Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Cellar Lumber Company

    4.5 (4 reviews)
    Closed 7:30 am - 4:00 pm

    Services - The Cellar Lumber Company

    Siding installation

    Siding repair

    Siding replacement

    The Cellar Lumber Company Photos

    You might also consider

    More like The Cellar Lumber Company

    Recommended Reviews - The Cellar Lumber Company

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Thomas C.
    20
    51
    22

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - The Cellar Lumber Company

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Building Supplies 610 times last month within 25 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Newman Roofing - The Newman Family

    Newman Roofing

    (26 reviews)

    Of the roofers I contacted, they were the only ones that communicated consistently…read more They were here a few minutes early for both the estimate and repair. They sent a drone to do the high-level roof inspection, then went up to look at the area they suspected was the problem before giving me the estimate. The work was done quickly and they showed me pictures of each step when they were done. They seem to have a very sound scheduling and communication process. The price was reasonable as well.

    Newman Roofing has less of a Yelp presence than on other sites. My kid had a leaky roof and was…read morewading through all the options. You've seen the circulars and the signs in yards. But is the company reputable? And do you really want to go with a relatively new company even if is owned by your buddy. He decided, no. Newman is competitive with hundreds of 5 star reviews. He went with Newman. Subsequently we had a hail storm and neighbors were advising us to get our roof checked out. Our roof was 20 years old. I wanted to be honest with the insurance company and not submit a claim unless Tyler from Newman,who came out to give us an estimate, was sure we needed a new roof and we suffered damage beyond normal wear and tear. Plus we had 2 houses. Well one needed a new roof and the other one likely has another couple of years left. As an aside, if you turn in a claim to your insurance company, even if it is denied, you risk higher premiums or cancelation. That is why it is important to have Newman Roofing spend time assessing. In our case, our roof was more wear and tear with minimal hail. Dan and his guys were on time, even early. Weather has consistently been in the mid 90's. I was worried. But Newman keeps them well supplied with hydration. 14 man crew meant lots of vehicles, even a dump truck but they were minimally disruptive to our neighbors. Furniture moved, netting put up to minimize construction mess on house and garden areas. And then they went to work. All I can say is WOW. I am so pleased. When they were finished, the cleaned up all the mess, including using a magnetized thing for nails in driveway, patio and grass. The yard, the patio, the driveway, the porches are SPOTLESS. I highly highly highly recommend Newman Roofing. They did my kid's. They did this roof and in 2 years they will do our other roof. Price is good too.

    The Architectural Products Company

    The Architectural Products Company

    (26 reviews)

    I hired Apco for deck and patio. It took them over a year to complete the project and even at the…read morecompletion of the project and my vocalization of my unhappiness with the patio, they were willing to reimburse me $300. Despite the patio not being treated before winter, then when they did come out it was a terrible finish and another company corrected. The patio is not level in a couple areas and the custom stamp and cuts they made in the patio were not lifted up causing a bubble like look. Also, while completing the project, I called in numerous times to complain, I would have people come out at the end, but after several services calls and nothing accomplished, I finally stopped fighting and said I would leave a review. So there's my reviewMy patio was never finished properly and it makes me very sad as I spent $53,000 so be very careful when hiring the correct pick for your outdoor patio.

    Buyer beware. If I could give zero stars that would be more appropriate. They are a horrible,…read moreterrible company filled with people who don't know what they are doing and don't seem to care. They have been given there trys to do a gutter system correctly on my home and I finally turned to another company to get it done properly even though the repair was still under warranty. That's how much I do not trust them. Then they showed up at my neighbor's today and without permission used my driveway as a dumping ground for debris. They took the debris away but left a dirty filthy mess and lots of rusty nails for me to contend with. The guy I tried to talk to on the job site was belligerent and would not stop using my property when asked to do so. I probably had every right to call authorities. I will report them to the appropriate consumer watch dog agency. DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY.

    Benchmark Roofing & Restoration - Dublin Ohio Roof Replacement

    Benchmark Roofing & Restoration

    (17 reviews)

    Beware of this company I had to report them to the better business bureau for a couple of reasons…read more They were assigned to my insurance claim to have my house repaired in a time of need. I remember vividly me and my adjuster reached out to them multiple times for two months with no response even though they have been assigned to this claim, after no response, me and my adjuster decided to report them to the insurance company only after we reported them to the insurance company they started responding to us after a two month delay. I decided I did not want to move forward with them for repairs because of this, And had to seek out a new construction company to do the repairs. I do not recommend this company at all if you're looking for a company that is responsive, professional, or with integrity.

    Consumers & Insurance Companies, beware!…read more We entered contract with Benchmark on January 11th, 2022 after experiencing water loss from a faulty bathroom faucet on December 14th, 2021. Our contract was signed with Benchmark for $14,795.78 to perform work including flooring, drywall repair, painting, vanity replacement, etc. Benchmark's contract in the bottom right hand corner includes insurance work addendums which were not filled out by the project manager, were not orally disclosed to us by the project manager nor did we as home owners initial or sign to the terms. It is important to note that we were referred to Benchmark by our insurance company and were not required to utilize this company but elected to. (All loss dollars were paid directly to us and were instructed we could hire any contractor we chose to.) Upon work completion in April payment was made to Benchmark in full. Unbeknown to us, Benchmark filed a supplement for additional work they claim to have completed in our home that was not included in the estimate for $2,327.37. After several written communications back and forth with the company owner, our adjustor was included. It was discovered that Benchmark furthermore did not updated the insurance estimate to include the real costs of materials used for repairs. This includes hundreds of dollars saved on a vanity/countertop and thousands of dollars saved by the hard wood flooring we selected being on close out. In addition, we were "required" by Benchmark to work with Rite Rug flooring. During this process, we replaced the additional carpet and flooring in our home in order for all rooms to match. We learned that Rite Rug adds around 20% of the invoice when working with Benchmark due to this being insurance work. Benchmark refuses to acknowledge this as true though the invoices once migrated to our names directly were around 20% lower and essentially mirrored what our neighbor had just paid a few weeks earlier for the same material and square footage. From our insurance adjustor's perspective, this dispute became between us as consumers and the contractor. Several emails from the owner included the language "we will move forward" with the assumption that they would file a mechanics lien on our property. The supplement has been paid to them at this time as we work with the Ohio Attorney General and the Ohio Department of Insurance Fraud & Enforcement Division. Hundreds if not thousands of dollars related to this claim belong to consumers or insurance companies related to this claim, not this contractor. Consumers are price gauged via increasing insurance rates from these types of poor unethical behaviors. Consider hiring a different contractor to perform your work.

    The Cellar Lumber Company - buildingsupplies - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...