The Siren&#x27;s Song Tavern

Great drinks. Better music. Pricey cocktails, but you get…read morewhat you pay for. It's one of our classier spots in eureka. We'll certainly be back.

Fun place, lots of local people. Bartender was great, drinks were good and people were friendly. We…read morewere visiting or else we would definitely be back again!

Guava margarita

See all

Cool hand drawn signs

The Shanty

4.1(121 reviews)

Sticky tables, punk rock, beer, what more do you need?…read more The shanty is fun. Good priced beer and fun clientele. Someone was always willing to strike a conversation or play some pinball. The music is great. Every time I've been, the bearded fella was manning the music. Good punk and hardcore playing, now that's the vibe I need. There's one regular who's over the top and will speak with you whether you want or not. That's part of the fun. I felt comfortable as a queer person here. Best bar in eureka hands down.

We are from out of town and we needed to stop to watch the England vs. Norway match but we have our…read moredog with us. The Shanty let us watch the game with our dog. Next time we are in Eureka we for sure will be back.

Cool hand drawn signs

See all

Jack Bot Pinball

The Palm Lounge

3.9(24 reviews)

0.4 mi

Luckily, we are in walking distance to The Palm at Eureka Inn. Been there many times & have always…read moreenjoyed the live music. The ambiance is lush, cozy & dark. Whether sitting at the bar or at a table, it is delightfully comfortable & in view of the stage & dance floor ;)). The bar service is always great! It is especially great when Jackie is working. She always remembers us & Is lively & entertaining.

I really liked this place! The old hotel gave real ambience to the venue. Dark walls made from…read morewood, long creepy hallways, a nice reception lounge where you could sit & mingle. I've never been before but they had a Halloween Party going on and the DJ had the dance floor packed. The drinks were pretty strong and the only disappointment was a small bar and slow bar service. It took up to 30 mins to get a drink. I was told on off nights it a cool place to come and relax and enjoy. Will have to give it a try!

Mom and daughter date couldn't get much better at the Palm Lounge

Jared...just in from potter valley! Absynthe for evryone!

See all

Http://www.yelp.com/biz/sbVGl1_fLw92jP2EExxXfg

Ernie's

4.2(31 reviews)

0.3 mi

I love this place! Fun service and dive bar ambiance. Free hot dogs on Mondays at 5 with a drink…read morepurchased. If you like bartenders who remember your drink and your name, this is the place!

Here to drop off the kid at the college. Thought Ernie's looked like the real deal. Definitely a…read moregreat happy very local bar. Jordan was extremely cool and welcoming. Will be back.

See all

Phatsy Kline's Parlor Lounge

4.4(180 reviews)

Cat theme? Check! Library aesthetic? Check!…read moreLocated in a historic building connected to a social hall? Check! This charming and eclectic bar/lounge was not only a fun hang for a drink, the food was exceptional and unexpected. I will happily return the next time I'm in town, and I can't recommend them enough for a quick drink OR a meal.

Still dreaming about their charcuterie board years later! I love stopping by this spot whenever I'm…read morein town. Low lit, romantic ambiance with lots of drink options available.

It's a vibe!

Weekly specials.. prawns

Phatsy Kline's Parlor Lounge - Looking for a romantic evening or a get together with friends make sure to ask about sitting on our patio. We're happy to spruce it up !

See all

Looking for a romantic evening or a get together with friends make sure to ask about sitting on our patio. We're happy to spruce it up !

North of Fourth

4.2(23 reviews)

Came in while doing a little trip up from the Bay Area to get away for a few days and glad I did…read more Drinks are excellent and fairly priced and the bar and building is gorgeous. But honestly the best part is the owner (Erika) is really nice and super knowledgeable about the area and the customer base seems super close knit. I came in on a Wednesday so definitely not peak hours but everyone that came in chatted with owner for a bit which was nice to see. Highly recommend for anyone visiting from out of town, Erika and her customers seem to know a lot about the area so a good first stop for anyone trying to get a sense of things to do! Will come back if I'm ever in eureka again

Always a Five star experience. Erica is one of the very best mixolologists in all of the tri…read morecounties area. The drinks are great, the regulars are chill, and She and chuck will treat you like family...just a gem of a bar! lots of history here!

Tart Cherry Sour!

See all

Dead Reckoning Tavern

4.3(59 reviews)

6.1 mi

Another great review. It's dead reck. Never change. I love all the beer. I'd drink one bajillion…read morebeers here

Great tap room with a cool vibe. Lots of beer to choose from. I like sitting at the counter looking…read moreout the windows.

I asked for Guinness and they said we have something better. They were right!

One of the many delicious stouts on tap

See all

The newest t-shirt design, drawn by David Paul Seymour.

Dave's Place

3.7(23 reviews)

1.6 mi

I always like visiting dive bars - they tend to offer up the best assessment of a city's townfolk…read more Happy to say that Dave's fit my expectations. Friendly staffperson behind the bar, a robust selection of beer, and best of all, clientele that are easy to interact with. Even though Eureka has the reputation of being perhaps a bit rough around the edges, for me I found this place to be anything and everything I would want, particularly with respect to cheap drinks, nonjudgmental people, and a generally chill atmosphere, and not necessarily in that order. And, no, not a spy, for those who know what I'm talking about. Rock on Dave's Place.

This place is without a doubt the greatest place ever great staff fun environment and great lookread more

Great Saturday night

BARFLY crew

See all

McClurg's

5.0(1 review)

0.8 mi

Great vibe in the place from the regulars, good selection of whiskey, Fireball and Jameson on tap,…read moreplus some super premium selections, make this an awesome place to chill.

See all

Vista Del Mar

4.3(368 reviews)

0.3 mi

We were on a road trip back home and looked up the reviews for somewhere to eat that wasn't fast…read morefood. So we searched Yelp and stumbled upon this gem. Due to the looks of neighborhood (especially since we don't live in the area) we thought we were going into a sketch dive. We couldn't have been more wrong. We all had fish and chips the batter was delish. The girl servicing tables was the only one there and she rocked it. I was watching her work and she anticipated her patrons and the bars needs without letting anyone else in the bar down. (We were there 7.26) Kudos to her! And the atmosphere was casual and happy. Thank you for the nice stop on our way home.

Tried to have a family dinner and got swiftly expelled!! lol Only for 21+…read more Did not see anything about that on the reviews otherwise I would have saved my time!

Inside

Firecracker fish taco

See all

The game is on

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

12 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Cat S.

0

1

0

3 years ago

‼ Sirens Song Tavern is allowing a predatory man to perform songs about groping and harassing women ‼ At the Sirens song tavern open mic last night, a man in his 70s finished his set with a song about sexual harassment. My friend and I had gone to listen to our friend's bands but ended up leaving early due to this man's song. "This is for all the girls who play guitar with their t1ts hanging out." Were his exact words. He introduced the song by saying it was about "coming to terms with the me too movement as a man."a another direct quote. In his song, he talked about how women always have their breasts out and expect men not to look, even though they dress that way for attention. About how young women dress so revealing and then have the audacity to get mad when guys look, but it's in their DNA to stare and grope. How men can't help it, can't help looking and "enjoying" young women, and it's fine when they're under 30, but when they get to his age it's creepy. Actually it's NEVER OKAY TO HARASS AND GROPE WOMEN AT ANY AGE. The chorus was literally about it being in male DNA to sexually harass women, saying they can't help it. He sang about groping women's breasts and staring at young girls in low cut tops, that were asking for it by wearing anything revealing. Talking about an a cup is good, b cup is better, c cup is great, "but give me your honking gs". THIS WAS AN ALL AGES EVENT. MANAGEMENT LET HIM CONTINUE THE SET. ALL AGES. Means CHILDREN are allowed there. Teen girls are allowed there. It was a good five minutes, it went on and on, each verse worse than the last. As a young woman I was extremely uncomfortable listening to this. I felt quite unsafe, and I'm willing to bet every other woman in that bar did too. However at the end, the men clapped and hollered in agreement. The manager and bartender listened to this play and did nothing. Management did nothing to stop this, despite half the bar being young females at an ALL AGES show. I understand it's an open mic and this is America and everything, but you need to draw the line somewhere. I was sick to my stomach hearing this, after years of facing the same sexual harassment all women face and no man will ever understand. I am sick to my stomach that in 2023, an entire bar sat there and listened and CLAPPED. Agreed. Cheered him on. I wish I had a video because what I'm saying sounds unreal, but it happened and there were a good 20 witnesses. If this is the type of performance allowed at sirens song I'm not surprised the bar was so empty. The manager asked us to buy drinks and support his business, which I encourage all of you to boycott. If this is the type of person permitted to perform there, what kind of guy is running this place?! I've been to perfectly enjoyable shows there before, at arts alive the bar is packed with college students, young women in cute outfits and perhaps low cut tops. When we go home at the end of the night, is this guy, who was clearly a regular, sitting there watching? It wouldn't be a stretch to say that he likely makes a specific appearance at this events so he can stare at these girls. He straight up admitted it in his song. This behavior is not acceptable. We cannot allow men to act this way and say these things, we cannot give them a platform, a literal stage and microphone, to spew this disturbing and predatory message. I am horrified that the owners of Sirens Song Tavern in Eureka allowed this performance to go on. You own the bar, take accountability for what is being played there. read more

Alicia A.

0

7

0

8 years ago

Great place to come see a show. No liquor but killer selection of beer, cider and mead. The staff is awesome and super friendly. They have little snacks that are house made and wonderful but not a full kitchen. read more

Robb S.

0

2

0

10 years ago

This is probably my favorite bar because of all the events they hold, wish they had a bigger food menu but I'm not complaining . Try the redwood Curtian IPA or the ciders . DELICIOUS read more

John G.

0

1

0

10 years ago

Extremely rude staff. The bar was empty and I still could not get the bartender's attention. I've never been treated so poorly at any spot in Eureka. Very disappointing. read more

Jodi W.

0

33

19

9 years ago

Rude bartender. The guy with the purple mohawk is extremely rude. He has the personality of a brick wall. It sucks because the ambience is really cool. read more

Jovi V.

0

1

0

8 years ago

Terrible, was treated very poorly, one of the so called managers with light brown hair, i think spencer or something wouldnt stop talking about my feet read more

Don Ezio R.

0

1

0

8 years ago

I went to this so called "Taven" to find a rude manager who had a head which represents a thumb and kept trying to find out my shoes size.

Ezra S.

0

12

0

8 years ago

so many great drinks, and the staff is always spot on with their recommendations. live music all the time, it's always a fun time here.

Lutea S.

0

12

14

4 years ago

Thought this place was really cute Family friendly Not crowded Nice atmosphere The bartender seemed like a really nice guy read more

Helen S.

0

11

0

10 years ago

Craft beers and I really like the Kombucha! Very artistic interior and full schedule of live music!

Sumanth Reddy K.

0

5

1

11 years ago

It's a great place to visit

Jena P.

51

10

29

12 years ago

Best bar in Humboldt.

The Siren's Song Tavern - bars - Updated September 2026

People who viewed The Siren's Song Tavern also viewed

North of Fourth

4.2

(23 reviews)

Came in while doing a little trip up from the Bay Area to get away for a few days and glad I did…read more Drinks are excellent and fairly priced and the bar and building is gorgeous. But honestly the best part is the owner (Erika) is really nice and super knowledgeable about the area and the customer base seems super close knit. I came in on a Wednesday so definitely not peak hours but everyone that came in chatted with owner for a bit which was nice to see. Highly recommend for anyone visiting from out of town, Erika and her customers seem to know a lot about the area so a good first stop for anyone trying to get a sense of things to do! Will come back if I'm ever in eureka again

Always a Five star experience. Erica is one of the very best mixolologists in all of the tri…read morecounties area. The drinks are great, the regulars are chill, and She and chuck will treat you like family...just a gem of a bar! lots of history here!

The Shanty

4.1

(121 reviews)

Sticky tables, punk rock, beer, what more do you need?…read more The shanty is fun. Good priced beer and fun clientele. Someone was always willing to strike a conversation or play some pinball. The music is great. Every time I've been, the bearded fella was manning the music. Good punk and hardcore playing, now that's the vibe I need. There's one regular who's over the top and will speak with you whether you want or not. That's part of the fun. I felt comfortable as a queer person here. Best bar in eureka hands down.

We are from out of town and we needed to stop to watch the England vs. Norway match but we have our…read moredog with us. The Shanty let us watch the game with our dog. Next time we are in Eureka we for sure will be back.

The Speakeasy

4.2

(113 reviews)

Great drinks. Better music. Pricey cocktails, but you get…read morewhat you pay for. It's one of our classier spots in eureka. We'll certainly be back.

Fun place, lots of local people. Bartender was great, drinks were good and people were friendly. We…read morewere visiting or else we would definitely be back again!

Logger Bar

4.5

(44 reviews)

If in or close to Arcata, the logger bar is a must! Great vibes, cool interior and good music.read more

First time at this bar. Such a cool location and atmosphere. The music and service was…read moreoutstanding and the decor hanging from the ceiling was so cool! We only orders drinks here, so not sure on their food items. The only suggestion would be to schedule a Lyft/uber in advance if coming from a neighboring city to ensure you have a ride back.

Ernie's

4.2

(31 reviews)

I love this place! Fun service and dive bar ambiance. Free hot dogs on Mondays at 5 with a drink…read morepurchased. If you like bartenders who remember your drink and your name, this is the place!

Here to drop off the kid at the college. Thought Ernie's looked like the real deal. Definitely a…read moregreat happy very local bar. Jordan was extremely cool and welcoming. Will be back.

Dave's Place

3.7

(23 reviews)

I always like visiting dive bars - they tend to offer up the best assessment of a city's townfolk…read more Happy to say that Dave's fit my expectations. Friendly staffperson behind the bar, a robust selection of beer, and best of all, clientele that are easy to interact with. Even though Eureka has the reputation of being perhaps a bit rough around the edges, for me I found this place to be anything and everything I would want, particularly with respect to cheap drinks, nonjudgmental people, and a generally chill atmosphere, and not necessarily in that order. And, no, not a spy, for those who know what I'm talking about. Rock on Dave's Place.

This place is without a doubt the greatest place ever great staff fun environment and great lookread more

Little Red Lion

3.8

(10 reviews)

This is great dive bar, which was fairly welcoming and friendly given that is a locals place. The…read morehappy hour bartender was one of the best I've had serve me in many years. Eat before you come, as the food menu is limited.

A neat, cozy little bar with a surprising amount of space. Crazy over priced though. My standard…read morered wine was $10. It was a decent pour, but come on, this isn't the Ritz. There's about four screens to watch the game. You won't have drifters, only hotel goers because it's not on the street, you have to walk around the corner inside to find it. I wouldn't recommend meeting people for drinks here. But if you're stuck at the hotel, it's the only place. So imbibe!

McClurg's

5.0

(1 review)

Great vibe in the place from the regulars, good selection of whiskey, Fireball and Jameson on tap,…read moreplus some super premium selections, make this an awesome place to chill.

707 Bar

3.8

(13 reviews)

Really cool late night should come on down and check it out. Freaking great awesome music good…read morevibes. Awesome drinks are amazing. It's amazing. Good night.

It gets a little wild on weekends but the vibe is good. Bartenders are professional & nice. And…read morethey put out food on football Sunday!

Phatsy Kline's Parlor Lounge

4.4

(180 reviews)