My Favorite Jewelry store! Alice and her team do an Amazing job with great customer service. You…read moreget a lot of bang for your buck.

So far my experience with Diamond Fantasy could not be better. I went in to have a watch battery…read morereplaced. They were very friendly, polite, courteous, and professional. I tried to pay with my credit card and the bill was only $10 so she asked for cash. I didn't think I had cash and the owner said: "It's ok, you can bring it another time". I couldn't believe how she trusted me. I found $9 cash and said I'm sure I have quarters in the car but once again she insisted it was ok. I felt bad but at the same time honored that she was so caring. (Don't judge me, I never carry cash). Anyway, I have more jewelry repair to get done so I will be back!

I forgot to check in, but I was there on 3/13/26. Had to get a watch sized and the service was…read moreamazing! Had the nicest conversation with both employees, and even got the most beautiful and affordable silver ring. I can't recommend this store enough! Thank you!!!

Perfectly done! Amazing price! Friendly staff! Honest people! Straight-shooters! Can't get better…read morein the area for repairs. Nice jewelry too, though I only had a repair done.

I had a POOR experience with this company. I tend to shop at smaller stores versus chains in the…read moremall because I feel they need it more. Instead of going to Banter to buy my daughter's Christmas Gift I came here. I ordered a nameplate for her on Dec 9th and was assured that it would be there on time for Christmas. I called and text in the days leading up to Christmas and got the run around. Finally I showed up right before closing on Christmas Eve and was told there was an issue with the shipment and it wouldn't be ready by Christmas. The staff apologized and offered me a small necklace free of charge so my daughter had something to open, while promising that the necklace would be there the following week and they would reach out when it's ready. Now here I am, over a week later and I'm being sent to voicemail and my text messages are going unanswered. Be careful with purchasing custom items from this store. It's one thing to purchase something there and in stock, but for anything that will come in later, this store may or not provide your item. I'll be reporting them to the BBB as I have not received any mention of a refund and haven't received my item.

Stopped by last week to get a custom bracelet made for my wife. Super fast turnaround and the…read moreengraving looked clean. The owners were friendly and answered all my questions. I'll definitely come back again. Thank you guys!

I am Gaga over my new ring!!! Through a trusted source, I made a purchase through careful…read moreconsultation and sharing photos via text. Kathy's neice Kathy helped me through the entire process kindly and enthusiastically. It arrived within 10 days I am over the moon pleased. I am making a pilgrimage to NJ from CT over the summer. Can't wait to buy more jewelry with them. It's the best combination of quality jewelry and excellent customer service.

Kathy made sure to understand my needs while working on a custom project. She acted honestly and…read moretransparently, ultimately making it an enjoyable process. Thank you.

Seems to be NO management at this center. I've emailed them several times, left a voicemessage (a…read moremonth later and no response) and finally filed a complaint with the Better Business Bureau to see if they respond to that. I had a serious issue with one of their vendors (Elegant Designs Jewelry booth 52) - was given Lab Grown Diamonds valued at only $1,000 when they were purported to be genuine diamonds valued at $7,000. Whatever you do, immediately get anything purchased there appraised by an independent jewelry so you are not in my position - losing $6,000 in the transaction! Plus it seems management doesn't care as they simply don't respond.

I've shopped here for a few years. I love the merchandise and the overall variety of selection…read more However, I observed several jewelers in my last two visits not wearing masks. Both times I turned right around and did not go inside. It's sad because I really like this establishment but I'm not willing to risk my life to buy jewelry.

Can't get more honest than Rich - highly recommended. Repairs are very reasonable…read more Have old jewelry you want to get rid of - you'll get a good price!

From the owner: "under the big green awning"…read more Founded in 1979, we are "under the big green awning" at 150 West West Pleasant Avenue in Maywood, NJ, We buy, sell, and trade Jewelry, Art, and Antiques, which includes gold and silver, diamonds, antique jewelry, costume jewelry, old paintings, bronze statues, swords and such, and much more! Call us or use our easy online submission form at AnotherFacet.com/sell.htm

Abe is the Best . We have been doing business with him for years .Has a beautiful selection and…read morealso will help you design if he doesn't offer it

The service is great. I have bought beautiful jewelry at great prices. There is a great selection…read moreof jewelry. I needed an appraisal and Abe did it for me on the spot. I highly recommend going to see what they have for you.

Ryan made selling my gold jewelry an easy and efficient process. He explained as he tested the…read morepieces and I learned a lot. He was very pleasant to deal with.

I just got back from here and I cannot say enough positive things about this place!…read moreFirst off, they are SUPER nice and grateful for their customers. I went in to sell my tiny wedding band from my ex. It was sitting in my drawer for 4 years and I had completely forgot about it. Super tiny with like 1/10 k of diamonds. I was expecting to get $15 and he gave me more than double! I'm so happy I didn't go to a check cashing place to pawn it. When I walked in Ryan, maybe the owner, greeted me with a smile. He was more than happy to help me and spend time explaining things even though they were closing. I told him why I was there and he immediately gave me a mini Poland Spring bottle of cold water. Immediately I was impressed. That type of hospitality is HUGE​ in my book! He weighed it while talking to me and told me how much it was worth. Of course I took the $$$. The ring was garbage to me. While he was helping me I couldn't help but notice the GORGEOUS items they had for sale. Wow, just stunning.....and the prices were right! I urge you to check this place out. I can almost guarantee you'll be impressed. Support small local businesses vs big companies who mostly care about their bottom line instead of making customers happy. I will definitely go there if I'm looking for a nice piece of jewelry.