If you're looking for a quick, reasonably priced meal and you don't mind counter service, stop on in. Let me start with this advice: they do have bottled drinks next to the cashier, but we made the mistake if not checking everything out first. Turns out there is a fountain drink Pepsi machine in the dining room, so if that's what you prefer, thank me for letting you know. Now, onto the food. Let me start by mentioning that the creamy cheese and the nice sized elbows made the macaroni and cheese and excellent side. Do not miss this opportunity. The consensus at the table was that all of the sandwiches were obviously made with very fresh ingredients and all was tasty. Dipping sauces and dressings were distinctly flavorful. To be honest, Lewistown gets a bad rap because of social issues and delinquent crime, but this little restaurant is a gem. read more

Great food, friendly staff, homemade everything, fantastic selection of top quality homemade bbq sauces

Every time I'm up this way I stop in. I know most will say the food is good and recommend it. However I have to say I make it a point to stop in because the service is spot on, the cuisine sublime and all of it wrapped in a clean quaint shop where you can just relax. So get your butts in here and try the shop for yourselves. read more

Quick service and delicious food served fresh daily. Specials menu changes daily while everyday options include chicken, sandwiches, and pulled pork. The brisket is delicious and you can choose from multiple sauces. The side of Mac and cheese, which is only available certain days, is a must have. Great option on the square in downtown lewistown. read more

The Square Cafe and Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lewistown, Pennsylvania

See all

I had a BBQ chicken sandwich and cheesy potatoes. The food was great. They offer a salad bar and desserts. Didn't try either but everything looked very appetizing. The interior is very cute and clean. Very affordable. read more

The Square Cafe and Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - Lewistown, Pennsylvania

They have good food and sometimes Kayla makes me my favorite cake is chololate peanut butter cake yummy .

The BBQ is so yummy! I had the chicken with hot BBQ and it was so good. Make sure you save room for the Whoopi pies. They are amazing.

This place had great reviews and I'm not certain why. It's basically a BBQ joint that sells whoopie pies. The veggies in the salad bar were old. The soup was microwaved and still not hot. They have tables like they want you to sit down but everything is served as if you should leave. My husband said the BBQ was fine, but naming this place a "cafe and bakery" is misleading. read more

On a rainy Wednesday we wanted to try a lunch place that we had never experienced before. A little Yelp research lead us to drive 22 miles to The Square Cafe and Bakery (it is located on a town square in Lewisburg, PA). Very unassuming from the street, we entered and found it clean and welcoming. It is counter service dining. Go up to the counter order what you want and take it to your table or it will be delivered to your table. I had the pulled pork sandwich with the spicy BBQ sauce. It was a generous serving that overflowed the roll and I had a couple bonus bites after the sandwich. The bakery offered a number of fresh baked cookies, whoopie pies (or gobs depending on where you live), and other rural PA offerings. My wife and daughter each liked their meals. My daughter had an Italian sub/hoagie and my wife had a salad. Before we left we stocked up on some goodies for the ride home and to eat later. They have daily specials and while the baked beans (very good) are served every day, the other sides rotate through the week. If you are looking for a place to try when you are hungry and in the Lewistown area, I would suggest giving them a try. They are a little over a year old and my taste buds hope they are around for a long time. read more