I hired Wayne at the Bathtub Medic to refinish a bathtub and replace the drain at a rental house. Even though this was an old tub, the porcelain finish was still very good (pic attached), but the area around the drain was rusted. Wayne assured me the bathtub would look "like new" when he was done.
The day after Wayne did the work, I received the invoice by email. I texted the tenants to ask them how the tub had turned out. They said the drain looked good, but there were some other issues, so I asked them to send me some pictures. On the pictures, I could see there were dark areas where the finish looked too thin. There were also some pinholes in the finish, some overspray on the floor, and a small piece of the flooring had been pulled up (so water could now get under the flooring). I contacted Wayne about the situation and sent him the photos. He said he would take care of the problems, but it would be about a month before he could get back out to do it. I said that was fine.
A few weeks later, I sent Wayne an email asking when he would be out to do the repairs because I wanted to get him paid. He then became a totally different person. He hadn't realized that I hadn't paid him yet, so he started insinuating that I was not going to pay him. (This bathtub was the second bathtub Wayne had refinished for me. I paid him for the first job immediately after the job was completed, even though he said I could wait for an invoice, so he had no reason to think I wouldn't pay). He was insulting and condescending, and he kept calling my tenants liars. He even told my tenants that I "was refusing to pay him a penny until the job was perfect" (so unprofessional). I kept explaining to him that I just wanted the job finished before I paid him, but he kept wanting me to pay him before it was done. He indicated that I needed to stop complaining and just pay the bill in full. He told me there was a 5 year warranty, but I told him that if I couldn't even get him to finish the job immediately after doing the work, what would make me think he would do it 5 years from now? He said that since the work was only cosmetic, he didn't consider it a high priority.
He did end up coming out to do the repairs, but he did not attempt to fix the floor, and some of the overspray and dark areas still remained. There was also a new scrape left in the finish. He also did not fix the pinholes because "rather than air brush them, which I thought would have left a bigger footprint and been a worse outcome, I left them alone". He kept saying they were microscopic (which they are not - see pics).
I explained to Wayne that there were still some issues with the tub, and I told him I could meet him there the next time (he did not get along with the tenant, a woman in her 70s). He asked if I could get some glue and fix the floor myself, and said he would send us a vial of touch-up paint for us to touch up the finish. He was still very accusatory and insulting. He eventually said he would come back only with the understanding that when he was done, we would need to sign a statement saying that the finished job was acceptable, and that I would not make any negative reviews on social media. He said if he could not get final approval (and accept the job as is), he would scuff up the surface and scrape off the coating around the drain, and remove the new drain he had installed.
After careful consideration, I decided not to allow Wayne to come back to the house for the repairs. He seemed very angry, and his accusations and insults to me and my tenants, plus his threats to my property, did not make me feel comfortable enough to allow him to come back. I went ahead and mailed him a check for the entire amount of the invoice.
I have noticed that the Bathtub Medic does have some good reviews, but I can't help but wonder if there are people whose jobs did not turn out well, and they were pressured into not leaving a bad review on social media to try to get their bathtub fixed, or decided not to pay him. He told me that he would rather me not pay him than to leave a bad review, but I was not trying to get something for free (like he accused me of); I just wanted what I was paying for. read more