Cancel

Open app

Search

Tilley's Tavern

4.3 (56 reviews)
InexpensiveChicken Wings, Burgers, Bars
Open • 11:00 am - 2:00 AM (Next day)

Tilley's Tavern Photos

TILLEY'S TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Casual
Live music
Good for kids
Outdoor seating

You might also consider

More like Tilley's Tavern

Recommended Reviews - Tilley's Tavern

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Bourbon Burger and seasoned fries.
Chad S.

Made a pit stop in Mt. Olive for fuel and a bite to eat and Tilley's Tavern sounded good. It is located on the main drag in an older building on a corner. I arrived before the usual supper time... around 3:45PM. There were a few customer there already enjoying a late lunch or early supper. They had a decent selection of can/bottle beer so I ordered a Voodoo Ranger and the bourbon burger with seasoned fries. I sat at the bar and there was sports in TV. It's an older space with a big bar and typical small town decor, including an old school tin ceiling. The server at the bar was extremely friendly and responsive. Food came out quickly and was prepared and delicious. The bourbon burger included, caramelized onions, bacon, cheddar cheese with bourbon glaze on a pretzel bun. Definitely recommend for a good burger and cold beer.

Beef horseshoe
Jason V.

I've heard a lot of great things about this smalltown place which is on Main Street in Mount Olive. It's a bar and grill or tavern, as one would expect in a little village as most (if not all) towns in southern Illinois have one. Everyone seemingly raves about the food and atmosphere here, so I had to check it out. The service was very slow, and it took the server 10 minutes to finally seat me. There were only two servers but the place was not busy. She later apologized, got my drink order and then my food which also took quite awhile. I got the beef horseshoe. It wasn't a large or small serving, but just right. The fries were very crispy, which I liked. The cheese? I wasn't sure how to put it. It didn't taste like queso, spicy or average cheese, but more sweet or something like it. Let's just say, it was different. But I had a full belly upon leaving. One of my friends from Mt. Olive told me the place was never the same after the original owner passed away a couple years ago, as some things slowly declined.

a view of the inside of the restaurant
Kathy F.

Small Town charm with food that would beat out 5 star restaurants in a big city. Walked in and was greeted and made to feel at home with the smile of ou r server Hayden she returned to check and refill our drinks Our food came out quick and hot the portion size are generous beyond words. It is definitely your hometown bar that has stopped in time nothing modern sturdy woodwork pressed tin ceiling

Burger and Puffalo Wings
Sean P.

This was definitely a hidden gem. A fantastically simple burger that was almost perfect. A group of wings that were a nice, vinegar base like a buffalo but with added red pepper flakes (Puffalo sauce). One of the better small-town taverns you will find, even if the menu is simple.. they do it very well.

Western Burger
Adam R.

Worth the drive! One of the best burgers around. The 1/2lb Pattys are no joke! Service was fast and friendly.

Dining Area

Stopped at this little spot while on the road. About a mile or so off the main highway. TOTALLY WORTH IT!! The burgers are huge & delicious and the seasoned fries were great too! Very reasonable prices. HIGHLY recommend!! One side of location is a small town bar and the other side is a dining area. I attached a picture of the dining area. Had a pretty cool patio area as well but was to cold outside to take advantage of it. Guarantee it is worth your attention!!

Ravioli's frozen and fried...leathery but good for soaking up alcohol.
Elwood P. D.

We are giving Tilley's an extra star simply for existing. Mt. Olive does not have a lot to offer and it was a real surprise to find Tilley's here. The first thing we noticed when we walked in was that is seems bigger on the inside than on the outside. The extra dining room and game room was unexpected. We happened to hit it on Monday (wing night) and the place was romping. Sitting at the bar we had a good view of the operation and had an opportunity to engage with the staff as well as other patrons. The universal advice was...get the wings. Tilley's was doing a great take out business while we were there. A steady stream of locals where hauling out large white plastic bags of styrofoam boxes with wings and extra sauce. Not wanting to look out of place we ordered the wings. And quietly ordered a salad and fried ravioli just to explore the menu. There are several choices of wing sauce. Following the bartenders suggestion I ordered a spicy sweet sauce. She warned me it was quite hot. When I received the wings I realized I had forgotten I was in the mid-west and their idea of spicy hot is different from much of the rest of the country. I've had spicier oatmeal than this. The fried raviolis were average at best. There were a lot of them in the basket which was nice but then I shouldn't expect much more than frozen and fried in Mt. Olive. The salad was iconic mid-west. Head lettuce with grated cheese. We ate it because it was green. Tilley's is a fun place to hang out and have a beer and we felt the place was very affordable. If you are looking for quality food then Mt. Olive may not be your best option. But Tilley's is your best option in Mt. Olive.

See all

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Gus M.
35
7
0

8 years ago

It's hard to find a vintage bar like this with great drink prices and awesome food. Definitely going back.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Stopped at Tilly's on the way home. Awesome experience! The bartender and waitress we're extremely friendly and the food was delicious!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Emma W.
208
9
1

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Tilley's is a great small town restaurant and bar. Stop in. Enjoy bar food and a drink. Well worth it.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Good food but good service is touch and go. If they work on their customer service I would be back way more often.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - Tilley's Tavern

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Get access to customer & competitor insights.

Verify this business

Rooster's Pub - Bone in Buffalo sauce

Rooster's Pub

4.1(14 reviews)
5.4 mi

Visits in JUL-AUG-OCT 2025…read more We moved into town this summer. Our realtor provided gift certificate as a closing congratulations. After we came the first visit I wanted to take my time, have a few more visits before I wrote. My rating of 3 (okay) in this case think of it as an academic C, a passing grade but certainly room for improvement. Rooster's Pub is okay, the food is okay, the service is okay, it is clean. If you are looking for a bar food meal this is an okay place to choose. You can stop here, disregard the rest and make your choice. I suspect that Rooster's is popular locally (and has some high ratings) is familiarity, and a customer base that hasn't widely traveled, there is nothing wrong with that. I am comfortable saying that this place is also likely a good bar, for those interested in that environment. It is not quite for me (us) as a restaurant. We have only been during the lunch hours. I have never owned a bar or restaurant. I worked in them at various levels earlier in life. I acknowledge how tough it is to be a bar that also has standout food. In my experience that is rather rare. I know that when a bar does get that balance right, they have a limited menu. They make a few things and make them well. A full menu is always going to have to carry some amount of frozen "Sysco" things dropped into hot oil. Our meals, I have had two okay tenderloins and one burger, my wife two fish (slightly overdone) meals, and one burger. My wish is for continued success for Rooster's, it is a fine place for others. As currently functioning it is not a place for me. This is also okay if the oil is always fresh, and the cook is attentive and pulls things soon enough to guard color/texture and the cooking finishes during delivery to table. On another note it seems that in our 3 visits, things are cooked hard and fast but then sit in the window, cooling until delivered lukewarm and past that "golden moment". A few lines about the fries. People do like them, I however do not prefer house cut fries. I think the basic restaurant frozen fry, well executed, is an easy win. Our's have been dark and soggy on arrival. I did get the tots on the middle visit (better), had forgotten the fry defeciency and got them this last time. My wife, a Midwestern lover of all things potato, left nearly half of her order. Overall plating has been a bit haphazard, not expecting a cooking show, but I do appreciate something that arrives looking intentional. There just doesn't seem to be a level of care applied to the meals that have come to our table (a note on that at the end). We have only had the same two front of house workers. They are polite (maybe stiffly and overly so), they get the order right and they accomplish the mission. However is feels a bit like a "transaction", which I understand it is, the customers aren't your friend. I don't think it's just us, there doesn't seem to be any warmth with anyone that comes in (even what I presume are regulars). If there is a scale with annoyed that I exist on one end, and a warm hug on the other, the service here is much closer to the left hashmark. A final note about my meals here. If the gaps in execution are some message that I am not worthy of a best effort, or simply not welcome- message received.

Ordered bacon burger and garlic butter burger , both were absolutely fantastic. Service was great,…read morefriendly and prompt. Will be back!

Photos
Rooster's Pub
Rooster's Pub - Regular Pepsi to go

Regular Pepsi to go

Rooster's Pub - Cheeseburger

See all

Cheeseburger

Route 138 Cafe - Hot Cocoa with whipped cream

Route 138 Cafe

2.9(20 reviews)
1.3 mi

There are times when you want to walk into a space that has been carefully put together by someone…read morewith all the right training, so the colors are just so. The furniture blends seemlessly into the theme of the menu or some such. There are other times when you are content to walk into a clean, simple space where the decor has been put together over the years by many different people, with different quirks and fancies. The furniture is functional, might not even all match...all good. Route 138 Cafe is that second kind of place. The name alone, is so plain sense Midwest, practical. It not some whimsical thought excercise like Nutmeg Hutch or some such. There are no fancy uniforms, the staff might have on T-shirts from the restaurant. We have had no issues with any of the staff, they have been nothing but pleasant, effective and welcoming. We have been here a few times now since moving to the area, this was the first time for lunch. I had a breaded pork tenderloin sandwich with seasoned fries, my wife got a BLT with same. Do splurge for the "special" fries vs. the standard crinkle cut. Somehow crinkle cut fries take me back to elementary school, and no matter how hot and great they may be in this present time, they take me back to luke warm unsalted punishment on a plastic tray. There is nothing fancy about anything I have eaten here. It's not perfect, what is- it is also obviously put together with care. That goes a long way. I have had beautiful, expensive meals and left hungry and full of regret. We left Saturday afternoon feeling full, comfortable and starting to fit in to our "fly-over" retirement.

Went for dinner with my grandfather. The waitresses were nice, but completely clueless. When a…read morenearby table asked for a manager, they were informed there was no manager. We waited 50 minutes for a chicken wrap and roast beef. They didn't have silverware clean, so we had to wait another 5 or 10 minutes for that after the food came out. There was one cook in the kitchen audibly yelling in the kitchen in time. Though the staff seemed overwhelmed were overwhelmed, although there were less than 10 tables. As someone with experience managing bars and restaurants all over St. Louis, the fault here lies with the owners or management. The staff were not set up for success. There should absolutely be a manager on duty. In fact, it's the law - in illinois you must have certified food protection manager on sight at all times. Not having a second cook on duty sounds like ownership trying to cheap out on overhead. The food was ok. Not bad, and not good. I'm not sure how this place passed a health inspection.

Photos
Route 138 Cafe - Pancake

Pancake

Route 138 Cafe - Buttered white toast with jelly

Buttered white toast with jelly

Route 138 Cafe - Crispy Pepsi

See all

Crispy Pepsi

Tilley's Tavern - chicken_wings - Updated June 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...