This is a great place if you are looking for a really specialized, unique olive oil OR balsamic vinegar. The owner is really friendly, and helps you decide on what is best, based on the taste profile you are seeking. There are little steel cups that you can use to sample everything (except for the premium oils such as the truffle oils).
I left with a Harissa olive oil, as the taste of the spicy peppers was prominent in the oil, but also had a delicious smoky taste. It would be amazing in pasta salads or drizzled on top of pizza; however, prices are quite steep, so I would use the oils sparingly! (For example, a 200ml of basil infused olive oil is $5.99 at La Bottega/Nicastro, whereas here it is $14.99...so definitely a splurge)!
Overall, I would come here if feeling splurgy (or was more baller, haha), otherwise I would probably stick with olive oils from regular stores. read more