Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

Pizza was very small for a large. Crust was not very good. Toppings were very skimped on. We…read morewon't be back. Idk why it's so hard to find good pizza in North Vernon. Somebody needs to make a New York style. Lady was nice during pickup, however she forgot my sauces until I was already to my car. Luckily she remembered before I drove away.

Great pizza and Love their Stromboli. Wings are delicious. Best customer service around. Delivey…read moreis spot on.

Top Crust Pizzeria

4.6(7 reviews)

2.8 mi

The Wings Were Amazing! The Pizza Was Hearty And Very Tasty!…read more There Is So Much Space And Seating, Approximately 15 Tables To Sit And Dine! They Opened At 4 And I Was Their First Customer, As I Was Waiting The Whole Parking Lot Filled Up! I Knew Then That I Was Purchasing Some Awesome Vitals!

Pizza is fantastic!! Takes a little time to get it but is way worth it!! Will definitely eat their…read morepizza again!

Veggie pizza with sausage

Menu

See all

Casey's

4.5(2 reviews)

1.6 mi

Nice local convenient open 24 hours a day gas station with a nice selection of snacks and…read morebeverages, the air and vacuum works perfect fine as well, the employees are very nice and helpful as well.

It didn't look like a lot but I was pretty hungry and it was about 9:00 in the morning so I decided…read moreI'd give it a try. Went in the cashier was extremely nice and I got one of their breakfast pizzas which was maybe one of the best gas station pizzas I have ever had. Great work. Keep it up

See all

Brittany's Brick Oven Pizza

4.9(102 reviews)

23.0 mi

Superb pizza and bread sticks! The small salad was of a generous portion and all the ingredients…read morewere fresh. The balsamic vinaigrette dressing tasted homemade. The restaurant was well staffed and all of the staff that serviced our table were extremely nice, attentive and friendly. Sweet and kind I'd say. The restaurant was busy with table seated guests and the staff was processing carry out orders efficiently. Quite possibly the best pizza this seasoned citizen has ever had! Excellent overall experience! Tidy and clean restaurant and bathroom too! A real delight!

"Brick Oven", I instantly know it'll be delicious. We got three separate personal pies, all…read moredelicious. Tons of toppings with the perfect crisp. And only $8-10 a pie! The breadsticks were okay, kinda plain but we still finished them! They have different featured desserts, and like 8 options. We struggled to decide but we got a chocolate cake (OMG YUM) and a peanut butter pie that was huge. Super cheap desserts, too! Small little place, but the staff were overly friendly. Just what we wanted and were looking for! Highly recommend. We were traveling through, but if I was local I would be here weekly.

Inside

Hungry as a bar of Pizza in the front. Gluten-free cheese pizza in the back

See all

Outside

North Vernon Pizza King

3.2(9 reviews)

2.5 mi

Definitely an interesting experience! The dining area is a bit cluttered and chaotic. The pizza was…read moregood! I'm from Muncie and pizza king there has a bit of a different style, but this was still good. The staff was very friendly.

Best local pizza that I have ever had. Staff is friendly, the food is always ready when we pull up…read moreto the window. And it's always fresh and delicious.

See all

Pizza Hut

3.6(8 reviews)

2.1 mi

Working in North Vernon, where I find myself several times a year. I was going to check out…read moreanother local pizza place but on the way I read some reviews that mentioned rudeness. Having had a rough day at work and not feeling up to dealing with rudeness I turned the other direction toward Pizza Hut, my usual NV dinner spot. I have always had good or great service here, occasionally outstanding service. The food is predictable Pizza Hut but actually quite tasty. It is always served hot and fresh, and somehow seems quite a bit better than expected from a pizza chain. This location is always clean and the service is fast. I have never been disappointed here. You could do much worse in NV than Pizza Hut, especially since the options are fairly limited to fast food. I also appreciate that Diet Dew is offered here. My favorite soda and not always easy to find in restaurants.

Never had any problems here, pizza is pretty good, breadsticks are great!…read more The pretzel crust is amazing!

See all

Hayden Hub

5.0(3 reviews)

7.0 mi

Great home style food. The store was clean and the prices were good. Definitely will be going back.read more

Great local spot for pizza! We got the super supreme and a cheese it was excellent- not "gas…read morestation pizza" hurriedly cranked out! Toppings were fresh, quality cheese, A+ pizza. Price was good, not as cheap as say a $5 pizza from one of the globocorp pizza chains but we definitely got what we paid for in terms of quality, quantity and taste. Friendly staff and good service all around!

See all

Papa Johns Pizza

2.4(5 reviews)

3.1 mi

I simply asked for ranch and the employee at the window look at me like I was stupid keep in mind…read morewe got 4 sets of wing and they gave us 1 thing of ranch the dude at the window walked away throwing his hands and giving me looks like I was stupid on his way back

General manager screamed at my legally blind husband for not being able to read a sign by the door…read moreabout only one customer at a time allowed in the store. The sign was written on white paper with a yellow highlighter. He came from behind the counter and out the door to scream at my legally blind one legged husband. Told us he wasn't going to give us our pizza or our money back. Had to call the credit card company to report fraud

The Brooklyn Pizza

4.6(82 reviews)

15.2 mi

Makes it easy to support locally owned businesses when the product itself is top-notch. Highly…read morerecommend!!

Great pizza for a great prize. A large pizza under 20 bucks nowadays is a good deal!…read more I like supporting this business because they give back to their community. There are some really cool memorabilia inside. Check out the John Cougar Mellencamp T-shirt... I did a takeout order. It took about 20 minutes to get my pizza. I would suggest calling your order in so you don't have to wait when you get there.

Spicy Mutha Clucka

See all

Menu February 2026

Pizza Palace

4.1(40 reviews)

15.1 mi

Good food and the place is laid back with good service. It would have gotten a 5 if they would have…read moretheir good beer selection back. That used to be our local go to place to try a variety of brews but lately it has been blah...hope they get the good beer back

The shape of the main dining area can cause it to be loud, but the food is consistent, flavorful…read moreand the service has been good everytime I have visited. Try the buffet to find what pizza/stromboli you like the most!

Pretzel with nacho cheese

Brew Link Ivory Stout Banana Cream Pie Nitro draft

See all

Pretzel

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

10 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Daniel F.

218

1

7 years ago

This is genuinely the best food I have ever in my life. The butter rum cheesecake made me cry. I went home and proposed to my girlfriend after this meal. I am willing to travel upwards of 10 hours to get to this food. I had a spiritual journey after eating Lakeside Pizza. My soul left me and ascended into the cosmos as I became a celestial body. read more

Michelle G.

0

3

0

11 years ago

Hands down the BEST pizza I've ever had. Never a bad experience here. My fiancé and I always order separate pizzas on purpose so that we have leftovers. The owner is so kind and you can tell he loves what he does. The rest of the team does a very good job as well. If you haven't tried this place your really missing out! read more

Melanie G.

0

1

0

8 years ago

My family and I have been here several times and have never been disappointed! We order the trainmaster pizza and it is awesome. The pizzas don't take much time to cook at all. This is definitely the best pizza I've ever had. They also serve desserts, and the homemade ice cream is great, too! read more

Michael D.

0

1

0

8 years ago

This place was amazing. Big fan. Used to go all the time but haven't been able to up until last week. Felt it was finally time to leave a review. Again, great pizza, amazing Home made ice cream. BIG FAN. read more

Steve H.

2

5

0

10 years ago

THIS is real pizza! Made the way pizza should be made. Fresh ingredients. Friendly staff and a great location. Do not miss this place!!!

Bob G.

0

2

0

4 years ago

Great home town place. It's nice to visit a local owner place where of the owner has put their heart and soul into the business.

Bob H.

0

3

0

9 years ago

Great place, nice people, super pizza. We will be back. Small business at its best. Real wood fired pizza oven.

Shanon S.

0

5

0

12 years ago

Awesome pizza! Need lower chairs! Their chairs are not very family friendly. No big deal. Love them!

Bob M.

0

8

1

9 years ago

Employs closet racists. Avoid if hungry while black. Not worth the hassle.

J. J.

0

1

0

12 years ago

They hire registered sex offenders!

Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Things to Do near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Desserts near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Restaurants near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Breakfast near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Bars near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Fast Food near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Shopping near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Thrift Stores near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

BEST of North Vernon, Indiana Seafood near Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza

People found Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza by searching for…

Restaurants in North Vernon, IN

New Restaurants in North Vernon, IN

Wood Fired Pizza in North Vernon, IN

Wood Oven Pizza in North Vernon, IN

Lunch in North Vernon, IN

Ice Cream in North Vernon, IN

Sandwiches in North Vernon, IN

Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt in North Vernon, IN

Lunch Specials in North Vernon, IN

Brick Oven Pizza Restaurants in North Vernon, IN

Pizza Deals in North Vernon, IN

Dog Friendly Restaurants in North Vernon, IN

Kid Friendly Restaurant in North Vernon, IN

Barbeque in North Vernon, IN

Romantic Restaurant in North Vernon, IN

Gluten Free Pizza in North Vernon, IN

Margherita Pizza in North Vernon, IN

Frozen Food in North Vernon, IN

Lunch Takeout in North Vernon, IN

Casual in North Vernon, IN

Menu in North Vernon, IN

Detroit Style Pizza in North Vernon, IN

Mushrooms in North Vernon, IN

Hole in the Wall Restaurants in North Vernon, IN

Best of North Vernon

Things to do in North Vernon

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Lakeside Wood Fire Pizza also viewed

Pizza Palace

4.1

(40 reviews)

Good food and the place is laid back with good service. It would have gotten a 5 if they would have…read moretheir good beer selection back. That used to be our local go to place to try a variety of brews but lately it has been blah...hope they get the good beer back

The shape of the main dining area can cause it to be loud, but the food is consistent, flavorful…read moreand the service has been good everytime I have visited. Try the buffet to find what pizza/stromboli you like the most!

Greek's Pizzeria Columbus

3.6

(51 reviews)

The food was amazing!! And the service was awesome the guy up front was very kind and nice!!read more

Just came under new ownership. Pizza was fantastic! The service did leave a bit to be desired, and…read morethe small amount of pepperoni are the only reasons this isn't 5 stars. Hopefully they can keep this consistency

The Brooklyn Pizza

4.6

(82 reviews)

Makes it easy to support locally owned businesses when the product itself is top-notch. Highly…read morerecommend!!

Great pizza for a great prize. A large pizza under 20 bucks nowadays is a good deal!…read more I like supporting this business because they give back to their community. There are some really cool memorabilia inside. Check out the John Cougar Mellencamp T-shirt... I did a takeout order. It took about 20 minutes to get my pizza. I would suggest calling your order in so you don't have to wait when you get there.

Blondie's Pizzeria & Pub

4.4

(12 reviews)

Another hidden gem. Pizza was cheesy and hot. Hit the spot. We will definitely make this a go to…read morespot when in the area.

Pizza was hard and over cooked. Service was slow for being 3 in the afternoon. Good location.read more

Carlos Pizza

4.4

(18 reviews)

Love this place !!! no surprises just consistent great quality food ever time…read more Been eating here since the 1980's if I remember correctly Best Italian restaurant in Columbus with reasonable prices a good selection on their menu don't pass up this place

We were craving pizza but didn't want a whole pizza so we visited Carlos for lunch…read more We ordered the combo of a slice, two breadsticks and a drink. Great deal if you ask me. We upgraded to large drinks and still came out under $20. We got a cheese slice. A deluxe slice. Some regular and some pepperoni breadsticks. And of course had to get some cheese sauce. I love a good cheese pizza and it definitely delivered. The pepperoni breadsticks are my favorite. We believe this place deserves so much more business, but the town either doesn't know or isn't willing to walk in to get it. It is soo good. Way better than its neighbor mother bears. The mall is sadly a wasted space for this restaurant as the city/ hospital seems to have ruined the charm of the entire mall. Hopefully people will visit and keep it here as it very much deserves to be kept alive. We will gladly be back over and over.

Pizzalicious

3.8

(34 reviews)

I used to live in Westport and I couldn't wait to have their pizza and Stromboli! I've been gone…read moreover 20 years! It tasted just as I remembered it!DELICIOUS!!! The difference is definitely in their sauce. I don't know what they do but it is definitely a step above any other pizza sauce I've ever had! Steak Stromboli... Pizza sauce and mushrooms! It is so good! So glad we got to stop in and enjoy one of our old favorites. It's so much larger inside now. They bought the area next to it and opened it up to a big dining area. It was very clean and would be a great spot to join friends.

Food was terrible. They didn't have our order in the computer when we walked in. Workers were rude…read more Pizza was greasy and gross. Wouldn't wish anyone this pizza on there death bed

Noble Roman's Pizza - West

4.3

(18 reviews)

Throwback to my teens! Same quality and delicious pizza exactly as I recall. Service was excellent…read more Ambiance is how I remember Noble Romans. Do yourself a favor and dine- in!

We visited Noble Roman's recently we wanted pizza and had not had Noble Roman's in forever…read more Truthfully we forgot we had one on the west side of town as I had always visited the one in town that has since been torn down. The inside was very nostalgic and in hindsight we should have taken pictures. The two guys working were both friendly and helpful. The place was clean. As for the food. It was fantastic and just what we were hoping for. We got a plain pepperoni pizza, a personal pan of the works and an order of breadsticks and cheese (of course). All were hot and tasty. The breadsticks stood no chance and we had them basically all gone before our pizza showed up. Hopefully we can keep it in our mind to come back. As we enjoyed it. We will intend to do so.

Mancino's Pizza & Grinders

3.7

(57 reviews)

For the best sandwiches and pizza in Columbus Indiana you must visit Mancino's. Great food and…read moregreat service. Plenty of room inside and parking is no problem. Pictured is a half ham and cheese grinder. Delicious !!

Food is always delicious, service is great, nice & clean always, waiters are always nice &…read moreefficient We love JoAnn England‼‼‼

Mother Bear's Pizza Columbus

4.1

(38 reviews)

I used to frequent this place on trips to Bloomington. I no longer get that way particularly often,…read moreso I was thrilled to hear that Columbus now has a location. And this Columbus location retains everything I love about the Bloomington one. And parking is easier than in Bloomington. I love this place, particularly the breadsticks. Their early bird special is also a terrific deal. Highly recommended.

The pizza was good. Service was pretty quick. At first I was worried due the pizzas being little…read moresmaller that it wouldn't be enough. However they offered a meal deal and honestly both pizzas was plenty. Overall feel of the place was welcoming. I loved the idea of people singing the wall. We didn't dine in we took home to watch fireworks. However I feel it would been a positive experience due to how attentive the staff was. I forgot to mention this was less than an hour before closing time and they was so nice. I asked if it was too late to order and they acted surprised. So customer service 10

Eddie's Lakeview Pizza

3.7

(42 reviews)