I like this place generally. I had chicken carbonara. Thinking try something different from wings and burgers. It was not my favourite. The noodles were chopped up. Everything stuck together like glue. The chicken, mushrooms, bacon and onions on there own tasted good. To much cheese. Sauce needed to be creamer. Traditional carbonara uses long strands (spaghetti, bucatini) that beautifully coat with the egg, cheese, and fat. Stick to burgers and beer here! read more

twas a Sunday on Father's Day, got to the pub around one and proceeded to wait 1 hour and 30 minutes for a BLT and a burger. Place seemed nice and food was decent but it was an awful experience. read more

Terrible food!! Expensive. A burger & a beer going to be $45 out the door. The burger wasn't even good. Slow! Don't go there hungry. Dinner is an hour wait. read more

The Mill House Pub is another Creemore staple, with tasty pub food and a bit of something for everyone on the menu. They also have a cute patio that's worth visiting in the summer. read more

The Old Mill House Pub - Chicken souvlaki and Greek salad - Pubs Near Me - Creemore, Ontario

Nice and comfortable pub when your in the middle on nowhere Ontario (joking) But when its really cold out its a nice place to warm up and get a beer, they have a decent selection from the Creemore Brewery but also from across Canada. PS - Try the sweet potato fries! read more

I've lived in Creemore for over 30 years and since this pub opened it has been great! The burgers are highly recommended, and the fish and chips are huge! if you're getting 2 fillets you better be hungry! Full bar selection and loads of craft beers (mostly Creemore). Thursday is half price wings and 5 dollar Creemore pints. It gets busy that night so get here early! Patio is open in the summer! read more

Food is okay it really hit or miss come here very often and sometime service and food are amazing but others it's horrible. Everything smell very clean and taken care off. It is normally very loud in here as it's pretty busy all the time. I do not recommend ordering take out as they normally forget something or run behind on take out order and is late by 30 minutes. read more

Had a fantastic dinner here on a Friday night. Fish and chips were amazing, the fish was delicious and the portions were generous. Waitress was also great. read more

A real pub. Best daught beer Great service Good food, very welcoming. Enjoy the patio in the summer. Clean environment. We will be back sooner then later read more

This was a quaint little place with pretty good food just a few steps from the Creemore Brewery. Pleasant service and pretty good food. There were too many flies inside the restaurant though that was very annoying. read more

The Old Mill House Pub - The beer I ordered. - Pubs Near Me - Creemore, Ontario

Decent sized portions with pub food that's well above average. The ambiance is welcoming and the staff is friendly. Came here on a recommendation and didn't regret it. read more

The Old Mill House Pub - Pubs Near Me - Creemore, Ontario

See all

I will report this to the public health department. In the meantime I want to warn others. Today I visited this pub and ordered the fish and chips. There was a maggot crawling in the middle of the plate. read more

We didn't plan on stopping by, but we needed a bite to eat after visiting the Creemore Springs brewery. Very simple decor, but it was busy and the staff was friendly and efficient. We had the Munchie Platter, which was just enough for the two of us to snack on. The mini risotto balls were a nice touch! And lots of sauces. Most places skimp, but not here. read more

This place is pretty good. Went here after visiting the Creemore Brewery. My partner and I ordered the 1lb of wings each. He had Mild sauce and I had plain. Our appetizers were the mozzarella sticks which actually came in short time and yet they were 5/5. Our server was Angela, I believe. She was great! She was talkative, made jokes with us, asked us what brought us to Creemore from Toronto and asked us to come again for their Thursday Wings special! When we got the chicken wings, it was delicious however I thought it was drier than I expected. Overall delicious and pretty big pieces too. Our server made sure we were always stocked up with wet wipes and plenty of napkins - especially for my partner who had the mild sauce. His mild sauce in particular was actually more 'hot' than a typical mild he's accustomed too...so I'm not sure what happened there...but overall he still enjoyed it and thought it was a place worth coming too. Also, if you're in the area on Thursday for a good chicken wings deal...come to this place! read more

Pub grub EXTRORDINARE...just gotta say that. The veggies served on the side as a "colour" for other pubs/restaurants are actually the first thing i eat on the plate they are that tasty! The Wings are the best this side of Buffalo (hint - Thursday Wing night is WAY busy) The Steak and Shrimp special on Weekends is a great deal. Ribs, Sandwiches...oh, and Fries are perfectly cooked (I like them brown with some skin), too good to cover with gravy, but go ahead. Enjoy it with a Creemore, or any of the fabulous craft brew selections OR try the Paddle Sample. Service is great, the staff are friendly and attentive. Covers all the bases! read more

The beer on tap was good as is should be, but ya like one of the the last guy said... The service is a bit slow. Brutally slow. Took like 45mins for a burger. So you'll be good & drunk if you keep ordering beers...lol. Not a big deal unless you got somewhere to go at a certain time!? So keep that in mind... Creemore downtown is really nice regardless. The food was really good! I had the Canadian eh! Burger very good! Gf had the wrap! Both very good, it's not the servers fault it was slow so don't be upset with her. read more

bizzy pub full of local drunks... and its not kid friendly small portions for high prices is what you pay. When you buy low grade product and charge for fine dinning prices its nowonder the drunks are the only ones who come. All they buy is pub food anyway. The wait staff look at you as a waste of time and would rather not have you there.may the new owner can mix it up and change things. Probably not they are all in it for profit nothing more . read more

Great burgers! Friendly staff and cool, pub environment. Reasonably priced! My wife and I stopped off in Creemore on way back to Toronto from Collingwood on a Sunday afternoon for a late lunch. Other places appeared to be closed or not open any longer for lunch so we went in to the pub as it had been recommended by a friend. Also, it was busy and that's always a good sign! The burgers and the fries are home-made! Nice to find a place that still does that and the quality shows. Will definitely return!! read more

Stopped in for a quick lunch before heading to Collingwood. Got the platter - cheese, sausage, veggies, and a Greek salad. Food was good, staff was attentive and nice. Waitress kept asking everyone where they traveled from, started a lot of conversations. Nice relaxing lunch was had! read more

Loved this place! Excellent food. Good portions. Good prices. Extensive menu. So many things I wanted to try!! Had the beer battered fish & chips. Out of this world! Go! You won't regret it read more

Great wing night every Thursday. Come early it gets busy. All the other food is great too. K Rowe

The Ruben was excellent but slower than molasses service kinda took away from the meal

Stopped in for lunch. Waited 40 minutes for a menu, which my husband had to finally ask for. We waited another 30 minutes but The server never came back to take our order. He was either trying to make a point that the owner is too cheap to hire enough staff or he is just a lousy server. We will not be going back. read more

Great beer selection. Service is horrible. Food is greezy. French fries taking 1.5hrs. Child screams for French fries. Wait staff looks on. Brings colouring book when time to pay the bill. Sad. read more

Waited over an hour for our food, very busy place but understaffed. People coming in after us were served their food before us. We ordered a clubhouse sandwich and said to the server that we waited long enough but they insisted it was coming shortly so we stayed. We received our sandwich and it was awful, thin pressed chicken, bread was dry and stale. No condiments on the sandwich, I think they rushed and forgot to put it together properly. The bacon was good. The owner came over and did not charge us for our meal.....extra star for that, she did the right thing. We sat near the door and other people were complaining also as they were leaving. It's a nice little spot but they need to get organized. One server for the entire restaurant does not cut it. read more

I live in Creemore, this is my pub. Not because it is the only pub in town but because it is a great place. Great food and service and best wings and fries around made to order for you. As for the negative review by Mauro, i thought he was a nice guy but then again i was probably in a "drunken stupor " as Rob says. read more