so many stars...food was really subpar and under seasoned. Shrimp tasted like rubber, steaks were cooked three different temperatures on one cut, and nothing had salt or pepper. Also got bread for the table after we got the entrees, got our drinks after our apps. Just a really not good dinner honestly. i really wanted to like it too. read more

The food was excellent. The service and drinks were amazing. Our waitress was very nice and the restaurant is what you would expect for fine dining. I would recommend a reservation. I thought it was pricey for what it was, but I would still eat there again. read more

Food and service always good. One of my go to's for the area. Try it, you will like it but be sure to make a reservation. read more

Great salad bar!! And steaks, and prime rib, and fish and desserts!! Oh and service!!!

The food was excellent, the deviled eggs are amazing. The rest of the menu looked great if it's anything like the fish though it is $$$. Reagan our waitress was wonderful, made sure we had everything we needed. I was also impressed how she knew without hesitation all the specials and specifics. Amazing service. The restaurant was very nice casual but would also be a place for a special night or gathering. The atmosphere is quiet but also has the atmosphere of gathering with friends. If in the Banner Elk area a must visit. read more

Stonewalls - Trout, Rice Pilaf and Maple sweet potatoes. - Steakhouses Near Me - Banner Elk, North Carolina

See all

We decided to dress up one night on our honeymoon and go out to eat the vibe was definitely there for a quiet yet fancy dinner just the two of us. The food was amazing and the waiter was supper attentive making sure our glasses were always full. Would definitely go back for the steak and the chocolate cake. read more

MAGGIE was the best server I've experienced in a great while! Food was excellent...8oz Filet/Salad Bar/Baked tater/Malbec. Would recommend: 10/10. Thanks again, Maggie! read more

Stonewalls came highly recommended and with 50+ years of being in business I had high expectations. Unfortunately, my partner and I left very disappointed. The only things I'd recommend are the lobster bisque, bread, and baked potato. The prime rib was served cold. The steak was undercooked. Then our check came before we could order dessert. We ordered dessert and it took over 23 minutes to get it. We might've mentioned some of these things to our server but she was MIA. To top it off... even though we still tipped 25% our server (J) added an additional $5 to the tip amount (it's the principle). read more

We loved our dinner at Stonewalls. The decor is lovely without being stuffy. We enjoyed the variety of the salad bar but there are also other salad options on the menu. We had a variety of menu items including escargot, prime rib, pasta and halibut. All were perfectly prepared. The mushroom fettuccini was especially flavorful. Save room for the house made desserts! You won't regret it. Definitely make a reservation during busy seasons. read more

Great service. Grace gave outstanding service. The steaks were great. It was our first visit and we will be back! read more

Stonewalls - More great angus ribeye and maple sweet potatoes - Steakhouses Near Me - Banner Elk, North Carolina

See all

This was the first time at this restaurant and decided to check it out for our anniversary dinner but it will probably be the last Service was great, ambiance was nice but the Food was mediocre at best. The best thing about our meal was the appetizers the escargot was delicious and the deviled eggs were delicious but the main entrees lacked seasoning and flavor. My wife got the prime rib and it was super tender but no flavor and I got the teriyaki chicken and it was just bland with no seasoning and it was served with the sauce on the side. If the pricing was less I would expect less but to be raved on as a more upscale establishment i expected Wow but was let down. read more

See all

Had a wonderful night we came In to ski this weekend but this was a highlight of my time here. We had the best server in the world tonight her name is Yvonne she is one of the best server's I have ever had if you ever come in try to get her. Had the 35 day dry aged ribeye steak special, great price 40 dollars for a 14 oz ribeye steak special with a side. Great place, great price, and most of all great service love Yvonne best server ever she made are night if you ever get the chance ask for her she is the best, seriously y'all she is the best. Ps try the desserts seriously they are all homemade love the chef they our delicious some of the best you can ever eat Yvonne sold me on 4 of the desserts, I say try the crème brûlée and the cinnamon rolls bread pudding it is amazing. read more

Josh provided excellent service last night and the prime rib was delicious. I also enjoyed the salad bar. We'll be back!

This place was awesome, right off the mountain from the resort/cabins so it's an easy drive to and from. Great atmosphere as soon as you walk up, they had a nice fire pit going that night. My party were originally sat at a tight table but when a larger round table opened up our server offered to move us which was very nice and he definitely didn't have to, it made for such a more enjoyable time. The food was spectacular from start to finish not to mentioned the drinks were top notch. First time ever having escargot and I have to say y'all might've set the bar a little too high, the butter sauce and puff pastry on top really made this my favorite new experience! Seas scallops and butternut squash risotto are simply two things I can't pass up and boy am I glad I didn't. Melt in your mouth scallops and the creamy risotto was a perfect pair. My buddy got the NY Strip and stated it was one of the best he's had in a long time. I can't recommend this place enough for a cozy, sophisticated yet inviting dinner. read more

See all