After a girls' weekend in Geneva on the Lake, we were looking for a great breakfast spot before heading home on Sunday morning. We came across The Little Pie Shop & Cafe and decided to give it a try and we are so glad we did! When we arrived, we were told there could be about an hour wait. A few of us weren't sure we wanted to wait, but we decided to stick it out. To our surprise, we were seated within about 15 minutes, and the friendly service started our visit off on a great note. I'm not a big breakfast person, so I ordered the BLT with potato chips, and it was delicious. The rest of my party ordered breakfast items, and everyone raved about their meals. The portions were generous, prices very reasonable and everyone agreed the food was excellent. The real star of our visit, though, was the pie! i ordered a slice of the strawberry rhubarb and it was absolutely fantastic. It was truly the highlight of the meal, and I honestly regret not ordering a whole pie to bring home. This place is exactly what you hope to find when traveling, a charming, local, mom-and-pop gem with delicious food, friendly service, and a welcoming atmosphere. I live over an hour away, and I would absolutely make the drive back just to visit The Little Pie Shop & Cafe. Don't leave without trying the pie! read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Strawberry rhubarb pie - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

See all

Such a cute place for breakfast and pies! Get there early by 10am there is a wait on Sunday morning. The biscuits and gravy were my favorite and the staff is very friendly. read more

See all

You can't go wrong with breakfast here + cozy vibe. They have all the usual selections. Good prices and friendly service. Haven't tried the pie, but you probably should! read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Veggie omelet + tots and wheat toast - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

See all

I'm obsessed with this little place. It's a new Geneva staple for me. The food was absolutely delicious nd it's so cute in here. I loved their banana crema pie, their soup and their breakfast. Will be back! read more

Everything about this diner is amazing, atmosphere, wait staff and the food is incredible and prices so well. Pie is one of the best I have ever eaten ...Dark Cherry - and warm fresh from the oven. Cannot go wrong. read more

Stopped by for breakfast while in the area for an event. Everything was made from scratch. Good coffee. Loved the sausage biscuits and gravy- huge serving. Another person in our party got the omelet and side of sausage- large patties. Poached eggs were cooked perfectly. Friendly and attentive service- mostly locals dining here. Got fantastic strawberry rhubarb and coconut cream pie to go. Definitely recommend if you're in the area between 6am-3pm daily. read more

See all

Friendly folks serving up generous portions at great prices. Stop in if you're in the area. read more

Amazing home cooked breakfast and small town charm. Quick service and friendly staff. Definitely a go to while in the area read more

See all

100% wonderful experience was fantastic. Place is well kept and very clean. not too busy. Everyone is very respectful. read more

See all

The food is delicious and cheep. It may look like it is very busy from the parking lot but when you get inside there is plenty of seating. Staff is friendly and service is quick. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Cinnamon roll - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

See all

I'm a diner girl, and the Little Pie shop is a diner after my own heart! Bonus points for being open on Monday... Anyway, I had an egg and cheese muffin sandwich with home fries and a coffee for just under $8! The potatoes were really good - soft and cut thick, sandwich was solid, and I ordered a giant French toast muffin and the apple caramel pie to go. The muffin was the surprise standout! It was really moist and tasted really good with cinnamon swirled in it! I enjoyed the pie, but I'd have to try some of their other varieties, I wasn't really picking up on the caramel. Counter and table service, and the staff knew people by name. So cute and a really solid, affordable breakfast. Also, super fast. read more

Casual breakfast spot with great pie I also loved the gravy on the chicken fried steak. Friendly staff and this will be my go to breakfast spot if I'm ever in Ashtabula. Quaint Americana perfection read more

See all

Good breakfast. Picked up a pie as well, it was delish. I had meat lovers omelet, wife had breakfast burrito. Good quantity. Quick coffee refills. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

Taylor is outstanding along with the food, service and pies!!! Try the eggs Benedict. it is amazing! Love this place!.

I was in the area for a few days, after reading the reviews, I had high expectations and decided to stop in here for breakfast on Thursday June 29, 2023 around 10:45. Service was ok, waited for at least 5 minutes before the waitress came over for drink orders. Ordered a waffle and a side of ham. The waffle had decent flavor but the texture was terrible, mushy and very flat. The side of ham left a lot to be desired. Guess I should have ordered pie for breakfast. I'd like to give them the benefit of the doubt and say maybe it was an off day, but I don't think I'll be rushing back next time I'm in town. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Waffle and side of ham - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

WOW!! I did not expect to get blown away by this place. I honestly have no idea how everything was made with such quality and value. The affordability alone had my jaw on the floor while the food was easily the best diner food I've ever had. Even the pancakes were somehow the best I've had. The strawberry rhubarb pie was phenomenal! All my friends and I left that place with a huge smile on our faces. Not to mention the owner was incredibly kind. So happy this kind of place exists at all! Loved the country fried steak. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - countryfried steak, rye bread, home fries - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

Were in the area to view the aurora. Stopped in here for breakfast based on reviews. Had one of the best breakfasts in a long time. Everything was perfectly prepared and very tasty. Coffee was good. Service was a little on the slow side, but the place was SUPER busy. They were very friendly & we didn't wait too long. Food was definitely worth the wait. Even though we were there for breakfast, we ended up getting dessert, because...PIE! The pies were amazing...how they get the crust that flaky is a wondrous mystery. We were going to order more pie to go, then decided against it so we didn't make ourselves feel terrible for the rest of the day. I would go back just for the pies, but the breakfast food was top notch, so there are even more reasons to return! read more

The best place ever for breakfast and lunch. The staff is amazing. It is clean and the service is top of the line. The absolute best value in the Geneva area. read more

sat at counter. Small and loud and cozy. Ordered clam chowder and a BLT combo: the chowder was thick and delicious, and might be the best clam chowder I've ever had, a judgment I don't make lightly: every spoonful of that thick soup was full of a complex taste. The BLT was merely very good. Coffee was okay. I had a slice of Dutch apple pie: it was remarkably good: somehow the crumbly top tasted like strudel. The entire meal cost $15.12 -- I was tempted to buy one of many pies I saw, and wished I could take the entire restaurant home with me. I left $20, and floated out to my car. Oh, and the service was so friendly I thought I'd been there before. If I had to choose my last meal I might just choose a soup and sandwich combo with a slice of pie from The Little Pie Shop & Café. read more

This is my little local breakfast stop!!! Very reasonable, delicious (get the red potatoes instead of hash browns!) Love it!!!!! I haven't had their pie yet sadly- but I cannot wait to post. My basic bitch breakfast - eggs, bacon, toast and red skin potatoes is $5.99! Love that it's a cheap, easy stop right close to where I live! read more

Came here for brunch, they close at 3pm. Ordered Western Omelette and corned beef hash. Generous serving and very reasonable, also had a small chat with the owner who was seating right next to us, very friendly as well as the staff. Small town feel. Of course we won't leave without trying their famous pies so many to choose from but we settled for the apple pie and strawberry rhubarb. They were amazing! Happy tummy! read more

See all

The idea of mixing breakfast and pies is a great one. Pittsburgh and one about 5-8 years ago in the Oakland/Bloomfield neighborhood (was it called Breakfast with Pie?). The breakfast was fine, but the pies were nothing to write home about. And when you have "pies" in the restaurants name, THAT is a fatal mistake. This place not only delivers the goods with their pie slices (or take a whole pie with you), but their breakfasts are also a standout. As many times as I've had corned beef hash and eggs, there was something in the taste of this one that truly set it apart. Red skin potatoes and four slices of rye toast made it all substantial enough to bypass lunch. The only downside was that neither of our first choices for pie were available for carry out. But when over a dozen pies are on the board, and you're partial to 80% of them, it's not a big deal. Great service to match everything else. Tip: they also mail whole pies read more

Food was delicious!! They were woefully understaffed in the kitchen, but the server came right out and said so and gave us an eta of when our food would be ready..... then kept us afloat in coffee and drinks...... it was def worth the wait... nothing fancy, just delicious, home cooked food! read more

Food and service was great. Great little place to have coffee. Their baked goods are great too. Everyone was nice friendly. Was a great experience will be back again. Prices were good not too high. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Very good food, service, and friendly staff. Cozy spot for a muffin or a large breakfast!! Coming back for sure!! - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

The best Fluffy Pancake the size of a plate, Senior egg omelet chocked full with ingredients and Chicken Fried Steak served up by Felicita for the best quality breakfast in town! read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Senior 2 egg omelet filled with bacon, cheddar and mushrooms - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

See all

Our family is visiting from Miami and we enjoyed the food so much we ate here every day. Everything is absolutely fantastic. Great service, great good and great prices. read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

Great breakfast stop! Plenty of locals but the staff made us out-of-towners feel welcome. Generous portions cooked to perfection; excellent fresh coffee. Two full breakfasts & 1 coffee for less than $12! We will be back when in the area! read more

Food is okay to mediocre. Severs are very nice. Took an hour and five minutes to get breakfast at 10:50 am on Saturday. It wasn't completely full, several empty tables. The owner was sitting at a table visiting with friends, and our sever told us (after we'd already been waiting 50 minutes) they only had 1 cook and one helper with no experience. So why's the person who is responsible for serving his customers sitting visiting while people are not being served? They should be courteous enough to tell people when they're being seated that they're going to have to wait over an hour to be served , let them decide in advance if they can invest that much time for 'okay' food. read more

Amazing food! We found this little gem by accident when we stayed at an Airbnb close to Geneva by the Lake. Huge selection of fresh pies baked daily sold by the slice or whole, you cannot go wrong. Great breakfasts and awesome coffee, freshly ground daily, reasonable prices and great service! All of their Omlettes can be made into a scramble and they even make their own hash browns! Yummo! We even drive 1 hr and 20 min each way for their pies when our pie cravings hit!! read more

This place is a total gem. It was packed on a Thursday morning with regulars when we went in today. The service was quick and friendly; the food was excellent. It's hard to mess up breakfast, but it's equally hard to make a really great breakfast. And they made a great breakfast. Fluffy eggs, juicy meats, crispy hash browns, and delicious sausage gravy. I can't say enough good things about this place. read more

Excellent pies!!!!! Ditch apple is our favorite! Breakfast is okay for a quick bite to eat but their pies get our vote!!!

If you like homemade pies, look no further. We stopped in for lunch and had an enjoyable meal, followed by some delicious pie. The place is very homey and it's clear that there is a huge following from local diners. read more

This place is so cute!!!! I went here on a breakfast date and it was my first time we were instantly welcomed with smiles from everyone the food was alright and you got a perfect amount and the pies were unforgettable delicious, the little pie shop is perfect for this restaurants name! read more

Oh I love the restaurant and their food but one of the waitresses was very rude to me so I won't go back there maybe later I will but not right now because I do not condone people to be rude to each other especially a waitress being rude to me because I was not rude to her and I find that very bad taste that they would keep her on and have her be rude to people that she supposed to be very nice to! read more

Since my last review 6 months ago, I visited twice for lunch. On the first occasion, my order was in error again (3rd time!). The second time, I waited at the counter to be acknowledged for 10 minutes as one server rolled napkins & silverware and the other ran around like a chicken with her head cut off. I finally gave up, left, & haven't returned since. I get the sense this is more of a hobby than a genuine attempt at running a restaurant. read more

Amazing breakfast and service. We come here every Sunday! Cheap too! The breakfast that cost us 5 dollars comes with 2 eggs bacon or sausage hash browns and toast! Best place for the best cheapest breakfast. read more

What a great breakfast spot, awesome prices and great food. The pancakes were amazing and the omelet was huge and packed with toppings.

Just was stopping in Ashtabula for a visit this place has amazing food, huge portions, home-style and great service! And scrumptious pie!!! read more

The Little Pie Shop & Cafe - Mushroom & Swiss omlette a short stack of pancakes and biscuits and gravy!! - Cafes Near Me - Ashtabula, Ohio

One of the better breakfast & lunch places in the area! Prices are exceptional! Food was Hot, served quickly, and perfect on the order. The waitress ALWAYS kept our coffee filled, and checked in on us frequently. They have several fresh fruit pies available every day. Took a slice home. Highly recommend! read more

The STUFFED FRENCH TOAST with a blueberry sauce that is not too sweet is to die for! Friendly staff, great prices and good food. What else can you ask for? Glad I live a mile away...check it out. read more