Picked out 2 items and they agreed to hold at the counter for a few hours. They also agreed to a…read more10% discount. Return 2.5 hrs later to find not only that they had sold one of the items but that they had reneged on the discount for the remaining item. Horrible way to do business.

Local Knit has a very cool concept- creating their own designs for local Montauk businesses. Their…read moreshirts are comfy and have a cool vintage look unique to each of them. It's cool to have unique shirts that not only remind you of Montauk and its mainstays, but it's always nice to rep small business! Definitely worth a stop in!

Catwalk Couture and Cathy are LIFE. She has a way of making…read moreyou feel like you're right at home. During one of the most difficult times in my life--navigating my breast cancer journey--Cathy and her store became a source of peace and healing. She didn't just welcome me as a customer; she welcomed me as a sister. Our conversations helped me open up--not just as a woman, but as a speaker and someone longing to build deeper community. Cathy leads with love, compassion, and a spirit of sisterhood that transcends race, gender, and background. I've witnessed it, and I've experienced it firsthand. Since discovering Catwalk Couture, I've stopped shopping at major department stores. Instead, I make the conscious choice to support businesses and people like Cathy--authentic, gifted, and deeply rooted in purpose. I love her not only as a businesswoman, but as a person whose God-given talent continues to bless so many. I pray for continued success and leaving a lasting legacy. I wish she was back in South Florida, but when we speak it's as if she right back where we met.

Catwalk Couture is definitely one of the finest places to shop for exquisite second hand deals. I…read morefind the owner to be very patient, informative, and quite knowledgeable about her items. I have purchased several items from Catwalk Couture, and have definitely recommended it to my friends. I read in a review about Catwalk Couture being prejudiced? Really? That is not the experience I've had at Catwalk Couture- and trust me my friends and I are as black and brown as they come. I value this store to purchase my high-end merchandise. I will ALWAYS give Catwalk a five star rating, until they give me reasons not to.

Absolutely beautiful high quality merchandise... Women's clothing, jewelry, accessories. Really…read morenice friendly outgoing sales people who were there and happy to help you. I go at least once a week to see what's new, with my two little terrier dogs who are most welcome to visit.

I absolutely LOVE this place! The clothes are super stylish, high quality and affordable as well as…read morebeing displayed in a way that makes shopping enjoyable. The staff members are also friendly and approachable. Especially, Kayleigh, who was extremely professional and helped me find the PERFECT outfit. DJ Hart is without a doubt one of the BEST hidden gems in Sag harbor!

Brought in an item I purchased at the store to be resold as consignment and owner claimed I did not…read morepurchase there. Basically said I was not being truthful. As an owner especially, you should not treat a customer in this manner, ever. Do not waste or bother going to this place.

This truly is a vintage store. That being said, do not come here expecting to pick up cheap basics…read moreor anything like that. You can tell the owners truly care to find high-quality, unique pieces. I picked up an embroidered top and told my friend that I thought it was cute. One of the ladies working overheard me and rushed to the back to find the cutest, vintage embroidered jacket for me. If only it had fit me and was not $245. They told us that all the prices could be negotiated, even the clothes that were already discounted. The ladies working here really made this place special. If you are looking for something, they will help you find it. They also told us that they are putting new items on the floor every day. There was also a large assortment of designer pieces, such as Chanel and Louis Vuitton. This store is definitely more catered toward people that can afford to live/vacation in the Hamptons, not a college student who happened to wander in. But if that's you, this place is a must-go.

Thanks to my mom I've been to many antique & vintage shops BUT none have looked as cool as this…read moreplace. This spot was a bit out of the way for me however the town is so nice we made a day trip of exploring the north fork. Being a fan of Ricky Teevees designs, this was a must go! This place is huge, the layout is fabulous. We went on a Sunday afternoon and it was rather busy. The displays of everything are perfect & the space feels very lived in. Price wise this spot is up there however it's real vintage stuff. I didn't need any help however the staff seemed nice and played some good music :)

The Times Vintage Shop is an amazing find for anyone who loves vintage. The vibe leans heavily into…read morethe 60s and 70s, with a cool retro kitchen setup in the back that adds to the charm. There are lots of clothing options, plus an impressive selection of records to dig through. Every area feels thoughtfully curated, making it a spot you can easily spend a long time exploring. We will post more travel guides, photos, and videos from our Greenport trip and other locations at https://ourownpathtravel.com and on YouTube at https://www.youtube.com/@OurOwnPath

Organic Chicken Salad! Par baked bread! Grab a latte and sit on the back desk overlooking the…read moreharbor hike enjoying the best B.E.C. on a baguette you will ever have in your life. Text your order ahead.

PRICEY PRICEY PRICEY! BUT some fabulous clothing and mostly high quality. I bought two blouses made…read moreof Indian cotton, overpriced but unique and fun. They have some gorgeous imported slipper type shoes with beading and sequence but they are not comfortable for me. The staff is helpful and friendly - not snotty like one might suspect in such a high-end boutique. But most of the clothing is super-casual. I know that anytime I visit the Island, I am going to get into trouble here!

Homespun is a fantastic little store. Beautiful dresses, wonderful children's clothing /toys and…read morenice greeting cards. Elizabeth, the owner, is lovely. She is such a pleasure to deal with! Highly recommend Homespun!

Very varied selection of gifts and notions. Nice selection of books and clothing and fabulous gifts.read more

Great little souvenir shop in the heart of Montauk. Tasteful…read moresouvenirs to enjoy when you return home from your vacation Friendly helpful staff

It was okay, very small selection for young men and sizes. Hopefully, as the season progresses the…read moreinventory improves. Wishing them a great summer.