Came in for a few beers since I was eating elsewhere. They have a small but good selection of beers. The pizza smelled very good and the bartender was friendly and attentive. Good place to stop if you're in the area. read more

See all

Great pizza for a great prize. A large pizza under 20 bucks nowadays is a good deal! I like supporting this business because they give back to their community. There are some really cool memorabilia inside. Check out the John Cougar Mellencamp T-shirt... I did a takeout order. It took about 20 minutes to get my pizza. I would suggest calling your order in so you don't have to wait when you get there. read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

The pizza was great. A bit crispier it would be fantastic. Homemade Root Beer is great as well.

Great ownership, great atmosphere, great service. Perfect combination of high quality beer made in house and pizzas with a good balance of traditional and adventurous topping options. read more

I was quite pleased with the pizza here. I'm originally from New Jersey, so I know great pizza and honestly, when I came here with a business associate, I was not expecting the pizza to be as good as it was. I must say that I was pleasantly surprised. The place was nothing fancy in twems of ambiance, but it was pleasant enough and really, there is nothing fancy about pizza. The service was also friendly and professional. All in all, I would definitely recommend here. read more

Can't say enough about how great this place is. Excellent pizza and really good beers. We live about 40 minutes away and make the trek often. The wait staff is friendly and attentive. Consistently great pizza. Limited number of tasty brews. We love this place! Yes it is a little purple in here. Happens to be the school color of the local high school. read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - Half meatza and half cheese funk. Too hungry to take the pic earlier. This pie is awesome but is even better the next day! - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

Great place located in a neighborhood mixed with businesses and homes. I had baked spaghetti, which I had never had before. It had a layer of baked cheese on top. I ate it all, even though I was full. Their garlic bread sticks are fantastic. They're brushed with butter and baked with garlic salt. I had a mixed green salad, which was one of the freshest salads I've had. Our friends had pizza, and barbecue chicken wings. If you're ever in Seymour, Indiana, this is a great place to visit. If you're cruising i-65, it's worth your time to get off the interstate and treat yourself. read more

See all

The pizza, breadsticks, and calzones cannot be beat!! They are delicious and usually ready in a timely manner. Service is always excellent! We usually do carry out just to give our kids a chance to wiggle around while eating a little more. read more

ABSOLUTELY PERFECT PIZZA! Not too thick and not too thin, and we love the cornmeal on the crust. The cheese is really flavorful and the sweet sauce is so good! Also super nice staff! We will definitely be back! read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - SO GOOD!!! Half cheese and half pepperoni. - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

Thankful to have a good pizza spot on the east end of Seymour. Very convenient for takeout, but have also eaten inside too. There is a 21+ only side with a bar and also a family room, which is where you place your order at the counter. Paper plates and silverware make for a casual dining experience and easy cleanup. Owner and staff is very nice & personable. They also have a spot for outdoor music. Bonus perks: get their punch card rewards to earn a free pizza, and also sign up for their texts to get deals :) read more

The specialty pizzas have great flavor, while the ambiance is superb with the musical talent they have stop by! The service has always been great and speedy! read more

Guys seriously... Don't walk, RUN to Brooklyn! It is an absolute GEM! The pizza is amazing, the atmosphere is unbeatable. Every time we are in the area we come at least once. The "standard" flavors are always a smash (veggie and meatza always hit the spot) and the unusual ones are even better (funky chicken and the one with chorizo) are some of the best pizzas I've ever had. read more

Absolutely amazing food and beer. We tried the spicy mutha clucka and it did not disappoint. We will definitely be back next time we're in town. Everyone was also so friendly and wonderful. read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - Spicy Mutha Clucka - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

I love this place EXCEPT for the canned mushrooms. You can ask for fresh mushrooms, but why bother because half the time either the server/bartender doesn't hear you or the kitchen screws it up. I wish they would just get rid of the canned mushrooms and raise prices. Other than that, this place is one of my favorites in the area, including Madison and Scottsburg. Be sure and double check the hours. Like any small business, the hours change frequently. Great pizza (except those mushrooms) and great beer! Live music often. read more

Amazing food and great service and by far the friendliest people you will ever meet. They can fix any kind of pizza you want if you haven't tried them please do. read more

Driving through Indiana looking for some pizza for dinner. Found this one and decided to give it a try. It's about 4 miles off the interstate but the food was worth it. Pizza came out great and hot. The staff were friendly and fast. read more

Good pizza done well! Nice folks but no delivery. Try the calzone. Nice outdoor space with summer live entertainment.

Malone is a great owner, promoter and chef. The beer, wings and music were great! A must stop if in Seymour...

If I lived in Seymour, I would visit the Brooklyn Pizza Co. a whole lot more often. You get such a cool vibe from the place from the moment you step inside. There's a family side and a bar side (that is getting larger with some recent construction). A plethora of artwork showcasing local buildings and landmarks line the walls (most from local artist / shop owner Kevin Greene) which give it a "connected community" feel. I particularly liked the fenced in outside sitting area that faces the street out front. On the side of the restaurant is a stage on an empty grass lot where local bands will play on the weekends all summer long. Lastly, I have to mention the sole unisex bathroom . . . it was hip (with album covers on the walls) and clean. I judge a lot of restaurants on how their bathroom looks, smells, etc. A+ on the WC. The bread sticks and pizza were excellent (especially compared to the local chain competition). Some locals say it's the best pizza in town. The locally brewed beer (next door) by seasoned brewer Ritch Mettert of The Seymour Brewing Co. was fantastic. The Oatmeal Stout was malty with hints of chocolate but not heavy like some stouts can be. Very drinkable and not too filling. The owner (Shawn Malone) came out on the patio to say "Hi" to our group and thanked us for stopping by. I like that. I REALLY like that. We need more of that in this world everywhere. :) Nice work on the place, Shawn. https://www.facebook.com/The-Seymour-Brewing-Company-1609705355737033/ read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

I came across this place while in town for the IHSAA 4A Sectional. Really close to the high school which makes it convenient for post game. You order and pay at the counter and they bring the food out to you. I was pleasantly surprised with the quickness the pie was brought to us. The pie was thicker than I anticipated, even though we ordered the thin. I'm not sure if it was, but the crust reminded me of a cornmeal crust, which is a great thing! The sauce was very good and the toppings were plentiful. My only negative is that all they had as fountain drinks were coke and Diet Coke, the rest were bottled drinks. But that's a minor thing. read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

They deliver to the hotel, which was nice, and the prices were decent. I had the stromboli and the Schmiddty. Both were good enough to eat, but they were delivered a little beat up after being wrapped in foil. If I had to choose between running out for a $5 ready-made pizza or this one, I'd definitely be ordering again. read more

We picked up pizza and a calzone on our way through town. It was so delicious. My sons loved the root beer too.

Súper good! :) a mis hijos les gusto mucha la pizza de hay. Me dijieron que si quisieran ir nuevamente

Best pizza around,forget going to a national chain,come here for great pizza,calzones, craft beef and live music.

Pizza is fantastic! Ingredients are top quality. Cheese sauce is tasty! Owners are awesome! Live music on occasion. Brewery right there! Who could ask for more! Local is always the best choice for dining out! read more

Was very surprised. It a brewery also. Small batches . Great beer. Oh the pizza is damn good also. The staff are very nice . Good people. I will definitely be coming back here when I'm in the area . read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - This place is a brewery also - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

I've been here a lot over the last 10 years and I've never had a bad experience. Always generous with topping and great flavors and variety. My personal favorite is The Bo, which uses Alfredo sauce. Calzones and sandwiches are also delicious and extensive. The breadsticks are my favorite from any pizza place and are delicious whether you get them in the restaurant or to go. I always get garlic sauce and cheese with them. There's also a brewery attached, so it's a one-stop-shop for food and craft beer! read more

Great small town pizza joint with the absolute best pizza and wonderful owners that are very passionate about their business and customers!

Best pizza in Seymour. Calzons are great. Outdoor, park like, setting and live music.

We have ordered this pizza to our office a few times since we came to Seymour. We love the variety of options from salad, breadsticks, cheese sticks, and pizza! The price is affordable, the pizza is great, the cheese sticks I dream about, and delivery is awesome! We have their menu on our office fridge! We will continue to order, great food and service! read more

Stopped in on our way home to Indianapolis and what a great find! Great NY style pizza and breadsticks! Shawn the owner was awesome and accommodating! We will be back! read more

This pizza is terrible. They skimped on the meat and sauce. You would get more toppings from a $5 pizza from Walmart and it would taste better. read more

The breadsticks and sauce are delicious! Good taste to the pizza and they do NOT skimp on toppings. Got delivery twice and everything was still nice and hot each time. read more

The quality of the food and craft beer at Brooklyn Pizza is excellent. The atmosphere and staff is wonderful with excellent service. They take pride in everything that they do and it shows. They use premium ingredients and the proof is in the taste. Unfortunately after you get used to eating Brooklyn Pizza other competitors will taste bland, especially due to the blend of cheeses used at BPC. It is one of my favorite places!!! And if you feel like a pint the Seymour Brewing Company side can fill just about any desire with a rotating menu of craft beers with Reno Gold always on tap. read more

The pizza is fabulous! Love the ever changing beer selections. Music nights are amazing. The owner and staff are welcoming and awesome.

Very nice little place, I'm from Detroit so their pizza isn't comparable, but is good. Nice bar area full of locals and service was 5 star. Definitely go back. read more

Here's the thing: this place makes a tasty pie, mainly because they have their pizza crust squared away. Their pies manage to be thin-ish, yet still soft and nom-lishisly toothy. Their sauce is nothing special, nor is the cheese blend or toppings (though they're not bad - they're just not exceptional), but overall, their pizzas are head and shoulders above those from the usual suspects. Specialty pies aren't exactly special. And it's not cheap, though it's certainly competitive with other independent pizza makers. Location is in a mostly residential neighborhood in Seymour proper (not out by the interstate), and (at least if you're coming from the I65 side of town) a trip across badly graded and un-gated railroad tracks (yep, in the middle of a residential neighborhood). There is a fair amount of parking in the area, though it's not marked that one won't be towed. The dining area is very small and no frills - this is really more of a take-away place. And then only if you live nearby. The crust on a fresh cooked pie can't withstand more than about a 20 minute drive-time - just an fyi. Next time, I may ask whether they will do partially cooked pizzas for take-away for this reason...but when I'm local, their pizza is worth it. read more

We drove from Starve Hollow based on their Yelp reviews and were not disappointed! The breadsticks were amazing and their Detroit style deep dish pizza will have us coming back again. Added bonus is the Seymour Brewing Company attached to the restaurant. The owner was very engaging and informative. We loved everything about this place! read more

This place is great! Cool ambiance, friendly staff and the food rocks! If you're passing through, don't go hungry, eat here!! read more

The Brooklyn Pizza - The pies are HUGE and the art decor is so refreshing. - Pizza Near Me - Seymour, Indiana

I was in the mood for pizza while in Seymore Indiana and a few locals told me Brooklyn Pizza was the best in town. The restaurant is pretty small although I didn't look in the bar area which is separate and designated 21+. The spinach and ricotta calzone was delicious and even without it having any meat I was plenty full from it. Tip: the paper they serve the calzones on gets wet and starts shredding onto your food. Transfer it to a plate before eating. read more