The Garrity Agency

1.0 (1 review)

Insurance

Open • 8:30 am - 5:30 pm

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

The Garrity Agency Photos

The Garrity Agency - Third Generation Agency Owners Sean Garrity and Caitlynne Laird - Insurance Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

The Garrity Agency - Insurance Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

The Garrity Agency - Second Generation Agency Owners Douglas Garrity and Gregory Garrity - Insurance Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

The Garrity Agency - The Garrity Agency Staff - Insurance Near Me - Carlisle, Pennsylvania

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - The Garrity Agency

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Him A.

3 years ago

Caitlynne Laird was very unprofessional had an attitude didn't want to assist and answer questions that I had asked and hung up the phone mid conversation. When I called back Sean Garrity kept telling me they weren't going to waste their time and didn't want to give me her Information or the presidents number gave me a fictitious number to call so I could file a complaint and wouldn't be of any assistance. I would not recommend this insurance agency to anyone due to their attitude and unwillingness to help so we know that will transfer to everyone if "they don't want to waste their time with this " in any situation . Use State Farm they are way better. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about The Garrity Agency

1786 Newville Rd
Carlisle, PA 17013
Directions
(717) 243-3467
Call Now
Visit Website
https://www.garrityagency.com

From the Business

Specialties

We strive to examine each client's individual situation to meet their insurance needs. The agency consists of fully-licensed, second and third-generation agents. Our agents take the time to review coverage so that customers understand what coverage they have and how it will affect them in the event of a loss. We specialize in auto, home, life, and business insurance.

History

Established in 1955.

The Garrity Agency, LLC is a third-generation ERIE agency established in 1955 in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. The agency sells auto, home, life, and business insurance in Pennsylvania and Maryland. "I personally have been picking up the phone in my father's agency since I was about 8 years old. Insurance is not just a job, it is and has always been a way of life for us," says Douglas. The agency is located approximately three and a half miles west of Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on Route 641, just before the village of Plainfield, Pennsylvania.

More Info

Hours

Ask the Community - The Garrity Agency

Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

Verify this business for free

People searched for Insurance 106 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Deibler Insurance Associates

(1 review)

I moved from State Farm to Erie because of Deibler Insurance. Our neighbor had a homeowners claim…read moreand I was very impressed with the professionalism and efficiency of the claim adjustor and the process as a whole. She raved about how well Deibler's staff treated her during this stressful time. I called and asked for quotes and have been happy with them ever since.

From the owner: We are a full service Independent Agency providing Auto, Home, Life, Business, Health, Disability…read moreand employee benefit programs

Edward Jones - Financial Advisor: Michael Cornfield

(1 review)

We have worked with Mike since 2014. He has been a responsive and trusted financial advisor for our…read moreentire family to include our two sons, my father, and my sister. They chose Mike as their financial advisor based on our recommendations and success with Edward Jones. Mike and Shelley have created a welcoming and professional office in Carlisle, PA.

From the owner: During these uncertain times, we're here for you - ready to listen, support and navigate this…read moretogether. We care about your physical health and your financial health. Please reach out and see how we can help you. Edward Jones is an investment firm that believes your financial goals deserve a face to face conversation. We can help you prepare for retirement, save for education and be a tax-smart investor.

AAA Central Penn

(4 reviews)

Been a member for 10+years and their renewal process is terrible. Can not renew online using a…read morenumber of websites. Evidently various regions have their own site. Called local office and on hold for over 15 minutes. Guess AAA not too concerned with customer retention.

My Audi broke down on westbound PA Turnpike, west of Carlisle. We managed to get to the Blue…read moreMountain rest stop, where I called AAA for help. Three hours later AAA called me back and told me they can't service the Turnpike and to call the Turnpike Authority for help. So I did that and the PA Turnpike Authority took my call, told me AAA was lying (there is no prohibition on AAA servicing the Turnpike, they just don't like paying the tolls) and would call me a AAA-certified toe truck. A non-AAA tow truck came and I had to pay out of pocket for the tow. Just a really bad experience for AAA, who promised me separately they would look into the situation but so far nothing. Just leaving a note from my experience.

The Garrity Agency - insurance - Updated September 2026

People who viewed The Garrity Agency also viewed

Consumers Insurance Agency

3.5

(8 reviews)

I called this morning and was witness to a very unprofessional person who answered the phone. He…read morewas overtaking me and would not let me even ask the question that I called about. As someone who worked for the Army for almost 40 years, I had to work with all kinds of people but this was an immature and arrogant fellow. He proceeded to tell me about how long he has worked which was irrelevant to the situation. Don't waste your time with these people, I would not want them involved with my insurance in any way.

Alex was great! Very responsive. Helped me get an awesome quote for both renters and auto…read moreinsurance. Even referred someone else to the agency!m.

Michael Hanscom Tax and Financial Services

5.0

(1 review)

Mr Hanscom is all about customer service. It has been a really long time since I felt like a valued…read morecustomer like this. This was a welcomed surprise in this day and age. He is very knowledgeable and efficient. Did a great job and I highly recommend him for all your tax and financial needs!!! Tonia Miller

By The Book Accounting

3.0

(2 reviews)

Mistakes were made and they wouldn't redo my taxes, i had to pay over 2000.00 in fees and…read morecorrections. Horrible experience and the gentleman is nasty.

Mr. Gumbinger is a great accountant. He is very knowledgeable, has been doing taxes for many years…read moreand he spends a lot of time asking questions to get everything right for you. I've gone to him the past two years and am pleased with the service.

Capital Region Insurance Agency

5.0

(1 review)

I highly recommend them! Logan helped me and my wife and is very professional. He helped me save…read morelots of money! They are very easy to work with and have the best insurance. Contact them today!! I am very happy with Erie insurance. Thanks Logan!

Grunden

4.4

(7 reviews)

This will be my third year using Grunden for my taxes. I am a small business owner, so I really…read moreappreciate Jason's responsiveness, timely and accurate preparation of my taxes and the reasonable fees. Jason is fully functional with QuickBooks, which makes everything a breeze! Highly recommended.

Highly Recommend. My family and I receive great service…read morewhether it's my simple return or my parent's complex returns. Thanks, Jason!

Langan Financial Group

5.0

(1 review)

Bob and Alex were extremely knowledgeable, professional and welcoming. I recommend Langan Financial…read moreto everyone.

Griffith & Johnson PC

5.0

(1 review)

I had the pleasure of working with Bobbi Johnson. She is both professional and very personable,…read morewhich is a rare combination. I had what I consider to be a complex situation and she was able to help me with ease and in a way that I understood. I highly recommend this firm for both business and individual accounting services!

Keller Financial Group

5.0

(1 review)

Here are the people to go to for expert advice on taxes, retirement planning, business or personal…read morefinance. Dwayne Keller is a longtime friend of mine, but he was my tax advisor first. This guy has saved me SO MUCH MONEY and he is the most cheerful, upbeat, friendly, lucid bean counter you will ever meet. I get nothing if you call him except the satisfaction that I have given back to him a fraction of the value he has given me over the last 25 years, and the knowledge that you will benefit from my experience. Go for it!

Gieseler & Joyce Insurance Agency - Erie Insurance

5.0

(2 reviews)

Even though we live in Carlisle, we choose Gieseler and Joyce to handle our all our insurance…read morelines, truck, snowmobile, car, home, contractor insurance, we love the service and great information they provide. We just couldn't think of using anyone else.

We have been customers for 15 years. The team is very professional, friendly, resposive and…read moreprovides excellent service. Mark was always helpful with suggestions and we are very greateful to him for saving us money especially when our daughter became a new driver and had to be added to our policy. We know that with them we get the best rates. We have already recommended this team to our friends and would always recommend them to anyone.

The Garrity Agency